Showing 1–16 of 16 results for author: Carrasco, J

Advancing Forest Fire Prevention: Deep Reinforcement Learning for Effective Firebreak Placement

Authors: Lucas Murray, Tatiana Castillo, Jaime Carrasco, Andrés Weintraub, Richard Weber, Isaac Martín de Diego, José Ramón González, Jordi García-Gonzalo

Abstract: Over the past decades, the increase in both frequency and intensity of large-scale wildfires due to climate change has emerged as a significant natural threat. The pressing need to design resilient landscapes capable of withstanding such disasters has become paramount, requiring the development of advanced decision-support tools. Existing methodologies, including Mixed Integer Programming, Stochas… ▽ More Over the past decades, the increase in both frequency and intensity of large-scale wildfires due to climate change has emerged as a significant natural threat. The pressing need to design resilient landscapes capable of withstanding such disasters has become paramount, requiring the development of advanced decision-support tools. Existing methodologies, including Mixed Integer Programming, Stochastic Optimization, and Network Theory, have proven effective but are hindered by computational demands, limiting their applicability. In response to this challenge, we propose using artificial intelligence techniques, specifically Deep Reinforcement Learning, to address the complex problem of firebreak placement in the landscape. We employ value-function based approaches like Deep Q-Learning, Double Deep Q-Learning, and Dueling Double Deep Q-Learning. Utilizing the Cell2Fire fire spread simulator combined with Convolutional Neural Networks, we have successfully implemented a computational agent capable of learning firebreak locations within a forest environment, achieving good results. Furthermore, we incorporate a pre-training loop, initially teaching our agent to mimic a heuristic-based algorithm and observe that it consistently exceeds the performance of these solutions. Our findings underscore the immense potential of Deep Reinforcement Learning for operational research challenges, especially in fire prevention. Our approach demonstrates convergence with highly favorable results in problem instances as large as 40 x 40 cells, marking a significant milestone in applying Reinforcement Learning to this critical issue. To the best of our knowledge, this study represents a pioneering effort in using Reinforcement Learning to address the aforementioned problem, offering promising perspectives in fire prevention and landscape management △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 20 pages, 15 figures

Comparison of metaheuristics for the firebreak placement problem: a simulation-based optimization approach

Authors: David Palacios-Meneses, Jaime Carrasco, Sebastián Dávila, Maximiliano Martínez, Rodrigo Mahaluf, Andrés Weintraub

Abstract: The problem of firebreak placement is crucial for fire prevention, and its effectiveness at landscape scale will depend on their ability to impede the progress of future wildfires. To provide an adequate response, it is therefore necessary to consider the stochastic nature of fires, which are highly unpredictable from ignition to extinction. Thus, the placement of firebreaks can be considered a st… ▽ More The problem of firebreak placement is crucial for fire prevention, and its effectiveness at landscape scale will depend on their ability to impede the progress of future wildfires. To provide an adequate response, it is therefore necessary to consider the stochastic nature of fires, which are highly unpredictable from ignition to extinction. Thus, the placement of firebreaks can be considered a stochastic optimization problem where: (1) the objective function is to minimize the expected cells burnt of the landscape; (2) the decision variables being the location of firebreaks; and (3) the random variable being the spatial propagation/behavior of fires. In this paper, we propose a solution approach for the problem from the perspective of simulation-based optimization (SbO), where the objective function is not available (a black-box function), but can be computed (and/or approximated) by wildfire simulations. For this purpose, Genetic Algorithm and GRASP are implemented. The final implementation yielded favorable results for the Genetic Algorithm, demonstrating strong performance in scenarios with medium to high operational capacity, as well as medium levels of stochasticity △ Less

Submitted 29 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Two Scalable Approaches for Burned-Area Mapping Using U-Net and Landsat Imagery

Authors: Ian Mancilla-Wulff, Jaime Carrasco, Cristobal Pais, Alejandro Miranda, Andres Weintraub

Abstract: Monitoring wildfires is an essential step in minimizing their impact on the planet, understanding the many negative environmental, economic, and social consequences. Recent advances in remote sensing technology combined with the increasing application of artificial intelligence methods have improved real-time, high-resolution fire monitoring. This study explores two proposed approaches based on th… ▽ More Monitoring wildfires is an essential step in minimizing their impact on the planet, understanding the many negative environmental, economic, and social consequences. Recent advances in remote sensing technology combined with the increasing application of artificial intelligence methods have improved real-time, high-resolution fire monitoring. This study explores two proposed approaches based on the U-Net model for automating and optimizing the burned-area mapping process. Denoted 128 and AllSizes (AS), they are trained on datasets with a different class balance by cropping input images to different sizes. They are then applied to Landsat imagery and time-series data from two fire-prone regions in Chile. The results obtained after enhancement of model performance by hyperparameter optimization demonstrate the effectiveness of both approaches. Tests based on 195 representative images of the study area show that increasing dataset balance using the AS model yields better performance. More specifically, AS exhibited a Dice Coefficient (DC) of 0.93, an Omission Error (OE) of 0.086, and a Commission Error (CE) of 0.045, while the 128 model achieved a DC of 0.86, an OE of 0.12, and a CE of 0.12. These findings should provide a basis for further development of scalable automatic burned-area mapping tools. △ Less

Submitted 29 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Sim-to-Real Deep Reinforcement Learning with Manipulators for Pick-and-place

Authors: Wenxing Liu, Hanlin Niu, Robert Skilton, Joaquin Carrasco

Abstract: When transferring a Deep Reinforcement Learning model from simulation to the real world, the performance could be unsatisfactory since the simulation cannot imitate the real world well in many circumstances. This results in a long period of fine-tuning in the real world. This paper proposes a self-supervised vision-based DRL method that allows robots to pick and place objects effectively and effic… ▽ More When transferring a Deep Reinforcement Learning model from simulation to the real world, the performance could be unsatisfactory since the simulation cannot imitate the real world well in many circumstances. This results in a long period of fine-tuning in the real world. This paper proposes a self-supervised vision-based DRL method that allows robots to pick and place objects effectively and efficiently when directly transferring a training model from simulation to the real world. A height-sensitive action policy is specially designed for the proposed method to deal with crowded and stacked objects in challenging environments. The training model with the proposed approach can be applied directly to a real suction task without any fine-tuning from the real world while maintaining a high suction success rate. It is also validated that our model can be deployed to suction novel objects in a real experiment with a suction success rate of 90\% without any real-world fine-tuning. The experimental video is available at: https://youtu.be/jSTC-EGsoFA. △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

A Remote Sim2real Aerial Competition: Fostering Reproducibility and Solutions' Diversity in Robotics Challenges

Authors: Spencer Teetaert, Wenda Zhao, Niu Xinyuan, Hashir Zahir, Huiyu Leong, Michel Hidalgo, Gerardo Puga, Tomas Lorente, Nahuel Espinosa, John Alejandro Duarte Carrasco, Kaizheng Zhang, Jian Di, Tao Jin, Xiaohan Li, Yijia Zhou, Xiuhua Liang, Chenxu Zhang, Antonio Loquercio, Siqi Zhou, Lukas Brunke, Melissa Greeff, Wolfgang Hoenig, Jacopo Panerati, Angela P. Schoellig

Abstract: Shared benchmark problems have historically been a fundamental driver of progress for scientific communities. In the context of academic conferences, competitions offer the opportunity to researchers with different origins, backgrounds, and levels of seniority to quantitatively compare their ideas. In robotics, a hot and challenging topic is sim2real-porting approaches that work well in simulation… ▽ More Shared benchmark problems have historically been a fundamental driver of progress for scientific communities. In the context of academic conferences, competitions offer the opportunity to researchers with different origins, backgrounds, and levels of seniority to quantitatively compare their ideas. In robotics, a hot and challenging topic is sim2real-porting approaches that work well in simulation to real robot hardware. In our case, creating a hybrid competition with both simulation and real robot components was also dictated by the uncertainties around travel and logistics in the post-COVID-19 world. Hence, this article motivates and describes an aerial sim2real robot competition that ran during the 2022 IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems, from the specification of the competition task, to the details of the software infrastructure supporting simulation and real-life experiments, to the approaches of the top-placed teams and the lessons learned by participants and organizers. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: 13 pages, 16 figures, 4 tables

Sim-and-Real Reinforcement Learning for Manipulation: A Consensus-based Approach

Authors: Wenxing Liu, Hanlin Niu, Wei Pan, Guido Herrmann, Joaquin Carrasco

Abstract: Sim-and-real training is a promising alternative to sim-to-real training for robot manipulations. However, the current sim-and-real training is neither efficient, i.e., slow convergence to the optimal policy, nor effective, i.e., sizeable real-world robot data. Given limited time and hardware budgets, the performance of sim-and-real training is not satisfactory. In this paper, we propose a Consens… ▽ More Sim-and-real training is a promising alternative to sim-to-real training for robot manipulations. However, the current sim-and-real training is neither efficient, i.e., slow convergence to the optimal policy, nor effective, i.e., sizeable real-world robot data. Given limited time and hardware budgets, the performance of sim-and-real training is not satisfactory. In this paper, we propose a Consensus-based Sim-And-Real deep reinforcement learning algorithm (CSAR) for manipulator pick-and-place tasks, which shows comparable performance in both sim-and-real worlds. In this algorithm, we train the agents in simulators and the real world to get the optimal policies for both sim-and-real worlds. We found two interesting phenomenons: (1) Best policy in simulation is not the best for sim-and-real training. (2) The more simulation agents, the better sim-and-real training. The experimental video is available at: https://youtu.be/mcHJtNIsTEQ. △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2023; v1 submitted 26 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: 7 pages, 8 figures, IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA) 2023

Anomaly Detection in Predictive Maintenance: A New Evaluation Framework for Temporal Unsupervised Anomaly Detection Algorithms

Authors: Jacinto Carrasco, Irina Markova, David López, Ignacio Aguilera, Diego García, Marta García-Barzana, Manuel Arias-Rodil, Julián Luengo, Francisco Herrera

Abstract: The research in anomaly detection lacks a unified definition of what represents an anomalous instance. Discrepancies in the nature itself of an anomaly lead to multiple paradigms of algorithms design and experimentation. Predictive maintenance is a special case, where the anomaly represents a failure that must be prevented. Related time-series research as outlier and novelty detection or time-seri… ▽ More The research in anomaly detection lacks a unified definition of what represents an anomalous instance. Discrepancies in the nature itself of an anomaly lead to multiple paradigms of algorithms design and experimentation. Predictive maintenance is a special case, where the anomaly represents a failure that must be prevented. Related time-series research as outlier and novelty detection or time-series classification does not apply to the concept of an anomaly in this field, because they are not single points which have not been seen previously and may not be precisely annotated. Moreover, due to the lack of annotated anomalous data, many benchmarks are adapted from supervised scenarios. To address these issues, we generalise the concept of positive and negative instances to intervals to be able to evaluate unsupervised anomaly detection algorithms. We also preserve the imbalance scheme for evaluation through the proposal of the Preceding Window ROC, a generalisation for the calculation of ROC curves for time-series scenarios. We also adapt the mechanism from a established time-series anomaly detection benchmark to the proposed generalisations to reward early detection. Therefore, the proposal represents a flexible evaluation framework for the different scenarios. To show the usefulness of this definition, we include a case study of Big Data algorithms with a real-world time-series problem provided by the company ArcelorMittal, and compare the proposal with an evaluation method. △ Less

Submitted 2 September, 2021; v1 submitted 26 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: 25 pages, 9 figures, 5 tables

ACM Class: J.2

Accelerated Sim-to-Real Deep Reinforcement Learning: Learning Collision Avoidance from Human Player

Authors: Hanlin Niu, Ze Ji, Farshad Arvin, Barry Lennox, Hujun Yin, Joaquin Carrasco

Abstract: This paper presents a sensor-level mapless collision avoidance algorithm for use in mobile robots that map raw sensor data to linear and angular velocities and navigate in an unknown environment without a map. An efficient training strategy is proposed to allow a robot to learn from both human experience data and self-exploratory data. A game format simulation framework is designed to allow the hu… ▽ More This paper presents a sensor-level mapless collision avoidance algorithm for use in mobile robots that map raw sensor data to linear and angular velocities and navigate in an unknown environment without a map. An efficient training strategy is proposed to allow a robot to learn from both human experience data and self-exploratory data. A game format simulation framework is designed to allow the human player to tele-operate the mobile robot to a goal and human action is also scored using the reward function. Both human player data and self-playing data are sampled using prioritized experience replay algorithm. The proposed algorithm and training strategy have been evaluated in two different experimental configurations: \textit{Environment 1}, a simulated cluttered environment, and \textit{Environment 2}, a simulated corridor environment, to investigate the performance. It was demonstrated that the proposed method achieved the same level of reward using only 16\% of the training steps required by the standard Deep Deterministic Policy Gradient (DDPG) method in Environment 1 and 20\% of that in Environment 2. In the evaluation of 20 random missions, the proposed method achieved no collision in less than 2~h and 2.5~h of training time in the two Gazebo environments respectively. The method also generated smoother trajectories than DDPG. The proposed method has also been implemented on a real robot in the real-world environment for performance evaluation. We can confirm that the trained model with the simulation software can be directly applied into the real-world scenario without further fine-tuning, further demonstrating its higher robustness than DDPG. The video and code are available: https://youtu.be/BmwxevgsdGc https://github.com/hanlinniu/turtlebot3_ddpg_collision_avoidance △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2021; v1 submitted 21 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

3D Vision-guided Pick-and-Place Using Kuka LBR iiwa Robot

Authors: Hanlin Niu, Ze Ji, Zihang Zhu, Hujun Yin, Joaquin Carrasco

Abstract: This paper presents the development of a control system for vision-guided pick-and-place tasks using a robot arm equipped with a 3D camera. The main steps include camera intrinsic and extrinsic calibration, hand-eye calibration, initial object pose registration, objects pose alignment algorithm, and pick-and-place execution. The proposed system allows the robot be able to to pick and place object… ▽ More This paper presents the development of a control system for vision-guided pick-and-place tasks using a robot arm equipped with a 3D camera. The main steps include camera intrinsic and extrinsic calibration, hand-eye calibration, initial object pose registration, objects pose alignment algorithm, and pick-and-place execution. The proposed system allows the robot be able to to pick and place object with limited times of registering a new object and the developed software can be applied for new object scenario quickly. The integrated system was tested using the hardware combination of kuka iiwa, Robotiq grippers (two finger gripper and three finger gripper) and 3D cameras (Intel realsense D415 camera, Intel realsense D435 camera, Microsoft Kinect V2). The whole system can also be modified for the combination of other robotic arm, gripper and 3D camera. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2021; v1 submitted 21 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Design, Integration and Sea Trials of 3D Printed Unmanned Aerial Vehicle and Unmanned Surface Vehicle for Cooperative Missions

Authors: Hanlin Niu, Ze Ji, Pietro Liguori, Hujun Yin, Joaquin Carrasco

Abstract: In recent years, Unmanned Surface Vehicles (USV) have been extensively deployed for maritime applications. However, USV has a limited detection range with sensor installed at the same elevation with the targets. In this research, we propose a cooperative Unmanned Aerial Vehicle - Unmanned Surface Vehicle (UAV-USV) platform to improve the detection range of USV. A floatable and waterproof UAV is de… ▽ More In recent years, Unmanned Surface Vehicles (USV) have been extensively deployed for maritime applications. However, USV has a limited detection range with sensor installed at the same elevation with the targets. In this research, we propose a cooperative Unmanned Aerial Vehicle - Unmanned Surface Vehicle (UAV-USV) platform to improve the detection range of USV. A floatable and waterproof UAV is designed and 3D printed, which allows it to land on the sea. A catamaran USV and landing platform are also developed. To land UAV on the USV precisely in various lighting conditions, IR beacon detector and IR beacon are implemented on the UAV and USV, respectively. Finally, a two-phase UAV precise landing method, USV control algorithm and USV path following algorithm are proposed and tested. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2021; v1 submitted 21 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Model Checking for Decision Making System of Long Endurance Unmanned Surface Vehicle

Authors: Hanlin Niu, Ze Ji, Al Savvaris, Antonios Tsourdos, Joaquin Carrasco

Abstract: This work aims to develop a model checking method to verify the decision making system of Unmanned Surface Vehicle (USV) in a long range surveillance mission. The scenario in this work was captured from a long endurance USV surveillance mission using C-Enduro, an USV manufactured by ASV Ltd. The C-Enduro USV may encounter multiple non-deterministic and concurrent problems including lost communicat… ▽ More This work aims to develop a model checking method to verify the decision making system of Unmanned Surface Vehicle (USV) in a long range surveillance mission. The scenario in this work was captured from a long endurance USV surveillance mission using C-Enduro, an USV manufactured by ASV Ltd. The C-Enduro USV may encounter multiple non-deterministic and concurrent problems including lost communication signals, collision risk and malfunction. The vehicle is designed to utilise multiple energy sources from solar panel, wind turbine and diesel generator. The energy state can be affected by the solar irradiance condition, wind condition, states of the diesel generator, sea current condition and states of the USV. In this research, the states and the interactive relations between environmental uncertainties, sensors, USV energy system, USV and Ground Control Station (GCS) decision making systems are abstracted and modelled successfully using Kripke models. The desirable properties to be verified are expressed using temporal logic statement and finally the safety properties and the long endurance properties are verified using the model checker MCMAS, a model checker for multi-agent systems. The verification results are analyzed and show the feasibility of applying model checking method to retrospect the desirable property of the USV decision making system. This method could assist researcher to identify potential design error of decision making system in advance. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2021; v1 submitted 21 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Theoretical and Experimental Perspectives of Quantum Verification

Authors: Jose Carrasco, Andreas Elben, Christian Kokail, Barbara Kraus, Peter Zoller

Abstract: In this perspective we discuss verification of quantum devices in the context of specific examples, formulated as proposed experiments. Our first example is verification of analog quantum simulators as Hamiltonian learning, where the input Hamiltonian as design goal is compared with the parent Hamiltonian for the quantum states prepared on the device. The second example discusses cross-device veri… ▽ More In this perspective we discuss verification of quantum devices in the context of specific examples, formulated as proposed experiments. Our first example is verification of analog quantum simulators as Hamiltonian learning, where the input Hamiltonian as design goal is compared with the parent Hamiltonian for the quantum states prepared on the device. The second example discusses cross-device verification on the quantum level, i.e. by comparing quantum states prepared on different quantum devices. We focus in particular on protocols using randomized measurements, and we propose establishing a central data repository, where existing experimental devices and platforms can be compared. In our final example, we address verification of the output of a quantum device from a computer science perspective, addressing the question of how a user of a quantum processor can be certain about the correctness of its output, and propose minimal demonstrations on present day devices. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2021; v1 submitted 11 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Journal ref: PRX Quantum 2, 010102 (2021)

Recent Trends in the Use of Statistical Tests for Comparing Swarm and Evolutionary Computing Algorithms: Practical Guidelines and a Critical Review

Authors: J. Carrasco, S. García, M. M. Rueda, S. Das, F. Herrera

Abstract: A key aspect of the design of evolutionary and swarm intelligence algorithms is studying their performance. Statistical comparisons are also a crucial part which allows for reliable conclusions to be drawn. In the present paper we gather and examine the approaches taken from different perspectives to summarise the assumptions made by these statistical tests, the conclusions reached and the steps f… ▽ More A key aspect of the design of evolutionary and swarm intelligence algorithms is studying their performance. Statistical comparisons are also a crucial part which allows for reliable conclusions to be drawn. In the present paper we gather and examine the approaches taken from different perspectives to summarise the assumptions made by these statistical tests, the conclusions reached and the steps followed to perform them correctly. In this paper, we conduct a survey on the current trends of the proposals of statistical analyses for the comparison of algorithms of computational intelligence and include a description of the statistical background of these tests. We illustrate the use of the most common tests in the context of the Competition on single-objective real parameter optimisation of the IEEE Congress on Evolutionary Computation (CEC) 2017 and describe the main advantages and drawbacks of the use of each kind of test and put forward some recommendations concerning their use. △ Less

Submitted 21 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 52 pages, 10 figures, 19 tables

Journal ref: SWEVO, Volume 54, May 2020, 100665

Adjusting Rate of Spread Factors through Derivative-Free Optimization: A New Methodology to Improve the Performance of Forest Fire Simulators

Authors: Jaime Carrasco, Cristobal Pais, Zuo-Jun Max Shen, Andres Weintraub

Abstract: In practical applications, it is common that wildfire simulators do not correctly predict the evolution of the fire scar. Usually, this is caused due to multiple factors including inaccuracy in the input data such as land cover classification, moisture, improperly represented local winds, cumulative errors in the fire growth simulation model, high level of discontinuity/heterogeneity within the la… ▽ More In practical applications, it is common that wildfire simulators do not correctly predict the evolution of the fire scar. Usually, this is caused due to multiple factors including inaccuracy in the input data such as land cover classification, moisture, improperly represented local winds, cumulative errors in the fire growth simulation model, high level of discontinuity/heterogeneity within the landscape, among many others. Therefore in practice, it is necessary to adjust the propagation of the fire to obtain better results, either to support suppression activities or to improve the performance of the simulator considering new default parameters for future events, best representing the current fire spread growth phenomenon. In this article, we address this problem through a new methodology using Derivative-Free Optimization (DFO) algorithms for adjusting the Rate of Spread (ROS) factors in a fire simulation growth model called Cell2Fire. To achieve this, we solve an error minimization optimization problem that captures the difference between the simulated and observed fire, which involves the evaluation of the simulator output in each iteration as part of a DFO framework, allowing us to find the best possible factors for each fuel present on the landscape. Numerical results for different objective functions are shown and discussed, including a performance comparison of alternative DFO algorithms. △ Less

Submitted 11 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 8 figures, 35 pages

Omnipotent Virtual Giant for Remote Human-Swarm Interaction

Authors: Inmo Jang, Junyan Hu, Farshad Arvin, Joaquin Carrasco, Barry Lennox

Abstract: This paper proposes an intuitive human-swarm interaction framework inspired by our childhood memory in which we interacted with living ants by changing their positions and environments as if we were omnipotent relative to the ants. In virtual reality, analogously, we can be a super-powered virtual giant who can supervise a swarm of mobile robots in a vast and remote environment by flying over or r… ▽ More This paper proposes an intuitive human-swarm interaction framework inspired by our childhood memory in which we interacted with living ants by changing their positions and environments as if we were omnipotent relative to the ants. In virtual reality, analogously, we can be a super-powered virtual giant who can supervise a swarm of mobile robots in a vast and remote environment by flying over or resizing the world and coordinate them by picking and placing a robot or creating virtual walls. This work implements this idea by using Virtual Reality along with Leap Motion, which is then validated by proof-of-concept experiments using real and virtual mobile robots in mixed reality. We conduct a usability analysis to quantify the effectiveness of the overall system as well as the individual interfaces proposed in this work. The results revealed that the proposed method is intuitive and feasible for interaction with swarm robots, but may require appropriate training for the new end-user interface device. △ Less

Submitted 1 April, 2019; v1 submitted 24 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: Submitted to IROS2019. The full demo video is available in https://youtu.be/LOIJPFM8YRA

Clustering Learning for Robotic Vision

Authors: Eugenio Culurciello, Jordan Bates, Aysegul Dundar, Jose Carrasco, Clement Farabet

Abstract: We present the clustering learning technique applied to multi-layer feedforward deep neural networks. We show that this unsupervised learning technique can compute network filters with only a few minutes and a much reduced set of parameters. The goal of this paper is to promote the technique for general-purpose robotic vision systems. We report its use in static image datasets and object tracking… ▽ More We present the clustering learning technique applied to multi-layer feedforward deep neural networks. We show that this unsupervised learning technique can compute network filters with only a few minutes and a much reduced set of parameters. The goal of this paper is to promote the technique for general-purpose robotic vision systems. We report its use in static image datasets and object tracking datasets. We show that networks trained with clustering learning can outperform large networks trained for many hours on complex datasets. △ Less

Submitted 13 March, 2013; v1 submitted 13 January, 2013; originally announced January 2013.

Comments: Code for this paper is available here: https://github.com/culurciello/CL_paper1_code