-
Validation of Sinus Drug Delivery Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) Modeling with In Vitro Gamma Scintigraphy
Authors:
K. Kudlaty,
W. Bennett,
L. Holbrook,
A. Burke,
J. Wu,
B. Langworthy,
J. P. Fine,
C. S. Ebert Jr.,
A. J. Kimple,
B. D. Thorp,
A. M. Zanation,
B. A. Senior,
J. S. Kimbell
Abstract:
Background: Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) is a prevalent and disruptive disease. Medical management including nasal steroid sprays is the primary treatment modality. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) has been used to characterize sinonasal airflow and intranasal drug delivery; however, variation in simulation methods indicates a need for large scale CFD model validation.
Methods: Anatomic recons…
▽ More
Background: Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) is a prevalent and disruptive disease. Medical management including nasal steroid sprays is the primary treatment modality. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) has been used to characterize sinonasal airflow and intranasal drug delivery; however, variation in simulation methods indicates a need for large scale CFD model validation.
Methods: Anatomic reconstructions of pre and post-operative CT scans of 3 functional endoscopic sinus surgery patients were created in Mimics(TM). Fluid analysis and drug particle deposition modeling were conducted using CFD methods with Fluent(TM) in 18 cases. Models were 3D printed and in vitro studies were performed using Tc99-labeled Nasacort(TM). Gamma scintigraphy signals and CFD-modeled spray mass were post-processed in a superimposed grid and compared. Statistical analysis using overlap coefficients (OCs) evaluated similarities between computational and experimental distributions and Kendall's tau rank correlation coefficient was employed to test independence.
Results: OCs revealed strong agreement in percent deposition and grid profiles between CFD models and experimental results (mean [range] for sagittal, axial, and coronal grids were 0.69 [0.57], 0.61 [0.49], and 0.78 [0.44], respectively). Kendall's tau values showed strong agreement (average 0.73) between distributions, which were statistically significant (p < 0.05) apart from a single coronal grid in one model and two sagittal grids of another.
Conclusions: CFD modeling demonstrates statistical agreement with in vitro experimental results. This validation study is one of the largest of its kind and supports the applicability of CFD in accurately modeling nasal spray drug delivery and using computational methods to investigate means of improving clinical drug delivery.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Numerical evaluation of spray position for improved nasal drug delivery
Authors:
Saikat Basu,
Landon T Holbrook,
Kathryn Kudlaty,
Olulade Fasanmade,
Jihong Wu,
Alyssa Burke,
Benjamin Langworthy,
Zainab Farzal,
Mohammed Mamdani,
William D Bennett,
Jason Fine,
Brent A Senior,
Adam M Zanation,
Charles S Ebert, Jr.,
Adam J Kimple,
Brian D Thorp,
Dennis O Frank-Ito,
Guilherme JM Garcia,
Julia S Kimbell
Abstract:
Topical intra-nasal sprays are amongst the most commonly prescribed therapeutic options for sinonasal diseases in humans. However, inconsistency and ambiguity in instructions show a lack of definitive knowledge on best spray use techniques. In this study, we have identified a new usage strategy for nasal sprays available over-the-counter, that registers an average 8-fold improvement in topical del…
▽ More
Topical intra-nasal sprays are amongst the most commonly prescribed therapeutic options for sinonasal diseases in humans. However, inconsistency and ambiguity in instructions show a lack of definitive knowledge on best spray use techniques. In this study, we have identified a new usage strategy for nasal sprays available over-the-counter, that registers an average 8-fold improvement in topical delivery of drugs at diseased sites, when compared to prevalent spray techniques. The protocol involves re-orienting the spray axis to harness inertial motion of particulates and has been developed using computational fluid dynamics simulations of respiratory airflow and droplet transport in medical imaging-based digital models. Simulated dose in representative models is validated through in vitro spray measurements in 3D-printed anatomic replicas using the gamma scintigraphy technique. This work breaks new ground in proposing an alternative user-friendly strategy that can significantly enhance topical delivery inside human nose. While these findings can eventually translate into personalized spray usage instructions and hence merit a change in nasal standard-of-care, this study also demonstrates how relatively simple engineering analysis tools can revolutionize everyday healthcare.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2019; v1 submitted 26 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Comparative Analysis of the Main Nasal Cavity and the Paranasal Sinuses in Chronic Rhinosinusitis: An Anatomic Study of Maximal Medical Therapy
Authors:
Satyan B. Sreenath,
Julia S. Kimbell,
Saikat Basu,
Andrew J. Coniglio,
Tatayana E. Fontenot,
Brian D. Thorp,
Charles S. Ebert,
Brent A. Senior,
Adam M. Zanation
Abstract:
Objective: Minimal literature exists investigating changes in inflammation with respect to the main nasal cavity (MNC) and paranasal sinuses (PS) before and after maximal medical therapy (MMT) for chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS). We hypothesized that MMT produces a differential level of change in the volume of air space in the MNC and PS, and that resolution of mucosal disease associated with the ost…
▽ More
Objective: Minimal literature exists investigating changes in inflammation with respect to the main nasal cavity (MNC) and paranasal sinuses (PS) before and after maximal medical therapy (MMT) for chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS). We hypothesized that MMT produces a differential level of change in the volume of air space in the MNC and PS, and that resolution of mucosal disease associated with the osteomeatal complex (OMC) influences clinical response to MMT. Study Design: Retrospective study of 12 pre- and post-MMT sinus-CT scans from 6 subjects with CRS, of which three succeeded and three failed therapy. Methods: Mimics was used to create 3D-models of the MNC and PS, and then analysis of the models was performed. Results: Mean differences in the sinonasal volume were 7866.5+/-4339.9 mm3 and 17869.10+/-19472.70 mm3, amongst the failures and successes, respectively. There is wide variability in the contribution of PS and MNC airspace volume change to the overall change in the sinonasal volume. In two subjects, the direction of volume change in the MNC and PS diverged with respect to the overall change in volume. Line-of-sight analysis demonstrated that successful responders to MMT had more patent MNC with direct access to the OMC. Conclusions: There is a differential contribution to sinonasal, airspace volume change after MMT, when comparing the MNC and PS. Response to MMT may not be solely attributable to PS change and may include a function of MNC change. Line-of-sight models suggest that direct access to the OMC may impact response to MMT.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Comparative Study of Simulated Nebulized and Spray Particle Deposition in Chronic Rhinosinusitis Patients
Authors:
Zainab Farzal,
Saikat Basu,
Alyssa Burke,
Olulade O. Fasanmade,
Erin M. Mamuyac,
William D. Bennett,
Charles S. Ebert Jr,
Adam M. Zanation,
Brent A. Senior,
Julia S. Kimbell
Abstract:
Introduction: Topical intranasal drugs are widely prescribed for Chronic Rhinosinusitis (CRS), although delivery can vary with device type and droplet size. The study objective was to compare nebulized and sprayed droplet deposition in the paranasal sinuses and ostiomeatal complex (OMC) across multiple droplet sizes in CRS patients using computational fluid dynamics (CFD). Methods: Three-dimension…
▽ More
Introduction: Topical intranasal drugs are widely prescribed for Chronic Rhinosinusitis (CRS), although delivery can vary with device type and droplet size. The study objective was to compare nebulized and sprayed droplet deposition in the paranasal sinuses and ostiomeatal complex (OMC) across multiple droplet sizes in CRS patients using computational fluid dynamics (CFD). Methods: Three-dimensional models of sinonasal cavities were constructed from computed tomography (CT) scans of three subjects with CRS refractory to medical therapy using imaging software. Assuming steady-state inspiratory airflow at resting rate, CFD was used to simulate 1-120 μm sprayed droplet deposition in the left and right sinuses and OMC with spray nozzle positioning as in current nasal spray use instructions. Zero-velocity nebulization simulations were performed for 1-30 μm droplet sizes, maximal sinus and OMC deposition fractions (MSDF) were obtained, and sizes that achieved at least 50% of MSDF were identified. Nebulized MSDF was compared to sprayed droplet deposition. We also validated CFD framework through in vitro experiments. Results: Among nebulized droplet sizes, 11-14 μm droplets achieved at least 50% of MSDF in all six sinonasal cavities. Five of six sinonasal cavities had greater sinus and OMC deposition with nebulized droplets than with sprayed droplets at optimal sizes. Conclusions: Nebulized droplets may target the sinuses and OMC more effectively than sprayed particles at sizes achieving best deposition. Further studies are needed to confirm our preliminary findings. Several commercial nasal nebulizers have average particle sizes outside the optimal nebulized droplet size range found here, suggesting potential for product enhancement.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
