Verbal Disinhibition towards Robots is Associated with General Antisociality
Authors:
Megan Strait,
Virginia Contreras,
Christian Duarte Vela
Abstract:
The emergence of agentic technologies (e.g., robots) in increasingly public realms (e.g., social media) has revealed surprising antisocial tendencies in human-agent interactions. In particular, there is growing indication of people's propensity to act aggressively towards such systems - without provocation and unabashedly so.
Towards understanding whether this aggressive behavior is anomalous or…
▽ More
The emergence of agentic technologies (e.g., robots) in increasingly public realms (e.g., social media) has revealed surprising antisocial tendencies in human-agent interactions. In particular, there is growing indication of people's propensity to act aggressively towards such systems - without provocation and unabashedly so.
Towards understanding whether this aggressive behavior is anomalous or whether it is associated with general antisocial tendencies in people's broader interactions, we examined people's verbal disinhibition towards two artificial agents. Using Twitter as a corpus of free-form, unsupervised interactions, we identified 40 independent Twitter users who tweeted abusively or non-abusively at one of two high-profile robots with Twitter accounts (TMI's Bina48 and Hanson Robotics' Sophia). Analysis of 50 of each user's tweets most proximate to their tweet at the respective robot (N=2,000) shows people's aggression towards the robots to be associated with more frequent abuse in their general tweeting. The findings thus suggest that disinhibition towards robots is not necessarily a pervasive tendency, but rather one driven by individual differences in antisociality. Nevertheless, such unprovoked abuse highlights a need for attention to the reception of agentic technologies in society, as well as the necessity of corresponding capacities to recognize and respond to antisocial dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
Robots Racialized in the Likeness of Marginalized Social Identities are Subject to Greater Dehumanization than those racialized as White
Authors:
Megan Strait,
Ana Sánchez Ramos,
Virginia Contreras,
Noemi Garcia
Abstract:
The emergence and spread of humanlike robots into increasingly public domains has revealed a concerning phenomenon: people's unabashed dehumanization of robots, particularly those gendered as female. Here we examined this phenomenon further towards understanding whether other socially marginalized cues (racialization in the likeness of Asian and Black identities), like female-gendering, are associ…
▽ More
The emergence and spread of humanlike robots into increasingly public domains has revealed a concerning phenomenon: people's unabashed dehumanization of robots, particularly those gendered as female. Here we examined this phenomenon further towards understanding whether other socially marginalized cues (racialization in the likeness of Asian and Black identities), like female-gendering, are associated with the manifestation of dehumanization (e.g., objectification, stereotyping) in human-robot interactions. To that end, we analyzed free-form comments (N=535) on three videos, each depicting a gynoid - Bina48, Nadine, or Yangyang - racialized as Black, White, and Asian respectively. As a preliminary control, we additionally analyzed commentary (N=674) on three videos depicting women embodying similar identity cues. The analyses indicate that people more frequently dehumanize robots racialized as Asian and Black, than they do of robots racialized as White. Additional, preliminary evaluation of how people's responding towards the gynoids compares to that towards other people suggests that the gynoids' ontology (as robots) further facilitates the dehumanization.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.