-
Addressing the Unforeseen Harms of Technology CCC Whitepaper
Authors:
Nadya Bliss,
Kevin Butler,
David Danks,
Ufuk Topcu,
Matthew Turk
Abstract:
Recent years have seen increased awareness of the potential significant impacts of computing technologies, both positive and negative. This whitepaper explores how to address possible harmful consequences of computing technologies that might be difficult to anticipate, and thereby mitigate or address. It starts from the assumption that very few harms due to technology are intentional or deliberate…
▽ More
Recent years have seen increased awareness of the potential significant impacts of computing technologies, both positive and negative. This whitepaper explores how to address possible harmful consequences of computing technologies that might be difficult to anticipate, and thereby mitigate or address. It starts from the assumption that very few harms due to technology are intentional or deliberate; rather, the vast majority result from failure to recognize and respond to them prior to deployment. Nonetheless, there are concrete steps that can be taken to address the difficult problem of anticipating and responding to potential harms from new technologies.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Computing Research for the Climate Crisis
Authors:
Nadya Bliss,
Elizabeth Bradley,
Claire Monteleoni
Abstract:
Climate change is an existential threat to the United States and the world. Inevitably, computing will play a key role in mitigation, adaptation, and resilience in response to this threat. The needs span all areas of computing, from devices and architectures (e.g., low-power sensor systems for wildfire monitoring) to algorithms (e.g., predicting impacts and evaluating mitigation), and robotics (e.…
▽ More
Climate change is an existential threat to the United States and the world. Inevitably, computing will play a key role in mitigation, adaptation, and resilience in response to this threat. The needs span all areas of computing, from devices and architectures (e.g., low-power sensor systems for wildfire monitoring) to algorithms (e.g., predicting impacts and evaluating mitigation), and robotics (e.g., autonomous UAVs for monitoring and actuation) -- as well as every level of the software stack, from data management systems and energy-aware operating systems to hardware/software co-design. The goal of this white paper is to highlight the role of computing research in addressing climate change-induced challenges. To that end, we outline six key impact areas in which these challenges will arise -- energy, environmental justice, transportation, infrastructure, agriculture, and environmental monitoring and forecasting -- then identify specific ways in which computing research can help address the associated problems. These impact areas will create a driving force behind, and enable, cross-cutting, system-level innovation. We further break down this information into four broad areas of computing research: devices & architectures, software, algorithms/AI/robotics, and sociotechnical computing.
Additional contributions by: Ilkay Altintas (San Diego Supercomputer Center), Kyri Baker (University of Colorado Boulder), Sujata Banerjee (VMware), Andrew A. Chien (University of Chicago), Thomas Dietterich (Oregon State University), Ian Foster (Argonne National Labs), Carla P. Gomes (Cornell University), Chandra Krintz (University of California, Santa Barbara), Jessica Seddon (World Resources Institute), and Regan Zane (Utah State University).
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2021; v1 submitted 12 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
CCC/Code 8.7: Applying AI in the Fight Against Modern Slavery
Authors:
Nadya Bliss,
Mark Briers,
Alice Eckstein,
James Goulding,
Daniel P. Lopresti,
Anjali Mazumder,
Gavin Smith
Abstract:
On any given day, tens of millions of people find themselves trapped in instances of modern slavery. The terms "human trafficking," "trafficking in persons," and "modern slavery" are sometimes used interchangeably to refer to both sex trafficking and forced labor. Human trafficking occurs when a trafficker compels someone to provide labor or services through the use of force, fraud, and/or coercio…
▽ More
On any given day, tens of millions of people find themselves trapped in instances of modern slavery. The terms "human trafficking," "trafficking in persons," and "modern slavery" are sometimes used interchangeably to refer to both sex trafficking and forced labor. Human trafficking occurs when a trafficker compels someone to provide labor or services through the use of force, fraud, and/or coercion. The wide range of stakeholders in human trafficking presents major challenges. Direct stakeholders are law enforcement, NGOs and INGOs, businesses, local/planning government authorities, and survivors. Viewed from a very high level, all stakeholders share in a rich network of interactions that produce and consume enormous amounts of information. The problems of making efficient use of such information for the purposes of fighting trafficking while at the same time adhering to community standards of privacy and ethics are formidable. At the same time they help us, technologies that increase surveillance of populations can also undermine basic human rights.
In early March 2020, the Computing Community Consortium (CCC), in collaboration with the Code 8.7 Initiative, brought together over fifty members of the computing research community along with anti-slavery practitioners and survivors to lay out a research roadmap. The primary goal was to explore ways in which long-range research in artificial intelligence (AI) could be applied to the fight against human trafficking. Building on the kickoff Code 8.7 conference held at the headquarters of the United Nations in February 2019, the focus for this workshop was to link the ambitious goals outlined in the A 20-Year Community Roadmap for Artificial Intelligence Research in the US (AI Roadmap) to challenges vital in achieving the UN's Sustainable Development Goal Target 8.7, the elimination of modern slavery.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
A Research Ecosystem for Secure Computing
Authors:
Nadya Bliss,
Lawrence A. Gordon,
Daniel Lopresti,
Fred Schneider,
Suresh Venkatasubramanian
Abstract:
Computing devices are vital to all areas of modern life and permeate every aspect of our society. The ubiquity of computing and our reliance on it has been accelerated and amplified by the COVID-19 pandemic. From education to work environments to healthcare to defense to entertainment - it is hard to imagine a segment of modern life that is not touched by computing. The security of computers, syst…
▽ More
Computing devices are vital to all areas of modern life and permeate every aspect of our society. The ubiquity of computing and our reliance on it has been accelerated and amplified by the COVID-19 pandemic. From education to work environments to healthcare to defense to entertainment - it is hard to imagine a segment of modern life that is not touched by computing. The security of computers, systems, and applications has been an active area of research in computer science for decades. However, with the confluence of both the scale of interconnected systems and increased adoption of artificial intelligence, there are many research challenges the community must face so that our society can continue to benefit and risks are minimized, not multiplied. Those challenges range from security and trust of the information ecosystem to adversarial artificial intelligence and machine learning.
Along with basic research challenges, more often than not, securing a system happens after the design or even deployment, meaning the security community is routinely playing catch-up and attempting to patch vulnerabilities that could be exploited any minute. While security measures such as encryption and authentication have been widely adopted, questions of security tend to be secondary to application capability. There needs to be a sea-change in the way we approach this critically important aspect of the problem: new incentives and education are at the core of this change. Now is the time to refocus research community efforts on developing interconnected technologies with security "baked in by design" and creating an ecosystem that ensures adoption of promising research developments. To realize this vision, two additional elements of the ecosystem are necessary - proper incentive structures for adoption and an educated citizenry that is well versed in vulnerabilities and risks.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
An Agenda for Disinformation Research
Authors:
Nadya Bliss,
Elizabeth Bradley,
Joshua Garland,
Filippo Menczer,
Scott W. Ruston,
Kate Starbird,
Chris Wiggins
Abstract:
In the 21st Century information environment, adversarial actors use disinformation to manipulate public opinion. The distribution of false, misleading, or inaccurate information with the intent to deceive is an existential threat to the United States--distortion of information erodes trust in the socio-political institutions that are the fundamental fabric of democracy: legitimate news sources, sc…
▽ More
In the 21st Century information environment, adversarial actors use disinformation to manipulate public opinion. The distribution of false, misleading, or inaccurate information with the intent to deceive is an existential threat to the United States--distortion of information erodes trust in the socio-political institutions that are the fundamental fabric of democracy: legitimate news sources, scientists, experts, and even fellow citizens. As a result, it becomes difficult for society to come together within a shared reality; the common ground needed to function effectively as an economy and a nation. Computing and communication technologies have facilitated the exchange of information at unprecedented speeds and scales. This has had countless benefits to society and the economy, but it has also played a fundamental role in the rising volume, variety, and velocity of disinformation. Technological advances have created new opportunities for manipulation, influence, and deceit. They have effectively lowered the barriers to reaching large audiences, diminishing the role of traditional mass media along with the editorial oversight they provided. The digitization of information exchange, however, also makes the practices of disinformation detectable, the networks of influence discernable, and suspicious content characterizable. New tools and approaches must be developed to leverage these affordances to understand and address this growing challenge.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Interdisciplinary Approaches to Understanding Artificial Intelligence's Impact on Society
Authors:
Suresh Venkatasubramanian,
Nadya Bliss,
Helen Nissenbaum,
Melanie Moses
Abstract:
Innovations in AI have focused primarily on the questions of "what" and "how"-algorithms for finding patterns in web searches, for instance-without adequate attention to the possible harms (such as privacy, bias, or manipulation) and without adequate consideration of the societal context in which these systems operate. In part, this is driven by incentives and forces in the tech industry, where a…
▽ More
Innovations in AI have focused primarily on the questions of "what" and "how"-algorithms for finding patterns in web searches, for instance-without adequate attention to the possible harms (such as privacy, bias, or manipulation) and without adequate consideration of the societal context in which these systems operate. In part, this is driven by incentives and forces in the tech industry, where a more product-driven focus tends to drown out broader reflective concerns about potential harms and misframings. But this focus on what and how is largely a reflection of the engineering and mathematics-focused training in computer science, which emphasizes the building of tools and development of computational concepts.
As a result of this tight technical focus, and the rapid, worldwide explosion in its use, AI has come with a storm of unanticipated socio-technical problems, ranging from algorithms that act in racially or gender-biased ways, get caught in feedback loops that perpetuate inequalities, or enable unprecedented behavioral monitoring surveillance that challenges the fundamental values of free, democratic societies.
Given that AI is no longer solely the domain of technologists but rather of society as a whole, we need tighter coupling of computer science and those disciplines that study society and societal values.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Assured Autonomy: Path Toward Living With Autonomous Systems We Can Trust
Authors:
Ufuk Topcu,
Nadya Bliss,
Nancy Cooke,
Missy Cummings,
Ashley Llorens,
Howard Shrobe,
Lenore Zuck
Abstract:
The challenge of establishing assurance in autonomy is rapidly attracting increasing interest in the industry, government, and academia. Autonomy is a broad and expansive capability that enables systems to behave without direct control by a human operator. To that end, it is expected to be present in a wide variety of systems and applications. A vast range of industrial sectors, including (but by…
▽ More
The challenge of establishing assurance in autonomy is rapidly attracting increasing interest in the industry, government, and academia. Autonomy is a broad and expansive capability that enables systems to behave without direct control by a human operator. To that end, it is expected to be present in a wide variety of systems and applications. A vast range of industrial sectors, including (but by no means limited to) defense, mobility, health care, manufacturing, and civilian infrastructure, are embracing the opportunities in autonomy yet face the similar barriers toward establishing the necessary level of assurance sooner or later. Numerous government agencies are poised to tackle the challenges in assured autonomy.
Given the already immense interest and investment in autonomy, a series of workshops on Assured Autonomy was convened to facilitate dialogs and increase awareness among the stakeholders in the academia, industry, and government. This series of three workshops aimed to help create a unified understanding of the goals for assured autonomy, the research trends and needs, and a strategy that will facilitate sustained progress in autonomy.
The first workshop, held in October 2019, focused on current and anticipated challenges and problems in assuring autonomous systems within and across applications and sectors. The second workshop held in February 2020, focused on existing capabilities, current research, and research trends that could address the challenges and problems identified in workshop. The third event was dedicated to a discussion of a draft of the major findings from the previous two workshops and the recommendations.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Monodromy Solver: Sequential and Parallel
Authors:
Nathan Bliss,
Timothy Duff,
Anton Leykin,
Jeff Sommars
Abstract:
We describe, study, and experiment with an algorithm for finding all solutions of systems of polynomial equations using homotopy continuation and monodromy. This algorithm follows a framework developed in previous work and can operate in the presence of a large number of failures of the homotopy continuation subroutine. We give special attention to parallelization and probabilistic analysis of a m…
▽ More
We describe, study, and experiment with an algorithm for finding all solutions of systems of polynomial equations using homotopy continuation and monodromy. This algorithm follows a framework developed in previous work and can operate in the presence of a large number of failures of the homotopy continuation subroutine. We give special attention to parallelization and probabilistic analysis of a model adapted to parallelization and failures. Apart from theoretical results, we developed a simulator that allows us to run a large number of experiments without recomputing the outcomes of the continuation subroutine.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
The Method of Gauss-Newton to Compute Power Series Solutions of Polynomial Homotopies
Authors:
Nathan Bliss,
Jan Verschelde
Abstract:
We consider the extension of the method of Gauss-Newton from complex floating-point arithmetic to the field of truncated power series with complex floating-point coefficients. With linearization we formulate a linear system where the coefficient matrix is a series with matrix coefficients, and provide a characterization for when the matrix series is regular based on the algebraic variety of an aug…
▽ More
We consider the extension of the method of Gauss-Newton from complex floating-point arithmetic to the field of truncated power series with complex floating-point coefficients. With linearization we formulate a linear system where the coefficient matrix is a series with matrix coefficients, and provide a characterization for when the matrix series is regular based on the algebraic variety of an augmented system. The structure of the linear system leads to a block triangular system. In the regular case, solving the linear system is equivalent to solving a Hermite interpolation problem. We show that this solution has cost cubic in the problem size. In general, at singular points, we rely on methods of tropical algebraic geometry to compute Puiseux series. With a few illustrative examples, we demonstrate the application to polynomial homotopy continuation.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2017; v1 submitted 15 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Computing all Space Curve Solutions of Polynomial Systems by Polyhedral Methods
Authors:
Nathan Bliss,
Jan Verschelde
Abstract:
A polyhedral method to solve a system of polynomial equations exploits its sparse structure via the Newton polytopes of the polynomials. We propose a hybrid symbolic-numeric method to compute a Puiseux series expansion for every space curve that is a solution of a polynomial system. The focus of this paper concerns the difficult case when the leading powers of the Puiseux series of the space curve…
▽ More
A polyhedral method to solve a system of polynomial equations exploits its sparse structure via the Newton polytopes of the polynomials. We propose a hybrid symbolic-numeric method to compute a Puiseux series expansion for every space curve that is a solution of a polynomial system. The focus of this paper concerns the difficult case when the leading powers of the Puiseux series of the space curve are contained in the relative interior of a higher dimensional cone of the tropical prevariety. We show that this difficult case does not occur for polynomials with generic coefficients. To resolve this case, we propose to apply polyhedral end games to recover tropisms hidden in the tropical prevariety.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Solving Polynomial Systems in the Cloud with Polynomial Homotopy Continuation
Authors:
Nathan Bliss,
Jeff Sommars,
Jan Verschelde,
Xiangcheng Yu
Abstract:
Polynomial systems occur in many fields of science and engineering. Polynomial homotopy continuation methods apply symbolic-numeric algorithms to solve polynomial systems. We describe the design and implementation of our web interface and reflect on the application of polynomial homotopy continuation methods to solve polynomial systems in the cloud. Via the graph isomorphism problem we organize an…
▽ More
Polynomial systems occur in many fields of science and engineering. Polynomial homotopy continuation methods apply symbolic-numeric algorithms to solve polynomial systems. We describe the design and implementation of our web interface and reflect on the application of polynomial homotopy continuation methods to solve polynomial systems in the cloud. Via the graph isomorphism problem we organize and classify the polynomial systems we solved. The classification with the canonical form of a graph identifies newly submitted systems with systems that have already been solved.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Spectral Anomaly Detection in Very Large Graphs: Models, Noise, and Computational Complexity
Authors:
Benjamin A. Miller,
Nicholas Arcolano,
Michael M. Wolf,
Nadya T. Bliss
Abstract:
Anomaly detection in massive networks has numerous theoretical and computational challenges, especially as the behavior to be detected becomes small in comparison to the larger network. This presentation focuses on recent results in three key technical areas, specifically geared toward spectral methods for detection. We first discuss recent models for network behavior, and how their structure can…
▽ More
Anomaly detection in massive networks has numerous theoretical and computational challenges, especially as the behavior to be detected becomes small in comparison to the larger network. This presentation focuses on recent results in three key technical areas, specifically geared toward spectral methods for detection. We first discuss recent models for network behavior, and how their structure can be exploited for efficient computation of the principal eigenspace of the graph. In addition to the stochasticity of background activity, a graph of interest may be observed through a noisy or imperfect mechanism, which may hinder the detection process. A few simple noise models are discussed, and we demonstrate the ability to fuse multiple corrupted observations and recover detection performance. Finally, we discuss the challenges in scaling the spectral algorithms to large-scale high-performance computing systems, and present preliminary recommendations to achieve good performance with current parallel eigensolvers.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
A Spectral Framework for Anomalous Subgraph Detection
Authors:
Benjamin A. Miller,
Michelle S. Beard,
Patrick J. Wolfe,
Nadya T. Bliss
Abstract:
A wide variety of application domains are concerned with data consisting of entities and their relationships or connections, formally represented as graphs. Within these diverse application areas, a common problem of interest is the detection of a subset of entities whose connectivity is anomalous with respect to the rest of the data. While the detection of such anomalous subgraphs has received a…
▽ More
A wide variety of application domains are concerned with data consisting of entities and their relationships or connections, formally represented as graphs. Within these diverse application areas, a common problem of interest is the detection of a subset of entities whose connectivity is anomalous with respect to the rest of the data. While the detection of such anomalous subgraphs has received a substantial amount of attention, no application-agnostic framework exists for analysis of signal detectability in graph-based data. In this paper, we describe a framework that enables such analysis using the principal eigenspace of a graph's residuals matrix, commonly called the modularity matrix in community detection. Leveraging this analytical tool, we show that the framework has a natural power metric in the spectral norm of the anomalous subgraph's adjacency matrix (signal power) and of the background graph's residuals matrix (noise power). We propose several algorithms based on spectral properties of the residuals matrix, with more computationally expensive techniques providing greater detection power. Detection and identification performance are presented for a number of signal and noise models, including clusters and bipartite foregrounds embedded into simple random backgrounds as well as graphs with community structure and realistic degree distributions. The trends observed verify intuition gleaned from other signal processing areas, such as greater detection power when the signal is embedded within a less active portion of the background. We demonstrate the utility of the proposed techniques in detecting small, highly anomalous subgraphs in real graphs derived from Internet traffic and product co-purchases.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2014; v1 submitted 29 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
