-
Convergence of Approximate and Packet Routing Equilibria to Nash Flows Over Time
Authors:
Neil Olver,
Leon Sering,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Infinitesimally small agents aim to travel from a source to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form based on the deterministic queueing model whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Are equilibria in t…
▽ More
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Infinitesimally small agents aim to travel from a source to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form based on the deterministic queueing model whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Are equilibria in this model meaningful as a prediction of traffic behavior? For this to be the case, a certain notion of stability under ongoing perturbations is needed. Real traffic consists of discrete, atomic ''packets'', rather than being a continuous flow of non-atomic agents. Users may not choose an absolutely quickest route available, if there are multiple routes with very similar travel times. We would hope that in both these situations -- a discrete packet model, with packet size going to 0, and $ε$-equilibria, with $ε$ going to 0 -- equilibria converge to dynamic equilibria in the flow over time model. No such convergence results were known. We show that such a convergence result does hold in single-commodity instances for both of these settings, in a unified way. More precisely, we introduce a notion of ''strict'' $ε$-equilibria, and show that these must converge to the exact dynamic equilibrium in the limit as $ε\to 0$. We then show that results for the two settings mentioned can be deduced from this with only moderate further technical effort.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Faster Dynamic Auctions via Polymatroid Sum
Authors:
Katharina Eickhoff,
Meike Neuwohner,
Britta Peis,
Niklas Rieken,
Laura Vargas Koch,
László A. Végh
Abstract:
We consider dynamic auctions for finding Walrasian equilibria in markets with indivisible items and strong gross substitutes valuation functions. Each price adjustment step in these auction algorithms requires finding an inclusion-wise minimal maximal overdemanded set or an inclusion-wise minimal maximal underdemanded set at the current prices. Both can be formulated as a submodular function minim…
▽ More
We consider dynamic auctions for finding Walrasian equilibria in markets with indivisible items and strong gross substitutes valuation functions. Each price adjustment step in these auction algorithms requires finding an inclusion-wise minimal maximal overdemanded set or an inclusion-wise minimal maximal underdemanded set at the current prices. Both can be formulated as a submodular function minimization problem.
We observe that minimizing this submodular function corresponds to a polymatroid sum problem, and using this viewpoint, we give a fast and simple push-relabel algorithm for finding the required sets. This improves on the previously best running time of Murota, Shioura and Yang (ISAAC 2013). Our algorithm is an adaptation of the push-relabel framework by Frank and Miklós (JJIAM 2012) to the particular setting. We obtain a further improvement for the special case of unit-supplies.
We further show the following monotonicty properties of Walrasian prices: both the minimal and maximal Walrasian prices can only increase if supply of goods decreases, or if the demand of buyers increases. This is derived from a fine-grained analysis of market prices. We call "packing prices" a price vector such that there is a feasible allocation where each buyer obtains a utility maximizing set. Conversely, by "covering prices" we mean a price vector such that there exists a collection of utility maximizing sets of the buyers that include all available goods. We show that for strong gross substitutes valuations, the component-wise minimal packing prices coincide with the minimal Walrasian prices and the component-wise maximal covering prices coincide with the maximal Walrasian prices. These properties in turn lead to the price monotonicity results.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2024; v1 submitted 12 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Single-Source Unsplittable Flows in Planar Graphs
Authors:
Vera Traub,
Laura Vargas Koch,
Rico Zenklusen
Abstract:
The single-source unsplittable flow (SSUF) problem asks to send flow from a common source to different terminals with unrelated demands, each terminal being served through a single path. One of the most heavily studied SSUF objectives is to minimize the violation of some given arc capacities. A seminal result of Dinitz, Garg, and Goemans showed that, whenever a fractional flow exists respecting th…
▽ More
The single-source unsplittable flow (SSUF) problem asks to send flow from a common source to different terminals with unrelated demands, each terminal being served through a single path. One of the most heavily studied SSUF objectives is to minimize the violation of some given arc capacities. A seminal result of Dinitz, Garg, and Goemans showed that, whenever a fractional flow exists respecting the capacities, then there is an unsplittable one violating the capacities by at most the maximum demand. Goemans conjectured a very natural cost version of the same result, where the unsplittable flow is required to be no more expensive than the fractional one. This intriguing conjecture remains open. More so, there are arguably no non-trivial graph classes for which it is known to hold.
We show that a slight weakening of it (with at most twice as large violations) holds for planar graphs. Our result is based on a connection to a highly structured discrepancy problem, whose repeated resolution allows us to successively reduce the number of paths used for each terminal, until we obtain an unsplittable flow. Moreover, our techniques also extend to simultaneous upper and lower bounds on the flow values. This also affirmatively answers a conjecture of Morell and Skutella for planar SSUF.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
A flow-based ascending auction to compute buyer-optimal Walrasian prices
Authors:
Katharina Eickhoff,
S. Thomas McCormick,
Britta Peis,
Niklas Rieken,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
We consider a market where a set of objects is sold to a set of buyers, each equipped with a valuation function for the objects. The goal of the auctioneer is to determine reasonable prices together with a stable allocation. One definition of "reasonable" and "stable" is a Walrasian equilibrium, which is a tuple consisting of a price vector together with an allocation satisfying the following desi…
▽ More
We consider a market where a set of objects is sold to a set of buyers, each equipped with a valuation function for the objects. The goal of the auctioneer is to determine reasonable prices together with a stable allocation. One definition of "reasonable" and "stable" is a Walrasian equilibrium, which is a tuple consisting of a price vector together with an allocation satisfying the following desirable properties: (i) the allocation is market-clearing in the sense that as much as possible is sold, and (ii) the allocation is stable in the sense that every buyer ends up with an optimal set with respect to the given prices. Moreover, "buyer-optimal" means that the prices are smallest possible among all Walrasian prices.
In this paper, we present a combinatorial network flow algorithm to compute buyer-optimal Walrasian prices in a multi-unit matching market with additive valuation functions and buyer demands. The algorithm can be seen as a generalization of the classical housing market auction and mimics the very natural procedure of an ascending auction. We use our structural insights to prove monotonicity of the buyer-optimal Walrasian prices with respect to changes in supply or demand.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2024; v1 submitted 27 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
A Simple Combinatorial Algorithm for Robust Matroid Center
Authors:
Georg Anegg,
Laura Vargas Koch,
Rico Zenklusen
Abstract:
Recent progress on robust clustering led to constant-factor approximations for Robust Matroid Center. After a first combinatorial $7$-approximation that is based on a matroid intersection approach, two tight LP-based $3$-approximations were discovered, both relying on the Ellipsoid Method. In this paper, we show how a carefully designed, yet very simple, greedy selection algorithm gives a $5$-appr…
▽ More
Recent progress on robust clustering led to constant-factor approximations for Robust Matroid Center. After a first combinatorial $7$-approximation that is based on a matroid intersection approach, two tight LP-based $3$-approximations were discovered, both relying on the Ellipsoid Method. In this paper, we show how a carefully designed, yet very simple, greedy selection algorithm gives a $5$-approximation. An important ingredient of our approach is a well-chosen use of Rado matroids. This enables us to capture with a single matroid a relaxed version of the original matroid, which, as we show, is amenable to straightforward greedy selections.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Techniques for Generalized Colorful $k$-Center Problems
Authors:
Georg Anegg,
Laura Vargas Koch,
Rico Zenklusen
Abstract:
Fair clustering enjoyed a surge of interest recently. One appealing way of integrating fairness aspects into classical clustering problems is by introducing multiple covering constraints. This is a natural generalization of the robust (or outlier) setting, which has been studied extensively and is amenable to a variety of classic algorithmic techniques. In contrast, for the case of multiple coveri…
▽ More
Fair clustering enjoyed a surge of interest recently. One appealing way of integrating fairness aspects into classical clustering problems is by introducing multiple covering constraints. This is a natural generalization of the robust (or outlier) setting, which has been studied extensively and is amenable to a variety of classic algorithmic techniques. In contrast, for the case of multiple covering constraints (the so-called colorful setting), specialized techniques have only been developed recently for $k$-Center clustering variants, which is also the focus of this paper. While prior techniques assume covering constraints on the clients, they do not address additional constraints on the facilities, which has been extensively studied in non-colorful settings.
In this paper, we present a quite versatile framework to deal with various constraints on the facilities in the colorful setting, by combining ideas from the iterative greedy procedure for Colorful $k$-Center by Inamdar and Varadarajan with new ingredients. To exemplify our framework, we show how it leads, for a constant number $γ$ of colors, to the first constant-factor approximations for both Colorful Matroid Supplier with respect to a linear matroid and Colorful Knapsack Supplier. In both cases, we readily get an $O(2^γ)$-approximation.
Moreover, for Colorful Knapsack Supplier, we show that it is possible to obtain constant approximation guarantees that are independent of the number of colors $γ$, as long as $γ=O(1)$, which is needed to obtain a polynomial running time. More precisely, we obtain a $7$-approximation by extending a technique recently introduced by Jia, Sheth, and Svensson for Colorful $k$-Center.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Continuity, Uniqueness and Long-Term Behavior of Nash Flows Over Time
Authors:
Neil Olver,
Leon Sering,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Users control infinitesimal flow particles aiming to travel from an origin to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Despite lots of interest, some very basic q…
▽ More
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Users control infinitesimal flow particles aiming to travel from an origin to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Despite lots of interest, some very basic questions remain open in this model. We resolve a number of them:
- We show uniqueness of journey times in equilibria.
- We show continuity of equilibria: small perturbations to the instance or to the traffic situation at some moment cannot lead to wildly different equilibrium evolutions.
- We demonstrate that, assuming constant inflow into the network at the source, equilibria always settle down into a "steady state" in which the behavior extends forever in a linear fashion.
One of our main conceptual contributions is to show that the answer to the first two questions, on uniqueness and continuity, are intimately connected to the third. To resolve the third question, we substantially extend the approach of Cominetti et al., who show a steady-state result in the regime where the input flow rate is smaller than the network capacity.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2024; v1 submitted 12 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Convergence of a Packet Routing Model to Flows Over Time
Authors:
Leon Sering,
Laura Vargas Koch,
Theresa Ziemke
Abstract:
The mathematical approaches for modeling dynamic traffic can roughly be divided into two categories: discrete packet routing models and continuous flow over time models. Despite very vital research activities on models in both categories, the connection between these approaches was poorly understood so far. In this work we build this connection by specifying a (competitive) packet routing model, w…
▽ More
The mathematical approaches for modeling dynamic traffic can roughly be divided into two categories: discrete packet routing models and continuous flow over time models. Despite very vital research activities on models in both categories, the connection between these approaches was poorly understood so far. In this work we build this connection by specifying a (competitive) packet routing model, which is discrete in terms of flow and time, and by proving its convergence to the intensively studied model of flows over time with deterministic queuing. More precisely, we prove that the limit of the convergence process, when decreasing the packet size and time step length in the packet routing model, constitutes a flow over time with multiple commodities. In addition, we show that the convergence result implies the existence of approximate equilibria in the competitive version of the packet routing model. This is of significant interest as exact pure Nash equilibria, similar to almost all other competitive models, cannot be guaranteed in the multi-commodity setting. Moreover, the introduced packet routing model with deterministic queuing is very application-oriented as it is based on the network loading module of the agent-based transport simulation MATSim. As the present work is the first mathematical formalization of this simulation, it provides a theoretical foundation and an environment for provable mathematical statements for MATSim.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2022; v1 submitted 27 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
A Greedy Algorithm for the Social Golfer and the Oberwolfach Problem
Authors:
Daniel Schmand,
Marc Schröder,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
Inspired by the increasing popularity of Swiss-system tournaments in sports, we study the problem of predetermining the number of rounds that can be guaranteed in a Swiss-system tournament. Matches of these tournaments are usually determined in a myopic round-based way dependent on the results of previous rounds. Together with the hard constraint that no two players meet more than once during the…
▽ More
Inspired by the increasing popularity of Swiss-system tournaments in sports, we study the problem of predetermining the number of rounds that can be guaranteed in a Swiss-system tournament. Matches of these tournaments are usually determined in a myopic round-based way dependent on the results of previous rounds. Together with the hard constraint that no two players meet more than once during the tournament, at some point it might become infeasible to schedule a next round. For tournaments with $n$ players and match sizes of $k\geq2$ players, we prove that we can always guarantee $\lfloor \frac{n}{k(k-1)} \rfloor$ rounds. We show that this bound is tight. This provides a simple polynomial time constant factor approximation algorithm for the social golfer problem.
We extend the results to the Oberwolfach problem. We show that a simple greedy approach guarantees at least $\lfloor \frac{n+4}{6} \rfloor$ rounds for the Oberwolfach problem. This yields a polynomial time $\frac{1}{3+ε}$-approximation algorithm for any fixed $ε>0$ for the Oberwolfach problem. Assuming that El-Zahar's conjecture is true, we improve the bound on the number of rounds to be essentially tight.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2021; v1 submitted 21 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Nash Flows over Time with Spillback and Kinematic Waves
Authors:
Leon Sering,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
Modeling traffic in road networks is a widely studied but challenging problem, especially under the assumption that drivers act selfishly. A common approach is the deterministic queuing model, for which the structure of dynamic equilibria has been studied extensively in the last couple of years. The basic idea is to model traffic by a continuous flow that travels over time through a network, in wh…
▽ More
Modeling traffic in road networks is a widely studied but challenging problem, especially under the assumption that drivers act selfishly. A common approach is the deterministic queuing model, for which the structure of dynamic equilibria has been studied extensively in the last couple of years. The basic idea is to model traffic by a continuous flow that travels over time through a network, in which the arcs are endowed with transit times and capacities. Whenever the flow rate exceeds the capacity the flow particles build up a queue. So far it was not possible to represent spillback or kinematic waves in this model. By introducing a storage capacity arcs can become full, and thus, might block preceding arcs, i.e., spillback occurs. Furthermore, we model kinematic waves by upstream moving flows over time representing the gaps between vehicles. We carry over the main results of the original model to our generalization, i.e., we characterize Nash flows over time by sequences of particular static flows, so-called spillback thin flows. Furthermore, we give a constructive proof for the existence of dynamic equilibria, which suggests an algorithm for their computation. This solves an open problem stated by [13].
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2020; v1 submitted 16 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Nash equilibria in routing games with edge priorities
Authors:
Robert Scheffler,
Martin Strehler,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
In this paper we present a new competitive packet routing model with edge priorities. We consider players that route selfishly through a network over time and try to reach their destinations as fast as possible. If the number of players who want to enter an edge at the same time exceeds the inflow capacity of this edge, edge priorities with respect to the preceding edge solve these conflicts. Our…
▽ More
In this paper we present a new competitive packet routing model with edge priorities. We consider players that route selfishly through a network over time and try to reach their destinations as fast as possible. If the number of players who want to enter an edge at the same time exceeds the inflow capacity of this edge, edge priorities with respect to the preceding edge solve these conflicts. Our edge priorities are well-motivated by applications in traffic. For this class of games, we show the existence of equilibrium solutions for single-source-single-sink games and we analyze structural properties of these solutions. We present an algorithm that computes Nash equilibria and we prove bounds both on the Price of Stability and on the Price of Anarchy. Moreover, we introduce the new concept of a Price of Mistrust. Finally, we also study the relations to earliest arrival flows.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2018; v1 submitted 2 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
