-
A new non-parametric method to infer galaxy cluster masses from weak lensing
Authors:
Tobias Mistele,
Amel Durakovic
Abstract:
We introduce a new, non-parametric method to infer deprojected 3D mass profiles $M(r)$ of galaxy clusters from weak gravitational lensing observations. The method assumes spherical symmetry and a moderately small convergence, $κ\lesssim 1$. The assumption of spherical symmetry is an important restriction, which is, however, quite common in practice, for example in methods that fit lensing data to…
▽ More
We introduce a new, non-parametric method to infer deprojected 3D mass profiles $M(r)$ of galaxy clusters from weak gravitational lensing observations. The method assumes spherical symmetry and a moderately small convergence, $κ\lesssim 1$. The assumption of spherical symmetry is an important restriction, which is, however, quite common in practice, for example in methods that fit lensing data to an NFW profile. Unlike other methods, our method relies on spherical symmetry only at radii larger than the radius $r$ at which the mass $M$ is inferred. That is, the method works even if there is a non-symmetric inner region. We provide an efficient implementation in Julia code that runs in a few milliseconds per galaxy cluster. We explicitly demonstrate the method by using data from KiDS DR4 to infer mass profiles for two example clusters, Abell 1835 and Abell 2744, finding results consistent with existing literature.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2024; v1 submitted 13 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Indefinitely Flat Circular Velocities and the Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation from Weak Lensing
Authors:
Tobias Mistele,
Stacy McGaugh,
Federico Lelli,
James Schombert,
Pengfei Li
Abstract:
We use a new deprojection formula to infer the gravitational potential around isolated galaxies from weak gravitational lensing. The results imply circular velocity curves that remain flat for hundreds of kpc, greatly extending the classic result from 21 cm observations. Indeed, there is no clear hint of a decline out to 1 Mpc, well beyond the expected virial radii of dark matter halos. Binning th…
▽ More
We use a new deprojection formula to infer the gravitational potential around isolated galaxies from weak gravitational lensing. The results imply circular velocity curves that remain flat for hundreds of kpc, greatly extending the classic result from 21 cm observations. Indeed, there is no clear hint of a decline out to 1 Mpc, well beyond the expected virial radii of dark matter halos. Binning the data by mass reveals a correlation with the flat circular speed that closely agrees with the Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation known from kinematic data. These results apply to both early and late type galaxies, indicating a common universal behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Radial acceleration relation of galaxies with joint kinematic and weak-lensing data
Authors:
Tobias Mistele,
Stacy McGaugh,
Federico Lelli,
James Schombert,
Pengfei Li
Abstract:
We combine kinematic and gravitational lensing data to construct the Radial Acceleration Relation (RAR) of galaxies over a large dynamic range. We improve on previous weak-lensing studies in two ways. First, we compute stellar masses using the same stellar population model as for the kinematic data. Second, we introduce a new method for converting excess surface density profiles to radial accelera…
▽ More
We combine kinematic and gravitational lensing data to construct the Radial Acceleration Relation (RAR) of galaxies over a large dynamic range. We improve on previous weak-lensing studies in two ways. First, we compute stellar masses using the same stellar population model as for the kinematic data. Second, we introduce a new method for converting excess surface density profiles to radial accelerations. This method is based on a new deprojection formula which is exact, computationally efficient, and gives smaller systematic uncertainties than previous methods. We find that the RAR inferred from weak-lensing data smoothly continues that inferred from kinematic data by about $2.5\,\mathrm{dex}$ in acceleration. Contrary to previous studies, we find that early- and late-type galaxies lie on the same joint RAR when a sufficiently strict isolation criterion is adopted and their stellar and gas masses are estimated consistently with the kinematic RAR.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2024; v1 submitted 23 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
A new scale in the quasi-static limit of Aether Scalar Tensor Theory
Authors:
Tobias Mistele
Abstract:
One of the aims of Aether Scalar Tensor Theory (AeST) is to reproduce the successes of Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) on galactic scales. Indeed, the quasi-static limit of AeST achieves precisely this, assuming that the vector field $\vec{A}$ vanishes and that the so-called ghost condensate can be neglected. The effects of the ghost condensate were investigated in detail in previous studies. H…
▽ More
One of the aims of Aether Scalar Tensor Theory (AeST) is to reproduce the successes of Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) on galactic scales. Indeed, the quasi-static limit of AeST achieves precisely this, assuming that the vector field $\vec{A}$ vanishes and that the so-called ghost condensate can be neglected. The effects of the ghost condensate were investigated in detail in previous studies. Here, we focus on the assumption of a vanishing vector field. We argue that this assumption is not always justified and show how to correctly take into account the vector field, finding that the quasi-static limit depends on a model parameter $m_\times$. In the limit $m_\times \to 0$, one recovers the quasi-static limit with a vanishing vector field. In particular, one finds a two-field version of MOND. In the opposite limit, $m_\times \to \infty$, one finds a single-field version of MOND. We show that, in practice, much of the phenomenology of the quasi-static limit depends only very little on the value of $m_\times$. Still, for some observational tests, such as those involving wide binaries, $m_\times$ has percent-level effects that may be important.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2024; v1 submitted 12 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Comment on "Observational Evidence for Cosmological Coupling of Black Holes and its Implications for an Astrophysical Source of Dark Energy"
Authors:
Tobias Mistele
Abstract:
It was recently claimed that black holes can explain the accelerated expansion of the universe. Here I point out that this claim is based on a confusion about the principle of least action, undermining the link between black holes and dark energy.
It was recently claimed that black holes can explain the accelerated expansion of the universe. Here I point out that this claim is based on a confusion about the principle of least action, undermining the link between black holes and dark energy.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2023; v1 submitted 19 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Superfluid dark matter in tension with weak gravitational lensing data
Authors:
Tobias Mistele,
Stacy McGaugh,
Sabine Hossenfelder
Abstract:
Superfluid dark matter (SFDM) is a model that promises to reproduce the successes of both particle dark matter on cosmological scales and those of Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) on galactic scales. SFDM reproduces MOND only up to a certain distance from the galactic center, and only for kinematic observables: It does not affect trajectories of light. We test whether this is consistent with a r…
▽ More
Superfluid dark matter (SFDM) is a model that promises to reproduce the successes of both particle dark matter on cosmological scales and those of Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) on galactic scales. SFDM reproduces MOND only up to a certain distance from the galactic center, and only for kinematic observables: It does not affect trajectories of light. We test whether this is consistent with a recent analysis of weak gravitational lensing that has probed accelerations around galaxies to unprecedentedly large radii. This analysis found the data to be close to the prediction of MOND, suggesting they might be difficult to fit with SFDM. To investigate this matter, we solved the equations of motion of the model and compared the result to observational data. Our results show that the SFDM model is incompatible with the weak-lensing observations, at least in its current form.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2023; v1 submitted 15 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Aether scalar tensor theory confronted with weak lensing data at small accelerations
Authors:
Tobias Mistele,
Stacy McGaugh,
Sabine Hossenfelder
Abstract:
The recently proposed aether scalar tensor (AeST) model reproduces both the successes of particle dark matter on cosmological scales and those of modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND) on galactic scales. But the AeST model reproduces MOND only up to a certain maximum galactocentric radius. Since MOND is known to fit very well to observations at these scales, this raises the question of whether the Ae…
▽ More
The recently proposed aether scalar tensor (AeST) model reproduces both the successes of particle dark matter on cosmological scales and those of modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND) on galactic scales. But the AeST model reproduces MOND only up to a certain maximum galactocentric radius. Since MOND is known to fit very well to observations at these scales, this raises the question of whether the AeST model comes into tension with data. We tested whether or not the AeST model is in conflict with observations using a recent analysis of data for weak gravitational lensing. We solved the equations of motion of the AeST model, analyzed the solutions' behavior, and compared the results to observational data. The AeST model shows some deviations from MOND at the radii probed by weak gravitational lensing. The data show no clear indication of these predicted deviations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2023; v1 submitted 9 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
How Close Dark Matter Halos and MOND Are to Each Other: Three-Dimensional Tests Based on Gaia DR2
Authors:
Yongda Zhu,
Hai-Xia Ma,
Xiao-Bo Dong,
Yang Huang,
Tobias Mistele,
Bo Peng,
Qian Long,
Tianqi Wang,
Liang Chang,
Xi Jin
Abstract:
Aiming at discriminating different gravitational potential models of the Milky Way, we perform tests based on the kinematic data powered by the Gaia DR2 astrometry, over a large range of $(R,z)$ locations. Invoking the complete form of Jeans equations that admit three integrals of motion, we use the independent $R$- and $z$-directional equations as two discriminators ($T_R$ and $T_z$). We apply th…
▽ More
Aiming at discriminating different gravitational potential models of the Milky Way, we perform tests based on the kinematic data powered by the Gaia DR2 astrometry, over a large range of $(R,z)$ locations. Invoking the complete form of Jeans equations that admit three integrals of motion, we use the independent $R$- and $z$-directional equations as two discriminators ($T_R$ and $T_z$). We apply the formula for spatial distributions of radial and vertical velocity dispersions proposed by Binney et al., and successfully extend it to azimuthal components, $σ_θ(R,z)$ and $V_θ(R,z)$; the analytic form avoids the numerical artifacts caused by numerical differentiation in Jeans-equations calculation given the limited spatial resolutions of observations, and more importantly reduces the impact of kinematic substructures in the Galactic disk. It turns out that whereas the current kinematic data are able to reject Moffat's Modified Gravity (let alone the Newtonian baryon-only model), Milgrom's MOND is still not rejected. In fact, both the carefully calibrated fiducial model invoking a spherical dark matter (DM) halo and MOND are equally consistent with the data at almost all spatial locations (except that probably both have respective problems at low-$|z|$ locations), no matter which a tracer population or which a meaningful density profile is used. Because there is no free parameter at all in the quasi-linear MOND model we use, and the baryonic parameters are actually fine-tuned in the DM context, such an effective equivalence is surprising, and might be calling forth a transcending synthesis of the two paradigms.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
A novel Cherenkov radiation constraint for hybrid MOND dark matter models
Authors:
Tobias Mistele
Abstract:
Modified gravity models often contain modes that couple to normal matter and propagate with slightly less than the speed of light. High-energy cosmic rays then lose energy due to Cherenkov radiation, which constrains such models. This is also true for some MOND (Modified Newtonian Dynamics) models. However, these constraints are difficult to make precise because MOND is inherently non-linear and b…
▽ More
Modified gravity models often contain modes that couple to normal matter and propagate with slightly less than the speed of light. High-energy cosmic rays then lose energy due to Cherenkov radiation, which constrains such models. This is also true for some MOND (Modified Newtonian Dynamics) models. However, these constraints are difficult to make precise because MOND is inherently non-linear and because the results may depend on the specific high-acceleration behavior of these models, i.e. the behavior outside the MOND regime. Recently, various hybrid MOND dark matter models were proposed, where cold dark matter (CDM) phenomenology on cosmological scales and MOND phenomenology on galactic scales share a common origin. Such models typically contain a mode that is directly coupled to matter (for MOND), but with non-relativistic sound speed (for CDM). Thus, even non-relativistic objects like stars can emit gravitational Cherenkov radiation. We calculate a lower bound on the associated energy loss. We use a controlled approximation that depends only on the MOND regime of these models. We apply our results to three concrete models: For the original superfluid dark matter model (SFDM), we rule out a part of the parameter space, including the most commonly used parameters. For two-field SFDM, we find no constraint since the matter coupling of the relevant mode is suppressed by mixing. For the recently-proposed model by Skordis and Złośnik, we find no constraint since the matter coupling is suppressed in non-static situations.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2022; v1 submitted 30 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Galactic Mass-to-Light Ratios With Superfluid Dark Matter
Authors:
Tobias Mistele,
Stacy McGaugh,
Sabine Hossenfelder
Abstract:
We make rotation curve fits to test the superfluid dark matter model. In addition to verifying that the resulting fits match the rotation curve data reasonably well, we aim to evaluate how satisfactory they are with respect to two criteria, namely, how reasonable the resulting stellar mass-to-light ratios are and whether the fits end up in the regime of superfluid dark matter where the model resem…
▽ More
We make rotation curve fits to test the superfluid dark matter model. In addition to verifying that the resulting fits match the rotation curve data reasonably well, we aim to evaluate how satisfactory they are with respect to two criteria, namely, how reasonable the resulting stellar mass-to-light ratios are and whether the fits end up in the regime of superfluid dark matter where the model resembles modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND). We fitted the superfluid dark matter model to the rotation curves of 169 galaxies in the SPARC sample. We found that the mass-to-light ratios obtained with superfluid dark matter are generally acceptable in terms of stellar populations. However, the best-fit mass-to-light ratios have an unnatural dependence on the size of the galaxy in that giant galaxies have systematically lower mass-to-light ratios than dwarf galaxies. A second finding is that the superfluid often fits the rotation curves best in the regime where the superfluid's force cannot resemble that of MOND without adjusting a boundary condition separately for each galaxy. In that case, we can no longer expect superfluid dark matter to reproduce the phenomenologically observed scaling relations that make MOND appealing. If, on the other hand, we consider only solutions whose force approximates MOND well, then the total mass of the superfluid is in tension with gravitational lensing data. We conclude that even the best fits with superfluid dark matter are still unsatisfactory for two reasons. First, the resulting stellar mass-to-light ratios show an unnatural trend with galaxy size. Second, the fits do not end up in the regime that automatically resembles MOND, and if we force the fits to do so, the total dark matter mass is in tension with strong lensing data.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2022; v1 submitted 18 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Cherenkov radiation from stars constrains hybrid MOND dark matter models
Authors:
Tobias Mistele
Abstract:
We propose a new method to constrain alternative models for dark matter with observations. Specifically, we consider hybrid models in which cold dark matter (CDM) phenomena on cosmological scales and Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) phenomena on galactic scales share a common origin. Various such models were recently proposed. They typically contain a mode that is directly coupled to matter (for…
▽ More
We propose a new method to constrain alternative models for dark matter with observations. Specifically, we consider hybrid models in which cold dark matter (CDM) phenomena on cosmological scales and Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) phenomena on galactic scales share a common origin. Various such models were recently proposed. They typically contain a mode that is directly coupled to matter (for MOND) and has a non-relativistic sound speed (for CDM). This allows even non-relativistic objects like stars to lose energy through Cherenkov radiation. This is unusual. Most modified gravity models have a relativistic sound speed, so that only high-energy cosmic rays emit Cherenkov radiation. We discuss the consequences of this Cherenkov radiation from stars.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2022; v1 submitted 31 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Three problems of superfluid dark matter and their solution
Authors:
Tobias Mistele
Abstract:
In superfluid dark matter (SFDM), the phonon field plays a double role: It carries the superfluid's energy density and it mediates the MOND-like phonon force. We show that these two roles are in tension with each other on galactic scales: A MOND-like phonon force is in tension with a superfluid in equilibrium and with a significant superfluid energy density. To avoid these tensions, we propose a m…
▽ More
In superfluid dark matter (SFDM), the phonon field plays a double role: It carries the superfluid's energy density and it mediates the MOND-like phonon force. We show that these two roles are in tension with each other on galactic scales: A MOND-like phonon force is in tension with a superfluid in equilibrium and with a significant superfluid energy density. To avoid these tensions, we propose a model where the two roles are split between two different fields. This also allows us to solve a stability problem in a more elegant way than standard SFDM. We argue that the standard estimates for the size of a galaxy's superfluid core need to be revisited.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2021; v1 submitted 7 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
The Milky Way's rotation curve with superfluid dark matter
Authors:
Sabine Hossenfelder,
Tobias Mistele
Abstract:
Recent studies have shown that dark matter with a superfluid phase in which phonons mediate a long-distance force gives rise to the phenomenologically well-established regularities of Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND). Superfluid dark matter, therefore, has emerged as a promising explanation for astrophysical observations by combining the benefits of both particle dark matter and MOND, or its rel…
▽ More
Recent studies have shown that dark matter with a superfluid phase in which phonons mediate a long-distance force gives rise to the phenomenologically well-established regularities of Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND). Superfluid dark matter, therefore, has emerged as a promising explanation for astrophysical observations by combining the benefits of both particle dark matter and MOND, or its relativistic completions, respectively. We here investigate whether superfluid dark matter can reproduce the observed Milky Way rotation curve for $ R < 25\,\rm{kpc}$ and are able to answer this question in the affirmative. Our analysis demonstrates that superfluid dark matter fits the data well with parameters in reasonable ranges. The most notable difference between superfluid dark matter and MOND is that superfluid dark matter requires about $ 20\% $ less total baryonic mass (with a suitable interpolation function). The total baryonic mass is then $5.96 \cdot 10^{10}\,M_\odot$, of which $1.03\cdot10^{10}\,M_\odot$ are from the bulge, $3.95\cdot10^{10}\,M_\odot$ are from the stellar disk, and $0.98\cdot10^{10}\,M_\odot$ are from the gas disk. Our analysis further allows us to estimate the radius of the Milky Way's superfluid core (concretely, the so-called NFW and thermal radii) and the total mass of dark matter in both the superfluid and the normal phase. By varying the boundary conditions of the superfluid to give virial masses $M_{200}^{\rm{DM}}$ in the range $0.5-3.0\cdot10^{12}\,M_\odot$, we find that the NFW radius $R_{\rm{NFW}}$ varies between $65\,\rm{kpc}$ and $73\,\rm{kpc}$, while the thermal radius $R_T$ varies between about $67\,\rm{kpc}$ and $105\,\rm{kpc}$. This is the first such treatment of a non-spherically-symmetric system in superfluid dark matter.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2020; v1 submitted 16 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
The role of the chemical potential in coupling superfluid dark matter to baryons
Authors:
Tobias Mistele
Abstract:
Superfluid dark matter postulates that the centers of galaxies contain superfluid condensates. An important quantity regarding these superfluids is their chemical potential $ μ$. Here, we discuss two issues related to this chemical potential. First, there is no exactly conserved quantity associated with this chemical potential due to the symmetry-breaking baryon-phonon coupling. Second, $ μ$ is so…
▽ More
Superfluid dark matter postulates that the centers of galaxies contain superfluid condensates. An important quantity regarding these superfluids is their chemical potential $ μ$. Here, we discuss two issues related to this chemical potential. First, there is no exactly conserved quantity associated with this chemical potential due to the symmetry-breaking baryon-phonon coupling. Second, $ μ$ is sometimes introduced by shifting the phonon field by $ μ\cdot t $ which -- again due to the symmetry-breaking baryon-phonon coupling -- introduces an explicit time dependence in the Lagrangian. We investigate under which conditions introducing a chemical potential is nevertheless justified and show how to correctly introduce it when these conditions are met. We further propose a model that recovers superfluid dark matter's zero-temperature equations of motion including a chemical potential even if the aforementioned conditions for justifying a chemical potential are not met.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2019; v1 submitted 2 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Strong lensing with superfluid dark matter
Authors:
Sabine Hossenfelder,
Tobias Mistele
Abstract:
In superfluid dark matter the exchange of phonons can create an additional force that has an effect similar to Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND). To test whether this hypothesis is compatible with observation, we study a set of strong gravitational lenses from the SLACS survey and check whether the measurements can be explained by a superfluid in the central region of galaxies. Concretely, we try…
▽ More
In superfluid dark matter the exchange of phonons can create an additional force that has an effect similar to Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND). To test whether this hypothesis is compatible with observation, we study a set of strong gravitational lenses from the SLACS survey and check whether the measurements can be explained by a superfluid in the central region of galaxies. Concretely, we try to simultaneously fit each lens's Einstein radius and velocity dispersion with a spherically symmetric density profile of a fluid that has both a normal and a superfluid component. We demonstrate that we can successfully fit all galaxies except one, and that the fits have reasonable stellar mass-to-light-ratios. We conclude that strong gravitational lensing does not pose a challenge for the idea that superfluid dark matter mimics modified gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2019; v1 submitted 4 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Predicting Citation Counts with a Neural Network
Authors:
Tobias Mistele,
Tom Price,
Sabine Hossenfelder
Abstract:
We here describe and present results of a simple neural network that predicts individual researchers' future citation counts based on a variety of data from the researchers' past. For publications available on the open access-server arXiv.org we find a higher predictability than previous studies.
We here describe and present results of a simple neural network that predicts individual researchers' future citation counts based on a variety of data from the researchers' past. For publications available on the open access-server arXiv.org we find a higher predictability than previous studies.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2018; v1 submitted 12 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
The Redshift-Dependence of Radial Acceleration: Modified Gravity versus Particle Dark Matter
Authors:
Sabine Hossenfelder,
Tobias Mistele
Abstract:
Modified Newtonian Dynamics has one free parameter and requires an interpolation function to recover the normal Newtonian limit. We here show that this interpolation function is unnecessary in a recently proposed covariant completion of Erik Verlinde's emergent gravity, and that Verlinde's approach moreover fixes the function's one free parameter. The so-derived correlation between the observed ac…
▽ More
Modified Newtonian Dynamics has one free parameter and requires an interpolation function to recover the normal Newtonian limit. We here show that this interpolation function is unnecessary in a recently proposed covariant completion of Erik Verlinde's emergent gravity, and that Verlinde's approach moreover fixes the function's one free parameter. The so-derived correlation between the observed acceleration (inferred from rotation curves) and the gravitational acceleration due to merely the baryonic matter fits well with data. We then argue that the redshift-dependence of galactic rotation curves could offer a way to tell apart different versions of modified gravity from particle dark matter.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Classical stability of higher-derivative q-theory in the four-form-field-strength realization
Authors:
F. R. Klinkhamer,
T. Mistele
Abstract:
We show that higher-derivative $q$-theory in the four-form-field-strength realization does not suffer from the Ostrogradsky instability at the classical level.
We show that higher-derivative $q$-theory in the four-form-field-strength realization does not suffer from the Ostrogradsky instability at the classical level.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2017; v1 submitted 18 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
