Showing 1–12 of 12 results for author: Acher, M

Testing for Fault Diversity in Reinforcement Learning

Authors: Quentin Mazouni, Helge Spieker, Arnaud Gotlieb, Mathieu Acher

Abstract: Reinforcement Learning is the premier technique to approach sequential decision problems, including complex tasks such as driving cars and landing spacecraft. Among the software validation and verification practices, testing for functional fault detection is a convenient way to build trustworthiness in the learned decision model. While recent works seek to maximise the number of detected faults, n… ▽ More Reinforcement Learning is the premier technique to approach sequential decision problems, including complex tasks such as driving cars and landing spacecraft. Among the software validation and verification practices, testing for functional fault detection is a convenient way to build trustworthiness in the learned decision model. While recent works seek to maximise the number of detected faults, none consider fault characterisation during the search for more diversity. We argue that policy testing should not find as many failures as possible (e.g., inputs that trigger similar car crashes) but rather aim at revealing as informative and diverse faults as possible in the model. In this paper, we explore the use of quality diversity optimisation to solve the problem of fault diversity in policy testing. Quality diversity (QD) optimisation is a type of evolutionary algorithm to solve hard combinatorial optimisation problems where high-quality diverse solutions are sought. We define and address the underlying challenges of adapting QD optimisation to the test of action policies. Furthermore, we compare classical QD optimisers to state-of-the-art frameworks dedicated to policy testing, both in terms of search efficiency and fault diversity. We show that QD optimisation, while being conceptually simple and generally applicable, finds effectively more diverse faults in the decision model, and conclude that QD-based policy testing is a promising approach. △ Less

Submitted 22 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 11 pages, 4 figures, 1 algorithm, AST @ ICSE 2024

A Review of Validation and Verification of Neural Network-based Policies for Sequential Decision Making

Authors: Q. Mazouni, H. Spieker, A. Gotlieb, M. Acher

Abstract: In sequential decision making, neural networks (NNs) are nowadays commonly used to represent and learn the agent's policy. This area of application has implied new software quality assessment challenges that traditional validation and verification practises are not able to handle. Subsequently, novel approaches have emerged to adapt those techniques to NN-based policies for sequential decision mak… ▽ More In sequential decision making, neural networks (NNs) are nowadays commonly used to represent and learn the agent's policy. This area of application has implied new software quality assessment challenges that traditional validation and verification practises are not able to handle. Subsequently, novel approaches have emerged to adapt those techniques to NN-based policies for sequential decision making. This survey paper aims at summarising these novel contributions and proposing future research directions. We conducted a literature review of recent research papers (from 2018 to beginning of 2023), whose topics cover aspects of the test or verification of NN-based policies. The selection has been enriched by a snowballing process from the previously selected papers, in order to relax the scope of the study and provide the reader with insight into similar verification challenges and their recent solutions. 18 papers have been finally selected. Our results show evidence of increasing interest for this subject. They highlight the diversity of both the exact problems considered and the techniques used to tackle them. △ Less

Submitted 15 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 10 pages, 3 figures, RJCIA 2023

Piloting Copilot and Codex: Hot Temperature, Cold Prompts, or Black Magic?

Authors: Jean-Baptiste Döderlein, Mathieu Acher, Djamel Eddine Khelladi, Benoit Combemale

Abstract: Language models are promising solutions for tackling increasing complex problems. In software engineering, they recently attracted attention in code assistants, with programs automatically written in a given programming language from a programming task description in natural language. They have the potential to save time and effort when writing code. However, these systems are currently poorly und… ▽ More Language models are promising solutions for tackling increasing complex problems. In software engineering, they recently attracted attention in code assistants, with programs automatically written in a given programming language from a programming task description in natural language. They have the potential to save time and effort when writing code. However, these systems are currently poorly understood, preventing them from being used optimally. In this paper, we investigate the various input parameters of two language models, and conduct a study to understand if variations of these input parameters (e.g. programming task description and the surrounding context, creativity of the language model, number of generated solutions) can have a significant impact on the quality of the generated programs. We design specific operators for varying input parameters and apply them over two code assistants (Copilot and Codex) and two benchmarks representing algorithmic problems (HumanEval and LeetCode). Our results showed that varying the input parameters can significantly improve the performance of language models. However, there is a tight dependency when varying the temperature, the prompt and the number of generated solutions, making potentially hard for developers to properly control the parameters to obtain an optimal result. This work opens opportunities to propose (automated) strategies for improving performance. △ Less

Submitted 15 February, 2023; v1 submitted 26 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 14 pages, 3 Figures (not counted the subfigures), 10 Tables

MSC Class: 68T50

Specialization of Run-time Configuration Space at Compile-time: An Exploratory Study

Authors: Xhevahire Tërnava, Mathieu Acher, Benoit Combemale

Abstract: Numerous software systems are highly configurable through run-time options, such as command-line parameters. Users can tune some of the options to meet various functional and non-functional requirements such as footprint, security, or execution time. However, some options are never set for a given system instance, and their values remain the same whatever the use cases of the system. Herein, we de… ▽ More Numerous software systems are highly configurable through run-time options, such as command-line parameters. Users can tune some of the options to meet various functional and non-functional requirements such as footprint, security, or execution time. However, some options are never set for a given system instance, and their values remain the same whatever the use cases of the system. Herein, we design a controlled experiment in which the system's run-time configuration space can be specialized at compile-time and combinations of options can be removed on demand. We perform an in-depth study of the well-known x264 video encoder and quantify the effects of its specialization to its non-functional properties, namely on binary size, attack surface, and performance while ensuring its validity. Our exploratory study suggests that the configurable specialization of a system has statistically significant benefits on most of its analysed non-functional properties, which benefits depend on the number of the debloated options. While our empirical results and insights show the importance of removing code related to unused run-time options to improve software systems, an open challenge is to further automate the specialization process. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 14 pages, 3 Figures (not counted the subfigures), 5 Tables, and 1 Algorithm

The Interaction between Inputs and Configurations fed to Software Systems: an Empirical Study

Authors: Luc Lesoil, Mathieu Acher, Arnaud Blouin, Jean-Marc Jézéquel

Abstract: Widely used software systems such as video encoders are by necessity highly configurable, with hundreds or even thousands of options to choose from. Their users often have a hard time finding suitable values for these options (i.e. finding a proper configuration of the software system) to meet their goals for the tasks at hand, e.g. compress a video down to a certain size. One dimension of the pro… ▽ More Widely used software systems such as video encoders are by necessity highly configurable, with hundreds or even thousands of options to choose from. Their users often have a hard time finding suitable values for these options (i.e. finding a proper configuration of the software system) to meet their goals for the tasks at hand, e.g. compress a video down to a certain size. One dimension of the problem is of course that performance depends on the input data: a video as input to an encoder like x264 or a file system fed to a tool like xz. To achieve good performance, users should therefore take into account both dimensions of (1) software variability and (2) input data. In this problem-statement paper, we conduct a large study over 8 configurable systems that quantifies the existing interactions between input data and configurations of software systems. The results exhibit that (1) inputs fed to software systems interact with their configuration options in non monotonous ways, significantly impacting their performance properties (2) tuning a software system for its input data makes it possible to multiply its performance by up to ten (3) input variability can jeopardize the relevance of performance predictive models for a field deployment. △ Less

Submitted 21 February, 2023; v1 submitted 14 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: 24 pages

Journal ref: Journal of Software and Systems 2023

Towards Quality Assurance of Software Product Lines with Adversarial Configurations

Authors: Paul Temple, Mathieu Acher, Gilles Perrouin, Battista Biggio, Jean-marc Jezequel, Fabio Roli

Abstract: Software product line (SPL) engineers put a lot of effort to ensure that, through the setting of a large number of possible configuration options, products are acceptable and well-tailored to customers' needs. Unfortunately, options and their mutual interactions create a huge configuration space which is intractable to exhaustively explore. Instead of testing all products, machine learning techniq… ▽ More Software product line (SPL) engineers put a lot of effort to ensure that, through the setting of a large number of possible configuration options, products are acceptable and well-tailored to customers' needs. Unfortunately, options and their mutual interactions create a huge configuration space which is intractable to exhaustively explore. Instead of testing all products, machine learning techniques are increasingly employed to approximate the set of acceptable products out of a small training sample of configurations. Machine learning (ML) techniques can refine a software product line through learned constraints and a priori prevent non-acceptable products to be derived. In this paper, we use adversarial ML techniques to generate adversarial configurations fooling ML classifiers and pinpoint incorrect classifications of products (videos) derived from an industrial video generator. Our attacks yield (up to) a 100% misclassification rate and a drop in accuracy of 5%. We discuss the implications these results have on SPL quality assurance. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: This is a preview version of a paper accepted and presented at SPLC'19 that took place in Paris from 9th to 13th of September 2019. Some minor changes might appear compared to the one from the proceedings of the conference

Learning Software Configuration Spaces: A Systematic Literature Review

Authors: Juliana Alves Pereira, Hugo Martin, Mathieu Acher, Jean-Marc Jézéquel, Goetz Botterweck, Anthony Ventresque

Abstract: Most modern software systems (operating systems like Linux or Android, Web browsers like Firefox or Chrome, video encoders like ffmpeg, x264 or VLC, mobile and cloud applications, etc.) are highly-configurable. Hundreds of configuration options, features, or plugins can be combined, each potentially with distinct functionality and effects on execution time, security, energy consumption, etc. Due t… ▽ More Most modern software systems (operating systems like Linux or Android, Web browsers like Firefox or Chrome, video encoders like ffmpeg, x264 or VLC, mobile and cloud applications, etc.) are highly-configurable. Hundreds of configuration options, features, or plugins can be combined, each potentially with distinct functionality and effects on execution time, security, energy consumption, etc. Due to the combinatorial explosion and the cost of executing software, it is quickly impossible to exhaustively explore the whole configuration space. Hence, numerous works have investigated the idea of learning it from a small sample of configurations' measurements. The pattern "sampling, measuring, learning" has emerged in the literature, with several practical interests for both software developers and end-users of configurable systems. In this survey, we report on the different application objectives (e.g., performance prediction, configuration optimization, constraint mining), use-cases, targeted software systems and application domains. We review the various strategies employed to gather a representative and cost-effective sample. We describe automated software techniques used to measure functional and non-functional properties of configurations. We classify machine learning algorithms and how they relate to the pursued application. Finally, we also describe how researchers evaluate the quality of the learning process. The findings from this systematic review show that the potential application objective is important; there are a vast number of case studies reported in the literature from the basis of several domains and software systems. Yet, the huge variant space of configurable systems is still challenging and calls to further investigate the synergies between artificial intelligence and software engineering. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Towards Adversarial Configurations for Software Product Lines

Authors: Paul Temple, Mathieu Acher, Battista Biggio, Jean-Marc Jézéquel, Fabio Roli

Abstract: Ensuring that all supposedly valid configurations of a software product line (SPL) lead to well-formed and acceptable products is challenging since it is most of the time impractical to enumerate and test all individual products of an SPL. Machine learning classifiers have been recently used to predict the acceptability of products associated with unseen configurations. For some configurations, a… ▽ More Ensuring that all supposedly valid configurations of a software product line (SPL) lead to well-formed and acceptable products is challenging since it is most of the time impractical to enumerate and test all individual products of an SPL. Machine learning classifiers have been recently used to predict the acceptability of products associated with unseen configurations. For some configurations, a tiny change in their feature values can make them pass from acceptable to non-acceptable regarding users' requirements and vice-versa. In this paper, we introduce the idea of leveraging these specific configurations and their positions in the feature space to improve the classifier and therefore the engineering of an SPL. Starting from a variability model, we propose to use Adversarial Machine Learning techniques to create new, adversarial configurations out of already known configurations by modifying their feature values. Using an industrial video generator we show how adversarial configurations can improve not only the classifier, but also the variability model, the variability implementation, and the testing oracle. △ Less

Submitted 30 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Test them all, is it worth it? Assessing configuration sampling on the JHipster Web development stack

Authors: Axel Halin, Alexandre Nuttinck, Mathieu Acher, Xavier Devroey, Gilles Perrouin, Benoit Baudry

Abstract: Many approaches for testing configurable software systems start from the same assumption: it is impossible to test all configurations. This motivated the definition of variability-aware abstractions and sampling techniques to cope with large configuration spaces. Yet, there is no theoretical barrier that prevents the exhaustive testing of all configurations by simply enumerating them, if the effor… ▽ More Many approaches for testing configurable software systems start from the same assumption: it is impossible to test all configurations. This motivated the definition of variability-aware abstractions and sampling techniques to cope with large configuration spaces. Yet, there is no theoretical barrier that prevents the exhaustive testing of all configurations by simply enumerating them, if the effort required to do so remains acceptable. Not only this: we believe there is lots to be learned by systematically and exhaustively testing a configurable system. In this case study, we report on the first ever endeavour to test all possible configurations of an industry-strength, open source configurable software system, JHipster, a popular code generator for web applications. We built a testing scaffold for the 26,000+ configurations of JHipster using a cluster of 80 machines during 4 nights for a total of 4,376 hours (182 days) CPU time. We find that 35.70% configurations fail and we identify the feature interactions that cause the errors. We show that sampling strategies (like dissimilarity and 2-wise): (1) are more effective to find faults than the 12 default configurations used in the JHipster continuous integration; (2) can be too costly and exceed the available testing budget. We cross this quantitative analysis with the qualitative assessment of JHipster's lead developers. △ Less

Submitted 11 June, 2018; v1 submitted 22 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: Submitted to Empirical Software Engineering

Large-scale Analysis of Chess Games with Chess Engines: A Preliminary Report

Authors: Mathieu Acher, François Esnault

Abstract: The strength of chess engines together with the availability of numerous chess games have attracted the attention of chess players, data scientists, and researchers during the last decades. State-of-the-art engines now provide an authoritative judgement that can be used in many applications like cheating detection, intrinsic ratings computation, skill assessment, or the study of human decision-mak… ▽ More The strength of chess engines together with the availability of numerous chess games have attracted the attention of chess players, data scientists, and researchers during the last decades. State-of-the-art engines now provide an authoritative judgement that can be used in many applications like cheating detection, intrinsic ratings computation, skill assessment, or the study of human decision-making. A key issue for the research community is to gather a large dataset of chess games together with the judgement of chess engines. Unfortunately the analysis of each move takes lots of times. In this paper, we report our effort to analyse almost 5 millions chess games with a computing grid. During summer 2015, we processed 270 millions unique played positions using the Stockfish engine with a quite high depth (20). We populated a database of 1+ tera-octets of chess evaluations, representing an estimated time of 50 years of computation on a single machine. Our effort is a first step towards the replication of research results, the supply of open data and procedures for exploring new directions, and the investigation of software engineering/scalability issues when computing billions of moves. △ Less

Submitted 28 April, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Synthesis of Attributed Feature Models From Product Descriptions: Foundations

Authors: Guillaume Bécan, Razieh Behjati, Arnaud Gotlieb, Mathieu Acher

Abstract: Feature modeling is a widely used formalism to characterize a set of products (also called configurations). As a manual elaboration is a long and arduous task, numerous techniques have been proposed to reverse engineer feature models from various kinds of artefacts. But none of them synthesize feature attributes (or constraints over attributes) despite the practical relevance of attributes for do… ▽ More Feature modeling is a widely used formalism to characterize a set of products (also called configurations). As a manual elaboration is a long and arduous task, numerous techniques have been proposed to reverse engineer feature models from various kinds of artefacts. But none of them synthesize feature attributes (or constraints over attributes) despite the practical relevance of attributes for documenting the different values across a range of products. In this report, we develop an algorithm for synthesizing attributed feature models given a set of product descriptions. We present sound, complete, and parametrizable techniques for computing all possible hierarchies, feature groups, placements of feature attributes, domain values, and constraints. We perform a complexity analysis w.r.t. number of features, attributes, configurations, and domain size. We also evaluate the scalability of our synthesis procedure using randomized configuration matrices. This report is a first step that aims to describe the foundations for synthesizing attributed feature models. △ Less

Submitted 16 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Metamorphic Domain-Specific Languages: A Journey Into the Shapes of a Language

Authors: Mathieu Acher, Benoit Combemale, Philippe Collet

Abstract: External or internal domain-specific languages (DSLs) or (fluent) APIs? Whoever you are -- a developer or a user of a DSL -- you usually have to choose your side; you should not! What about metamorphic DSLs that change their shape according to your needs? We report on our 4-years journey of providing the "right" support (in the domain of feature modeling), leading us to develop an external DSL, di… ▽ More External or internal domain-specific languages (DSLs) or (fluent) APIs? Whoever you are -- a developer or a user of a DSL -- you usually have to choose your side; you should not! What about metamorphic DSLs that change their shape according to your needs? We report on our 4-years journey of providing the "right" support (in the domain of feature modeling), leading us to develop an external DSL, different shapes of an internal API, and maintain all these languages. A key insight is that there is no one-size-fits-all solution or no clear superiority of a solution compared to another. On the contrary, we found that it does make sense to continue the maintenance of an external and internal DSL. The vision that we foresee for the future of software languages is their ability to be self-adaptable to the most appropriate shape (including the corresponding integrated development environment) according to a particular usage or task. We call metamorphic DSL such a language, able to change from one shape to another shape. △ Less

Submitted 27 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.