-
The Debate Over Understanding in AI's Large Language Models
Authors:
Melanie Mitchell,
David C. Krakauer
Abstract:
We survey a current, heated debate in the AI research community on whether large pre-trained language models can be said to "understand" language -- and the physical and social situations language encodes -- in any important sense. We describe arguments that have been made for and against such understanding, and key questions for the broader sciences of intelligence that have arisen in light of th…
▽ More
We survey a current, heated debate in the AI research community on whether large pre-trained language models can be said to "understand" language -- and the physical and social situations language encodes -- in any important sense. We describe arguments that have been made for and against such understanding, and key questions for the broader sciences of intelligence that have arisen in light of these arguments. We contend that a new science of intelligence can be developed that will provide insight into distinct modes of understanding, their strengths and limitations, and the challenge of integrating diverse forms of cognition.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2023; v1 submitted 14 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Simulation Intelligence: Towards a New Generation of Scientific Methods
Authors:
Alexander Lavin,
David Krakauer,
Hector Zenil,
Justin Gottschlich,
Tim Mattson,
Johann Brehmer,
Anima Anandkumar,
Sanjay Choudry,
Kamil Rocki,
Atılım Güneş Baydin,
Carina Prunkl,
Brooks Paige,
Olexandr Isayev,
Erik Peterson,
Peter L. McMahon,
Jakob Macke,
Kyle Cranmer,
Jiaxin Zhang,
Haruko Wainwright,
Adi Hanuka,
Manuela Veloso,
Samuel Assefa,
Stephan Zheng,
Avi Pfeffer
Abstract:
The original "Seven Motifs" set forth a roadmap of essential methods for the field of scientific computing, where a motif is an algorithmic method that captures a pattern of computation and data movement. We present the "Nine Motifs of Simulation Intelligence", a roadmap for the development and integration of the essential algorithms necessary for a merger of scientific computing, scientific simul…
▽ More
The original "Seven Motifs" set forth a roadmap of essential methods for the field of scientific computing, where a motif is an algorithmic method that captures a pattern of computation and data movement. We present the "Nine Motifs of Simulation Intelligence", a roadmap for the development and integration of the essential algorithms necessary for a merger of scientific computing, scientific simulation, and artificial intelligence. We call this merger simulation intelligence (SI), for short. We argue the motifs of simulation intelligence are interconnected and interdependent, much like the components within the layers of an operating system. Using this metaphor, we explore the nature of each layer of the simulation intelligence operating system stack (SI-stack) and the motifs therein: (1) Multi-physics and multi-scale modeling; (2) Surrogate modeling and emulation; (3) Simulation-based inference; (4) Causal modeling and inference; (5) Agent-based modeling; (6) Probabilistic programming; (7) Differentiable programming; (8) Open-ended optimization; (9) Machine programming. We believe coordinated efforts between motifs offers immense opportunity to accelerate scientific discovery, from solving inverse problems in synthetic biology and climate science, to directing nuclear energy experiments and predicting emergent behavior in socioeconomic settings. We elaborate on each layer of the SI-stack, detailing the state-of-art methods, presenting examples to highlight challenges and opportunities, and advocating for specific ways to advance the motifs and the synergies from their combinations. Advancing and integrating these technologies can enable a robust and efficient hypothesis-simulation-analysis type of scientific method, which we introduce with several use-cases for human-machine teaming and automated science.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2022; v1 submitted 6 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
The Cultural Evolution of National Constitutions
Authors:
Daniel N. Rockmore,
Chen Fang,
Nicholas J. Foti,
Tom Ginsburg,
David C. Krakauer
Abstract:
We explore how ideas from infectious disease and genetics can be used to uncover patterns of cultural inheritance and innovation in a corpus of 591 national constitutions spanning 1789 - 2008. Legal "Ideas" are encoded as "topics" - words statistically linked in documents - derived from topic modeling the corpus of constitutions. Using these topics we derive a diffusion network for borrowing from…
▽ More
We explore how ideas from infectious disease and genetics can be used to uncover patterns of cultural inheritance and innovation in a corpus of 591 national constitutions spanning 1789 - 2008. Legal "Ideas" are encoded as "topics" - words statistically linked in documents - derived from topic modeling the corpus of constitutions. Using these topics we derive a diffusion network for borrowing from ancestral constitutions back to the US Constitution of 1789 and reveal that constitutions are complex cultural recombinants. We find systematic variation in patterns of borrowing from ancestral texts and "biological"-like behavior in patterns of inheritance with the distribution of "offspring" arising through a bounded preferential-attachment process. This process leads to a small number of highly innovative (influential) constitutions some of which have yet to have been identified as so in the current literature. Our findings thus shed new light on the critical nodes of the constitution-making network. The constitutional network structure reflects periods of intense constitution creation, and systematic patterns of variation in constitutional life-span and temporal influence.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Capturing collective conflict dynamics with sparse social circuits
Authors:
Edward Lee,
Bryan Daniels,
Jessica Flack,
David Krakauer
Abstract:
We discuss a set of computational techniques, called Inductive Game Theory, for extracting strategic decision-making rules from time series data and constructing probabilistic social circuits. We construct these circuits by connecting component individuals and groups with strategies in a game and propose an inductive approach to reconstructing the edges. We demonstrate this approach with conflict…
▽ More
We discuss a set of computational techniques, called Inductive Game Theory, for extracting strategic decision-making rules from time series data and constructing probabilistic social circuits. We construct these circuits by connecting component individuals and groups with strategies in a game and propose an inductive approach to reconstructing the edges. We demonstrate this approach with conflict behavior in a society of pigtailed macaques by identifying significant patterns in decision-making by individuals. With the constructed circuit, we then capture macroscopic features of the system that were not specified in the construction of the initial circuit, providing a mapping between individual level behaviors to collective behaviors over the scale of the group. We extend on previous work in Inductive Game Theory by more efficiently searching the space of possible strategies by grouping individuals into socially relevant sets to produce a more efficient, parsimonious specification of the underlying interactions between components. We discuss how we reduce the dimensionality of these circuits using coarse-graining or compression to build cognitive effective theories for collective behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
