-
Learning Object Compliance via Young's Modulus from Single Grasps with Camera-Based Tactile Sensors
Authors:
Michael Burgess
Abstract:
Compliance is a useful parametrization of tactile information that humans often utilize in manipulation tasks. It can be used to inform low-level contact-rich actions or characterize objects at a high-level. In robotic manipulation, existing approaches to estimate compliance have struggled to generalize across object shape and material. Using camera-based tactile sensors, we present a novel approa…
▽ More
Compliance is a useful parametrization of tactile information that humans often utilize in manipulation tasks. It can be used to inform low-level contact-rich actions or characterize objects at a high-level. In robotic manipulation, existing approaches to estimate compliance have struggled to generalize across object shape and material. Using camera-based tactile sensors, we present a novel approach to parametrize compliance through Young's modulus E. We evaluate our method over a novel dataset of 285 common objects, including a wide array of shapes and materials with Young's moduli ranging from 5.0 kPa to 250 GPa. Data is collected over automated parallel grasps of each object. Combining analytical and data-driven approaches, we develop a hybrid system using a multi-tower neural network to analyze a sequence of tactile images from grasping. This system is shown to estimate the Young's modulus of unseen objects within an order of magnitude at 74.2% accuracy across our dataset. This is a drastic improvement over a purely analytical baseline, which exhibits only 28.9% accuracy. Importantly, this estimation system performs irrespective of object geometry and demonstrates robustness across object materials. Thus, it could be applied in a general robotic manipulation setting to characterize unknown objects and inform decision-making, for instance to sort produce by ripeness.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
A Promise Theory Perspective on the Role of Intent in Group Dynamics
Authors:
M. Burgess,
R. I. M. Dunbar
Abstract:
We present a simple argument using Promise Theory and dimensional analysis for the Dunbar scaling hierarchy, supported by recent data from group formation in Wikipedia editing. We show how the assumption of a common priority seeds group alignment until the costs associated with attending to the group outweigh the benefits in a detailed balance scenario. Subject to partial efficiency of implementin…
▽ More
We present a simple argument using Promise Theory and dimensional analysis for the Dunbar scaling hierarchy, supported by recent data from group formation in Wikipedia editing. We show how the assumption of a common priority seeds group alignment until the costs associated with attending to the group outweigh the benefits in a detailed balance scenario. Subject to partial efficiency of implementing promised intentions, we can reproduce a series of compatible rates that balance growth with entropy.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Causal evidence for social group sizes from Wikipedia editing data
Authors:
M. Burgess,
R. I. M. Dunbar
Abstract:
Human communities have self-organizing properties in which specific Dunbar Numbers may be invoked to explain group attachments. By analyzing Wikipedia editing histories across a wide range of subject pages, we show that there is an emergent coherence in the size of transient groups formed to edit the content of subject texts, with two peaks averaging at around $N=8$ for the size corresponding to m…
▽ More
Human communities have self-organizing properties in which specific Dunbar Numbers may be invoked to explain group attachments. By analyzing Wikipedia editing histories across a wide range of subject pages, we show that there is an emergent coherence in the size of transient groups formed to edit the content of subject texts, with two peaks averaging at around $N=8$ for the size corresponding to maximal contention, and at around $N=4$ as a regular team. These values are consistent with the observed sizes of conversational groups, as well as the hierarchical structuring of Dunbar graphs. We use the Promise Theory model of bipartite trust to derive a scaling law that fits the data and may apply to all group size distributions, when based on attraction to a seeded group process. In addition to providing further evidence that even spontaneous communities of strangers are self-organizing, the results have important implications for the governance of the Wikipedia commons and for the security of all online social platforms and associations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2024; v1 submitted 1 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Robotic Arm Manipulation to Perform Rock Skipping in Simulation
Authors:
Nicholas Ramirez,
Michael Burgess
Abstract:
Rock skipping is a highly dynamic and relatively complex task that can easily be performed by humans. This project aims to bring rock skipping into a robotic setting, utilizing the lessons we learned in Robotic Manipulation. Specifically, this project implements a system consisting of a robotic arm and dynamic environment to perform rock skipping in simulation. By varying important parameters such…
▽ More
Rock skipping is a highly dynamic and relatively complex task that can easily be performed by humans. This project aims to bring rock skipping into a robotic setting, utilizing the lessons we learned in Robotic Manipulation. Specifically, this project implements a system consisting of a robotic arm and dynamic environment to perform rock skipping in simulation. By varying important parameters such as release velocity, we hope to use our system to gain insight into the most important factors for maximizing the total number of skips. In addition, by implementing the system in simulation, we have a more rigorous and precise testing approach over these varied test parameters. However, this project experienced some limitations due to gripping inefficiencies and problems with release height trajectories which is further discussed in our report.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Hybrid Trajectory Optimization of Simple Skateboarding Tricks through Contact
Authors:
Michael Burgess
Abstract:
Trajectories are optimized for a two-dimensional simplified skateboarding system to allow it to perform a fundamental skateboarding trick called an "ollie". A methodology for generating trick trajectories by controlling the position of a point-mass relative to a board is presented and demonstrated over a range of peak jump heights. A hybrid dynamics approach is taken to perform this optimization,…
▽ More
Trajectories are optimized for a two-dimensional simplified skateboarding system to allow it to perform a fundamental skateboarding trick called an "ollie". A methodology for generating trick trajectories by controlling the position of a point-mass relative to a board is presented and demonstrated over a range of peak jump heights. A hybrid dynamics approach is taken to perform this optimization, with contact constraints applied along a sequence of discrete timesteps based on the board's position throughout designated sections of the trick. These constraints introduce explicit and implicit discontinuities between chosen sections of the trick sequence. The approach has been shown to be successful for a set of realistic system parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Continuous Integration of Data Histories into Consistent Namespaces
Authors:
Mark Burgess,
Andras Gerlits
Abstract:
We describe a policy-based approach to the scaling of shared data services, using a hierarchy of calibrated data pipelines to automate the continuous integration of data flows. While there is no unique solution to the problem of time order, we show how to use a fair interleaving to reproduce reliable `latest version' semantics in a controlled way, by trading locality for temporal resolution. We th…
▽ More
We describe a policy-based approach to the scaling of shared data services, using a hierarchy of calibrated data pipelines to automate the continuous integration of data flows. While there is no unique solution to the problem of time order, we show how to use a fair interleaving to reproduce reliable `latest version' semantics in a controlled way, by trading locality for temporal resolution. We thus establish an invariant global ordering from a spanning tree over all shards, with controlled scalability. This forms a versioned coordinate system (or versioned namespace) with consistent semantics and self-protecting rate-limited versioning, analogous to publish-subscribe addressing schemes for Content Delivery Network (CDN) or Name Data Networking (NDN) schemes.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
On The Scale Dependence and Spacetime Dimension of the Internet with Causal Sets
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
A statistical measure of dimension is used to compute the effective average space dimension for the Internet and other graphs, based on typed edges (links) from an ensemble of starting points. The method is applied to CAIDA's ITDK data for the Internet. The effective dimension at different scales is calibrated to the conventional Euclidean dimension using low dimensional hypercubes. Internet space…
▽ More
A statistical measure of dimension is used to compute the effective average space dimension for the Internet and other graphs, based on typed edges (links) from an ensemble of starting points. The method is applied to CAIDA's ITDK data for the Internet. The effective dimension at different scales is calibrated to the conventional Euclidean dimension using low dimensional hypercubes. Internet spacetime has a 'foamy' multi-scale containment hierarchy, with interleaving semantic types. There is an emergent scale for approximate long range order in the device node spectrum, but this is not evident at the AS level, where there is finite distance containment. Statistical dimension is thus a locally varying measure, which is scale-dependent, giving an visual analogy for the hidden scale-dependent dimensions of Kaluza-Klein theories. The characteristic exterior dimensions of the Internet lie between 1.66 +- 0.00 and 6.12 +- 0.00, and maximal interior dimensions rise to 7.7.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Characterization of Frequent Online Shoppers using Statistical Learning with Sparsity
Authors:
Rajiv Sambasivan,
Mark Burgess,
Jörg Schad,
Arthur Keen,
Christopher Woodward,
Alexander Geenen,
Sachin Sharma
Abstract:
Developing shopping experiences that delight the customer requires businesses to understand customer taste. This work reports a method to learn the shopping preferences of frequent shoppers to an online gift store by combining ideas from retail analytics and statistical learning with sparsity. Shopping activity is represented as a bipartite graph. This graph is refined by applying sparsity-based s…
▽ More
Developing shopping experiences that delight the customer requires businesses to understand customer taste. This work reports a method to learn the shopping preferences of frequent shoppers to an online gift store by combining ideas from retail analytics and statistical learning with sparsity. Shopping activity is represented as a bipartite graph. This graph is refined by applying sparsity-based statistical learning methods. These methods are interpretable and reveal insights about customers' preferences as well as products driving revenue to the store.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
On system rollback and totalised fields
Authors:
Mark Burgess,
Alva Couch
Abstract:
In system operations it is commonly assumed that arbitrary changes to a system can be reversed or `rolled back', when errors of judgement and procedure occur. We point out that this view is flawed and provide an alternative approach to determining the outcome of changes.
Convergent operators are fixed-point generators that stem from the basic properties of multiplication by zero. They are capabl…
▽ More
In system operations it is commonly assumed that arbitrary changes to a system can be reversed or `rolled back', when errors of judgement and procedure occur. We point out that this view is flawed and provide an alternative approach to determining the outcome of changes.
Convergent operators are fixed-point generators that stem from the basic properties of multiplication by zero. They are capable of yielding a repeated and predictable outcome even in an incompletely specified or `open' system. We formulate such `convergent operators' for configuration change in the language of groups and rings and show that, in this form, the problem of convergent reversibility becomes equivalent to the `division by zero' problem. Hence, we discuss how recent work by Bergstra and Tucker on zero-totalised fields helps to clear up long-standing confusion about the options for `rollback' in change management.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Empirically Classifying Network Mechanisms
Authors:
Ryan E. Langendorf,
Matthew G. Burgess
Abstract:
Network models are used to study interconnected systems across many physical, biological, and social disciplines. Such models often assume a particular network-generating mechanism, which when fit to data produces estimates of mechanism-specific parameters that describe how systems function. For instance, a social network model might assume new individuals connect to others with probability propor…
▽ More
Network models are used to study interconnected systems across many physical, biological, and social disciplines. Such models often assume a particular network-generating mechanism, which when fit to data produces estimates of mechanism-specific parameters that describe how systems function. For instance, a social network model might assume new individuals connect to others with probability proportional to their number of pre-existing connections ('preferential attachment'), and then estimate the disparity in interactions between famous and obscure individuals with similar qualifications. However, without a means of testing the relevance of the assumed mechanism, conclusions from such models could be misleading. Here we introduce a simple empirical approach which can mechanistically classify arbitrary network data. Our approach compares empirical networks to model networks from a user-provided candidate set of mechanisms, and classifies each network--with high accuracy--as originating from either one of the mechanisms or none of them. We tested 373 empirical networks against five of the most widely studied network mechanisms and found that most (228) were unlike any of these mechanisms. This raises the possibility that some empirical networks arise from mixtures of mechanisms. We show that mixtures are often unidentifiable because different mixtures can produce functionally equivalent networks. In such systems, which are governed by multiple mechanisms, our approach can still accurately predict out-of-sample functional properties.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2021; v1 submitted 21 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Testing the Quantitative Spacetime Hypothesis using Artificial Narrative Comprehension (I) : Bootstrapping Meaning from Episodic Narrative viewed as a Feature Landscape
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
The problem of extracting important and meaningful parts of a sensory data stream, without prior training, is studied for symbolic sequences, by using textual narrative as a test case. This is part of a larger study concerning the extraction of concepts from spacetime processes, and their knowledge representations within hybrid symbolic-learning `Artificial Intelligence'. Most approaches to text a…
▽ More
The problem of extracting important and meaningful parts of a sensory data stream, without prior training, is studied for symbolic sequences, by using textual narrative as a test case. This is part of a larger study concerning the extraction of concepts from spacetime processes, and their knowledge representations within hybrid symbolic-learning `Artificial Intelligence'. Most approaches to text analysis make extensive use of the evolved human sense of language and semantics. In this work, streams are parsed without knowledge of semantics, using only measurable patterns (size and time) within the changing stream of symbols -- as an event `landscape'. This is a form of interferometry. Using lightweight procedures that can be run in just a few seconds on a single CPU, this work studies the validity of the Semantic Spacetime Hypothesis, for the extraction of concepts as process invariants. This `semantic preprocessor' may then act as a front-end for more sophisticated long-term graph-based learning techniques. The results suggest that what we consider important and interesting about sensory experience is not solely based on higher reasoning, but on simple spacetime process cues, and this may be how cognitive processing is bootstrapped in the beginning.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Testing the Quantitative Spacetime Hypothesis using Artificial Narrative Comprehension (II) : Establishing the Geometry of Invariant Concepts, Themes, and Namespaces
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
Given a pool of observations selected from a sensor stream, input data can be robustly represented, via a multiscale process, in terms of invariant concepts, and themes. Applying this to episodic natural language data, one may obtain a graph geometry associated with the decomposition, which is a direct encoding of spacetime relationships for the events. This study contributes to an ongoing applica…
▽ More
Given a pool of observations selected from a sensor stream, input data can be robustly represented, via a multiscale process, in terms of invariant concepts, and themes. Applying this to episodic natural language data, one may obtain a graph geometry associated with the decomposition, which is a direct encoding of spacetime relationships for the events. This study contributes to an ongoing application of the Semantic Spacetime Hypothesis, and demonstrates the unsupervised analysis of narrative texts using inexpensive computational methods without knowledge of linguistics. Data streams are parsed and fractionated into small constituents, by multiscale interferometry, in the manner of bioinformatic analysis. Fragments may then be recombined to construct original sensory episodes---or form new narratives by a chemistry of association and pattern reconstruction, based only on the four fundamental spacetime relationships. There is a straightforward correspondence between bioinformatic processes and this cognitive representation of natural language. Features identifiable as `concepts' and `narrative themes' span three main scales (micro, meso, and macro). Fragments of the input act as symbols in a hierarchy of alphabets that define new effective languages at each scale.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Information and Causality in Promise Theory
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
The explicit link between Promise Theory and Information Theory, while perhaps obvious, is laid out explicitly here. It's shown how causally related observations of promised behaviours relate to the probabilistic formulation of causal information in Shannon's theory, and thus clarify the meaning of autonomy or causal independence, and further the connection between information and causal sets. Pro…
▽ More
The explicit link between Promise Theory and Information Theory, while perhaps obvious, is laid out explicitly here. It's shown how causally related observations of promised behaviours relate to the probabilistic formulation of causal information in Shannon's theory, and thus clarify the meaning of autonomy or causal independence, and further the connection between information and causal sets. Promise Theory helps to make clear a number of assumptions which are commonly taken for granted in causal descriptions. The concept of a promise is hard to escape. It serves as proxy for intent, whether a priori or by inference, and it is intrinsic to the interpretations of observations in the latter.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Candidate Software Process Flaws for the Boeing 737 Max MCAS Algorithm and Risks for a Proposed Upgrade
Authors:
Jan A. Bergstra,
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
By reasoning about the claims and speculations promised as part of the public discourse, we analyze the hypothesis that flaws in software engineering played a critical role in the Boeing 737 MCAS incidents. We use promise-based reasoning to discuss how, from an outsider's perspective, one may assemble clues about what went wrong. Rather than looking for a Rational Alternative Design (RAD), as sugg…
▽ More
By reasoning about the claims and speculations promised as part of the public discourse, we analyze the hypothesis that flaws in software engineering played a critical role in the Boeing 737 MCAS incidents. We use promise-based reasoning to discuss how, from an outsider's perspective, one may assemble clues about what went wrong. Rather than looking for a Rational Alternative Design (RAD), as suggested by Wendel, we look for candidate flaws in the software process. We describe four such potential flaws. Recently, Boeing has circulated information on its envisaged MCAS algorithm upgrade. We cast this as a promise to resolve the flaws, i.e. to provide a RAD for the B737 Max. We offer an assessment of B-Max-New based on the public discourse.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
A Promise Theoretic Account of the Boeing 737 Max MCAS Algorithm Affair
Authors:
J. A. Bergstra,
M. Burgess
Abstract:
Many public controversies involve the assessment of statements about which we have imperfect information. Without a structured approach, it is quite difficult to develop an approach to reasoning which is not based on ad hoc choices. Forms of logic have been used in the past to try to bring such clarity, but these fail for a variety of reasons. We demonstrate a simple approach to bringing a standar…
▽ More
Many public controversies involve the assessment of statements about which we have imperfect information. Without a structured approach, it is quite difficult to develop an approach to reasoning which is not based on ad hoc choices. Forms of logic have been used in the past to try to bring such clarity, but these fail for a variety of reasons. We demonstrate a simple approach to bringing a standardized approach to semantics, in certain discourse, using Promise Theory. As a case, we use Promise Theory (PT) to collect and structure publicly available information about the case of the MCAS software component for the Boeing 737 Max flight control system.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2019;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Locality, Statefulness, and Causality in Distributed Information Systems (Concerning the Scale Dependence Of System Promises)
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
Several popular best-practice manifestos for IT design and architecture use terms like `stateful', `stateless', `shared nothing', etc, and describe `fact based' or `functional' descriptions of causal evolution to describe computer processes, especially in cloud computing. The concepts are used ambiguously and sometimes in contradictory ways, which has led to many imprecise beliefs about their impl…
▽ More
Several popular best-practice manifestos for IT design and architecture use terms like `stateful', `stateless', `shared nothing', etc, and describe `fact based' or `functional' descriptions of causal evolution to describe computer processes, especially in cloud computing. The concepts are used ambiguously and sometimes in contradictory ways, which has led to many imprecise beliefs about their implications. This paper outlines the simple view of state and causation in Promise Theory, which accounts for the scaling of processes and the relativity of different observers in a natural way. It's shown that the concepts of statefulness or statelessness are artifacts of observational scale and causal bias towards functional evaluation. If we include feedback loops, recursion, and process convergence, which appear acausal to external observers, the arguments about (im)mutable state need to be modified in a scale-dependent way. In most cases the intended focus of such remarks is not terms like `statelessness' but process predictability. A simple principle may be substituted in most cases as a guide to system design: the principle the separation of dynamic scales.
Understanding data reliance and the ability to keep stable promises is of crucial importance to the consistency of data pipelines, and distributed client-server interactions, albeit in different ways. With increasingly data intensive processes over widely separated distributed deployments, e.g. in the Internet of Things and AI applications, the effects of instability need a more careful treatment.
These notes are part of an initiative to engage with thinkers and practitioners towards a more rational and disciplined language for systems engineering for era of ubiquitous extended-cloud computing.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
From Observability to Significance in Distributed Information Systems
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
To understand and explain process behaviour we need to be able to see it, and decide its significance, i.e. be able to tell a story about its behaviours. This paper describes a few of the modelling challenges that underlie monitoring and observation of processes in IT, by human or by software. The topic of the observability of systems has been elevated recently in connection with computer monitori…
▽ More
To understand and explain process behaviour we need to be able to see it, and decide its significance, i.e. be able to tell a story about its behaviours. This paper describes a few of the modelling challenges that underlie monitoring and observation of processes in IT, by human or by software. The topic of the observability of systems has been elevated recently in connection with computer monitoring and tracing of processes for debugging and forensics. It raises the issue of well-known principles of measurement, in bounded contexts, but these issues have been left implicit in the Computer Science literature. This paper aims to remedy this omission, by laying out a simple promise theoretic model, summarizing a long standing trail of work on the observation of distributed systems, based on elementary distinguishability of observations, and classical causality, with history. Three distinct views of a system are sought, across a number of scales, that described how information is transmitted (and lost) as it moves around the system, aggregated into journals and logs.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2019; v1 submitted 12 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Koalja: from Data Plumbing to Smart Workspaces in the Extended Cloud
Authors:
Mark Burgess,
Ewout Prangsma
Abstract:
Koalja describes a generalized data wiring or `pipeline' platform, built on top of Kubernetes, for plugin user code. Koalja makes the Kubernetes underlay transparent to users (for a `serverless' experience), and offers a breadboarding experience for development of data sharing circuitry, to commoditize its gradual promotion to a production system, with a minimum of infrastructure knowledge. Enterp…
▽ More
Koalja describes a generalized data wiring or `pipeline' platform, built on top of Kubernetes, for plugin user code. Koalja makes the Kubernetes underlay transparent to users (for a `serverless' experience), and offers a breadboarding experience for development of data sharing circuitry, to commoditize its gradual promotion to a production system, with a minimum of infrastructure knowledge. Enterprise grade metadata are captured as data payloads flow through the circuitry, allowing full tracing of provenance and forensic reconstruction of transactional processes, down to the versions of software that led to each outcome. Koalja attends to optimizations for avoiding unwanted processing and transportation of data, that are rapidly becoming sustainability imperatives. Thus one can minimize energy expenditure and waste, and design with scaling in mind, especially with regard to edge computing, to accommodate an Internet of Things, Network Function Virtualization, and more.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Spacetime-Entangled Networks (I) Relativity and Observability of Stepwise Consensus
Authors:
Paul Borrill,
Mark Burgess,
Alan Karp,
Atsushi Kasuya
Abstract:
Consensus protocols can be an effective tool for synchronizing small amounts of data over small regions. We describe the concept and implementation of entangled links, applied to data transmission, using the framework of Promise Theory as a tool to help bring certainty to distributed consensus. Entanglement describes co-dependent evolution of state. Networks formed by entanglement of agents keep c…
▽ More
Consensus protocols can be an effective tool for synchronizing small amounts of data over small regions. We describe the concept and implementation of entangled links, applied to data transmission, using the framework of Promise Theory as a tool to help bring certainty to distributed consensus. Entanglement describes co-dependent evolution of state. Networks formed by entanglement of agents keep certain promises: they deliver sequential messages, end-to-end, in order, and with atomic confirmation of delivery to both ends of the link. These properties can be used recursively to assure a hierarchy of conditional promises at any scale. This is a useful property where a consensus of state or `common knowledge' is required. We intentionally straddle theory and implementation in this discussion.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2020; v1 submitted 23 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
A Spacetime Approach to Generalized Cognitive Reasoning in Multi-scale Learning
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
In modern machine learning, pattern recognition replaces realtime semantic reasoning. The mapping from input to output is learned with fixed semantics by training outcomes deliberately. This is an expensive and static approach which depends heavily on the availability of a very particular kind of prior raining data to make inferences in a single step. Conventional semantic network approaches, on t…
▽ More
In modern machine learning, pattern recognition replaces realtime semantic reasoning. The mapping from input to output is learned with fixed semantics by training outcomes deliberately. This is an expensive and static approach which depends heavily on the availability of a very particular kind of prior raining data to make inferences in a single step. Conventional semantic network approaches, on the other hand, base multi-step reasoning on modal logics and handcrafted ontologies, which are ad hoc, expensive to construct, and fragile to inconsistency. Both approaches may be enhanced by a hybrid approach, which completely separates reasoning from pattern recognition. In this report, a quasi-linguistic approach to knowledge representation is discussed, motivated by spacetime structure. Tokenized patterns from diverse sources are integrated to build a lightly constrained and approximately scale-free network. This is then be parsed with very simple recursive algorithms to generate `brainstorming' sets of reasoned knowledge.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2017; v1 submitted 12 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Spacetimes with Semantics (III) - The Structure of Functional Knowledge Representation and Artificial Reasoning
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
Using the previously developed concepts of semantic spacetime, I explore the interpretation of knowledge representations, and their structure, as a semantic system, within the framework of promise theory. By assigning interpretations to phenomena, from observers to observed, we may approach a simple description of knowledge-based functional systems, with direct practical utility. The focus is espe…
▽ More
Using the previously developed concepts of semantic spacetime, I explore the interpretation of knowledge representations, and their structure, as a semantic system, within the framework of promise theory. By assigning interpretations to phenomena, from observers to observed, we may approach a simple description of knowledge-based functional systems, with direct practical utility. The focus is especially on the interpretation of concepts, associative knowledge, and context awareness. The inference seems to be that most if not all of these concepts emerge from purely semantic spacetime properties, which opens the possibility for a more generalized understanding of what constitutes a learning, or even `intelligent' system.
Some key principles emerge for effective knowledge representation: 1) separation of spacetime scales, 2) the recurrence of four irreducible types of association, by which intent propagates: aggregation, causation, cooperation, and similarity, 3) the need for discrimination of identities (discrete), which is assisted by distinguishing timeline simultaneity from sequential events, and 4) the ability to learn (memory). It is at least plausible that emergent knowledge abstraction capabilities have their origin in basic spacetime structures.
These notes present a unified view of mostly well-known results; they allow us to see information models, knowledge representations, machine learning, and semantic networking (transport and information base) in a common framework. The notion of `smart spaces' thus encompasses artificial systems as well as living systems, across many different scales, e.g. smart cities and organizations.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2017; v1 submitted 7 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
On the scaling of functional spaces, from smart cities to cloud computing
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
The study of spacetime, and its role in understanding functional systems has received little attention in information science. Recent work, on the origin of universal scaling in cities and biological systems, provides an intriguing insight into the functional use of space, and its measurable effects. Cities are large information systems, with many similarities to other technological infrastructure…
▽ More
The study of spacetime, and its role in understanding functional systems has received little attention in information science. Recent work, on the origin of universal scaling in cities and biological systems, provides an intriguing insight into the functional use of space, and its measurable effects. Cities are large information systems, with many similarities to other technological infrastructures, so the results shed new light indirectly on the scaling the expected behaviour of smart pervasive infrastructures and the communities that make use of them.
Using promise theory, I derive and extend the scaling laws for cities to expose what may be extrapolated to technological systems. From the promise model, I propose an explanation for some anomalous exponents in the original work, and discuss what changes may be expected due to technological advancement.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Link-Prediction Enhanced Consensus Clustering for Complex Networks
Authors:
Matthew Burgess,
Eytan Adar,
Michael Cafarella
Abstract:
Many real networks that are inferred or collected from data are incomplete due to missing edges. Missing edges can be inherent to the dataset (Facebook friend links will never be complete) or the result of sampling (one may only have access to a portion of the data). The consequence is that downstream analyses that consume the network will often yield less accurate results than if the edges were c…
▽ More
Many real networks that are inferred or collected from data are incomplete due to missing edges. Missing edges can be inherent to the dataset (Facebook friend links will never be complete) or the result of sampling (one may only have access to a portion of the data). The consequence is that downstream analyses that consume the network will often yield less accurate results than if the edges were complete. Community detection algorithms, in particular, often suffer when critical intra-community edges are missing. We propose a novel consensus clustering algorithm to enhance community detection on incomplete networks. Our framework utilizes existing community detection algorithms that process networks imputed by our link prediction based algorithm. The framework then merges their multiple outputs into a final consensus output. On average our method boosts performance of existing algorithms by 7% on artificial data and 17% on ego networks collected from Facebook.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Spacetimes with Semantics (II), Scaling of agency, semantics, and tenancy
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
Using Promise Theory as a calculus, I review how to define agency in a scalable way, for the purpose of understanding semantic spacetimes. By following simple scaling rules, replacing individual agents with `super-agents' (sub-spaces), it is shown how agency can be scaled both dynamically and semantically.
The notion of occupancy and tenancy, or how space is used and filled in different ways, is…
▽ More
Using Promise Theory as a calculus, I review how to define agency in a scalable way, for the purpose of understanding semantic spacetimes. By following simple scaling rules, replacing individual agents with `super-agents' (sub-spaces), it is shown how agency can be scaled both dynamically and semantically.
The notion of occupancy and tenancy, or how space is used and filled in different ways, is also defined, showing how spacetime can be shared between independent parties, both by remote association and local encapsulation. I describe how to build up dynamic and semantic continuity, by joining discrete individual atoms and molecules of space into quasi-continuous lattices.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Spacetimes with Semantics
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
Relationships between objects constitute our notion of space. When these relationships change we interpret this as the passage of time. Observer interpretations are essential to the way we understand these relationships. Hence observer semantics are an integral part of what we mean by spacetime.
Semantics make up the essential difference in how one describes and uses the concept of space in phys…
▽ More
Relationships between objects constitute our notion of space. When these relationships change we interpret this as the passage of time. Observer interpretations are essential to the way we understand these relationships. Hence observer semantics are an integral part of what we mean by spacetime.
Semantics make up the essential difference in how one describes and uses the concept of space in physics, chemistry, biology and technology. In these notes, I have tried to assemble what seems to be a set of natural, and pragmatic, considerations about discrete, finite spacetimes, to unify descriptions of these areas.
It reviews familiar notions of spacetime, and brings them together into a less familiar framework of promise theory (autonomous agents), in order to illuminate the goal of encoding the semantics of observers into a description of spacetime itself. Autonomous agents provide an exacting atomic and local model for finite spacetime, which quickly reveals the issues of incomplete information and non-locality. From this we should be able to reconstruct all other notions of spacetime.
The aim of this exercise is to apply related tools and ideas to an initial unification of real and artificial spaces, e.g. databases and information webs with natural spacetime. By reconstructing these spaces from autonomous agents, we may better understand naming and coordinatization of semantic spaces, from crowds and swarms to datacentres and libraries, as well as the fundamental arena of natural science.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
A Promise Theory Perspective on Data Networks
Authors:
Paul Borril,
Mark Burgess,
Todd Craw,
Mike Dvorkin
Abstract:
Networking is undergoing a transformation throughout our industry. The need for scalable network control and automation shifts the focus from hardware driven products with ad hoc control to Software Defined Networks. This process is now well underway. In this paper, we adopt the perspective of the Promise Theory to examine the current and future states of networking technologies. The goal is to se…
▽ More
Networking is undergoing a transformation throughout our industry. The need for scalable network control and automation shifts the focus from hardware driven products with ad hoc control to Software Defined Networks. This process is now well underway. In this paper, we adopt the perspective of the Promise Theory to examine the current and future states of networking technologies. The goal is to see beyond specific technologies, topologies and approaches and define principles. Promise Theory's bottom-up modeling has been applied to server management for many years and lends itself to principles of self-healing, scalability and robustness.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Promises, Impositions, and other Directionals
Authors:
Jan A. Bergstra,
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
Promises, impositions, proposals, predictions, and suggestions are categorized as voluntary co-operational methods. The class of voluntary co-operational methods is included in the class of so-called directionals. Directionals are mechanisms supporting the mutual coordination of autonomous agents.
Notations are provided capable of expressing residual fragments of directionals. An extensive examp…
▽ More
Promises, impositions, proposals, predictions, and suggestions are categorized as voluntary co-operational methods. The class of voluntary co-operational methods is included in the class of so-called directionals. Directionals are mechanisms supporting the mutual coordination of autonomous agents.
Notations are provided capable of expressing residual fragments of directionals. An extensive example, involving promises about the suitability of programs for tasks imposed on the promisee is presented. The example illustrates the dynamics of promises and more specifically the corresponding mechanism of trust updating and credibility updating. Trust levels and credibility levels then determine the way certain promises and impositions are handled.
The ubiquity of promises and impositions is further demonstrated with two extensive examples involving human behaviour: an artificial example about an agent planning a purchase, and a realistic example describing technology mediated interaction concerning the solution of pay station failure related problems arising for an agent intending to leave the parking area.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Local and Global Trust Based on the Concept of Promises
Authors:
Jan Bergstra,
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
We use the notion of a promise to define local trust between agents possessing autonomous decision-making. An agent is trustworthy if it is expected that it will keep a promise. This definition satisfies most commonplace meanings of trust. Reputation is then an estimation of this expectation value that is passed on from agent to agent.
Our definition distinguishes types of trust, for different…
▽ More
We use the notion of a promise to define local trust between agents possessing autonomous decision-making. An agent is trustworthy if it is expected that it will keep a promise. This definition satisfies most commonplace meanings of trust. Reputation is then an estimation of this expectation value that is passed on from agent to agent.
Our definition distinguishes types of trust, for different behaviours, and decouples the concept of agent reliability from the behaviour on which the judgement is based. We show, however, that trust is fundamentally heuristic, as it provides insufficient information for agents to make a rational judgement. A global trustworthiness, or community trust can be defined by a proportional, self-consistent voting process, as a weighted eigenvector-centrality function of the promise theoretical graph.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
A static theory of promises
Authors:
Jan A. Bergstra,
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
We discuss for the concept of promises within a framework that can be applied to either humans or technology. We compare promises to the more established notion of obligations and find promises to be both simpler and more effective at reducing uncertainty in behavioural outcomes.
We discuss for the concept of promises within a framework that can be applied to either humans or technology. We compare promises to the more established notion of obligations and find promises to be both simpler and more effective at reducing uncertainty in behavioural outcomes.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2014; v1 submitted 18 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
Program Promises
Authors:
Demissies Aredo,
Mark Burgess,
Simen Hagen
Abstract:
The framework of promise theory offers an alternative way of understanding programming models, especially in distributed systems. We show that promise theory can express some familiar constructs and resolve some problems in program interface design, using fewer and simpler concepts than the Unified Modelling Language (UML).
The framework of promise theory offers an alternative way of understanding programming models, especially in distributed systems. We show that promise theory can express some familiar constructs and resolve some problems in program interface design, using fewer and simpler concepts than the Unified Modelling Language (UML).
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
-
A process algebra based framework for promise theory
Authors:
Jan Bergstra,
Inge Bethke,
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
We present a process algebra based approach to formalize the interactions of computing devices such as the representation of policies and the resolution of conflicts. As an example we specify how promises may be used in coming to an agreement regarding a simple though practical transportation problem.
We present a process algebra based approach to formalize the interactions of computing devices such as the representation of policies and the resolution of conflicts. As an example we specify how promises may be used in coming to an agreement regarding a simple though practical transportation problem.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
On the theory of system administration
Authors:
Mark Burgess
Abstract:
This paper describes necessary elements for constructing theoretical models of network and system administration. Armed with a theoretical model it becomes possible to determine best practices and optimal strategies in a way which objectively relates policies and assumptions to results obtained. It is concluded that a mixture of automation and human, or other intelligent incursion is required to…
▽ More
This paper describes necessary elements for constructing theoretical models of network and system administration. Armed with a theoretical model it becomes possible to determine best practices and optimal strategies in a way which objectively relates policies and assumptions to results obtained. It is concluded that a mixture of automation and human, or other intelligent incursion is required to fully implement system policy with current technology. Some aspects of the author's immunity model for automated system administration are explained, as an example. A theoretical framework makes the prediction that the optimal balance between resource availability and garbage collection strategies is encompassed by the immunity model.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2000;
originally announced March 2000.
