-
CQE in OWL 2 QL: A "Longest Honeymoon" Approach (extended version)
Authors:
Piero Bonatti,
Gianluca Cima,
Domenico Lembo,
Lorenzo Marconi,
Riccardo Rosati,
Luigi Sauro,
Domenico Fabio Savo
Abstract:
Controlled Query Evaluation (CQE) has been recently studied in the context of Semantic Web ontologies. The goal of CQE is concealing some query answers so as to prevent external users from inferring confidential information. In general, there exist multiple, mutually incomparable ways of concealing answers, and previous CQE approaches choose in advance which answers are visible and which are not.…
▽ More
Controlled Query Evaluation (CQE) has been recently studied in the context of Semantic Web ontologies. The goal of CQE is concealing some query answers so as to prevent external users from inferring confidential information. In general, there exist multiple, mutually incomparable ways of concealing answers, and previous CQE approaches choose in advance which answers are visible and which are not. In this paper, instead, we study a dynamic CQE method, namely, we propose to alter the answer to the current query based on the evaluation of previous ones. We aim at a system that, besides being able to protect confidential data, is maximally cooperative, which intuitively means that it answers affirmatively to as many queries as possible; it achieves this goal by delaying answer modifications as much as possible. We also show that the behavior we get cannot be intensionally simulated through a static approach, independent of query history. Interestingly, for OWL 2 QL ontologies and policy expressed through denials, query evaluation under our semantics is first-order rewritable, and thus in AC0 in data complexity. This paves the way for the development of practical algorithms, which we also preliminarily discuss in the paper.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Defeasible reasoning in Description Logics: an overview on DL^N
Authors:
Piero A. Bonatti,
Iliana M. Petrova,
Luigi Sauro
Abstract:
DL^N is a recent approach that extends description logics with defeasible reasoning capabilities. In this paper we provide an overview on DL^N, illustrating the underlying knowledge engineering requirements as well as the characteristic features that preserve DL^N from some recurrent semantic and computational drawbacks. We also compare DL^N with some alternative nonmonotonic semantics, enlighteni…
▽ More
DL^N is a recent approach that extends description logics with defeasible reasoning capabilities. In this paper we provide an overview on DL^N, illustrating the underlying knowledge engineering requirements as well as the characteristic features that preserve DL^N from some recurrent semantic and computational drawbacks. We also compare DL^N with some alternative nonmonotonic semantics, enlightening the relationships between the KLM postulates and DL^N.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2020; v1 submitted 10 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Machine Understandable Policies and GDPR Compliance Checking
Authors:
Piero A. Bonatti,
Sabrina Kirrane,
Iliana M. Petrova,
Luigi Sauro
Abstract:
The European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) calls for technical and organizational measures to support its implementation. Towards this end, the SPECIAL H2020 project aims to provide a set of tools that can be used by data controllers and processors to automatically check if personal data processing and sharing complies with the obligations set forth in the GDPR. The primary contributio…
▽ More
The European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) calls for technical and organizational measures to support its implementation. Towards this end, the SPECIAL H2020 project aims to provide a set of tools that can be used by data controllers and processors to automatically check if personal data processing and sharing complies with the obligations set forth in the GDPR. The primary contributions of the project include: (i) a policy language that can be used to express consent, business policies, and regulatory obligations; and (ii) two different approaches to automated compliance checking that can be used to demonstrate that data processing performed by data controllers / processors complies with consent provided by data subjects, and business processes comply with regulatory obligations set forth in the GDPR.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Fast Compliance Checking with General Vocabularies
Authors:
P. A. Bonatti,
L. Ioffredo,
I. M. Petrova,
L. Sauro
Abstract:
We address the problem of complying with the GDPR while processing and transferring personal data on the web. For this purpose we introduce an extensible profile of OWL2 for representing data protection policies. With this language, a company's data usage policy can be checked for compliance with data subjects' consent and with a formalized fragment of the GDPR by means of subsumption queries. The…
▽ More
We address the problem of complying with the GDPR while processing and transferring personal data on the web. For this purpose we introduce an extensible profile of OWL2 for representing data protection policies. With this language, a company's data usage policy can be checked for compliance with data subjects' consent and with a formalized fragment of the GDPR by means of subsumption queries. The outer structure of the policies is restricted in order to make compliance checking highly scalable, as required when processing high-frequency data streams or large data volumes. However, the vocabularies for specifying policy properties can be chosen rather freely from expressive Horn fragments of OWL2. We exploit IBQ reasoning to integrate specialized reasoners for the policy language and the vocabulary's language. Our experiments show that this approach significantly improves performance.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Real Time Reasoning in OWL2 for GDPR Compliance
Authors:
P. A. Bonatti,
L. Ioffredo,
I. Petrova,
L. Sauro,
I. R. Siahaan
Abstract:
This paper shows how knowledge representation and reasoning techniques can be used to support organizations in complying with the GDPR, that is, the new European data protection regulation. This work is carried out in a European H2020 project called SPECIAL. Data usage policies, the consent of data subjects, and selected fragments of the GDPR are encoded in a fragment of OWL2 called PL (policy lan…
▽ More
This paper shows how knowledge representation and reasoning techniques can be used to support organizations in complying with the GDPR, that is, the new European data protection regulation. This work is carried out in a European H2020 project called SPECIAL. Data usage policies, the consent of data subjects, and selected fragments of the GDPR are encoded in a fragment of OWL2 called PL (policy language); compliance checking and policy validation are reduced to subsumption checking and concept consistency checking. This work proposes a satisfactory tradeoff between the expressiveness requirements on PL posed by the GDPR, and the scalability requirements that arise from the use cases provided by SPECIAL's industrial partners. Real-time compliance checking is achieved by means of a specialized reasoner, called PLR, that leverages knowledge compilation and structural subsumption techniques. The performance of a prototype implementation of PLR is analyzed through systematic experiments, and compared with the performance of other important reasoners. Moreover, we show how PL and PLR can be extended to support richer ontologies, by means of import-by-query techniques. PL and its integration with OWL2's profiles constitute new tractable fragments of OWL2. We prove also some negative results, concerning the intractability of unrestricted reasoning in PL, and the limitations posed on ontology import.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Optimizing the computation of overriding
Authors:
Piero Andrea Bonatti,
Iliana Mineva Petrova,
Luigi Sauro
Abstract:
We introduce optimization techniques for reasoning in DLN---a recently introduced family of nonmonotonic description logics whose characterizing features appear well-suited to model the applicative examples naturally arising in biomedical domains and semantic web access control policies. Such optimizations are validated experimentally on large KBs with more than 30K axioms. Speedups exceed 1 order…
▽ More
We introduce optimization techniques for reasoning in DLN---a recently introduced family of nonmonotonic description logics whose characterizing features appear well-suited to model the applicative examples naturally arising in biomedical domains and semantic web access control policies. Such optimizations are validated experimentally on large KBs with more than 30K axioms. Speedups exceed 1 order of magnitude. For the first time, response times compatible with real-time reasoning are obtained with nonmonotonic KBs of this size.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Partial Preferences for Mediated Bargaining
Authors:
Piero A. Bonatti,
Marco Faella,
Luigi Sauro
Abstract:
In this work we generalize standard Decision Theory by assuming that two outcomes can also be incomparable. Two motivating scenarios show how incomparability may be helpful to represent those situations where, due to lack of information, the decision maker would like to maintain different options alive and defer the final decision. In particular, a new axiomatization is given which turns out to be…
▽ More
In this work we generalize standard Decision Theory by assuming that two outcomes can also be incomparable. Two motivating scenarios show how incomparability may be helpful to represent those situations where, due to lack of information, the decision maker would like to maintain different options alive and defer the final decision. In particular, a new axiomatization is given which turns out to be a weakening of the classical set of axioms used in Decision Theory. Preliminary results show how preferences involving complex distributions are related to judgments on single alternatives.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Defeasible Inclusions in Low-Complexity DLs
Authors:
Piero A. Bonatti,
Marco Faella,
Luigi Sauro
Abstract:
Some of the applications of OWL and RDF (e.g. biomedical knowledge representation and semantic policy formulation) call for extensions of these languages with nonmonotonic constructs such as inheritance with overriding. Nonmonotonic description logics have been studied for many years, however no practical such knowledge representation languages exist, due to a combination of semantic difficulties…
▽ More
Some of the applications of OWL and RDF (e.g. biomedical knowledge representation and semantic policy formulation) call for extensions of these languages with nonmonotonic constructs such as inheritance with overriding. Nonmonotonic description logics have been studied for many years, however no practical such knowledge representation languages exist, due to a combination of semantic difficulties and high computational complexity. Independently, low-complexity description logics such as DL-lite and EL have been introduced and incorporated in the OWL standard. Therefore, it is interesting to see whether the syntactic restrictions characterizing DL-lite and EL bring computational benefits to their nonmonotonic versions, too. In this paper we extensively investigate the computational complexity of Circumscription when knowledge bases are formulated in DL-lite_R, EL, and fragments thereof. We identify fragments whose complexity ranges from P to the second level of the polynomial hierarchy, as well as fragments whose complexity raises to PSPACE and beyond.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.