-
Convergence of Approximate and Packet Routing Equilibria to Nash Flows Over Time
Authors:
Neil Olver,
Leon Sering,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Infinitesimally small agents aim to travel from a source to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form based on the deterministic queueing model whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Are equilibria in t…
▽ More
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Infinitesimally small agents aim to travel from a source to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form based on the deterministic queueing model whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Are equilibria in this model meaningful as a prediction of traffic behavior? For this to be the case, a certain notion of stability under ongoing perturbations is needed. Real traffic consists of discrete, atomic ''packets'', rather than being a continuous flow of non-atomic agents. Users may not choose an absolutely quickest route available, if there are multiple routes with very similar travel times. We would hope that in both these situations -- a discrete packet model, with packet size going to 0, and $ε$-equilibria, with $ε$ going to 0 -- equilibria converge to dynamic equilibria in the flow over time model. No such convergence results were known. We show that such a convergence result does hold in single-commodity instances for both of these settings, in a unified way. More precisely, we introduce a notion of ''strict'' $ε$-equilibria, and show that these must converge to the exact dynamic equilibrium in the limit as $ε\to 0$. We then show that results for the two settings mentioned can be deduced from this with only moderate further technical effort.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Continuity, Uniqueness and Long-Term Behavior of Nash Flows Over Time
Authors:
Neil Olver,
Leon Sering,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Users control infinitesimal flow particles aiming to travel from an origin to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Despite lots of interest, some very basic q…
▽ More
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Users control infinitesimal flow particles aiming to travel from an origin to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Despite lots of interest, some very basic questions remain open in this model. We resolve a number of them:
- We show uniqueness of journey times in equilibria.
- We show continuity of equilibria: small perturbations to the instance or to the traffic situation at some moment cannot lead to wildly different equilibrium evolutions.
- We demonstrate that, assuming constant inflow into the network at the source, equilibria always settle down into a "steady state" in which the behavior extends forever in a linear fashion.
One of our main conceptual contributions is to show that the answer to the first two questions, on uniqueness and continuity, are intimately connected to the third. To resolve the third question, we substantially extend the approach of Cominetti et al., who show a steady-state result in the regime where the input flow rate is smaller than the network capacity.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2024; v1 submitted 12 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Convergence of a Packet Routing Model to Flows Over Time
Authors:
Leon Sering,
Laura Vargas Koch,
Theresa Ziemke
Abstract:
The mathematical approaches for modeling dynamic traffic can roughly be divided into two categories: discrete packet routing models and continuous flow over time models. Despite very vital research activities on models in both categories, the connection between these approaches was poorly understood so far. In this work we build this connection by specifying a (competitive) packet routing model, w…
▽ More
The mathematical approaches for modeling dynamic traffic can roughly be divided into two categories: discrete packet routing models and continuous flow over time models. Despite very vital research activities on models in both categories, the connection between these approaches was poorly understood so far. In this work we build this connection by specifying a (competitive) packet routing model, which is discrete in terms of flow and time, and by proving its convergence to the intensively studied model of flows over time with deterministic queuing. More precisely, we prove that the limit of the convergence process, when decreasing the packet size and time step length in the packet routing model, constitutes a flow over time with multiple commodities. In addition, we show that the convergence result implies the existence of approximate equilibria in the competitive version of the packet routing model. This is of significant interest as exact pure Nash equilibria, similar to almost all other competitive models, cannot be guaranteed in the multi-commodity setting. Moreover, the introduced packet routing model with deterministic queuing is very application-oriented as it is based on the network loading module of the agent-based transport simulation MATSim. As the present work is the first mathematical formalization of this simulation, it provides a theoretical foundation and an environment for provable mathematical statements for MATSim.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2022; v1 submitted 27 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
ReLU Neural Networks of Polynomial Size for Exact Maximum Flow Computation
Authors:
Christoph Hertrich,
Leon Sering
Abstract:
This paper studies the expressive power of artificial neural networks with rectified linear units. In order to study them as a model of real-valued computation, we introduce the concept of Max-Affine Arithmetic Programs and show equivalence between them and neural networks concerning natural complexity measures. We then use this result to show that two fundamental combinatorial optimization proble…
▽ More
This paper studies the expressive power of artificial neural networks with rectified linear units. In order to study them as a model of real-valued computation, we introduce the concept of Max-Affine Arithmetic Programs and show equivalence between them and neural networks concerning natural complexity measures. We then use this result to show that two fundamental combinatorial optimization problems can be solved with polynomial-size neural networks. First, we show that for any undirected graph with $n$ nodes, there is a neural network (with fixed weights and biases) of size $\mathcal{O}(n^3)$ that takes the edge weights as input and computes the value of a minimum spanning tree of the graph. Second, we show that for any directed graph with $n$ nodes and $m$ arcs, there is a neural network of size $\mathcal{O}(m^2n^2)$ that takes the arc capacities as input and computes a maximum flow. Our results imply that these two problems can be solved with strongly polynomial time algorithms that solely use affine transformations and maxima computations, but no comparison-based branchings.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2024; v1 submitted 12 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Multi-Commodity Nash Flows Over Time
Authors:
Leon Sering
Abstract:
Motivated by the dynamic traffic assignment problem, we consider flows over time model with deterministic queuing. Dynamic equilibria, called Nash flows over time, have been studied intensively since their introduction by Koch and Skutella in 2009. Unfortunately, the original model can only handle a single commodity, i.e., all flow goes from one origin to one destination, therefore, this theory is…
▽ More
Motivated by the dynamic traffic assignment problem, we consider flows over time model with deterministic queuing. Dynamic equilibria, called Nash flows over time, have been studied intensively since their introduction by Koch and Skutella in 2009. Unfortunately, the original model can only handle a single commodity, i.e., all flow goes from one origin to one destination, therefore, this theory is not applicable to every-day traffic scenarios. For this reason we consider Nash flows over time in a setting with multiple commodities, each with a individual origin and destination. We prove their existence with the help of multi-commodity thin flows with resetting. This proof gives some interesting structural insights into the strategy profiles underlying the equilibria, as they emphasis the inter-commodity dependencies. Finally, we show that the two special cases of a common origin or a common destination can be reduced to the single-commodity case.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Atomic Splittable Flow Over Time Games
Authors:
Antonia Adamik,
Leon Sering
Abstract:
In an atomic splittable flow over time game, finitely many players route flow dynamically through a network, in which edges are equipped with transit times, specifying the traversing time, and with capacities, restricting flow rates. Infinitesimally small flow particles controlled by the same player arrive at a constant rate at the player's origin and the player's goal is to maximize the flow volu…
▽ More
In an atomic splittable flow over time game, finitely many players route flow dynamically through a network, in which edges are equipped with transit times, specifying the traversing time, and with capacities, restricting flow rates. Infinitesimally small flow particles controlled by the same player arrive at a constant rate at the player's origin and the player's goal is to maximize the flow volume that arrives at the player's destination within a given time horizon. Hereby, the flow dynamics described by the deterministic queuing model, i.e., flow of different players merges perfectly, but excessive flow has to wait in a queue in front of the bottle-neck. In order to determine Nash equilibria in such games, the main challenge is to consider suitable definitions for the players' strategies, which depend on the level of information the players receive throughout the game. For the most restricted version, in which the players receive no information on the network state at all, we can show that there is no Nash equilibrium in general, not even for networks with only two edges. However, if the current edge congestions are provided over time, the players can adopt their route choices dynamically. We show that a profile of those strategies always lead to a unique feasible flow over time. Hence, those atomic splittable flow over time games are well-defined. For parallel-edge networks Nash equilibria exists and the total flow arriving in time equals the value of a maximum flow over time leading to a price of anarchy of 1.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2022; v1 submitted 5 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
The Impact of Spillback on the Price of Anarchy for Flows Over Time
Authors:
Jonas Israel,
Leon Sering
Abstract:
Flows over time enable a mathematical modeling of traffic that changes as time progresses. In order to evaluate these dynamic flows from a game theoretical perspective we consider the price of anarchy (PoA). In this paper we study the impact of spillback effects on the PoA, which turn out to be substantial. It is known that, in general, the PoA is unbounded in the spillback setting. We extend this…
▽ More
Flows over time enable a mathematical modeling of traffic that changes as time progresses. In order to evaluate these dynamic flows from a game theoretical perspective we consider the price of anarchy (PoA). In this paper we study the impact of spillback effects on the PoA, which turn out to be substantial. It is known that, in general, the PoA is unbounded in the spillback setting. We extend this by showing that it is still unbounded even when considering networks with unit edge capacities and that the Braess ratio can be arbitrarily large. In contrast to that, we show that on a fixed network the PoA as a function of the flow amount is bounded by a constant and also upper bound the PoA for the set of networks where the outflow capacities satisfy certain constraints depending on the quickest flow. This upper bound only depends on the worst spillback factor of the Nash flows over time of the given network. It therefore provides a way to quantify the impact of spillback to the quality of the dynamic equilibria. In addition, we show the surprising fact that the introduction of spillback behavior can actually speed up dynamic equilibria in some networks.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Dynamic Equilibria in Time-Varying Networks
Authors:
Hoang Minh Pham,
Leon Sering
Abstract:
Predicting selfish behavior in public environments by considering Nash equilibria is a central concept of game theory. For the dynamic traffic assignment problem modeled by a flow over time game, in which every particle tries to reach its destination as fast as possible, the dynamic equilibria are called Nash flows over time. So far, this model has only been considered for networks in which each a…
▽ More
Predicting selfish behavior in public environments by considering Nash equilibria is a central concept of game theory. For the dynamic traffic assignment problem modeled by a flow over time game, in which every particle tries to reach its destination as fast as possible, the dynamic equilibria are called Nash flows over time. So far, this model has only been considered for networks in which each arc is equipped with a constant capacity, limiting the outflow rate, and with a transit time, determining the time it takes for a particle to traverse the arc. However, real-world traffic networks can be affected by temporal changes, for example, caused by construction works or special speed zones during some time period. To model these traffic scenarios appropriately, we extend the flow over time model by time-dependent capacities and time-dependent transit times. Our first main result is the characterization of the structure of Nash flows over time. Similar to the static-network model, the strategies of the particles in dynamic equilibria can be characterized by specific static flows, called thin flows with resetting. The second main result is the existence of Nash flows over time, which we show in a constructive manner by extending a flow over time step by step by these thin flows.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Dynamic Flows with Adaptive Route Choice
Authors:
Lukas Graf,
Tobias Harks,
Leon Sering
Abstract:
We study dynamic network flows and introduce a notion of instantaneous dynamic equilibrium (IDE) requiring that for any positive inflow into an edge, this edge must lie on a currently shortest path towards the respective sink. We measure current shortest path length by current waiting times in queues plus physical travel times. As our main results, we show: 1. existence and constructive computatio…
▽ More
We study dynamic network flows and introduce a notion of instantaneous dynamic equilibrium (IDE) requiring that for any positive inflow into an edge, this edge must lie on a currently shortest path towards the respective sink. We measure current shortest path length by current waiting times in queues plus physical travel times. As our main results, we show: 1. existence and constructive computation of IDE flows for single-source single-sink networks assuming constant network inflow rates, 2. finite termination of IDE flows for multi-source single-sink networks assuming bounded and finitely lasting inflow rates, 3. the existence of IDE flows for multi-source multi-sink instances assuming general measurable network inflow rates, 4. the existence of a complex single-source multi-sink instance in which any IDE flow is caught in cycles and flow remains forever in the network.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2020; v1 submitted 18 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Nash Flows over Time with Spillback and Kinematic Waves
Authors:
Leon Sering,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
Modeling traffic in road networks is a widely studied but challenging problem, especially under the assumption that drivers act selfishly. A common approach is the deterministic queuing model, for which the structure of dynamic equilibria has been studied extensively in the last couple of years. The basic idea is to model traffic by a continuous flow that travels over time through a network, in wh…
▽ More
Modeling traffic in road networks is a widely studied but challenging problem, especially under the assumption that drivers act selfishly. A common approach is the deterministic queuing model, for which the structure of dynamic equilibria has been studied extensively in the last couple of years. The basic idea is to model traffic by a continuous flow that travels over time through a network, in which the arcs are endowed with transit times and capacities. Whenever the flow rate exceeds the capacity the flow particles build up a queue. So far it was not possible to represent spillback or kinematic waves in this model. By introducing a storage capacity arcs can become full, and thus, might block preceding arcs, i.e., spillback occurs. Furthermore, we model kinematic waves by upstream moving flows over time representing the gaps between vehicles. We carry over the main results of the original model to our generalization, i.e., we characterize Nash flows over time by sequences of particular static flows, so-called spillback thin flows. Furthermore, we give a constructive proof for the existence of dynamic equilibria, which suggests an algorithm for their computation. This solves an open problem stated by [13].
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2020; v1 submitted 16 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Multi-Source Multi-Sink Nash Flows Over Time
Authors:
Leon Sering,
Martin Skutella
Abstract:
Nash flows over time describe the behavior of selfish users eager to reach their destination as early as possible while traveling along the arcs of a network with capacities and transit times. Throughout the past decade, they have been thoroughly studied in single-source single-sink networks for the deterministic queuing model, which is of particular relevance and frequently used in the context of…
▽ More
Nash flows over time describe the behavior of selfish users eager to reach their destination as early as possible while traveling along the arcs of a network with capacities and transit times. Throughout the past decade, they have been thoroughly studied in single-source single-sink networks for the deterministic queuing model, which is of particular relevance and frequently used in the context of traffic and transport networks. In this setting there exist Nash flows over time that can be described by a sequence of static flows featuring special properties, so-called `thin flows with resetting'. This insight can also be used algorithmically to compute Nash flows over time. We present an extension of these result to networks with multiple sources and sinks which are much more relevant in practical applications. In particular, we come up with a subtle generalization of thin flows with resetting which yields a compact description as well as an algorithmic approach for computing multi-terminal Nash flows over time.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2020; v1 submitted 3 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Rainbow cycles in flip graphs
Authors:
Stefan Felsner,
Linda Kleist,
Torsten Mütze,
Leon Sering
Abstract:
The flip graph of triangulations has as vertices all triangulations of a convex $n$-gon, and an edge between any two triangulations that differ in exactly one edge. An $r$-rainbow cycle in this graph is a cycle in which every inner edge of the triangulation appears exactly $r$ times. This notion of a rainbow cycle extends in a natural way to other flip graphs. In this paper we investigate the exis…
▽ More
The flip graph of triangulations has as vertices all triangulations of a convex $n$-gon, and an edge between any two triangulations that differ in exactly one edge. An $r$-rainbow cycle in this graph is a cycle in which every inner edge of the triangulation appears exactly $r$ times. This notion of a rainbow cycle extends in a natural way to other flip graphs. In this paper we investigate the existence of $r$-rainbow cycles for three different flip graphs on classes of geometric objects: the aforementioned flip graph of triangulations of a convex $n$-gon, the flip graph of plane trees on an arbitrary set of $n$ points, and the flip graph of non-crossing perfect matchings on a set of $n$ points in convex position. In addition, we consider two flip graphs on classes of non-geometric objects: the flip graph of permutations of $\{1,2,\dots,n\}$ and the flip graph of $k$-element subsets of $\{1,2,\dots,n\}$. In each of the five settings, we prove the existence and non-existence of rainbow cycles for different values of $r$, $n$ and~$k$.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2018; v1 submitted 20 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
