Showing 1–50 of 59 results for author: Agarwalla, B K

Effect of order of transfer matrix exceptional points on transport at band edges

Authors: Madhumita Saha, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Manas Kulkarni, Archak Purkayastha

Abstract: Recently, it has been shown that, in one dimensional fermionic systems, close to band edges, the zero temperature conductance scales as $1/N^2$, where $N$ is the system length. This universal subdiffusive scaling of conductance at band edges has been tied to an exceptional point (EP) of the transfer matrix of the system that occur at every band edge. Further, in presence of bulk dephasing probes,… ▽ More Recently, it has been shown that, in one dimensional fermionic systems, close to band edges, the zero temperature conductance scales as $1/N^2$, where $N$ is the system length. This universal subdiffusive scaling of conductance at band edges has been tied to an exceptional point (EP) of the transfer matrix of the system that occur at every band edge. Further, in presence of bulk dephasing probes, this EP has been shown to lead to a counterintuitive superballistic scaling of conductance, where the conductance increases with $N$ over a finite but large regime of system lengths. In this work, we explore how these behaviors are affected by the order of the transfer matrix EP at the band edge. We consider a one-dimensional fermionic lattice chain with a finite range of hopping. Depending on the range of hopping and the hopping parameters, this system can feature band edges which correspond to arbitrarily higher order EPs of the associated transfer matrix. Using this system we establish in generality that, in absence of bulk dephasing, surprisingly, the universal $1/N^2$ scaling of conductance is completely unaffected by the order of the EP. This is despite the fact that existence of transfer matrix EP is crucial for such behavior. In presence of bulk dephasing, however, the phase coherence length, the extent of the superballisitic scaling regime and the exponent of superballistic scaling, all encode the order of the transfer matrix EP. △ Less

Submitted 15 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Super-ballistic transport in an open quantum ring

Authors: Moumita Patra, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Santanu K. Maiti

Abstract: When the degeneracies of the ring-Hamiltonian are removed by the asymmetric ring-to-electrodes configuration for an open quantum ring (OQR), the overall junction transmission function exhibits fano-type antiresonance, resulting a net circular current appears within the channel, that is the ring around the degenerate energy levels of the ring-Hamiltonian. We investigate the system size scaling prop… ▽ More When the degeneracies of the ring-Hamiltonian are removed by the asymmetric ring-to-electrodes configuration for an open quantum ring (OQR), the overall junction transmission function exhibits fano-type antiresonance, resulting a net circular current appears within the channel, that is the ring around the degenerate energy levels of the ring-Hamiltonian. We investigate the system size scaling properties of the channel conductance and the overall junction conductance of an OQR. Ballistic transport is the unhindered flow of a charge carrier within a conductor. Here we find beyond-ballistic transport near both the degenerate and non-degenerate eigenenergies of the ring-Hamiltonian, depending on the ring-to-lead configuration. This is a purely OQR phenomenon associated with the quantum interference effect between two counter-propagating electronic waves having nearly equal and opposite momenta. Thus there is no equivalent phenomenon in open quantum junctions with linear channel. △ Less

Submitted 8 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: 9 pages, 10 figures

Anomalous transport in long-ranged open quantum systems

Authors: Abhinav Dhawan, Katha Ganguly, Manas Kulkarni, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We consider a one-dimensional fermionic lattice system with long-ranged power-law decaying hopping with exponent $α$. The system is further subjected to dephasing noise in the bulk. We investigate two variants of the problem: (i) an open quantum system where the setup is further subjected to boundary reservoirs enabling the scenario of a non-equilibrium steady state charge transport, and (ii) time… ▽ More We consider a one-dimensional fermionic lattice system with long-ranged power-law decaying hopping with exponent $α$. The system is further subjected to dephasing noise in the bulk. We investigate two variants of the problem: (i) an open quantum system where the setup is further subjected to boundary reservoirs enabling the scenario of a non-equilibrium steady state charge transport, and (ii) time dynamics of an initially localized single particle excitation in the absence of boundary reservoirs. In both variants, anomalous super-diffusive behavior is observed for $1< α< 1.5$, and for $α> 1.5$ the setup is effectively short-ranged and exhibits conventional diffusive transport. Our findings are supported by analytical calculations based on the multiple-scale analysis technique that leads to the emergence of a fractional diffusion equation for the density profile. Our study unravels an interesting interplay between long-range interaction and dephasing mechanism that could result in the emergence of unconventional behaviour in open quantum systems. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: 9 pages, 3 figures

Impact of dephasing probes on incommensurate lattices

Authors: Bishal Ghosh, Sandipan Mohanta, Manas Kulkarni, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We investigate open quantum dynamics for a one-dimensional incommensurate Aubry-André-Harper lattice chain, a part of which is initially filled with electrons and is further connected to dephasing probes at the filled lattice sites. This setup is akin to a step-initial configuration where the non-zero part of the step is subjected to dephasing. We investigate the quantum dynamics of local electron… ▽ More We investigate open quantum dynamics for a one-dimensional incommensurate Aubry-André-Harper lattice chain, a part of which is initially filled with electrons and is further connected to dephasing probes at the filled lattice sites. This setup is akin to a step-initial configuration where the non-zero part of the step is subjected to dephasing. We investigate the quantum dynamics of local electron density, the scaling of the density front as a function of time both inside and outside of the initial step, and the growth of the total number of electrons outside the step. We analyze these quantities in all three regimes, namely, the de-localized, critical, and localized phases of the underlying lattice. Outside the initial step, we observe that the density front spreads according to the underlying nature of single-particle states of the lattice, for both the de-localized and critical phases. For the localized phase, the spread of the density front hints at a logarithmic behaviour in time that has no parallel in the isolated case (\emph{i.e.}, in the absence of probes). Inside the initial step, due to the presence of the probes, the density front spreads in a diffusive manner for all the phases. This combination of rich and different dynamical behaviour, outside and inside the initial step, results in the emergence of mixed dynamical phases. While the total occupation of electrons remains conserved, the value outside or inside the initial step turns out to have a rich dynamical behaviour. Our work is widely adaptable and has interesting consequences when disordered/quasi-disordered systems are subjected to a thermodynamically large number of probes. △ Less

Submitted 19 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 18 pages, 8 figures

Impact of dephasing on non-equilibrium steady-state transport in fermionic chains with long-range hopping

Authors: Subhajit Sarkar, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Devendra Singh Bhakuni

Abstract: Quantum transport in a non-equilibrium setting plays a fundamental role in understanding the properties of systems ranging from quantum devices to biological systems. Dephasing -- a key aspect of out-of-equilibrium systems -- arises from the interactions with the noisy environment and can profoundly modify transport features. Here, we investigate the impact of dephasing on the non-equilibrium stea… ▽ More Quantum transport in a non-equilibrium setting plays a fundamental role in understanding the properties of systems ranging from quantum devices to biological systems. Dephasing -- a key aspect of out-of-equilibrium systems -- arises from the interactions with the noisy environment and can profoundly modify transport features. Here, we investigate the impact of dephasing on the non-equilibrium steady-state transport properties of non-interacting fermions on a one-dimensional lattice with long-range hopping ($\sim \frac{1}{r^α}$). We show the emergence of distinct transport regimes as the long-range hopping parameter $α$ is tuned. In the short-range limit ($α\gg 1$), transport is diffusive, while for the long-range limit ($α\sim \mathcal{O}(1)$), we observe a super-diffusive transport regime. Using the numerical simulation of the Lindblad master equation, and corroborated with the analysis of the current operator norm, we identify a critical long-range hopping parameter, $α_c \approx 1.5$, below which super-diffusive transport becomes evident that quickly becomes independent of the dephasing strength. Interstingly, within the super-diffusive regime, we find a crossover from logarithmic to power-law system-size dependence in the non-equilibrium steady-state resistance when $α$ varies from $α\leq 1$ to $α\lesssim 1.5$. Our results, thus, elucidate the intricate balance between dephasing and unitary dynamics, revealing novel steady-state transport features. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 2023; v1 submitted 2 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: Comments are welcome

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 109, 165408 (2024)

Study of non-equilibrium Green's functions beyond Born approximation in open quantum systems

Authors: Katha Ganguly, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We provide a systematic approach to compute different kinds of non-equilibrium Green's functions for open quantum systems which are essentially two-point correlation functions in time. We reveal that the definition of Green's functions based on the Born approximation does not provide the correct results in the leading order of the system-bath coupling. We next provide a systematic correction term… ▽ More We provide a systematic approach to compute different kinds of non-equilibrium Green's functions for open quantum systems which are essentially two-point correlation functions in time. We reveal that the definition of Green's functions based on the Born approximation does not provide the correct results in the leading order of the system-bath coupling. We next provide a systematic correction term in Green's functions by going beyond the Born approximation and incorporating a finite correlation between the system and the bath. We primarily focus on two paradigmatic models of open quantum systems, namely, the dissipative Caldeira-Leggett model and the dissipative spin-boson model. We show that the inclusion of such a correction correctly reproduces the Kadanoff-Baym type equation for the so-called lesser or greater components of the Green's functions and provides the correct long-time result up to the first non-zero order of the system-bath coupling, satisfying the detailed balance condition in thermal equilibrium. We further extend our study to a system coupled to multiple reservoirs simultaneously that are maintained at different temperatures and obtain expressions for non-equilibrium steady-state energy current, once again correct up to the first non-zero order of the system-bath coupling. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 20 pages

Full statistics of non-equilibrium heat and work for many-body quantum Otto engines and universal bounds: A non-equilibrium Green's function approach

Authors: Sandipan Mohanta, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We consider a generic four-stroke quantum Otto engine consisting of two unitary and two thermalization strokes with an arbitrary many-body working medium. Using the Schwinger-Keldysh non-equilibrium Green's function formalism, we provide an analytical expression for the cumulant generating function corresponding to the joint probability distribution of non-equilibrium work and heat. The obtained r… ▽ More We consider a generic four-stroke quantum Otto engine consisting of two unitary and two thermalization strokes with an arbitrary many-body working medium. Using the Schwinger-Keldysh non-equilibrium Green's function formalism, we provide an analytical expression for the cumulant generating function corresponding to the joint probability distribution of non-equilibrium work and heat. The obtained result is valid up to the second order of the external driving amplitude. We then focus on the linear response limit and obtain Onsager's transport coefficients for the generic Otto cycle and showed that the traditional fluctuation-dissipation relation for the total work is violated in the quantum domain, whereas for heat it is preserved. This leads to remarkable consequences in obtaining universal constraints on heat and work fluctuations for engine and refrigerator regimes of the Otto cycle and further allows us to make connections to the thermodynamic uncertainty relations. These findings are illustrated using a paradigmatic model that can be feasibly implemented in experiments. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2023; v1 submitted 10 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Modified quantum regression theorem and consistency with Kubo-Martin-Schwinger condition

Authors: Sakil Khan, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Sachin Jain

Abstract: We show that the long-time limit of the two-point correlation function obtained via the standard quantum regression theorem, a standard tool to compute correlation functions in open quantum systems, does not respect the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger equilibrium condition to the non-zero order of the system-bath coupling. We then follow the recently developed Heisenberg operator method for open quantum sys… ▽ More We show that the long-time limit of the two-point correlation function obtained via the standard quantum regression theorem, a standard tool to compute correlation functions in open quantum systems, does not respect the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger equilibrium condition to the non-zero order of the system-bath coupling. We then follow the recently developed Heisenberg operator method for open quantum systems and by applying a ``{\it weak}" Markov approximation, derive a new modified version of the quantum regression theorem that not only respects the KMS condition but further predicts exact answers for certain paradigmatic models in specific limits. We also show that in cases where the modified quantum regression theorem does not match with exact answers, it always performs better than the standard quantum regression theorem. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 10 pages, 1 figure

Exceptional hypersurfaces of transfer matrices of finite-range lattice models and their consequences on quantum transport properties

Authors: Madhumita Saha, Manas Kulkarni, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We investigate the emergence and corresponding nature of exceptional points located on exceptional hyper-surfaces of non-hermitian transfer matrices for finite-range one-dimensional lattice models. We unravel the non-trivial role of these exceptional points in determining the system size scaling of electrical conductance in non-equilibrium steady state. We observe that the band edges of the system… ▽ More We investigate the emergence and corresponding nature of exceptional points located on exceptional hyper-surfaces of non-hermitian transfer matrices for finite-range one-dimensional lattice models. We unravel the non-trivial role of these exceptional points in determining the system size scaling of electrical conductance in non-equilibrium steady state. We observe that the band edges of the system always correspond to the transfer matrix exceptional points. Interestingly, albeit the lower band edge always occurs at wave-vector $k=0$, the upper band edge may or may not correspond to $k=π$. Nonetheless, in all the cases, the system exhibits universal subdiffusive transport for conductance at every band edge with scaling $N^{-b}$ with scaling exponent $b= 2$. However, for cases when the upper band edge is not located at $k=π$, the conductance features interesting oscillations with overall $N^{-2}$ scaling. Our work further reveals that this setup is uniquely suited to systematically generate higher order transfer matrix exceptional points at upper band edge when one considers finite range hoppings beyond nearest neighbour. Additional exceptional points other than those at band edges are shown to occur, although interestingly, these do not give rise to anomalous transport. △ Less

Submitted 31 October, 2023; v1 submitted 6 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Quantum coherent control of nonlinear thermoelectric transport in a triple-dot Aharonov-Bohm heat engine

Authors: Jayasmita Behera, Salil Bedkihal, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Malay Bandyopadhyay

Abstract: We investigate the role of quantum coherence and higher harmonics resulting from multiple-path interference in nonlinear thermoelectricity in a two-terminal triangular triple-dot Aharonov-Bohm (AB) interferometer. We quantify the trade-off between efficiency and power in the nonlinear regime of our simple setup comprising three non-interacting quantum dots (two connected to two biased metallic res… ▽ More We investigate the role of quantum coherence and higher harmonics resulting from multiple-path interference in nonlinear thermoelectricity in a two-terminal triangular triple-dot Aharonov-Bohm (AB) interferometer. We quantify the trade-off between efficiency and power in the nonlinear regime of our simple setup comprising three non-interacting quantum dots (two connected to two biased metallic reservoirs) placed at the vertex of an equilateral triangle, and a magnetic flux $Φ$ pierces it perpendicularly. For a spatially symmetric setup, we achieve optimal efficiency and power output when the inter-dot tunneling strength is comparable to the dot-lead coupling, AB phase $φ=π/2$. Our analysis reveals that the presence of higher harmonics is necessary but not sufficient to achieve optimal power output. The maximal constructive interference represented by three close-packed resonance peaks of the unit transmission can enhance the power output ($P_{max}\sim 2.35\,\mathrm{fW}$) almost 3.5 times as compared to the case where only a single channel participates in the transport, and the corresponding efficiency is about $0.80η_{c}$ where $η_{c}$ is the Carnot efficiency. Geometric asymmetries and their effects on efficiency and power output are also investigated. An asymmetric setup characterized by the ratio of the coupling to the source and the drain terminals ($x$) can further enhance the maximum power output $P_{max}\sim 3.85\,\mathrm{fW}$ for $x=1.5$ with the same efficiency as that of the symmetric case. Our investigation reveals that the output power and efficiency are optimal in the wide-band limit. The power output is significantly reduced for the narrow-band case. On the other hand, disorder effects radically reduce the performance of the heat engine. △ Less

Submitted 9 November, 2023; v1 submitted 16 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 108, 165419 (2023)

Filling an empty lattice by local injection of quantum particles

Authors: Akash Trivedi, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Abhishek Dhar, Manas Kulkarni, Anupam Kundu, Sanjib Sabhapandit

Abstract: We study the quantum dynamics of filling an empty lattice of size $L$, by connecting it locally with an equilibrium thermal bath that injects non-interacting bosons or fermions. We adopt four different approaches, namely (i) direct exact numerics, (ii) Redfield equation, (iii) Lindblad equation, and (iv) quantum Langevin equation -- which are unique in their ways for solving the time dynamics and… ▽ More We study the quantum dynamics of filling an empty lattice of size $L$, by connecting it locally with an equilibrium thermal bath that injects non-interacting bosons or fermions. We adopt four different approaches, namely (i) direct exact numerics, (ii) Redfield equation, (iii) Lindblad equation, and (iv) quantum Langevin equation -- which are unique in their ways for solving the time dynamics and the steady-state. Our setup offers a simplistic platform to understand fundamental aspects of dynamics and approach to thermalization. The quantities of interest that we consider are the spatial density profile and the total number of bosons/fermions in the lattice. The spatial spread is ballistic in nature and the local occupation eventually settles down owing to equilibration. The ballistic spread of local density admits a universal scaling form. We show that this universality is only seen when the condition of detailed balance is satisfied by the baths. The difference between bosons and fermions shows up in the early time growth rate and the saturation values of the profile. The techniques developed here are applicable to systems in arbitrary dimensions and for arbitrary geometries. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 18 pages, 10 figures

Study of bounds on non-equilibrium fluctuations for asymmetrically driven quantum Otto engine

Authors: Sandipan Mohanta, Madhumita Saha, B. Prasanna Venkatesh, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: For a four-stroke asymmetrically driven quantum Otto engine with working medium modeled by a single qubit, we study the bounds on non-equilibrium fluctuations of work and heat. We find strict relations between the fluctuations of work and individual heat for hot and cold reservoirs in arbitrary operational regimes. Focusing on the engine regime, we show that the ratio of non-equilibrium fluctuatio… ▽ More For a four-stroke asymmetrically driven quantum Otto engine with working medium modeled by a single qubit, we study the bounds on non-equilibrium fluctuations of work and heat. We find strict relations between the fluctuations of work and individual heat for hot and cold reservoirs in arbitrary operational regimes. Focusing on the engine regime, we show that the ratio of non-equilibrium fluctuations of output work to input heat from the hot reservoir is both upper and lower bounded. As a consequence, we establish hierarchical relation between the relative fluctuations of work and heat for both cold and hot reservoirs and further make a connection with the thermodynamic uncertainty relations. We discuss the fate of these bounds also in the refrigerator regime. The reported bounds, for such asymmetrically driven engines, emerge once both the time-forward and the corresponding reversed cycles of the engine are considered on an equal footing. We also extend our study and report bounds for a parametrically driven harmonic oscillator Otto engine. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2023; v1 submitted 11 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: 14 pages, 6 figures

Environment assisted superballistic scaling of conductance

Authors: Madhumita Saha, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Manas Kulkarni, Archak Purkayastha

Abstract: We find that, in the presence of weak incoherent effects from surrounding environments, the zero temperature conductance of nearest neighbour tight-binding chains exhibits a counter-intuitive power-law growth with system length at band-edges, indicating superballistic scaling. This fascinating environment assisted superballistic scaling of conductance occurs over a finite but extended regime of sy… ▽ More We find that, in the presence of weak incoherent effects from surrounding environments, the zero temperature conductance of nearest neighbour tight-binding chains exhibits a counter-intuitive power-law growth with system length at band-edges, indicating superballistic scaling. This fascinating environment assisted superballistic scaling of conductance occurs over a finite but extended regime of system lengths. This scaling regime can be systematically expanded by decreasing the coupling to the surrounding environments. There is no corresponding analog of this behavior for isolated systems. This superballistic scaling stems from an intricate interplay of incoherent effects from surrounding environments and exceptional points of the system's transfer matrix that occur at every band-edge. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2023; v1 submitted 8 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Universal subdiffusive behavior at band edges from transfer matrix exceptional points

Authors: Madhumita Saha, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Manas Kulkarni, Archak Purkayastha

Abstract: We discover a deep connection between parity-time (PT) symmetric optical systems and quantum transport in one-dimensional fermionic chains in a two-terminal open system setting. The spectrum of one dimensional tight-binding chain with periodic on-site potential can be obtained by casting the problem in terms of $2 \times 2$ transfer matrices. We find that these non-Hermitian matrices have a symmet… ▽ More We discover a deep connection between parity-time (PT) symmetric optical systems and quantum transport in one-dimensional fermionic chains in a two-terminal open system setting. The spectrum of one dimensional tight-binding chain with periodic on-site potential can be obtained by casting the problem in terms of $2 \times 2$ transfer matrices. We find that these non-Hermitian matrices have a symmetry exactly analogous to the PT-symmetry of balanced-gain-loss optical systems, and hence show analogous transitions across exceptional points. We show that the exceptional points of the transfer matrix of a unit cell correspond to the band edges of the spectrum. When connected to two zero temperature baths at two ends, this consequently leads to subdiffusive scaling of conductance with system size, with an exponent $2$, if the chemical potential of the baths are equal to the band edges. We further demonstrate the existence of a dissipative quantum phase transition as the chemical potential is tuned across any band edge. Remarkably, this feature is analogous to transition across a mobility edge in quasiperiodic systems. This behavior is universal, irrespective of the details of the periodic potential and the number of bands of the underlying lattice. It, however, has no analog in absence of the baths. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2023; v1 submitted 4 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Precision bound and optimal control in periodically modulated continuous quantum thermal machines

Authors: Arpan Das, Shishira Mahunta, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Victor Mukherjee

Abstract: We use Floquet formalism to study fluctuations in periodically modulated continuous quantum thermal machines. We present a generic theory for such machines, followed by specific examples of sinusoidal, optimal, and circular modulations respectively. The thermodynamic uncertainty relations (TUR) hold for all modulations considered. Interestingly, in the case of sinusoidal modulation, the TUR ratio… ▽ More We use Floquet formalism to study fluctuations in periodically modulated continuous quantum thermal machines. We present a generic theory for such machines, followed by specific examples of sinusoidal, optimal, and circular modulations respectively. The thermodynamic uncertainty relations (TUR) hold for all modulations considered. Interestingly, in the case of sinusoidal modulation, the TUR ratio assumes a minimum at the heat engine to refrigerator transition point, while the Chopped Random Basis (CRAB) optimization protocol allows us to keep the ratio small for a wide range of modulation frequencies. Furthermore, our numerical analysis suggests that TUR can show signatures of heat engine to refrigerator transition, for more generic modulation schemes. We also study bounds in fluctuations in the efficiencies of such machines; our results indicate that fluctuations in efficiencies are bounded from above for a refrigerator, and from below for an engine. Overall, this study emphasizes the crucial role played by different modulation schemes in designing practical quantum thermal machines. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2023; v1 submitted 29 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 17 pages, 6 figures. Close to published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev E 108, 014137 (2023)

Quantum transport in quasi-periodic lattice systems in presence of Büttiker probes

Authors: Madhumita Saha, B. Prasanna Venkatesh, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: Quasi-periodic lattice systems offer diverse transport properties. In this work, we investigate the environment induced effects on transport properties for quasi-periodic systems, namely the one-dimensional Aubry-André-Harper (AAH) lattice chain and its generalized version (GAAH) by considering the Büttiker probe approach. We first consider voltage probe situation and study the electrical conducta… ▽ More Quasi-periodic lattice systems offer diverse transport properties. In this work, we investigate the environment induced effects on transport properties for quasi-periodic systems, namely the one-dimensional Aubry-André-Harper (AAH) lattice chain and its generalized version (GAAH) by considering the Büttiker probe approach. We first consider voltage probe situation and study the electrical conductance properties in the linear response regime. At zero temperature, we observe enhancement in conductance at all the no-transport regimes, located both inside and outside of the band of the original system, for small probe coupling strength $γ$ with a power-law scaling $γ^4$. Whereas, for large probe coupling strengths, the conductance at all Fermi energies is the same and decays as a power-law with scaling $1/γ^4$. This particular scaling survives even in the finite-temperature limit. Interestingly, this scaling result is different from the one recently predicted following the local Lindblad master equation approach. The transport eventually becomes diffusive for all energy ranges and in all regimes of the original model for a sufficiently strong coupling with the probes. We further extend our study and consider voltage-temperature probes to analyze the thermoelectric performance of the chain in terms of the figure of merit. We also demonstrate the validity of two recently obtained bounds on thermoelectric efficiency that are tighter than the seminal Carnot bound and express the same in terms of the Onsager's transport coefficients. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2022; v1 submitted 28 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Counting statistics of energy transport across squeezed thermal reservoirs

Authors: Hari Kumar Yadalam, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Upendra Harbola

Abstract: A general formalism for computing the full counting statistics of energy exchanged between 'N' squeezed thermal photon reservoirs weakly coupled to a cavity with 'M' photon modes is presented. The formalism is based on the two-point measurement scheme and is applied to two simple special cases, the relaxation dynamics of a single mode cavity in contact with a single squeezed thermal photon reservo… ▽ More A general formalism for computing the full counting statistics of energy exchanged between 'N' squeezed thermal photon reservoirs weakly coupled to a cavity with 'M' photon modes is presented. The formalism is based on the two-point measurement scheme and is applied to two simple special cases, the relaxation dynamics of a single mode cavity in contact with a single squeezed thermal photon reservoir and the steady-state energy transport between two squeezed thermal photon reservoirs coupled to a single cavity mode. Using analytical results, it is found that the short time statistics is significantly affected by noncommutivity of the initial energy measurements with the reservoirs squeezed states, and may lead to negative probabilities if not accounted properly. Furthermore, it is found that for the single reservoir setup, generically there is no transient or steady-state fluctuation theorems for energy transport. In contrast, for the two reservoir case, although there is no generic transient fluctuation theorem, steady-state fluctuation theorem with a non-universal affinity is found to be valid. Statistics of energy currents are further discussed. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 13 pages and 3 figures

Universal bounds on fluctuations for machines with broken time-reversal symmetry

Authors: Sushant Saryal, Sandipan Mohanta, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: For a generic class of machines with broken time-reversal symmetry we show that in the linear response regime the relative fluctuation of the sum of output currents for time-forward and time-reversed processes is always lower bounded by the corresponding relative fluctuation of the sum of input currents. This bound is received when the same operating condition, for example, engine, refrigerator or… ▽ More For a generic class of machines with broken time-reversal symmetry we show that in the linear response regime the relative fluctuation of the sum of output currents for time-forward and time-reversed processes is always lower bounded by the corresponding relative fluctuation of the sum of input currents. This bound is received when the same operating condition, for example, engine, refrigerator or pump, is imposed in both the forward and the reversed processes. As a consequence, universal upper and lower bounds for the ratio of fluctuations between the output and the input current is obtained. Furthermore, we establish an important connection between our results and the recently obtained generalized thermodynamic uncertainty relation for time-reversal symmetry broken systems. We illustrate these findings for two different types of machines: (i) a steady-state three-terminal quantum thermoelectric setup in presence of an external magnetic field, and (ii) a periodically driven classical Brownian heat engine. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 7 pages, 2 figures

Universal bounds on cooling power and cooling efficiency for autonomous absorption refrigerators

Authors: Sandipan Mohanta, Sushant Saryal, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: For steady-state autonomous absorption refrigerators operating in the linear response regime, we show that there exists a hierarchy between the relative fluctuation of currents for cold, hot, and work terminals. Our proof requires the Onsager's reciprocity relation along with the refrigeration condition that sets the direction of the mean currents for each terminal. As a consequence, the universal… ▽ More For steady-state autonomous absorption refrigerators operating in the linear response regime, we show that there exists a hierarchy between the relative fluctuation of currents for cold, hot, and work terminals. Our proof requires the Onsager's reciprocity relation along with the refrigeration condition that sets the direction of the mean currents for each terminal. As a consequence, the universal bounds on the mean cooling power, obtained following the thermodynamic uncertainty relations, receive a hierarchy. Interestingly, within this hierarchy, the tightest bound is given in terms of the work current fluctuation. Furthermore, the relative uncertainty hierarchy hands over additional bounds that can be tighter than the bounds obtained from the thermodynamic uncertainty relations. Interestingly, all of these bounds saturate in the tight-coupling limit. We test the validity of our results for two paradigmatic absorption refrigerator models: (i) a four-level working fluid and (ii) a two-level working fluid, operating, respectively, in the weak (additive) and in the strong (multiplicative) system-bath interaction regime. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2021; v1 submitted 24 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures

Sub-diffusive phases in open clean long-range systems

Authors: Archak Purkayastha, Madhumita Saha, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We show that a one-dimensional ordered fermionic lattice system with power-law-decaying hopping, when connected to two baths at its two ends with different chemical potentials at zero temperature, features two phases showing sub-diffusive scaling of conductance with system size. These phases have no analogues in the isolated system (i.e, in absence of the baths) where the transport is perfectly ba… ▽ More We show that a one-dimensional ordered fermionic lattice system with power-law-decaying hopping, when connected to two baths at its two ends with different chemical potentials at zero temperature, features two phases showing sub-diffusive scaling of conductance with system size. These phases have no analogues in the isolated system (i.e, in absence of the baths) where the transport is perfectly ballistic. In the open system scenario, interestingly, there occurs two chemical-potential-driven sub-diffusive to ballistic phase transitions at zero temperature. We discuss how these phase transitions, to our knowledge, are different from all the known non-equilibrium quantum phase transitions. We provide a clear understanding of the microscopic origin of these phases and argue that the sub-diffusive phases are robust against the presence of arbitrary number-conserving many-body interactions in the system. These phases showing sub-diffusive scaling of conductance with system size in a two-terminal set-up are therefore universal properties of all ordered one-dimensional number-conserving fermionic systems with power-law-decaying hopping at zero temperature. △ Less

Submitted 8 November, 2021; v1 submitted 10 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Bounds on fluctuations for finite-time quantum Otto cycle

Authors: Sushant Saryal, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: For finite-time quantum Otto heat engine with working fluid consisting of either a (i) qubit or (ii) a harmonic oscillator, we show that the relative fluctuation of output work is always greater than the corresponding relative fluctuation of input heat absorbed from the hot bath. As a result, the ratio between the work fluctuation and the input heat fluctuation receives a lower bound in terms of t… ▽ More For finite-time quantum Otto heat engine with working fluid consisting of either a (i) qubit or (ii) a harmonic oscillator, we show that the relative fluctuation of output work is always greater than the corresponding relative fluctuation of input heat absorbed from the hot bath. As a result, the ratio between the work fluctuation and the input heat fluctuation receives a lower bound in terms of the square value of the average efficiency of the engine. The saturation of the lower bound is received in the quasi-static limit of the engine and can be shown for a class of working fluids that follow a scale-invariant energy eigenspectra under driving. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 103, 060103 (2021)

Universal Bounds on Fluctuations in Continuous Thermal Machines

Authors: Sushant Saryal, Matthew Gerry, Ilia Khait, Dvira Segal, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We study bounds on ratios of fluctuations in steady-state time-reversal heat engines controlled by multi affinities. In the linear response regime, we prove that the relative fluctuations (precision) of the output current (power) is always lower-bounded by the relative fluctuations of the input current (heat current absorbed from the hot bath). As a consequence, the ratio between the fluctuations… ▽ More We study bounds on ratios of fluctuations in steady-state time-reversal heat engines controlled by multi affinities. In the linear response regime, we prove that the relative fluctuations (precision) of the output current (power) is always lower-bounded by the relative fluctuations of the input current (heat current absorbed from the hot bath). As a consequence, the ratio between the fluctuations of the output and input currents are bounded both from above and below, where the lower (upper) bound is determined by the square of the averaged efficiency (square of the Carnot efficiency) of the engine. The saturation of the lower bound is achieved in the tight-coupling limit when the determinant of the Onsager response matrix vanishes. Our analysis can be applied to different operational regimes, including engines, refrigerators, and heat pumps. We illustrate our findings in two types of continuous engines: two-terminal coherent thermoelectric junctions and three-terminal quantum absorption refrigerators. Numerical simulations in the far-from-equilibrium regime suggest that these bounds apply more broadly, beyond linear response. △ Less

Submitted 24 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Harmonic chains and the thermal diode effect

Authors: Na'im Kalantar, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Dvira Segal

Abstract: Harmonic oscillator chains connecting two harmonic reservoirs at different constant temperatures cannot act as thermal diodes, irrespective of structural asymmetry. However, here we prove that perfectly harmonic junctions can rectify heat once the reservoirs (described by white Langevin noise) are placed under temperature gradients, which are asymmetric at the two sides, an effect that we term "te… ▽ More Harmonic oscillator chains connecting two harmonic reservoirs at different constant temperatures cannot act as thermal diodes, irrespective of structural asymmetry. However, here we prove that perfectly harmonic junctions can rectify heat once the reservoirs (described by white Langevin noise) are placed under temperature gradients, which are asymmetric at the two sides, an effect that we term "temperature-gradient harmonic oscillator diodes". This nonlinear diode effect results from the additional constraint -- the imposed thermal gradient at the boundaries. We demonstrate the rectification behavior based on the exact analytical formulation of steady state heat transport in harmonic systems coupled to Langevin baths, which can describe quantum and classical transport, both regimes realizing the diode effect under the involved boundary conditions. Our study shows that asymmetric harmonic systems, such as room-temperature hydrocarbon molecules with varying side groups and end groups, or a linear lattice of trapped ions may rectify heat by going beyond simple boundary conditions. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 103, 052130 (2021)

Read-out of Quasi-periodic Systems using Qubits

Authors: Madhumita Saha, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, B. Prasanna Venkatesh

Abstract: We develop a theoretical scheme to perform a read-out of the properties of a quasi-periodic system by coupling it to one or two qubits. We show that the decoherence dynamics of a single qubit coupled via a pure dephasing type term to a 1D quasi-periodic system with a potential given by the André-Aubry-Harper (AAH) model and its generalized versions (GAAH model) is sensitive to the nature of the si… ▽ More We develop a theoretical scheme to perform a read-out of the properties of a quasi-periodic system by coupling it to one or two qubits. We show that the decoherence dynamics of a single qubit coupled via a pure dephasing type term to a 1D quasi-periodic system with a potential given by the André-Aubry-Harper (AAH) model and its generalized versions (GAAH model) is sensitive to the nature of the single particle eigenstates (SPEs). More specifically, we can use the non-markovianity of the qubit dynamics as quantified by the backflow of information to clearly distinguish the localized, delocalized, and mixed regimes with a mobility edge of the AAH and GAAH model and evidence the transition between them. By attaching two qubits at distinct sites of the system, we demonstrate that the transport property of the quasi-periodic system is encoded in the scaling of the threshold time to develop correlations between the qubits with the distance between the qubits. This scaling can also be used to distinguish and infer different regimes of transport such as ballistic, diffusive and no transport engendered by SPEs that are delocalized, critical and localized respectively. When there is a mobility edge allowing the coexistence of different kinds of SPEs in the spectrum, such as the coexistence of localized and delocalized states in the GAAH models, we find that the transport behaviour and the scaling of the threshold time with qubit separation is governed by the fastest spreading states. △ Less

Submitted 6 April, 2022; v1 submitted 27 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 103, 023330 (2021)

On the definitions and simulations of vibrational heat transport in nanojunctions

Authors: Na'im Kalantar, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Dvira Segal

Abstract: Thermal transport through nanosystems is central to numerous processes in chemistry, material sciences, electrical and mechanical engineering, with classical molecular dynamics as the key simulation tool. Here we focus on thermal junctions with a molecule bridging two solids that are maintained at different temperatures. The classical steady state heat current in this system can be simulated in di… ▽ More Thermal transport through nanosystems is central to numerous processes in chemistry, material sciences, electrical and mechanical engineering, with classical molecular dynamics as the key simulation tool. Here we focus on thermal junctions with a molecule bridging two solids that are maintained at different temperatures. The classical steady state heat current in this system can be simulated in different ways, either at the interfaces with the solids, which are represented by thermostats, or between atoms within the conducting molecule. We show that while the latter, intramolecular definition feasibly converges to the correct limit, the molecule-thermostat interface definition is more challenging to converge to the correct result. The problem with the interface definition is demonstrated by simulating heat transport in harmonic and anharmonic one-dimensional chains illustrating unphysical effects such as thermal rectification in harmonic junctions. △ Less

Submitted 28 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Thermodynamic uncertainty relation for energy transport in transient regime -- Model study

Authors: Sushant Saryal, Onkar Sadekar, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We investigate transient version of the recently discovered thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR) which provides a precision-cost trade-off relation for certain out-of-equilibrium thermodynamic observables in terms of net entropy production. We explore this relation in the context of energy transport in a bipartite setting for three exactly solvable toy model systems (two coupled harmonic oscil… ▽ More We investigate transient version of the recently discovered thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR) which provides a precision-cost trade-off relation for certain out-of-equilibrium thermodynamic observables in terms of net entropy production. We explore this relation in the context of energy transport in a bipartite setting for three exactly solvable toy model systems (two coupled harmonic oscillators, two coupled qubits and a hybrid coupled oscillator-qubit system) and analyze the role played by the underlying statistics of the transport carriers in TUR. Interestingly, for all these models, depending on the statistics, the TUR ratio can be expressed as a sum or a difference of an universal term which is always greater or equal to 2 and a corresponding entropy production term. We find that the generalized version of the TUR, originating from the universal fluctuation symmetry is always satisfied. However, interestingly, the specialized TUR, a tighter bound, is always satisfied for the coupled harmonic oscillator system obeying Bose-Einstein statistics. Whereas, for both the coupled qubit, obeying Fermi-like statistics and the hybrid qubit-oscillator system with mixed Fermi-Bose statistics, violation of tighter bound is observed in certain parameter regimes. We have provided conditions for such violations. We also provide a rigorous proof following the non-equilibrium Green's function approach that the tighter bound is always satisfied in the weak-coupling regime for generic bipartite systems. △ Less

Submitted 19 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: 15 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 103, 022141 (2021)

Thermodynamic uncertainty relation in atomic-scale quantum conductors

Authors: Hava Meira Friedman, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Ofir Shein-Lumbroso, Oren Tal, Dvira Segal

Abstract: The thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR) is expected to hold in nanoscale electronic conductors, when the electron transport process is quantum coherent and the transmission probability is constant (energy and voltage independent). We present measurements of the electron current and its noise in gold atomic-scale junctions and confirm the validity of the TUR for electron transport in realistic… ▽ More The thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR) is expected to hold in nanoscale electronic conductors, when the electron transport process is quantum coherent and the transmission probability is constant (energy and voltage independent). We present measurements of the electron current and its noise in gold atomic-scale junctions and confirm the validity of the TUR for electron transport in realistic quantum coherent conductors. Furthermore, we show that it is beneficial to present the current and its noise as a TUR ratio in order to identify deviations from noninteracting-electron coherent dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 9 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 101, 195423 (2020)

Experimental study of the thermodynamic uncertainty relation

Authors: Soham Pal, Sushant Saryal, Dvira Segal, T. S. Mahesh, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: A cost-precision trade-off relationship, the so-called thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR), has been recently discovered in stochastic thermodynamics. It bounds certain thermodynamic observables in terms of the associated entropy production. In this work, we experimentally study the TUR in a two-qubit system using an NMR setup. Each qubit is prepared in an equilibrium state, but at different… ▽ More A cost-precision trade-off relationship, the so-called thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR), has been recently discovered in stochastic thermodynamics. It bounds certain thermodynamic observables in terms of the associated entropy production. In this work, we experimentally study the TUR in a two-qubit system using an NMR setup. Each qubit is prepared in an equilibrium state, but at different temperatures. The qubits are then coupled, allowing energy exchange (in the form of heat). Using the quantum state tomography technique we obtain the moments of heat exchange within a certain time interval and analyze the relative uncertainty of the energy exchange process. We find that generalized versions of the TUR, which are based on the fluctuation relation, are obeyed. However, the specialized TUR, a tighter bound that is valid under specific dynamics, is violated in certain regimes of operation, in excellent agreement with analytic results. Altogether, this experiment-theory study provides a deep understanding of heat exchange in quantum systems, revealing favorable noise-dissipation regimes of operation. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 2, 022044 (2020)

Thermodynamic uncertainty relation in thermal transport

Authors: Sushant Saryal, Hava Friedman, Dvira Segal, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We use the fundamental nonequilibrium steady-state fluctuation symmetry and derive a condition on the validity of the thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR) in thermal transport problems, classical or quantum alike. We test this condition and study the breakdown of the TUR in different thermal transport junctions of bosonic and electronic degrees of freedom. First, we prove that the TUR is valid… ▽ More We use the fundamental nonequilibrium steady-state fluctuation symmetry and derive a condition on the validity of the thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR) in thermal transport problems, classical or quantum alike. We test this condition and study the breakdown of the TUR in different thermal transport junctions of bosonic and electronic degrees of freedom. First, we prove that the TUR is valid in harmonic oscillator junctions. In contrast, in the nonequilibrium spin-boson model, which realizes many-body effects, it is satisfied in the Markovian limit, but violations arise as we tune (reduce) the cutoff frequency of the thermal baths, thus observing non-Markovian dynamics. Finally, we consider heat transport by noninteracting electrons in a tight-binding chain model. Here we show that the TUR is feasibly violated by tuning e.g. the hybridization energy of the chain to the metal leads. These results manifest that the validity of the TUR relies on the statistics of the participating carriers, their interaction, and the nature of their couplings to the macroscopic contacts (metal electrodes, phonon baths). △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 10 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 100, 042101 (2019)

Photon statistics of a double quantum dot micromaser: Quantum treatment

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Manas Kulkarni, Dvira Segal

Abstract: A semiconductor single-atom micromaser consists of a microwave cavity coupled to a gain medium, a double quantum dot driven out of equilibrium by a bias voltage. The masing threshold of this system was recently probed by measuring photon statistics in the cavity [Y-Y. Liu \textit{et al}, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 097702 (2017)]. In this paper, we develop an in-depth, rigorous understanding of this exp… ▽ More A semiconductor single-atom micromaser consists of a microwave cavity coupled to a gain medium, a double quantum dot driven out of equilibrium by a bias voltage. The masing threshold of this system was recently probed by measuring photon statistics in the cavity [Y-Y. Liu \textit{et al}, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 097702 (2017)]. In this paper, we develop an in-depth, rigorous understanding of this experiment and related works. First, we use a semiclassical theory and study transmission spectroscopy. This approach allows us to derive the masing threshold condition for arbitrary temperature and voltage bias, and expose microscopic principles required for realizing photon gain and thereby a photon amplifier. Next, by employing the quantum master equation approach we extend the Scully-Lamb quantum theory of a laser to the present setup, and investigate the statistics of emitted photons below and above the masing threshold as a function of experimentally tunable parameters. Although our focus is primarily on hybrid quantum dot circuit - quantum electrodynamics systems, our approach is adaptable to other light-matter systems where the gain medium consists of a mesoscopic structure. △ Less

Submitted 19 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 14 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 100, 035412 (2019)

Quantum entanglement and transport in non-equilibrium interacting double-dot setup: The curious role of degeneracy

Authors: Anirban Dey, Devendra Singh Bhakuni, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Auditya Sharma

Abstract: We study quantum entanglement and its relation to transport in a non-equilibrium interacting double dot system connected to electronic baths. The dynamical properties in the non-interacting regime are studied using an exact numerical approach whereas the steady state properties are obtained following the well-known non-equilibrium Green's function (NEGF) approach. By means of mutual information an… ▽ More We study quantum entanglement and its relation to transport in a non-equilibrium interacting double dot system connected to electronic baths. The dynamical properties in the non-interacting regime are studied using an exact numerical approach whereas the steady state properties are obtained following the well-known non-equilibrium Green's function (NEGF) approach. By means of mutual information and concurrence we explore the connection between the quantum correlations in the system and the current flowing through the dots. It is observed that entanglement between the dots is heavily influenced by the degeneracy or the lack thereof, of the dot levels. In the non-degenerate case, the concurrence falls sharply when the applied bias crosses a certain critical value. In contrast when the dot energy levels are degenerate, the concurrence reaches a very high asymptotic value of 1/2. When interactions are switched on, the degeneracy is lifted, and once again concurrence falls to zero beyond a critical value of the applied bias. Lastly it is observed that the concurrence can be made to reach almost the value of 1.0 if the chemical potential in both baths is made very large (while keeping the sign the same) provided the dot levels are kept degenerate within the non-interacting limit. A combination of NEGF method, brute-force numerics and asymptotics are employed to corroborate our findings. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2019; v1 submitted 1 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 32(7), 075603 (2020)

Path-integral methodology and simulations of quantum thermal transport: Full counting statistics approach

Authors: Michael Kilgour, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We develop and test a computational framework to study heat exchange in interacting, nonequilibrium open quantum systems. Our iterative full counting statistics path integral (iFCSPI) approach extends a previously well-established influence functional path integral method, by going beyond reduced system dynamics to provide the cumulant generating function of heat exchange. The method is straightfo… ▽ More We develop and test a computational framework to study heat exchange in interacting, nonequilibrium open quantum systems. Our iterative full counting statistics path integral (iFCSPI) approach extends a previously well-established influence functional path integral method, by going beyond reduced system dynamics to provide the cumulant generating function of heat exchange. The method is straightforward; we implement it for the nonequilibrium spin boson model to calculate transient and long-time observables, focusing on the steady-state heat current flowing through the system under a temperature difference. Results are compared to perturbative treatments and demonstrate good agreement in the appropriate limits. The challenge of converging nonequilibrium quantities, currents and high order cumulants, is discussed in detail. The iFCSPI, a numerically exact technique, naturally captures strong system-bath coupling and non-Markovian effects of the environment. As such, it is a promising tool for probing fundamental questions in quantum transport and quantum thermodynamics. △ Less

Submitted 7 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Experimental verification of quantum heat exchange fluctuation relation

Authors: Soham Pal, T S Mahesh, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We experimentally verify the Jarzynski and Wöjcik quantum heat exchange fluctuation relation by implementing the interferometric technique in liquid-state Nuclear Magnetic Resonance setup and study the exchange heat statistics between two weakly coupled spin-1/2 quantum systems. In presence of uncorrelated initial state with individual spins prepared in local Gibbs thermal states at different temp… ▽ More We experimentally verify the Jarzynski and Wöjcik quantum heat exchange fluctuation relation by implementing the interferometric technique in liquid-state Nuclear Magnetic Resonance setup and study the exchange heat statistics between two weakly coupled spin-1/2 quantum systems. In presence of uncorrelated initial state with individual spins prepared in local Gibbs thermal states at different temperatures, the exchange fluctuation symmetry is verified for arbitrary transient time. In contrast, when the initial preparation includes correlation, the fluctuation symmetry breaks down and further leads to an apparent spontaneous flow of heat from cold to hot. Our experimental approach is general and can be systematically extended to study heat statistics for more complex out-of-equilibrium many-body quantum systems. △ Less

Submitted 18 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 100, 042119 (2019)

On the validity of the thermodynamic uncertainty relation in quantum systems

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We examine the so-called thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR), a cost-precision trade-off relationship in transport systems. Based on the fluctuation symmetry, we derive a condition on the validity of the TUR for general nonequilibrium (classical and quantum) systems. We find that the first non-zero contribution to the TUR beyond equilibrium, given in terms of nonlinear transport coefficients,… ▽ More We examine the so-called thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR), a cost-precision trade-off relationship in transport systems. Based on the fluctuation symmetry, we derive a condition on the validity of the TUR for general nonequilibrium (classical and quantum) systems. We find that the first non-zero contribution to the TUR beyond equilibrium, given in terms of nonlinear transport coefficients, can be positive or negative, thus affirming or violating the TUR depending on the details of the system. We exemplify our results for noninteracting quantum systems by deriving the thermodynamic uncertainty relation in the language of the transmission function. We demonstrate that quantum coherent systems that do not follow a population Markovian master equation, e.g. by supporting high order tunneling processes or relying on coherences, violate the TUR. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2018; v1 submitted 14 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 98, 155438 (2018)

Quantum energy exchange and refrigeration: A full-counting statistics approach

Authors: Hava Meira Friedman, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We formulate a full-counting statistics description to study energy exchange in multi-terminal junctions. Our approach applies to quantum systems that are coupled either additively or non-additively (cooperatively) to multiple reservoirs. We derive a Markovian Redfield-type equation for the counting-field dependent reduced density operator. Under the secular approximation, we confirm that the cumu… ▽ More We formulate a full-counting statistics description to study energy exchange in multi-terminal junctions. Our approach applies to quantum systems that are coupled either additively or non-additively (cooperatively) to multiple reservoirs. We derive a Markovian Redfield-type equation for the counting-field dependent reduced density operator. Under the secular approximation, we confirm that the cumulant generating function satisfies the heat exchange fluctuation theorem. Our treatment thus respects the second law of thermodynamics. We exemplify our formalism on a multi-terminal two-level quantum system, and apply it to realize the smallest quantum absorption refrigerator, operating through engineered reservoirs, and achievable only through a cooperative bath interaction model. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2018; v1 submitted 1 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Qubit absorption refrigerator at strong coupling

Authors: Anqi Mu, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Gernot Schaller, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We demonstrate that a quantum absorption refrigerator can be realized from the smallest quantum system, a qubit, by coupling it in a non-additive (strong) manner to three heat baths. This function is un-attainable for the qubit model under the weak system-bath coupling limit, when the dissipation is additive. In an optimal design, the reservoirs are engineered and characterized by a single frequen… ▽ More We demonstrate that a quantum absorption refrigerator can be realized from the smallest quantum system, a qubit, by coupling it in a non-additive (strong) manner to three heat baths. This function is un-attainable for the qubit model under the weak system-bath coupling limit, when the dissipation is additive. In an optimal design, the reservoirs are engineered and characterized by a single frequency component. We obtain then closed expressions for the cooling window and refrigeration efficiency, as well as bounds for the maximal cooling efficiency and the efficiency at maximal power. Our results agree with macroscopic designs and with three-level models for quantum absorption refrigerators, which are based on the weak system-bath coupling assumption. Beyond the optimal limit, we show with analytic calculations and numerical simulations that the cooling efficiency varies in a non-universal manner with model parameters. Our work demonstrates that strongly-coupled quantum machines can exhibit function that is un-attainable under the weak system-bath coupling assumption. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Journal ref: New Journal of Physics 19, 123034 (2017)

Quantum efficiency bound for continuous heat engines coupled to non-canonical reservoirs

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Jian-Hua Jiang, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We derive an efficiency bound for continuous quantum heat engines absorbing heat from squeezed thermal reservoirs. Our approach relies on a full-counting statistics description of nonequilibrium transport and it is not limited to the framework of irreversible thermodynamics. Our result, a generalized Carnot efficiency bound, is valid beyond the small squeezing and high temperature limit. Our findi… ▽ More We derive an efficiency bound for continuous quantum heat engines absorbing heat from squeezed thermal reservoirs. Our approach relies on a full-counting statistics description of nonequilibrium transport and it is not limited to the framework of irreversible thermodynamics. Our result, a generalized Carnot efficiency bound, is valid beyond the small squeezing and high temperature limit. Our findings are embodied in a prototype three-terminal quantum photoelectric engine where a qubit converts heat absorbed from a squeezed thermal reservoir into electrical power. We demonstrate that in the quantum regime the efficiency can be greatly amplified by squeezing. From the fluctuation relation we further receive other operational measures in linear response, for example, the universal maximum power efficiency bound. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 96, 104304 (2017)

The Anderson impurity model out of equilibrium: Assessing the accuracy of simulation techniques with an exact current-occupation relation

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We study the interacting, symmetrically coupled single impurity Anderson model. By employing the nonequilibrium Green's function formalism, we establish an exact relationship between the steady-state charge current flowing through the impurity (dot) and its occupation. We argue that the steady state current-occupation relation can be used to assess the consistency of simulation techniques, and ide… ▽ More We study the interacting, symmetrically coupled single impurity Anderson model. By employing the nonequilibrium Green's function formalism, we establish an exact relationship between the steady-state charge current flowing through the impurity (dot) and its occupation. We argue that the steady state current-occupation relation can be used to assess the consistency of simulation techniques, and identify spurious transport phenomena. We test this relation in two different model variants: First, we study the Anderson-Holstein model in the strong electron-vibration coupling limit using the polaronic quantum master equation method. We find that the current-occupation relation is violated numerically in standard calculations, with simulations bringing up incorrect transport effects. Using a numerical procedure, we resolve the problem efficiently. Second, we simulate the Anderson model with electron-electron interaction on the dot using a deterministic numerically-exact time-evolution scheme. Here, we observe that the current-occupation relation is satisfied in the steady-state limit---even before results converge to the exact limit. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2017; v1 submitted 1 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Journal ref: JCP 147, 054104 (2017)

Energy current and its statistics in the nonequilibrium spin-boson model: Majorana fermion representation

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We study the statistics of thermal energy transfer in the nonequilibrium (two-bath) spin-boson model. This quantum many-body impurity system serves as a canonical model for quantum energy transport. Our method makes use of the Majorana fermion representation for the spin operators, in combination with the Keldysh nonequilibrium Green's function approach. We derive an analytical expression for the… ▽ More We study the statistics of thermal energy transfer in the nonequilibrium (two-bath) spin-boson model. This quantum many-body impurity system serves as a canonical model for quantum energy transport. Our method makes use of the Majorana fermion representation for the spin operators, in combination with the Keldysh nonequilibrium Green's function approach. We derive an analytical expression for the cumulant generating function of the model in the steady state limit, and show that it satisfies the Gallavotti-Cohen fluctuation symmetry. We obtain analytical expressions for the heat current and its noise, valid beyond the sequential and the co-tunnelling regimes. Our results satisfy the quantum mechanical bound for heat current in interacting nanojunctions. Results are compared with other approximate theories, as well as with a non-interacting model, a fully harmonic thermal junction. △ Less

Submitted 3 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Journal ref: New J. Phys. 19, 043030 (2017)

Giant photon gain in large-scale quantum dot circuit-QED systems

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Manas Kulkarni, Shaul Mukamel, Dvira Segal

Abstract: Motivated by recent experiments on the generation of coherent light in engineered hybrid quantum systems, we investigate gain in a microwave photonic cavity coupled to quantum dot structures, and develop concrete directions for achieving a giant amplification in photon transmission. We propose two architectures for scaling up the electronic gain medium: (i) $N$ double quantum dot systems (N-DQD),… ▽ More Motivated by recent experiments on the generation of coherent light in engineered hybrid quantum systems, we investigate gain in a microwave photonic cavity coupled to quantum dot structures, and develop concrete directions for achieving a giant amplification in photon transmission. We propose two architectures for scaling up the electronic gain medium: (i) $N$ double quantum dot systems (N-DQD), (ii) $M$ quantum dots arranged in series akin to a quantum cascade laser setup. In both setups, the fermionic reservoirs are voltage biased, and the quantum dots are coupled to a single-mode cavity. Optical amplification is explained based on a sum rule for the transmission function, and it is determined by an intricate competition between two different processes: charge density response in the gain medium, and cavity losses to input and output ports. The same design principle is also responsible for the corresponding giant amplification in other photonic observables, mean photon number and emission spectrum, thereby realizing a quantum device that behaves as a giant microwave amplifier. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 94, 121305(R) (2016)

Effects of vibrational anharmonicity on molecular electronic conduction and thermoelectric efficiency

Authors: Hava Meira Friedman, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We study inelastic vibration-assisted charge transfer effects in two-site molecular junctions, focusing on signatures of vibrational anharmonicity on the electrical characteristics and the thermoelectric response of the junction. We consider three types of oscillators: harmonic, anharmonic-Morse allowing bond dissociation, and harmonic-quartic, mimicking a confinement potential. Using a quantum ma… ▽ More We study inelastic vibration-assisted charge transfer effects in two-site molecular junctions, focusing on signatures of vibrational anharmonicity on the electrical characteristics and the thermoelectric response of the junction. We consider three types of oscillators: harmonic, anharmonic-Morse allowing bond dissociation, and harmonic-quartic, mimicking a confinement potential. Using a quantum master equation method which is perturbative in the electron-vibration interaction we find that the (inelastic) electrical and thermal conductances can be largely affected by the nature of the vibrational potential. In contrast, the Seebeck coefficient, the thermoelectric figure-of-merit, and the thermoelectric efficiency beyond linear response, conceal this information, showing a rather weak sensitivity to vibrational anharmonicity. Our work illustrates that anharmonic (many-body) effects, consequential to the current-voltage characteristics, are of little effect for the thermoelectric performance. △ Less

Submitted 9 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 146, 092303 (2017)

Tunable photonic cavity coupled to a voltage-biased double quantum dot system: Diagrammatic NEGF approach

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Manas Kulkarni, Shaul Mukamel, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We investigate gain in microwave photonic cavities coupled to voltage-biased double quantum dot systems with an arbitrary strong dot-lead coupling and with a Holstein-like light-matter interaction, by adapting the diagrammatic Keldysh nonequilibrium Green's function approach. We compute out-of-equilibrium properties of the cavity : its transmission, phase response, mean photon number, power spectr… ▽ More We investigate gain in microwave photonic cavities coupled to voltage-biased double quantum dot systems with an arbitrary strong dot-lead coupling and with a Holstein-like light-matter interaction, by adapting the diagrammatic Keldysh nonequilibrium Green's function approach. We compute out-of-equilibrium properties of the cavity : its transmission, phase response, mean photon number, power spectrum, and spectral function. We show that by the careful engineering of these hybrid light-matter systems, one can achieve a significant amplification of the optical signal with the voltage-biased electronic system serving as a gain medium. We also study the steady state current across the device, identifying elastic and inelastic tunnelling processes which involve the cavity mode. Our results show how recent advances in quantum electronics can be exploited to build hybrid light-matter systems that behave as single-atom amplifiers and photon source devices. The diagrammatic Keldysh approach is primarily discussed for a cavity-coupled double quantum dot architecture, but it is generalizable to other hybrid light-matter systems. △ Less

Submitted 6 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: 30 pages, 13 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 94, 035434 (2016)

Geometric effects in non-equilibrium electron transfer statistics in adiabatically driven quantum junctions

Authors: Himangshu Prabal Goswami, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Upendra Harbola

Abstract: Cyclic Pancharatnam-Berry (PB) and adiabatic noncyclic geometric (ANG) effects are investigated in a single electron orbital system connected to two metal contacts with externally driven chemical potential and/or temperatures.The PB contribution does not affect the density matrix evolution, but has quantitative effect on the statistics (fluctuations) of electron transfer. The ANG contribution, on… ▽ More Cyclic Pancharatnam-Berry (PB) and adiabatic noncyclic geometric (ANG) effects are investigated in a single electron orbital system connected to two metal contacts with externally driven chemical potential and/or temperatures.The PB contribution does not affect the density matrix evolution, but has quantitative effect on the statistics (fluctuations) of electron transfer. The ANG contribution, on the other hand, affects the net flux across the junction. Unlike the PB, the ANG contribution is non-zero when two parameters are identically driven. Closed analytical expressions are derived for the ANG contribution to the flux, and the PB contribution to the first two leading order fluctuations. Fluctuations can be modified by manipulating the relative phases of the drivings. Interestingly, we find that the fluctuations of the pumped charge do not satisfy the steady state fluctuation theorem in presence of nonzero geometric contribution, but can be recovered for a vanishing geometric contribution even in presence of the external driving. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2016; v1 submitted 22 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: 14 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 93, 195441 (2016)

Reconciling perturbative approaches in phonon assisted transport junctions

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We present consistent results for molecular conduction using two central-complementary approaches: the non-equilibrium Green's function technique and the quantum master equation method. Our model describes electronic conduction in a donor-acceptor junction in which electron transfer is coupled to nuclear motion, modeled by a harmonic vibrational mode. This primary mode is further coupled to second… ▽ More We present consistent results for molecular conduction using two central-complementary approaches: the non-equilibrium Green's function technique and the quantum master equation method. Our model describes electronic conduction in a donor-acceptor junction in which electron transfer is coupled to nuclear motion, modeled by a harmonic vibrational mode. This primary mode is further coupled to secondary phonon modes, a thermal bath. Assuming weak electron-phonon coupling but arbitrary large molecule-metal hybridization, we compute several non-equilibrium transport quantities: the mean phonon number of the primary mode, charge current statistics. We further present scaling relations for the cumulants valid in the large voltage regime. Our analysis illustrates that the non-equilibrium Green's function technique and the quantum master equation method can be worked out consistently, when taking into account corresponding scattering processes. △ Less

Submitted 6 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Journal ref: JCP 144, 074102 (2016)

Full counting statistics of vibrationally-assisted electronic conduction: transport and fluctuations of the thermoelectric efficiency

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Jian-Hua Jiang, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We study the statistical properties of charge and energy transport in electron conducting junctions with electron-phonon interactions, specifically, the thermoelectric efficiency and its fluctuations. The system comprises donor and acceptor electronic states, representing a two-site molecule or a double quantum dot system. Electron transfer between metals through the two molecular sites is coupled… ▽ More We study the statistical properties of charge and energy transport in electron conducting junctions with electron-phonon interactions, specifically, the thermoelectric efficiency and its fluctuations. The system comprises donor and acceptor electronic states, representing a two-site molecule or a double quantum dot system. Electron transfer between metals through the two molecular sites is coupled to a particular vibrational mode which is taken to be either harmonic or anharmonic- a truncated (two-state) spectrum. Considering these models we derive the cumulant generating function in steady state for charge and energy transfer, correct to second-order in the electron-phonon interaction, but exact to all orders in the metal-molecule coupling strength. This is achieved by using the non-equilibrium Green's function approach (harmonic mode) and a kinetic quantum master equation method (anharmonic mode). From the cumulant generating function we calculate the charge current and its noise and the large deviation function for the thermoelectric efficiency. We demonstrate that at large bias the charge current, differential conductance, and the current noise can identify energetic and structural properties of the junction. We further examine the operation of the junction as a thermoelectric engine and show that while the macroscopic thermoelectric efficiency is indifferent to the nature of the mode (harmonic or anharmonic), efficiency fluctuations do reflect this property. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2015; v1 submitted 10 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: 18 pages, 11 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 92, 245418 (2015)

Vibrational Heat Transport in Molecular Junctions

Authors: Dvira Segal, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla

Abstract: We review studies of vibrational energy transfer in a molecular junction geometry, consisting of a molecule bridging two heat reservoirs, solids or large chemical compounds. This setup is of interest for applications in molecular electronics, thermoelectrics, and nanophononics, and for addressing basic questions in the theory of classical and quantum transport. Calculations show that system size,… ▽ More We review studies of vibrational energy transfer in a molecular junction geometry, consisting of a molecule bridging two heat reservoirs, solids or large chemical compounds. This setup is of interest for applications in molecular electronics, thermoelectrics, and nanophononics, and for addressing basic questions in the theory of classical and quantum transport. Calculations show that system size, disorder, structure, dimensionality, internal anharmonicities, contact interaction, and quantum coherent effects, are factors that interplay to determine the predominant mechanism (ballistic/diffusive), effectiveness (poor/good) and functionality (linear/nonlinear) of thermal conduction at the nanoscale. We review recent experiments and relevant calculations of quantum heat transfer in molecular junctions. We recount the Landauer approach, appropriate for the study of elastic (harmonic) phononic transport, and outline techniques which incorporate molecular anharmonicities. Theoretical methods are described along with examples illustrating the challenge of reaching control over vibrational heat conduction in molecules. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: review, submitted to Annual Review of Physical Chemistry

Thermoelectricity in molecular junctions with harmonic and anharmonic modes

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Jian-Hua Jiang, Dvira Segal

Abstract: We study charge and energy transfer in two-site molecular electronic junctions in which electron transport is assisted by a vibrational mode. To understand the role of mode harmonicity/anharmonicity on transport behavior, we consider two limiting situations: (i) the mode is assumed harmonic, (ii) we truncate the mode spectrum to include only two vibrational levels, to represent an anharmonic molec… ▽ More We study charge and energy transfer in two-site molecular electronic junctions in which electron transport is assisted by a vibrational mode. To understand the role of mode harmonicity/anharmonicity on transport behavior, we consider two limiting situations: (i) the mode is assumed harmonic, (ii) we truncate the mode spectrum to include only two vibrational levels, to represent an anharmonic molecular mode. Based on the models' cumulant generating functions, we analyze the linear-response and nonlinear performance of these junctions and demonstrate that while the electrical and thermal conductances are sensitive to whether the mode is harmonic/anharmonic, the Seebeck coefficient, the thermoelectric figure-of-merit, and the thermoelectric efficiency beyond linear response, conceal this information. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2015; v1 submitted 9 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: for Beilstein Journal of Nanotechnology, Thematic Series on "molecular machines and devices"

Efficiency Statistics and Bounds for Systems with Broken Time-Reversal Symmetry

Authors: Jian-Hua Jiang, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Dvira Segal

Abstract: Universal properties of the statistics of stochastic efficiency for mesoscopic time-reversal symmetry broken energy transducers are revealed in the Gaussian approximation. We also discuss how the second law of thermodynamics restricts the statistics of stochastic efficiency. The tight-coupling (reversible) limit becomes unfavorable, characterized by an infinitely broad distribution of efficiency a… ▽ More Universal properties of the statistics of stochastic efficiency for mesoscopic time-reversal symmetry broken energy transducers are revealed in the Gaussian approximation. We also discuss how the second law of thermodynamics restricts the statistics of stochastic efficiency. The tight-coupling (reversible) limit becomes unfavorable, characterized by an infinitely broad distribution of efficiency at {\em all times}, when time-reversal symmetry breaking leads to an asymmetric Onsager response matrix. The underlying physics is demonstrated through the integer quantum Hall effect and further elaborated in a triple-quantum-dot three-terminal thermoelectric engine. △ Less

Submitted 21 July, 2015; v1 submitted 14 March, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: 5+8 pages 10 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 040601 (2015)

Exchange fluctuation theorem for heat transport between multi-terminal harmonic systems

Authors: Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Huanan Li, Baowen Li, Jian-Sheng Wang

Abstract: We study full counting statistics for transferred heat and entropy production between multi-terminal systems in absence of a finite junction. The systems are modelled as collections of coupled harmonic oscillators which are kept at different equilibrium temperatures and are connected via arbitrary time dependent couplings. Following consistent quantum framework and two-time measurement concept we… ▽ More We study full counting statistics for transferred heat and entropy production between multi-terminal systems in absence of a finite junction. The systems are modelled as collections of coupled harmonic oscillators which are kept at different equilibrium temperatures and are connected via arbitrary time dependent couplings. Following consistent quantum framework and two-time measurement concept we obtain analytical expressions for the generalized cumulant generating function. We discuss transient and steady-state fluctuation theorems for the transferred quantities. We also address the effect of coupling strength on the exchange fluctuation theorem. △ Less

Submitted 18 April, 2014; v1 submitted 7 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.

Comments: 10 pages, 6 figures (accepted in Phys. Rev. E)

Nonequilibrium Green's function method for quantum thermal transport

Authors: Jian-Sheng Wang, Bijay Kumar Agarwalla, Huanan Li, Juzar Thingna

Abstract: This review deals with the nonequilibrium Green's function (NEGF) method applied to the problems of energy transport due to atomic vibrations (phonons), primarily for small junction systems. We present a pedagogical introduction to the subject, deriving some of the well-known results such as the Laudauer-like formula for heat current in ballistic systems. The main aim of the review is to build the… ▽ More This review deals with the nonequilibrium Green's function (NEGF) method applied to the problems of energy transport due to atomic vibrations (phonons), primarily for small junction systems. We present a pedagogical introduction to the subject, deriving some of the well-known results such as the Laudauer-like formula for heat current in ballistic systems. The main aim of the review is to build the machinery of the method so that it can be applied to other situations, which are not directly treated here. In addition to the above, we consider a number of applications of NEGF, not in routine model system calculations, but in a few new aspects showing the power and usefulness of the formalism. In particular, we discuss the problems of multiple leads, coupled left-right-lead system, and system without a center. We also apply the method to the problem of full counting statistics. In the case of nonlinear systems, we make general comments on the thermal expansion effect, phonon relaxation time, and a certain class of mean-field approximations. Lastly, we examine the relationship between NEGF, reduced density matrix, and master equation approaches to thermal transport. △ Less

Submitted 29 March, 2013; originally announced March 2013.

Comments: 21 pages, submitted to "Frontiers of Physics"