-
Descending Price Auctions with Bounded Number of Price Levels and Batched Prophet Inequality
Authors:
Saeed Alaei,
Ali Makhdoumi,
Azarakhsh Malekian,
Rad Niazadeh
Abstract:
We consider descending price auctions for selling $m$ units of a good to unit demand i.i.d. buyers where there is an exogenous bound of $k$ on the number of price levels the auction clock can take. The auctioneer's problem is to choose price levels $p_1 > p_2 > \cdots > p_{k}$ for the auction clock such that auction expected revenue is maximized. The prices levels are announced prior to the auctio…
▽ More
We consider descending price auctions for selling $m$ units of a good to unit demand i.i.d. buyers where there is an exogenous bound of $k$ on the number of price levels the auction clock can take. The auctioneer's problem is to choose price levels $p_1 > p_2 > \cdots > p_{k}$ for the auction clock such that auction expected revenue is maximized. The prices levels are announced prior to the auction. We reduce this problem to a new variant of prophet inequality, which we call \emph{batched prophet inequality}, where a decision-maker chooses $k$ (decreasing) thresholds and then sequentially collects rewards (up to $m$) that are above the thresholds with ties broken uniformly at random. For the special case of $m=1$ (i.e., selling a single item), we show that the resulting descending auction with $k$ price levels achieves $1- 1/e^k$ of the unrestricted (without the bound of $k$) optimal revenue. That means a descending auction with just 4 price levels can achieve more than 98\% of the optimal revenue. We then extend our results for $m>1$ and provide a closed-form bound on the competitive ratio of our auction as a function of the number of units $m$ and the number of price levels $k$.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Response Prediction for Low-Regret Agents
Authors:
Saeed Alaei,
Ashwinkumar Badanidiyuru,
Mohammad Mahdian,
Sadra Yazdanbod
Abstract:
Companies like Google and Microsoft run billions of auctions every day to sell advertising opportunities. Any change to the rules of these auctions can have a tremendous effect on the revenue of the company and the welfare of the advertisers and the users. Therefore, any change requires careful evaluation of its potential impacts. Currently, such impacts are often evaluated by running simulations…
▽ More
Companies like Google and Microsoft run billions of auctions every day to sell advertising opportunities. Any change to the rules of these auctions can have a tremendous effect on the revenue of the company and the welfare of the advertisers and the users. Therefore, any change requires careful evaluation of its potential impacts. Currently, such impacts are often evaluated by running simulations or small controlled experiments. This, however, misses the important factor that the advertisers respond to changes. Our goal is to build a theoretical framework for predicting the actions of an agent (the advertiser) that is optimizing her actions in an uncertain environment. We model this problem using a variant of the multi-armed bandit setting where playing an arm is costly. The cost of each arm changes over time and is publicly observable. The value of playing an arm is drawn stochastically from a static distribution and is observed by the agent and not by us. We, however, observe the actions of the agent. Our main result is that assuming the agent is playing a strategy with a regret of at most $f(T)$ within the first $T$ rounds, we can learn to play the multi-armed bandits game (without observing the rewards) in such a way that the regret of our selected actions is at most $O(k^4(f(T)+1)\log(T))$, where $k$ is the number of arms.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Computing Equilibrium in Matching Markets
Authors:
Saeed Alaei,
Pooya Jalaly,
Eva Tardos
Abstract:
Market equilibria of matching markets offer an intuitive and fair solution for matching problems without money with agents who have preferences over the items. Such a matching market can be viewed as a variation of Fisher market, albeit with rather peculiar preferences of agents. These preferences can be described by piece-wise linear concave (PLC) functions, which however, are not separable (due…
▽ More
Market equilibria of matching markets offer an intuitive and fair solution for matching problems without money with agents who have preferences over the items. Such a matching market can be viewed as a variation of Fisher market, albeit with rather peculiar preferences of agents. These preferences can be described by piece-wise linear concave (PLC) functions, which however, are not separable (due to each agent only asking for one item), are not monotone, and do not satisfy the gross substitute property-- increase in price of an item can result in increased demand for the item. Devanur and Kannan in FOCS 08 showed that market clearing prices can be found in polynomial time in markets with fixed number of items and general PLC preferences. They also consider Fischer markets with fixed number of agents (instead of fixed number of items), and give a polynomial time algorithm for this case if preferences are separable functions of the items, in addition to being PLC functions.
Our main result is a polynomial time algorithm for finding market clearing prices in matching markets with fixed number of different agent preferences, despite that the utility corresponding to matching markets is not separable. We also give a simpler algorithm for the case of matching markets with fixed number of different items.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Optimal Auctions vs. Anonymous Pricing
Authors:
Saeed Alaei,
Jason Hartline,
Rad Niazadeh,
Emmanouil Pountourakis,
Yang Yuan
Abstract:
For selling a single item to agents with independent but non-identically distributed values, the revenue optimal auction is complex. With respect to it, Hartline and Roughgarden (2009) showed that the approximation factor of the second-price auction with an anonymous reserve is between two and four. We consider the more demanding problem of approximating the revenue of the ex ante relaxation of th…
▽ More
For selling a single item to agents with independent but non-identically distributed values, the revenue optimal auction is complex. With respect to it, Hartline and Roughgarden (2009) showed that the approximation factor of the second-price auction with an anonymous reserve is between two and four. We consider the more demanding problem of approximating the revenue of the ex ante relaxation of the auction problem by posting an anonymous price (while supplies last) and prove that their worst-case ratio is e. As a corollary, the upper-bound of anonymous pricing or anonymous reserves versus the optimal auction improves from four to $e$. We conclude that, up to an $e$ factor, discrimination and simultaneity are unimportant for driving revenue in single-item auctions.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
TimeMachine: Timeline Generation for Knowledge-Base Entities
Authors:
Tim Althoff,
Xin Luna Dong,
Kevin Murphy,
Safa Alai,
Van Dang,
Wei Zhang
Abstract:
We present a method called TIMEMACHINE to generate a timeline of events and relations for entities in a knowledge base. For example for an actor, such a timeline should show the most important professional and personal milestones and relationships such as works, awards, collaborations, and family relationships. We develop three orthogonal timeline quality criteria that an ideal timeline should sat…
▽ More
We present a method called TIMEMACHINE to generate a timeline of events and relations for entities in a knowledge base. For example for an actor, such a timeline should show the most important professional and personal milestones and relationships such as works, awards, collaborations, and family relationships. We develop three orthogonal timeline quality criteria that an ideal timeline should satisfy: (1) it shows events that are relevant to the entity; (2) it shows events that are temporally diverse, so they distribute along the time axis, avoiding visual crowding and allowing for easy user interaction, such as zooming in and out; and (3) it shows events that are content diverse, so they contain many different types of events (e.g., for an actor, it should show movies and marriages and awards, not just movies). We present an algorithm to generate such timelines for a given time period and screen size, based on submodular optimization and web-co-occurrence statistics with provable performance guarantees. A series of user studies using Mechanical Turk shows that all three quality criteria are crucial to produce quality timelines and that our algorithm significantly outperforms various baseline and state-of-the-art methods.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2015; v1 submitted 16 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
On Random Sampling Auctions for Digital Goods
Authors:
Saeed Alaei,
Azarakhsh Malekian,
Aravind Srinivasan
Abstract:
In the context of auctions for digital goods, an interesting random sampling auction has been proposed by Goldberg, Hartline, and Wright [2001]. This auction has been analyzed by Feige, Flaxman, Hartline, and Kleinberg [2005], who have shown that it is 15-competitive in the worst case {which is substantially better than the previously proven constant bounds but still far from the conjectured compe…
▽ More
In the context of auctions for digital goods, an interesting random sampling auction has been proposed by Goldberg, Hartline, and Wright [2001]. This auction has been analyzed by Feige, Flaxman, Hartline, and Kleinberg [2005], who have shown that it is 15-competitive in the worst case {which is substantially better than the previously proven constant bounds but still far from the conjectured competitive ratio of 4. In this paper, we prove that the aforementioned random sampling auction is indeed 4-competitive for a large class of instances where the number of bids above (or equal to) the optimal sale price is at least 6. We also show that it is 4:68-competitive for the small class of remaining instances thus leaving a negligible gap between the lower and upper bound. We employ a mix of probabilistic techniques and dynamic programming to compute these bounds.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
The Simple Economics of Approximately Optimal Auctions
Authors:
Saeed Alaei,
Hu Fu,
Nima Haghpanah,
Jason Hartline
Abstract:
The intuition that profit is optimized by maximizing marginal revenue is a guiding principle in microeconomics. In the classical auction theory for agents with linear utility and single-dimensional preferences, Bulow and Roberts (1989) show that the optimal auction of Myerson (1981) is in fact optimizing marginal revenue. In particular Myerson's virtual values are exactly the derivative of an appr…
▽ More
The intuition that profit is optimized by maximizing marginal revenue is a guiding principle in microeconomics. In the classical auction theory for agents with linear utility and single-dimensional preferences, Bulow and Roberts (1989) show that the optimal auction of Myerson (1981) is in fact optimizing marginal revenue. In particular Myerson's virtual values are exactly the derivative of an appropriate revenue curve.
This paper considers mechanism design in environments where the agents have multi-dimensional and non-linear preferences. Understanding good auctions for these environments is considered to be the main challenge in Bayesian optimal mechanism design. In these environments maximizing marginal revenue may not be optimal and there is sometimes no direct way to implement the marginal revenue maximization. Our contributions are three fold: we characterize the settings for which marginal revenue maximization is optimal (by identifying an important condition that we call revenue linearity), we give simple procedures for implementing marginal revenue maximization in general, and we show that marginal revenue maximization is approximately optimal. Our approximation factor smoothly degrades in a term that quantifies how far the environment is from ideal (where marginal revenue maximization is optimal). Because the marginal revenue mechanism is optimal for single-dimensional agents, our generalization immediately approximately extends many results for single-dimensional agents.
One of the biggest open questions in Bayesian algorithmic mechanism design is developing methodologies that are not brute-force in the size of the agent type space. Our methods identify a subproblem that, e.g., for unit-demand agents with values drawn from product distributions, enables approximation mechanisms that are polynomial in the dimension.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2014; v1 submitted 15 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Bayesian Optimal Auctions via Multi- to Single-agent Reduction
Authors:
Saeed Alaei,
Hu Fu,
Nima Haghpanah,
Jason Hartline,
Azarakhsh Malekian
Abstract:
We study an abstract optimal auction problem for a single good or service. This problem includes environments where agents have budgets, risk preferences, or multi-dimensional preferences over several possible configurations of the good (furthermore, it allows an agent's budget and risk preference to be known only privately to the agent). These are the main challenge areas for auction theory. A si…
▽ More
We study an abstract optimal auction problem for a single good or service. This problem includes environments where agents have budgets, risk preferences, or multi-dimensional preferences over several possible configurations of the good (furthermore, it allows an agent's budget and risk preference to be known only privately to the agent). These are the main challenge areas for auction theory. A single-agent problem is to optimize a given objective subject to a constraint on the maximum probability with which each type is allocated, a.k.a., an allocation rule. Our approach is a reduction from multi-agent mechanism design problem to collection of single-agent problems. We focus on maximizing revenue, but our results can be applied to other objectives (e.g., welfare).
An optimal multi-agent mechanism can be computed by a linear/convex program on interim allocation rules by simultaneously optimizing several single-agent mechanisms subject to joint feasibility of the allocation rules. For single-unit auctions, Border \citeyearpar{B91} showed that the space of all jointly feasible interim allocation rules for $n$ agents is a $\NumTypes$-dimensional convex polytope which can be specified by $2^\NumTypes$ linear constraints, where $\NumTypes$ is the total number of all agents' types. Consequently, efficiently solving the mechanism design problem requires a separation oracle for the feasibility conditions and also an algorithm for ex-post implementation of the interim allocation rules. We show that the polytope of jointly feasible interim allocation rules is the projection of a higher dimensional polytope which can be specified by only $O(\NumTypes^2)$ linear constraints. Furthermore, our proof shows that finding a preimage of the interim allocation rules in the higher dimensional polytope immediately gives an ex-post implementation.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
AdCell: Ad Allocation in Cellular Networks
Authors:
Saeed Alaei,
Mohammad T. Hajiaghayi,
Vahid Liaghat,
Dan Pei,
Barna Saha
Abstract:
With more than four billion usage of cellular phones worldwide, mobile advertising has become an attractive alternative to online advertisements. In this paper, we propose a new targeted advertising policy for Wireless Service Providers (WSPs) via SMS or MMS- namely {\em AdCell}. In our model, a WSP charges the advertisers for showing their ads. Each advertiser has a valuation for specific types o…
▽ More
With more than four billion usage of cellular phones worldwide, mobile advertising has become an attractive alternative to online advertisements. In this paper, we propose a new targeted advertising policy for Wireless Service Providers (WSPs) via SMS or MMS- namely {\em AdCell}. In our model, a WSP charges the advertisers for showing their ads. Each advertiser has a valuation for specific types of customers in various times and locations and has a limit on the maximum available budget. Each query is in the form of time and location and is associated with one individual customer. In order to achieve a non-intrusive delivery, only a limited number of ads can be sent to each customer. Recently, new services have been introduced that offer location-based advertising over cellular network that fit in our model (e.g., ShopAlerts by AT&T) .
We consider both online and offline version of the AdCell problem and develop approximation algorithms with constant competitive ratio. For the online version, we assume that the appearances of the queries follow a stochastic distribution and thus consider a Bayesian setting. Furthermore, queries may come from different distributions on different times. This model generalizes several previous advertising models such as online secretary problem \cite{HKP04}, online bipartite matching \cite{KVV90,FMMM09} and AdWords \cite{saberi05}. ...
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2012; v1 submitted 22 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
Bayesian Combinatorial Auctions: Expanding Single Buyer Mechanisms to Many Buyers
Authors:
Saeed Alaei
Abstract:
For Bayesian combinatorial auctions, we present a general framework for approximately reducing the mechanism design problem for multiple buyers to single buyer sub-problems. Our framework can be applied to any setting which roughly satisfies the following assumptions: (i) buyers' types must be distributed independently (not necessarily identically), (ii) objective function must be linearly separab…
▽ More
For Bayesian combinatorial auctions, we present a general framework for approximately reducing the mechanism design problem for multiple buyers to single buyer sub-problems. Our framework can be applied to any setting which roughly satisfies the following assumptions: (i) buyers' types must be distributed independently (not necessarily identically), (ii) objective function must be linearly separable over the buyers, and (iii) except for the supply constraints, there should be no other inter-buyer constraints. Our framework is general in the sense that it makes no explicit assumption about buyers' valuations, type distributions, and single buyer constraints (e.g., budget, incentive compatibility, etc).
We present two generic multi buyer mechanisms which use single buyer mechanisms as black boxes; if an $α$-approximate single buyer mechanism can be constructed for each buyer, and if no buyer requires more than $\frac{1}{k}$ of all units of each item, then our generic multi buyer mechanisms are $γ_kα$-approximation of the optimal multi buyer mechanism, where $γ_k$ is a constant which is at least $1-\frac{1}{\sqrt{k+3}}$. Observe that $γ_k$ is at least 1/2 (for $k=1$) and approaches 1 as $k \to \infty$. As a byproduct of our construction, we present a generalization of prophet inequalities. Furthermore, as applications of our framework, we present multi buyer mechanisms with improved approximation factor for several settings from the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2012; v1 submitted 6 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Maximizing Sequence-Submodular Functions and its Application to Online Advertising
Authors:
Saeed Alaei,
Ali Makhdoumi,
Azarakhsh Malekian
Abstract:
Motivated by applications in online advertising, we consider a class of maximization problems where the objective is a function of the sequence of actions as well as the running duration of each action. For these problems, we introduce the concepts of \emph{sequence-submodularity} and \emph{sequence-monotonicity} which extend the notions of submodularity and monotonicity from functions defined ove…
▽ More
Motivated by applications in online advertising, we consider a class of maximization problems where the objective is a function of the sequence of actions as well as the running duration of each action. For these problems, we introduce the concepts of \emph{sequence-submodularity} and \emph{sequence-monotonicity} which extend the notions of submodularity and monotonicity from functions defined over sets to functions defined over sequences. We establish that if the objective function is sequence-submodular and sequence-non-decreasing, then there exists a greedy algorithm that achieves $1-1/e$ of the optimal solution. We apply our algorithm and analysis to two applications in online advertising: online ad allocation and query rewriting. We first show that both problems can be formulated as maximizing non-decreasing sequence-submodular functions. We then apply our framework to these two problems, leading to simple greedy approaches with guaranteed performances. In particular, for online ad allocation problem the performance of our algorithm is $1-1/e$, which matches the best known existing performance, and for query rewriting problem the performance of our algorithm is $1- 1/e^{1-1/e}$ which improves upon the best known existing performance in the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2019; v1 submitted 21 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
Competitive Equilibria in Two Sided Matching Markets with Non-transferable Utilities
Authors:
Saeed Alaei,
Kamal Jain,
Azarakhsh Malekian
Abstract:
We consider two sided matching markets consisting of agents with non-transferable utilities; agents from the opposite sides form matching pairs (e.g., buyers-sellers) and negotiate the terms of their math which may include a monetary transfer. Competitive equilibria are the elements of the core of this game.
We present the first combinatorial characterization of competitive equilibria that relat…
▽ More
We consider two sided matching markets consisting of agents with non-transferable utilities; agents from the opposite sides form matching pairs (e.g., buyers-sellers) and negotiate the terms of their math which may include a monetary transfer. Competitive equilibria are the elements of the core of this game.
We present the first combinatorial characterization of competitive equilibria that relates the utility of each agent at equilibrium to the equilibrium utilities of other agents in a strictly smaller market excluding that agent; thus automatically providing a constructive proof of existence of competitive equilibria in such markets.
Our characterization also yields a group strategyproof mechanism for allocating indivisible goods to unit demand buyers with non-quasilinear utilities that highly resembles the Vickrey Clarke Groves (VCG) mechanism. As a direct application of this, we present a group strategyproof welfare maximizing mechanism for Ad-Auctions without requiring the usual assumption that search engine and advertisers have consistent estimates of the clickthrough rates.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2012; v1 submitted 24 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
