-
Are Large Language Models Capable of Generating Human-Level Narratives?
Authors:
Yufei Tian,
Tenghao Huang,
Miri Liu,
Derek Jiang,
Alexander Spangher,
Muhao Chen,
Jonathan May,
Nanyun Peng
Abstract:
This paper investigates the capability of LLMs in storytelling, focusing on narrative development and plot progression. We introduce a novel computational framework to analyze narratives through three discourse-level aspects: i) story arcs, ii) turning points, and iii) affective dimensions, including arousal and valence. By leveraging expert and automatic annotations, we uncover significant discre…
▽ More
This paper investigates the capability of LLMs in storytelling, focusing on narrative development and plot progression. We introduce a novel computational framework to analyze narratives through three discourse-level aspects: i) story arcs, ii) turning points, and iii) affective dimensions, including arousal and valence. By leveraging expert and automatic annotations, we uncover significant discrepancies between the LLM- and human- written stories. While human-written stories are suspenseful, arousing, and diverse in narrative structures, LLM stories are homogeneously positive and lack tension. Next, we measure narrative reasoning skills as a precursor to generative capacities, concluding that most LLMs fall short of human abilities in discourse understanding. Finally, we show that explicit integration of aforementioned discourse features can enhance storytelling, as is demonstrated by over 40% improvement in neural storytelling in terms of diversity, suspense, and arousal.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Tracking the Newsworthiness of Public Documents
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Emilio Ferrara,
Ben Welsh,
Nanyun Peng,
Serdar Tumgoren,
Jonathan May
Abstract:
Journalists must find stories in huge amounts of textual data (e.g. leaks, bills, press releases) as part of their jobs: determining when and why text becomes news can help us understand coverage patterns and help us build assistive tools. Yet, this is challenging because very few labelled links exist, language use between corpora is very different, and text may be covered for a variety of reasons…
▽ More
Journalists must find stories in huge amounts of textual data (e.g. leaks, bills, press releases) as part of their jobs: determining when and why text becomes news can help us understand coverage patterns and help us build assistive tools. Yet, this is challenging because very few labelled links exist, language use between corpora is very different, and text may be covered for a variety of reasons. In this work we focus on news coverage of local public policy in the San Francisco Bay Area by the San Francisco Chronicle. First, we gather news articles, public policy documents and meeting recordings and link them using probabilistic relational modeling, which we show is a low-annotation linking methodology that outperforms other retrieval-based baselines. Second, we define a new task: newsworthiness prediction, to predict if a policy item will get covered. We show that different aspects of public policy discussion yield different newsworthiness signals. Finally we perform human evaluation with expert journalists and show our systems identify policies they consider newsworthy with 68% F1 and our coverage recommendations are helpful with an 84% win-rate.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Stay on topic with Classifier-Free Guidance
Authors:
Guillaume Sanchez,
Honglu Fan,
Alexander Spangher,
Elad Levi,
Pawan Sasanka Ammanamanchi,
Stella Biderman
Abstract:
Classifier-Free Guidance (CFG) has recently emerged in text-to-image generation as a lightweight technique to encourage prompt-adherence in generations. In this work, we demonstrate that CFG can be used broadly as an inference-time technique in pure language modeling. We show that CFG (1) improves the performance of Pythia, GPT-2 and LLaMA-family models across an array of tasks: Q\&A, reasoning, c…
▽ More
Classifier-Free Guidance (CFG) has recently emerged in text-to-image generation as a lightweight technique to encourage prompt-adherence in generations. In this work, we demonstrate that CFG can be used broadly as an inference-time technique in pure language modeling. We show that CFG (1) improves the performance of Pythia, GPT-2 and LLaMA-family models across an array of tasks: Q\&A, reasoning, code generation, and machine translation, achieving SOTA on LAMBADA with LLaMA-7B over PaLM-540B; (2) brings improvements equivalent to a model with twice the parameter-count; (3) can stack alongside other inference-time methods like Chain-of-Thought and Self-Consistency, yielding further improvements in difficult tasks; (4) can be used to increase the faithfulness and coherence of assistants in challenging form-driven and content-driven prompts: in a human evaluation we show a 75\% preference for GPT4All using CFG over baseline.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Identifying Informational Sources in News Articles
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Nanyun Peng,
Jonathan May,
Emilio Ferrara
Abstract:
News articles are driven by the informational sources journalists use in reporting. Modeling when, how and why sources get used together in stories can help us better understand the information we consume and even help journalists with the task of producing it. In this work, we take steps toward this goal by constructing the largest and widest-ranging annotated dataset, to date, of informational s…
▽ More
News articles are driven by the informational sources journalists use in reporting. Modeling when, how and why sources get used together in stories can help us better understand the information we consume and even help journalists with the task of producing it. In this work, we take steps toward this goal by constructing the largest and widest-ranging annotated dataset, to date, of informational sources used in news writing. We show that our dataset can be used to train high-performing models for information detection and source attribution. We further introduce a novel task, source prediction, to study the compositionality of sources in news articles. We show good performance on this task, which we argue is an important proof for narrative science exploring the internal structure of news articles and aiding in planning-based language generation, and an important step towards a source-recommendation system to aid journalists.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Sequentially Controlled Text Generation
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Xinyu Hua,
Yao Ming,
Nanyun Peng
Abstract:
While GPT-2 generates sentences that are remarkably human-like, longer documents can ramble and do not follow human-like writing structure. We study the problem of imposing structure on long-range text. We propose a novel controlled text generation task, sequentially controlled text generation, and identify a dataset, NewsDiscourse as a starting point for this task. We develop a sequential control…
▽ More
While GPT-2 generates sentences that are remarkably human-like, longer documents can ramble and do not follow human-like writing structure. We study the problem of imposing structure on long-range text. We propose a novel controlled text generation task, sequentially controlled text generation, and identify a dataset, NewsDiscourse as a starting point for this task. We develop a sequential controlled text generation pipeline with generation and editing. We test different degrees of structural awareness and show that, in general, more structural awareness results in higher control-accuracy, grammaticality, coherency and topicality, approaching human-level writing performance.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
If it Bleeds, it Leads: A Computational Approach to Covering Crime in Los Angeles
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Divya Choudhary
Abstract:
Developing and improving computational approaches to covering news can increase journalistic output and improve the way stories are covered. In this work we approach the problem of covering crime stories in Los Angeles. We present a machine-in-the-loop system that covers individual crimes by (1) learning the prototypical coverage archetypes from classical news articles on crime to learn their stru…
▽ More
Developing and improving computational approaches to covering news can increase journalistic output and improve the way stories are covered. In this work we approach the problem of covering crime stories in Los Angeles. We present a machine-in-the-loop system that covers individual crimes by (1) learning the prototypical coverage archetypes from classical news articles on crime to learn their structure and (2) using output from the Los Angeles Police department to generate "lede paragraphs", first structural unit of crime-articles. We introduce a probabilistic graphical model for learning article structure and a rule-based system for generating ledes. We hope our work can lead to systems that use these components together to form the skeletons of news articles covering crime.
This work was done for a class project in Jonathan May's Advanced Natural Language Processing Course, Fall, 2019.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
NewsEdits: A News Article Revision Dataset and a Document-Level Reasoning Challenge
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Xiang Ren,
Jonathan May,
Nanyun Peng
Abstract:
News article revision histories provide clues to narrative and factual evolution in news articles. To facilitate analysis of this evolution, we present the first publicly available dataset of news revision histories, NewsEdits. Our dataset is large-scale and multilingual; it contains 1.2 million articles with 4.6 million versions from over 22 English- and French-language newspaper sources based in…
▽ More
News article revision histories provide clues to narrative and factual evolution in news articles. To facilitate analysis of this evolution, we present the first publicly available dataset of news revision histories, NewsEdits. Our dataset is large-scale and multilingual; it contains 1.2 million articles with 4.6 million versions from over 22 English- and French-language newspaper sources based in three countries, spanning 15 years of coverage (2006-2021).
We define article-level edit actions: Addition, Deletion, Edit and Refactor, and develop a high-accuracy extraction algorithm to identify these actions. To underscore the factual nature of many edit actions, we conduct analyses showing that added and deleted sentences are more likely to contain updating events, main content and quotes than unchanged sentences.
Finally, to explore whether edit actions are predictable, we introduce three novel tasks aimed at predicting actions performed during version updates. We show that these tasks are possible for expert humans but are challenging for large NLP models. We hope this can spur research in narrative framing and help provide predictive tools for journalists chasing breaking news.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Learning Action Conditions from Instructional Manuals for Instruction Understanding
Authors:
Te-Lin Wu,
Caiqi Zhang,
Qingyuan Hu,
Alex Spangher,
Nanyun Peng
Abstract:
The ability to infer pre- and postconditions of an action is vital for comprehending complex instructions, and is essential for applications such as autonomous instruction-guided agents and assistive AI that supports humans to perform physical tasks. In this work, we propose a task dubbed action condition inference, and collecting a high-quality, human annotated dataset of preconditions and postco…
▽ More
The ability to infer pre- and postconditions of an action is vital for comprehending complex instructions, and is essential for applications such as autonomous instruction-guided agents and assistive AI that supports humans to perform physical tasks. In this work, we propose a task dubbed action condition inference, and collecting a high-quality, human annotated dataset of preconditions and postconditions of actions in instructional manuals. We propose a weakly supervised approach to automatically construct large-scale training instances from online instructional manuals, and curate a densely human-annotated and validated dataset to study how well the current NLP models can infer action-condition dependencies in the instruction texts. We design two types of models differ by whether contextualized and global information is leveraged, as well as various combinations of heuristics to construct the weak supervisions. Our experimental results show a >20% F1-score improvement with considering the entire instruction contexts and a >6% F1-score benefit with the proposed heuristics.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2024; v1 submitted 24 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Understanding Multimodal Procedural Knowledge by Sequencing Multimodal Instructional Manuals
Authors:
Te-Lin Wu,
Alex Spangher,
Pegah Alipoormolabashi,
Marjorie Freedman,
Ralph Weischedel,
Nanyun Peng
Abstract:
The ability to sequence unordered events is an essential skill to comprehend and reason about real world task procedures, which often requires thorough understanding of temporal common sense and multimodal information, as these procedures are often communicated through a combination of texts and images. Such capability is essential for applications such as sequential task planning and multi-source…
▽ More
The ability to sequence unordered events is an essential skill to comprehend and reason about real world task procedures, which often requires thorough understanding of temporal common sense and multimodal information, as these procedures are often communicated through a combination of texts and images. Such capability is essential for applications such as sequential task planning and multi-source instruction summarization. While humans are capable of reasoning about and sequencing unordered multimodal procedural instructions, whether current machine learning models have such essential capability is still an open question. In this work, we benchmark models' capability of reasoning over and sequencing unordered multimodal instructions by curating datasets from popular online instructional manuals and collecting comprehensive human annotations. We find models not only perform significantly worse than humans but also seem incapable of efficiently utilizing the multimodal information. To improve machines' performance on multimodal event sequencing, we propose sequentiality-aware pretraining techniques that exploit the sequential alignment properties of both texts and images, resulting in > 5% significant improvements.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024; v1 submitted 16 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
StateCensusLaws.org: A Web Application for Consuming and Annotating Legal Discourse Learning
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Jonathan May
Abstract:
In this work, we create a web application to highlight the output of NLP models trained to parse and label discourse segments in law text. Our system is built primarily with journalists and legal interpreters in mind, and we focus on state-level law that uses U.S. Census population numbers to allocate resources and organize government.
Our system exposes a corpus we collect of 6,000 state-level…
▽ More
In this work, we create a web application to highlight the output of NLP models trained to parse and label discourse segments in law text. Our system is built primarily with journalists and legal interpreters in mind, and we focus on state-level law that uses U.S. Census population numbers to allocate resources and organize government.
Our system exposes a corpus we collect of 6,000 state-level laws that pertain to the U.S. census, using 25 scrapers we built to crawl state law websites, which we release. We also build a novel, flexible annotation framework that can handle span-tagging and relation tagging on an arbitrary input text document and be embedded simply into any webpage. This framework allows journalists and researchers to add to our annotation database by correcting and tagging new data.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2022; v1 submitted 20 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
"Don't quote me on that": Finding Mixtures of Sources in News Articles
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Nanyun Peng,
Jonathan May,
Emilio Ferrara
Abstract:
Journalists publish statements provided by people, or \textit{sources} to contextualize current events, help voters make informed decisions, and hold powerful individuals accountable. In this work, we construct an ontological labeling system for sources based on each source's \textit{affiliation} and \textit{role}. We build a probabilistic model to infer these attributes for named sources and to d…
▽ More
Journalists publish statements provided by people, or \textit{sources} to contextualize current events, help voters make informed decisions, and hold powerful individuals accountable. In this work, we construct an ontological labeling system for sources based on each source's \textit{affiliation} and \textit{role}. We build a probabilistic model to infer these attributes for named sources and to describe news articles as mixtures of these sources. Our model outperforms existing mixture modeling and co-clustering approaches and correctly infers source-type in 80\% of expert-evaluated trials. Such work can facilitate research in downstream tasks like opinion and argumentation mining, representing a first step towards machine-in-the-loop \textit{computational journalism} systems.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Modeling "Newsworthiness" for Lead-Generation Across Corpora
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Nanyun Peng,
Jonathan May,
Emilio Ferrara
Abstract:
Journalists obtain "leads", or story ideas, by reading large corpora of government records: court cases, proposed bills, etc. However, only a small percentage of such records are interesting documents. We propose a model of "newsworthiness" aimed at surfacing interesting documents. We train models on automatically labeled corpora -- published newspaper articles -- to predict whether each article w…
▽ More
Journalists obtain "leads", or story ideas, by reading large corpora of government records: court cases, proposed bills, etc. However, only a small percentage of such records are interesting documents. We propose a model of "newsworthiness" aimed at surfacing interesting documents. We train models on automatically labeled corpora -- published newspaper articles -- to predict whether each article was a front-page article (i.e., \textbf{newsworthy}) or not (i.e., \textbf{less newsworthy}). We transfer these models to unlabeled corpora -- court cases, bills, city-council meeting minutes -- to rank documents in these corpora on "newsworthiness". A fine-tuned RoBERTa model achieves .93 AUC performance on heldout labeled documents, and .88 AUC on expert-validated unlabeled corpora. We provide interpretation and visualization for our models.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
NewsEdits: A Dataset of Revision Histories for News Articles (Technical Report: Data Processing)
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Jonathan May
Abstract:
News article revision histories have the potential to give us novel insights across varied fields of linguistics and social sciences. In this work, we present, to our knowledge, the first publicly available dataset of news article revision histories, or NewsEdits.
Our dataset is multilingual; it contains 1,278,804 articles with 4,609,430 versions from over 22 English- and French-language newspap…
▽ More
News article revision histories have the potential to give us novel insights across varied fields of linguistics and social sciences. In this work, we present, to our knowledge, the first publicly available dataset of news article revision histories, or NewsEdits.
Our dataset is multilingual; it contains 1,278,804 articles with 4,609,430 versions from over 22 English- and French-language newspaper sources based in three countries. Across version pairs, we count 10.9 million added sentences; 8.9 million changed sentences and 6.8 million removed sentences. Within the changed sentences, we derive 72 million atomic edits. NewsEdits is, to our knowledge, the largest corpus of revision histories of any domain.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2022; v1 submitted 19 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Multitask Learning for Class-Imbalanced Discourse Classification
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Jonathan May,
Sz-rung Shiang,
Lingjia Deng
Abstract:
Small class-imbalanced datasets, common in many high-level semantic tasks like discourse analysis, present a particular challenge to current deep-learning architectures. In this work, we perform an extensive analysis on sentence-level classification approaches for the News Discourse dataset, one of the largest high-level semantic discourse datasets recently published. We show that a multitask appr…
▽ More
Small class-imbalanced datasets, common in many high-level semantic tasks like discourse analysis, present a particular challenge to current deep-learning architectures. In this work, we perform an extensive analysis on sentence-level classification approaches for the News Discourse dataset, one of the largest high-level semantic discourse datasets recently published. We show that a multitask approach can improve 7% Micro F1-score upon current state-of-the-art benchmarks, due in part to label corrections across tasks, which improve performance for underrepresented classes. We also offer a comparative review of additional techniques proposed to address resource-poor problems in NLP, and show that none of these approaches can improve classification accuracy in such a setting.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Analysis of Strategy and Spread of Russia-sponsored Content in the US in 2017
Authors:
Alexander Spangher,
Gireeja Ranade,
Besmira Nushi,
Adam Fourney,
Eric Horvitz
Abstract:
The Russia-based Internet Research Agency (IRA) carried out a broad information campaign in the U.S. before and after the 2016 presidential election. The organization created an expansive set of internet properties: web domains, Facebook pages, and Twitter bots, which received traffic via purchased Facebook ads, tweets, and search engines indexing their domains. We investigate the scope of IRA act…
▽ More
The Russia-based Internet Research Agency (IRA) carried out a broad information campaign in the U.S. before and after the 2016 presidential election. The organization created an expansive set of internet properties: web domains, Facebook pages, and Twitter bots, which received traffic via purchased Facebook ads, tweets, and search engines indexing their domains. We investigate the scope of IRA activities in 2017, joining data from Facebook and Twitter with logs from the Internet Explorer 11 and Edge browsers and the Bing.com search engine. The studies demonstrate both the ease with which malicious actors can harness social media and search engines for propaganda campaigns, and the ability to track and understand such activities by fusing content and activity resources from multiple internet services. We show how cross-platform analyses can provide an unprecedented lens on attempts to manipulate opinions and elections in democracies.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Actionable Recourse in Linear Classification
Authors:
Berk Ustun,
Alexander Spangher,
Yang Liu
Abstract:
Machine learning models are increasingly used to automate decisions that affect humans - deciding who should receive a loan, a job interview, or a social service. In such applications, a person should have the ability to change the decision of a model. When a person is denied a loan by a credit score, for example, they should be able to alter its input variables in a way that guarantees approval.…
▽ More
Machine learning models are increasingly used to automate decisions that affect humans - deciding who should receive a loan, a job interview, or a social service. In such applications, a person should have the ability to change the decision of a model. When a person is denied a loan by a credit score, for example, they should be able to alter its input variables in a way that guarantees approval. Otherwise, they will be denied the loan as long as the model is deployed. More importantly, they will lack the ability to influence a decision that affects their livelihood.
In this paper, we frame these issues in terms of recourse, which we define as the ability of a person to change the decision of a model by altering actionable input variables (e.g., income vs. age or marital status). We present integer programming tools to ensure recourse in linear classification problems without interfering in model development. We demonstrate how our tools can inform stakeholders through experiments on credit scoring problems. Our results show that recourse can be significantly affected by standard practices in model development, and motivate the need to evaluate recourse in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2019; v1 submitted 17 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.