-
Networks of Networks: Complexity Class Principles Applied to Compound AI Systems Design
Authors:
Jared Quincy Davis,
Boris Hanin,
Lingjiao Chen,
Peter Bailis,
Ion Stoica,
Matei Zaharia
Abstract:
As practitioners seek to surpass the current reliability and quality frontier of monolithic models, Compound AI Systems consisting of many language model inference calls are increasingly employed. In this work, we construct systems, which we call Networks of Networks (NoNs) organized around the distinction between generating a proposed answer and verifying its correctness, a fundamental concept in…
▽ More
As practitioners seek to surpass the current reliability and quality frontier of monolithic models, Compound AI Systems consisting of many language model inference calls are increasingly employed. In this work, we construct systems, which we call Networks of Networks (NoNs) organized around the distinction between generating a proposed answer and verifying its correctness, a fundamental concept in complexity theory that we show empirically extends to Language Models (LMs). We introduce a verifier-based judge NoN with K generators, an instantiation of "best-of-K" or "judge-based" compound AI systems. Through experiments on synthetic tasks such as prime factorization, and core benchmarks such as the MMLU, we demonstrate notable performance gains. For instance, in factoring products of two 3-digit primes, a simple NoN improves accuracy from 3.7\% to 36.6\%. On MMLU, a verifier-based judge construction with only 3 generators boosts accuracy over individual GPT-4-Turbo calls by 2.8\%. Our analysis reveals that these gains are most pronounced in domains where verification is notably easier than generation--a characterization which we believe subsumes many reasoning and procedural knowledge tasks, but doesn't often hold for factual and declarative knowledge-based settings. For mathematical and formal logic reasoning-based subjects of MMLU, we observe a 5-8\% or higher gain, whilst no gain on others such as geography and religion. We provide key takeaways for ML practitioners, including the importance of considering verification complexity, the impact of witness format on verifiability, and a simple test to determine the potential benefit of this NoN approach for a given problem distribution. This work aims to inform future research and practice in the design of compound AI systems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Bayesian Inference with Deep Weakly Nonlinear Networks
Authors:
Boris Hanin,
Alexander Zlokapa
Abstract:
We show at a physics level of rigor that Bayesian inference with a fully connected neural network and a shaped nonlinearity of the form $φ(t) = t + ψt^3/L$ is (perturbatively) solvable in the regime where the number of training datapoints $P$ , the input dimension $N_0$, the network layer widths $N$, and the network depth $L$ are simultaneously large. Our results hold with weak assumptions on the…
▽ More
We show at a physics level of rigor that Bayesian inference with a fully connected neural network and a shaped nonlinearity of the form $φ(t) = t + ψt^3/L$ is (perturbatively) solvable in the regime where the number of training datapoints $P$ , the input dimension $N_0$, the network layer widths $N$, and the network depth $L$ are simultaneously large. Our results hold with weak assumptions on the data; the main constraint is that $P < N_0$. We provide techniques to compute the model evidence and posterior to arbitrary order in $1/N$ and at arbitrary temperature. We report the following results from the first-order computation:
1. When the width $N$ is much larger than the depth $L$ and training set size $P$, neural network Bayesian inference coincides with Bayesian inference using a kernel. The value of $ψ$ determines the curvature of a sphere, hyperbola, or plane into which the training data is implicitly embedded under the feature map.
2. When $LP/N$ is a small constant, neural network Bayesian inference departs from the kernel regime. At zero temperature, neural network Bayesian inference is equivalent to Bayesian inference using a data-dependent kernel, and $LP/N$ serves as an effective depth that controls the extent of feature learning.
3. In the restricted case of deep linear networks ($ψ=0$) and noisy data, we show a simple data model for which evidence and generalization error are optimal at zero temperature. As $LP/N$ increases, both evidence and generalization further improve, demonstrating the benefit of depth in benign overfitting.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Are More LLM Calls All You Need? Towards Scaling Laws of Compound Inference Systems
Authors:
Lingjiao Chen,
Jared Quincy Davis,
Boris Hanin,
Peter Bailis,
Ion Stoica,
Matei Zaharia,
James Zou
Abstract:
Many recent state-of-the-art results in language tasks were achieved using compound systems that perform multiple Language Model (LM) calls and aggregate their responses. However, there is little understanding of how the number of LM calls - e.g., when asking the LM to answer each question multiple times and taking a majority vote - affects such a compound system's performance. In this paper, we i…
▽ More
Many recent state-of-the-art results in language tasks were achieved using compound systems that perform multiple Language Model (LM) calls and aggregate their responses. However, there is little understanding of how the number of LM calls - e.g., when asking the LM to answer each question multiple times and taking a majority vote - affects such a compound system's performance. In this paper, we initiate the study of scaling properties of compound inference systems. We analyze, theoretically and empirically, how the number of LM calls affects the performance of Vote and Filter-Vote, two of the simplest compound system designs, which aggregate LM responses via majority voting, optionally applying LM filters. We find, surprisingly, that across multiple language tasks, the performance of both Vote and Filter-Vote can first increase but then decrease as a function of the number of LM calls. Our theoretical results suggest that this non-monotonicity is due to the diversity of query difficulties within a task: more LM calls lead to higher performance on "easy" queries, but lower performance on "hard" queries, and non-monotone behavior can emerge when a task contains both types of queries. This insight then allows us to compute, from a small number of samples, the number of LM calls that maximizes system performance, and define an analytical scaling model for both systems. Experiments show that our scaling model can accurately predict the performance of Vote and Filter-Vote systems and thus find the optimal number of LM calls to make.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2024; v1 submitted 4 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Principled Architecture-aware Scaling of Hyperparameters
Authors:
Wuyang Chen,
Junru Wu,
Zhangyang Wang,
Boris Hanin
Abstract:
Training a high-quality deep neural network requires choosing suitable hyperparameters, which is a non-trivial and expensive process. Current works try to automatically optimize or design principles of hyperparameters, such that they can generalize to diverse unseen scenarios. However, most designs or optimization methods are agnostic to the choice of network structures, and thus largely ignore th…
▽ More
Training a high-quality deep neural network requires choosing suitable hyperparameters, which is a non-trivial and expensive process. Current works try to automatically optimize or design principles of hyperparameters, such that they can generalize to diverse unseen scenarios. However, most designs or optimization methods are agnostic to the choice of network structures, and thus largely ignore the impact of neural architectures on hyperparameters. In this work, we precisely characterize the dependence of initializations and maximal learning rates on the network architecture, which includes the network depth, width, convolutional kernel size, and connectivity patterns. By pursuing every parameter to be maximally updated with the same mean squared change in pre-activations, we can generalize our initialization and learning rates across MLPs (multi-layer perception) and CNNs (convolutional neural network) with sophisticated graph topologies. We verify our principles with comprehensive experiments. More importantly, our strategy further sheds light on advancing current benchmarks for architecture design. A fair comparison of AutoML algorithms requires accurate network rankings. However, we demonstrate that network rankings can be easily changed by better training networks in benchmarks with our architecture-aware learning rates and initialization.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Depthwise Hyperparameter Transfer in Residual Networks: Dynamics and Scaling Limit
Authors:
Blake Bordelon,
Lorenzo Noci,
Mufan Bill Li,
Boris Hanin,
Cengiz Pehlevan
Abstract:
The cost of hyperparameter tuning in deep learning has been rising with model sizes, prompting practitioners to find new tuning methods using a proxy of smaller networks. One such proposal uses $μ$P parameterized networks, where the optimal hyperparameters for small width networks transfer to networks with arbitrarily large width. However, in this scheme, hyperparameters do not transfer across dep…
▽ More
The cost of hyperparameter tuning in deep learning has been rising with model sizes, prompting practitioners to find new tuning methods using a proxy of smaller networks. One such proposal uses $μ$P parameterized networks, where the optimal hyperparameters for small width networks transfer to networks with arbitrarily large width. However, in this scheme, hyperparameters do not transfer across depths. As a remedy, we study residual networks with a residual branch scale of $1/\sqrt{\text{depth}}$ in combination with the $μ$P parameterization. We provide experiments demonstrating that residual architectures including convolutional ResNets and Vision Transformers trained with this parameterization exhibit transfer of optimal hyperparameters across width and depth on CIFAR-10 and ImageNet. Furthermore, our empirical findings are supported and motivated by theory. Using recent developments in the dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) description of neural network learning dynamics, we show that this parameterization of ResNets admits a well-defined feature learning joint infinite-width and infinite-depth limit and show convergence of finite-size network dynamics towards this limit.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2023; v1 submitted 28 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Les Houches Lectures on Deep Learning at Large & Infinite Width
Authors:
Yasaman Bahri,
Boris Hanin,
Antonin Brossollet,
Vittorio Erba,
Christian Keup,
Rosalba Pacelli,
James B. Simon
Abstract:
These lectures, presented at the 2022 Les Houches Summer School on Statistical Physics and Machine Learning, focus on the infinite-width limit and large-width regime of deep neural networks. Topics covered include various statistical and dynamical properties of these networks. In particular, the lecturers discuss properties of random deep neural networks; connections between trained deep neural ne…
▽ More
These lectures, presented at the 2022 Les Houches Summer School on Statistical Physics and Machine Learning, focus on the infinite-width limit and large-width regime of deep neural networks. Topics covered include various statistical and dynamical properties of these networks. In particular, the lecturers discuss properties of random deep neural networks; connections between trained deep neural networks, linear models, kernels, and Gaussian processes that arise in the infinite-width limit; and perturbative and non-perturbative treatments of large but finite-width networks, at initialization and after training.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2024; v1 submitted 4 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Quantitative CLTs in Deep Neural Networks
Authors:
Stefano Favaro,
Boris Hanin,
Domenico Marinucci,
Ivan Nourdin,
Giovanni Peccati
Abstract:
We study the distribution of a fully connected neural network with random Gaussian weights and biases in which the hidden layer widths are proportional to a large constant $n$. Under mild assumptions on the non-linearity, we obtain quantitative bounds on normal approximations valid at large but finite $n$ and any fixed network depth. Our theorems show both for the finite-dimensional distributions…
▽ More
We study the distribution of a fully connected neural network with random Gaussian weights and biases in which the hidden layer widths are proportional to a large constant $n$. Under mild assumptions on the non-linearity, we obtain quantitative bounds on normal approximations valid at large but finite $n$ and any fixed network depth. Our theorems show both for the finite-dimensional distributions and the entire process, that the distance between a random fully connected network (and its derivatives) to the corresponding infinite width Gaussian process scales like $n^{-γ}$ for $γ>0$, with the exponent depending on the metric used to measure discrepancy. Our bounds are strictly stronger in terms of their dependence on network width than any previously available in the literature; in the one-dimensional case, we also prove that they are optimal, i.e., we establish matching lower bounds.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2024; v1 submitted 12 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Principles for Initialization and Architecture Selection in Graph Neural Networks with ReLU Activations
Authors:
Gage DeZoort,
Boris Hanin
Abstract:
This article derives and validates three principles for initialization and architecture selection in finite width graph neural networks (GNNs) with ReLU activations. First, we theoretically derive what is essentially the unique generalization to ReLU GNNs of the well-known He-initialization. Our initialization scheme guarantees that the average scale of network outputs and gradients remains order…
▽ More
This article derives and validates three principles for initialization and architecture selection in finite width graph neural networks (GNNs) with ReLU activations. First, we theoretically derive what is essentially the unique generalization to ReLU GNNs of the well-known He-initialization. Our initialization scheme guarantees that the average scale of network outputs and gradients remains order one at initialization. Second, we prove in finite width vanilla ReLU GNNs that oversmoothing is unavoidable at large depth when using fixed aggregation operator, regardless of initialization. We then prove that using residual aggregation operators, obtained by interpolating a fixed aggregation operator with the identity, provably alleviates oversmoothing at initialization. Finally, we show that the common practice of using residual connections with a fixup-type initialization provably avoids correlation collapse in final layer features at initialization. Through ablation studies we find that using the correct initialization, residual aggregation operators, and residual connections in the forward pass significantly and reliably speeds up early training dynamics in deep ReLU GNNs on a variety of tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Depth Dependence of $μ$P Learning Rates in ReLU MLPs
Authors:
Samy Jelassi,
Boris Hanin,
Ziwei Ji,
Sashank J. Reddi,
Srinadh Bhojanapalli,
Sanjiv Kumar
Abstract:
In this short note we consider random fully connected ReLU networks of width $n$ and depth $L$ equipped with a mean-field weight initialization. Our purpose is to study the dependence on $n$ and $L$ of the maximal update ($μ$P) learning rate, the largest learning rate for which the mean squared change in pre-activations after one step of gradient descent remains uniformly bounded at large $n,L$. A…
▽ More
In this short note we consider random fully connected ReLU networks of width $n$ and depth $L$ equipped with a mean-field weight initialization. Our purpose is to study the dependence on $n$ and $L$ of the maximal update ($μ$P) learning rate, the largest learning rate for which the mean squared change in pre-activations after one step of gradient descent remains uniformly bounded at large $n,L$. As in prior work on $μ$P of Yang et. al., we find that this maximal update learning rate is independent of $n$ for all but the first and last layer weights. However, we find that it has a non-trivial dependence of $L$, scaling like $L^{-3/2}.$
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Bayesian Interpolation with Deep Linear Networks
Authors:
Boris Hanin,
Alexander Zlokapa
Abstract:
Characterizing how neural network depth, width, and dataset size jointly impact model quality is a central problem in deep learning theory. We give here a complete solution in the special case of linear networks with output dimension one trained using zero noise Bayesian inference with Gaussian weight priors and mean squared error as a negative log-likelihood. For any training dataset, network dep…
▽ More
Characterizing how neural network depth, width, and dataset size jointly impact model quality is a central problem in deep learning theory. We give here a complete solution in the special case of linear networks with output dimension one trained using zero noise Bayesian inference with Gaussian weight priors and mean squared error as a negative log-likelihood. For any training dataset, network depth, and hidden layer widths, we find non-asymptotic expressions for the predictive posterior and Bayesian model evidence in terms of Meijer-G functions, a class of meromorphic special functions of a single complex variable. Through novel asymptotic expansions of these Meijer-G functions, a rich new picture of the joint role of depth, width, and dataset size emerges. We show that linear networks make provably optimal predictions at infinite depth: the posterior of infinitely deep linear networks with data-agnostic priors is the same as that of shallow networks with evidence-maximizing data-dependent priors. This yields a principled reason to prefer deeper networks when priors are forced to be data-agnostic. Moreover, we show that with data-agnostic priors, Bayesian model evidence in wide linear networks is maximized at infinite depth, elucidating the salutary role of increased depth for model selection. Underpinning our results is a novel emergent notion of effective depth, given by the number of hidden layers times the number of data points divided by the network width; this determines the structure of the posterior in the large-data limit.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2023; v1 submitted 29 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Maximal Initial Learning Rates in Deep ReLU Networks
Authors:
Gaurav Iyer,
Boris Hanin,
David Rolnick
Abstract:
Training a neural network requires choosing a suitable learning rate, which involves a trade-off between speed and effectiveness of convergence. While there has been considerable theoretical and empirical analysis of how large the learning rate can be, most prior work focuses only on late-stage training. In this work, we introduce the maximal initial learning rate $η^{\ast}$ - the largest learning…
▽ More
Training a neural network requires choosing a suitable learning rate, which involves a trade-off between speed and effectiveness of convergence. While there has been considerable theoretical and empirical analysis of how large the learning rate can be, most prior work focuses only on late-stage training. In this work, we introduce the maximal initial learning rate $η^{\ast}$ - the largest learning rate at which a randomly initialized neural network can successfully begin training and achieve (at least) a given threshold accuracy. Using a simple approach to estimate $η^{\ast}$, we observe that in constant-width fully-connected ReLU networks, $η^{\ast}$ behaves differently from the maximum learning rate later in training. Specifically, we find that $η^{\ast}$ is well predicted as a power of depth $\times$ width, provided that (i) the width of the network is sufficiently large compared to the depth, and (ii) the input layer is trained at a relatively small learning rate. We further analyze the relationship between $η^{\ast}$ and the sharpness $λ_{1}$ of the network at initialization, indicating they are closely though not inversely related. We formally prove bounds for $λ_{1}$ in terms of depth $\times$ width that align with our empirical results.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2023; v1 submitted 14 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Deep Architecture Connectivity Matters for Its Convergence: A Fine-Grained Analysis
Authors:
Wuyang Chen,
Wei Huang,
Xinyu Gong,
Boris Hanin,
Zhangyang Wang
Abstract:
Advanced deep neural networks (DNNs), designed by either human or AutoML algorithms, are growing increasingly complex. Diverse operations are connected by complicated connectivity patterns, e.g., various types of skip connections. Those topological compositions are empirically effective and observed to smooth the loss landscape and facilitate the gradient flow in general. However, it remains elusi…
▽ More
Advanced deep neural networks (DNNs), designed by either human or AutoML algorithms, are growing increasingly complex. Diverse operations are connected by complicated connectivity patterns, e.g., various types of skip connections. Those topological compositions are empirically effective and observed to smooth the loss landscape and facilitate the gradient flow in general. However, it remains elusive to derive any principled understanding of their effects on the DNN capacity or trainability, and to understand why or in which aspect one specific connectivity pattern is better than another. In this work, we theoretically characterize the impact of connectivity patterns on the convergence of DNNs under gradient descent training in fine granularity. By analyzing a wide network's Neural Network Gaussian Process (NNGP), we are able to depict how the spectrum of an NNGP kernel propagates through a particular connectivity pattern, and how that affects the bound of convergence rates. As one practical implication of our results, we show that by a simple filtration on "unpromising" connectivity patterns, we can trim down the number of models to evaluate, and significantly accelerate the large-scale neural architecture search without any overhead. Code is available at: https://github.com/VITA-Group/architecture_convergence.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2022; v1 submitted 11 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Random Fully Connected Neural Networks as Perturbatively Solvable Hierarchies
Authors:
Boris Hanin
Abstract:
This article considers fully connected neural networks with Gaussian random weights and biases as well as $L$ hidden layers, each of width proportional to a large parameter $n$. For polynomially bounded non-linearities we give sharp estimates in powers of $1/n$ for the joint cumulants of the network output and its derivatives. Moreover, we show that network cumulants form a perturbatively solvable…
▽ More
This article considers fully connected neural networks with Gaussian random weights and biases as well as $L$ hidden layers, each of width proportional to a large parameter $n$. For polynomially bounded non-linearities we give sharp estimates in powers of $1/n$ for the joint cumulants of the network output and its derivatives. Moreover, we show that network cumulants form a perturbatively solvable hierarchy in powers of $1/n$ in that $k$-th order cumulants in one layer have recursions that depend to leading order in $1/n$ only on $j$-th order cumulants at the previous layer with $j\leq k$. By solving a variety of such recursions, however, we find that the depth-to-width ratio $L/n$ plays the role of an effective network depth, controlling both the scale of fluctuations at individual neurons and the size of inter-neuron correlations. Thus, while the cumulant recursions we derive form a hierarchy in powers of $1/n$, contributions of order $1/n^k$ often grow like $L^k$ and are hence non-negligible at positive $L/n$. We use this to study a somewhat simplified version of the exploding and vanishing gradient problem, proving that this particular variant occurs if and only if $L/n$ is large. Several key ideas in this article were first developed at a physics level of rigor in a recent monograph of Daniel A. Roberts, Sho Yaida, and the author. This article not only makes these ideas mathematically precise but also significantly extends them, opening the way to obtaining corrections to all orders in $1/n$.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2023; v1 submitted 3 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Ridgeless Interpolation with Shallow ReLU Networks in $1D$ is Nearest Neighbor Curvature Extrapolation and Provably Generalizes on Lipschitz Functions
Authors:
Boris Hanin
Abstract:
We prove a precise geometric description of all one layer ReLU networks $z(x;θ)$ with a single linear unit and input/output dimensions equal to one that interpolate a given dataset $\mathcal D=\{(x_i,f(x_i))\}$ and, among all such interpolants, minimize the $\ell_2$-norm of the neuron weights. Such networks can intuitively be thought of as those that minimize the mean-squared error over…
▽ More
We prove a precise geometric description of all one layer ReLU networks $z(x;θ)$ with a single linear unit and input/output dimensions equal to one that interpolate a given dataset $\mathcal D=\{(x_i,f(x_i))\}$ and, among all such interpolants, minimize the $\ell_2$-norm of the neuron weights. Such networks can intuitively be thought of as those that minimize the mean-squared error over $\mathcal D$ plus an infinitesimal weight decay penalty. We therefore refer to them as ridgeless ReLU interpolants. Our description proves that, to extrapolate values $z(x;θ)$ for inputs $x\in (x_i,x_{i+1})$ lying between two consecutive datapoints, a ridgeless ReLU interpolant simply compares the signs of the discrete estimates for the curvature of $f$ at $x_i$ and $x_{i+1}$ derived from the dataset $\mathcal D$. If the curvature estimates at $x_i$ and $x_{i+1}$ have different signs, then $z(x;θ)$ must be linear on $(x_i,x_{i+1})$. If in contrast the curvature estimates at $x_i$ and $x_{i+1}$ are both positive (resp. negative), then $z(x;θ)$ is convex (resp. concave) on $(x_i,x_{i+1})$. Our results show that ridgeless ReLU interpolants achieve the best possible generalization for learning $1d$ Lipschitz functions, up to universal constants.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Random Neural Networks in the Infinite Width Limit as Gaussian Processes
Authors:
Boris Hanin
Abstract:
This article gives a new proof that fully connected neural networks with random weights and biases converge to Gaussian processes in the regime where the input dimension, output dimension, and depth are kept fixed, while the hidden layer widths tend to infinity. Unlike prior work, convergence is shown assuming only moment conditions for the distribution of weights and for quite general non-lineari…
▽ More
This article gives a new proof that fully connected neural networks with random weights and biases converge to Gaussian processes in the regime where the input dimension, output dimension, and depth are kept fixed, while the hidden layer widths tend to infinity. Unlike prior work, convergence is shown assuming only moment conditions for the distribution of weights and for quite general non-linearities.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
The Principles of Deep Learning Theory
Authors:
Daniel A. Roberts,
Sho Yaida,
Boris Hanin
Abstract:
This book develops an effective theory approach to understanding deep neural networks of practical relevance. Beginning from a first-principles component-level picture of networks, we explain how to determine an accurate description of the output of trained networks by solving layer-to-layer iteration equations and nonlinear learning dynamics. A main result is that the predictions of networks are…
▽ More
This book develops an effective theory approach to understanding deep neural networks of practical relevance. Beginning from a first-principles component-level picture of networks, we explain how to determine an accurate description of the output of trained networks by solving layer-to-layer iteration equations and nonlinear learning dynamics. A main result is that the predictions of networks are described by nearly-Gaussian distributions, with the depth-to-width aspect ratio of the network controlling the deviations from the infinite-width Gaussian description. We explain how these effectively-deep networks learn nontrivial representations from training and more broadly analyze the mechanism of representation learning for nonlinear models. From a nearly-kernel-methods perspective, we find that the dependence of such models' predictions on the underlying learning algorithm can be expressed in a simple and universal way. To obtain these results, we develop the notion of representation group flow (RG flow) to characterize the propagation of signals through the network. By tuning networks to criticality, we give a practical solution to the exploding and vanishing gradient problem. We further explain how RG flow leads to near-universal behavior and lets us categorize networks built from different activation functions into universality classes. Altogether, we show that the depth-to-width ratio governs the effective model complexity of the ensemble of trained networks. By using information-theoretic techniques, we estimate the optimal aspect ratio at which we expect the network to be practically most useful and show how residual connections can be used to push this scale to arbitrary depths. With these tools, we can learn in detail about the inductive bias of architectures, hyperparameters, and optimizers.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2021; v1 submitted 18 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Deep ReLU Networks Preserve Expected Length
Authors:
Boris Hanin,
Ryan Jeong,
David Rolnick
Abstract:
Assessing the complexity of functions computed by a neural network helps us understand how the network will learn and generalize. One natural measure of complexity is how the network distorts length - if the network takes a unit-length curve as input, what is the length of the resulting curve of outputs? It has been widely believed that this length grows exponentially in network depth. We prove th…
▽ More
Assessing the complexity of functions computed by a neural network helps us understand how the network will learn and generalize. One natural measure of complexity is how the network distorts length - if the network takes a unit-length curve as input, what is the length of the resulting curve of outputs? It has been widely believed that this length grows exponentially in network depth. We prove that in fact this is not the case: the expected length distortion does not grow with depth, and indeed shrinks slightly, for ReLU networks with standard random initialization. We also generalize this result by proving upper bounds both for higher moments of the length distortion and for the distortion of higher-dimensional volumes. These theoretical results are corroborated by our experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2021; v1 submitted 20 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
How Data Augmentation affects Optimization for Linear Regression
Authors:
Boris Hanin,
Yi Sun
Abstract:
Though data augmentation has rapidly emerged as a key tool for optimization in modern machine learning, a clear picture of how augmentation schedules affect optimization and interact with optimization hyperparameters such as learning rate is nascent. In the spirit of classical convex optimization and recent work on implicit bias, the present work analyzes the effect of augmentation on optimization…
▽ More
Though data augmentation has rapidly emerged as a key tool for optimization in modern machine learning, a clear picture of how augmentation schedules affect optimization and interact with optimization hyperparameters such as learning rate is nascent. In the spirit of classical convex optimization and recent work on implicit bias, the present work analyzes the effect of augmentation on optimization in the simple convex setting of linear regression with MSE loss.
We find joint schedules for learning rate and data augmentation scheme under which augmented gradient descent provably converges and characterize the resulting minimum. Our results apply to arbitrary augmentation schemes, revealing complex interactions between learning rates and augmentations even in the convex setting. Our approach interprets augmented (S)GD as a stochastic optimization method for a time-varying sequence of proxy losses. This gives a unified way to analyze learning rate, batch size, and augmentations ranging from additive noise to random projections. From this perspective, our results, which also give rates of convergence, can be viewed as Monro-Robbins type conditions for augmented (S)GD.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2021; v1 submitted 21 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Finite Depth and Width Corrections to the Neural Tangent Kernel
Authors:
Boris Hanin,
Mihai Nica
Abstract:
We prove the precise scaling, at finite depth and width, for the mean and variance of the neural tangent kernel (NTK) in a randomly initialized ReLU network. The standard deviation is exponential in the ratio of network depth to width. Thus, even in the limit of infinite overparameterization, the NTK is not deterministic if depth and width simultaneously tend to infinity. Moreover, we prove that f…
▽ More
We prove the precise scaling, at finite depth and width, for the mean and variance of the neural tangent kernel (NTK) in a randomly initialized ReLU network. The standard deviation is exponential in the ratio of network depth to width. Thus, even in the limit of infinite overparameterization, the NTK is not deterministic if depth and width simultaneously tend to infinity. Moreover, we prove that for such deep and wide networks, the NTK has a non-trivial evolution during training by showing that the mean of its first SGD update is also exponential in the ratio of network depth to width. This is sharp contrast to the regime where depth is fixed and network width is very large. Our results suggest that, unlike relatively shallow and wide networks, deep and wide ReLU networks are capable of learning data-dependent features even in the so-called lazy training regime.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Deep ReLU Networks Have Surprisingly Few Activation Patterns
Authors:
Boris Hanin,
David Rolnick
Abstract:
The success of deep networks has been attributed in part to their expressivity: per parameter, deep networks can approximate a richer class of functions than shallow networks. In ReLU networks, the number of activation patterns is one measure of expressivity; and the maximum number of patterns grows exponentially with the depth. However, recent work has showed that the practical expressivity of de…
▽ More
The success of deep networks has been attributed in part to their expressivity: per parameter, deep networks can approximate a richer class of functions than shallow networks. In ReLU networks, the number of activation patterns is one measure of expressivity; and the maximum number of patterns grows exponentially with the depth. However, recent work has showed that the practical expressivity of deep networks - the functions they can learn rather than express - is often far from the theoretical maximum. In this paper, we show that the average number of activation patterns for ReLU networks at initialization is bounded by the total number of neurons raised to the input dimension. We show empirically that this bound, which is independent of the depth, is tight both at initialization and during training, even on memorization tasks that should maximize the number of activation patterns. Our work suggests that realizing the full expressivity of deep networks may not be possible in practice, at least with current methods.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2019; v1 submitted 3 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Nonlinear Approximation and (Deep) ReLU Networks
Authors:
I. Daubechies,
R. DeVore,
S. Foucart,
B. Hanin,
G. Petrova
Abstract:
This article is concerned with the approximation and expressive powers of deep neural networks. This is an active research area currently producing many interesting papers. The results most commonly found in the literature prove that neural networks approximate functions with classical smoothness to the same accuracy as classical linear methods of approximation, e.g. approximation by polynomials o…
▽ More
This article is concerned with the approximation and expressive powers of deep neural networks. This is an active research area currently producing many interesting papers. The results most commonly found in the literature prove that neural networks approximate functions with classical smoothness to the same accuracy as classical linear methods of approximation, e.g. approximation by polynomials or by piecewise polynomials on prescribed partitions. However, approximation by neural networks depending on n parameters is a form of nonlinear approximation and as such should be compared with other nonlinear methods such as variable knot splines or n-term approximation from dictionaries. The performance of neural networks in targeted applications such as machine learning indicate that they actually possess even greater approximation power than these traditional methods of nonlinear approximation. The main results of this article prove that this is indeed the case. This is done by exhibiting large classes of functions which can be efficiently captured by neural networks where classical nonlinear methods fall short of the task. The present article purposefully limits itself to studying the approximation of univariate functions by ReLU networks. Many generalizations to functions of several variables and other activation functions can be envisioned. However, even in this simplest of settings considered here, a theory that completely quantifies the approximation power of neural networks is still lacking.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Complexity of Linear Regions in Deep Networks
Authors:
Boris Hanin,
David Rolnick
Abstract:
It is well-known that the expressivity of a neural network depends on its architecture, with deeper networks expressing more complex functions. In the case of networks that compute piecewise linear functions, such as those with ReLU activation, the number of distinct linear regions is a natural measure of expressivity. It is possible to construct networks with merely a single region, or for which…
▽ More
It is well-known that the expressivity of a neural network depends on its architecture, with deeper networks expressing more complex functions. In the case of networks that compute piecewise linear functions, such as those with ReLU activation, the number of distinct linear regions is a natural measure of expressivity. It is possible to construct networks with merely a single region, or for which the number of linear regions grows exponentially with depth; it is not clear where within this range most networks fall in practice, either before or after training. In this paper, we provide a mathematical framework to count the number of linear regions of a piecewise linear network and measure the volume of the boundaries between these regions. In particular, we prove that for networks at initialization, the average number of regions along any one-dimensional subspace grows linearly in the total number of neurons, far below the exponential upper bound. We also find that the average distance to the nearest region boundary at initialization scales like the inverse of the number of neurons. Our theory suggests that, even after training, the number of linear regions is far below exponential, an intuition that matches our empirical observations. We conclude that the practical expressivity of neural networks is likely far below that of the theoretical maximum, and that this gap can be quantified.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2019; v1 submitted 25 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
How to Start Training: The Effect of Initialization and Architecture
Authors:
Boris Hanin,
David Rolnick
Abstract:
We identify and study two common failure modes for early training in deep ReLU nets. For each we give a rigorous proof of when it occurs and how to avoid it, for fully connected and residual architectures. The first failure mode, exploding/vanishing mean activation length, can be avoided by initializing weights from a symmetric distribution with variance 2/fan-in and, for ResNets, by correctly wei…
▽ More
We identify and study two common failure modes for early training in deep ReLU nets. For each we give a rigorous proof of when it occurs and how to avoid it, for fully connected and residual architectures. The first failure mode, exploding/vanishing mean activation length, can be avoided by initializing weights from a symmetric distribution with variance 2/fan-in and, for ResNets, by correctly weighting the residual modules. We prove that the second failure mode, exponentially large variance of activation length, never occurs in residual nets once the first failure mode is avoided. In contrast, for fully connected nets, we prove that this failure mode can happen and is avoided by keeping constant the sum of the reciprocals of layer widths. We demonstrate empirically the effectiveness of our theoretical results in predicting when networks are able to start training. In particular, we note that many popular initializations fail our criteria, whereas correct initialization and architecture allows much deeper networks to be trained.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2018; v1 submitted 5 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Which Neural Net Architectures Give Rise To Exploding and Vanishing Gradients?
Authors:
Boris Hanin
Abstract:
We give a rigorous analysis of the statistical behavior of gradients in a randomly initialized fully connected network N with ReLU activations. Our results show that the empirical variance of the squares of the entries in the input-output Jacobian of N is exponential in a simple architecture-dependent constant beta, given by the sum of the reciprocals of the hidden layer widths. When beta is large…
▽ More
We give a rigorous analysis of the statistical behavior of gradients in a randomly initialized fully connected network N with ReLU activations. Our results show that the empirical variance of the squares of the entries in the input-output Jacobian of N is exponential in a simple architecture-dependent constant beta, given by the sum of the reciprocals of the hidden layer widths. When beta is large, the gradients computed by N at initialization vary wildly. Our approach complements the mean field theory analysis of random networks. From this point of view, we rigorously compute finite width corrections to the statistics of gradients at the edge of chaos.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2018; v1 submitted 11 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Approximating Continuous Functions by ReLU Nets of Minimal Width
Authors:
Boris Hanin,
Mark Sellke
Abstract:
This article concerns the expressive power of depth in deep feed-forward neural nets with ReLU activations. Specifically, we answer the following question: for a fixed $d_{in}\geq 1,$ what is the minimal width $w$ so that neural nets with ReLU activations, input dimension $d_{in}$, hidden layer widths at most $w,$ and arbitrary depth can approximate any continuous, real-valued function of…
▽ More
This article concerns the expressive power of depth in deep feed-forward neural nets with ReLU activations. Specifically, we answer the following question: for a fixed $d_{in}\geq 1,$ what is the minimal width $w$ so that neural nets with ReLU activations, input dimension $d_{in}$, hidden layer widths at most $w,$ and arbitrary depth can approximate any continuous, real-valued function of $d_{in}$ variables arbitrarily well? It turns out that this minimal width is exactly equal to $d_{in}+1.$ That is, if all the hidden layer widths are bounded by $d_{in}$, then even in the infinite depth limit, ReLU nets can only express a very limited class of functions, and, on the other hand, any continuous function on the $d_{in}$-dimensional unit cube can be approximated to arbitrary precision by ReLU nets in which all hidden layers have width exactly $d_{in}+1.$ Our construction in fact shows that any continuous function $f:[0,1]^{d_{in}}\to\mathbb R^{d_{out}}$ can be approximated by a net of width $d_{in}+d_{out}$. We obtain quantitative depth estimates for such an approximation in terms of the modulus of continuity of $f$.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2018; v1 submitted 30 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Universal Function Approximation by Deep Neural Nets with Bounded Width and ReLU Activations
Authors:
Boris Hanin
Abstract:
This article concerns the expressive power of depth in neural nets with ReLU activations and bounded width. We are particularly interested in the following questions: what is the minimal width $w_{\text{min}}(d)$ so that ReLU nets of width $w_{\text{min}}(d)$ (and arbitrary depth) can approximate any continuous function on the unit cube $[0,1]^d$ aribitrarily well? For ReLU nets near this minimal…
▽ More
This article concerns the expressive power of depth in neural nets with ReLU activations and bounded width. We are particularly interested in the following questions: what is the minimal width $w_{\text{min}}(d)$ so that ReLU nets of width $w_{\text{min}}(d)$ (and arbitrary depth) can approximate any continuous function on the unit cube $[0,1]^d$ aribitrarily well? For ReLU nets near this minimal width, what can one say about the depth necessary to approximate a given function? Our approach to this paper is based on the observation that, due to the convexity of the ReLU activation, ReLU nets are particularly well-suited for representing convex functions. In particular, we prove that ReLU nets with width $d+1$ can approximate any continuous convex function of $d$ variables arbitrarily well. These results then give quantitative depth estimates for the rate of approximation of any continuous scalar function on the $d$-dimensional cube $[0,1]^d$ by ReLU nets with width $d+3.$
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2017; v1 submitted 8 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
