-
Approximation Algorithms for Correlated Knapsack Orienteering
Authors:
David Aleman Espinosa,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider the {\em correlated knapsack orienteering} (CSKO) problem: we are given a travel budget $B$, processing-time budget $W$, finite metric space $(V,d)$ with root $ρ\in V$, where each vertex is associated with a job with possibly correlated random size and random reward that become known only when the job completes. Random variables are independent across different vertices. The goal is to…
▽ More
We consider the {\em correlated knapsack orienteering} (CSKO) problem: we are given a travel budget $B$, processing-time budget $W$, finite metric space $(V,d)$ with root $ρ\in V$, where each vertex is associated with a job with possibly correlated random size and random reward that become known only when the job completes. Random variables are independent across different vertices. The goal is to compute a $ρ$-rooted path of length at most $B$, in a possibly adaptive fashion, that maximizes the reward collected from jobs that processed by time $W$. To our knowledge, CSKO has not been considered before, though prior work has considered the uncorrelated problem, {\em stochastic knapsack orienteering}, and {\em correlated orienteering}, which features only one budget constraint on the {\em sum} of travel-time and processing-times.
We show that the {\em adaptivity gap of CSKO is not a constant, and is at least $Ω\bigl(\max\sqrt{\log{B}},\sqrt{\log\log{W}}\}\bigr)$}. Complementing this, we devise {\em non-adaptive} algorithms that obtain: (a) $O(\log\log W)$-approximation in quasi-polytime; and (b) $O(\log W)$-approximation in polytime. We obtain similar guarantees for CSKO with cancellations, wherein a job can be cancelled before its completion time, foregoing its reward. We also consider the special case of CSKO, wherein job sizes are weighted Bernoulli distributions, and more generally where the distributions are supported on at most two points (2-CSKO). Although weighted Bernoulli distributions suffice to yield an $Ω(\sqrt{\log\log B})$ adaptivity-gap lower bound for (uncorrelated) {\em stochastic orienteering}, we show that they are easy instances for CSKO. We develop non-adaptive algorithms that achieve $O(1)$-approximation in polytime for weighted Bernoulli distributions, and in $(n+\log B)^{O(\log W)}$-time for the more general case of 2-CSKO.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
On the Randomized Metric Distortion Conjecture
Authors:
Haripriya Pulyassary,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
In the single winner determination problem, we have n voters and m candidates and each voter j incurs a cost c(i, j) if candidate i is chosen. Our objective is to choose a candidate that minimizes the expected total cost incurred by the voters; however as we only have access to the agents' preference rankings over the outcomes, a loss of efficiency is inevitable. This loss of efficiency is quantif…
▽ More
In the single winner determination problem, we have n voters and m candidates and each voter j incurs a cost c(i, j) if candidate i is chosen. Our objective is to choose a candidate that minimizes the expected total cost incurred by the voters; however as we only have access to the agents' preference rankings over the outcomes, a loss of efficiency is inevitable. This loss of efficiency is quantified by distortion. We give an instance of the metric single winner determination problem for which any randomized social choice function has distortion at least 2.063164. This disproves the long-standing conjecture that there exists a randomized social choice function that has a worst-case distortion of at most 2.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2021; v1 submitted 16 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Combinatorial Algorithms for Rooted Prize-Collecting Walks and Applications to Orienteering and Minimum-Latency Problems
Authors:
Sina Dezfuli,
Zachary Friggstad,
Ian Post,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider the rooted prize-collecting walks (PCW) problem, wherein we seek a collection $C$ of rooted walks having minimum prize-collecting cost, which is the (total cost of walks in $C$) + (total node-reward of nodes not visited by any walk in $C$). This problem arises naturally as the Lagrangian relaxation of both orienteering, where we seek a length-bounded walk of maximum reward, and the…
▽ More
We consider the rooted prize-collecting walks (PCW) problem, wherein we seek a collection $C$ of rooted walks having minimum prize-collecting cost, which is the (total cost of walks in $C$) + (total node-reward of nodes not visited by any walk in $C$). This problem arises naturally as the Lagrangian relaxation of both orienteering, where we seek a length-bounded walk of maximum reward, and the $\ell$-stroll problem, where we seek a minimum-length walk covering at least $\ell$ nodes. Our main contribution is to devise a simple, combinatorial algorithm for the PCW problem in directed graphs that returns a rooted tree whose prize-collecting cost is at most the optimum value of the prize-collecting walks problem.
We utilize our algorithm to develop combinatorial approximation algorithms for two fundamental vehicle-routing problems (VRPs): (1) orienteering; and (2) $k$-minimum-latency problem ($k$-MLP), wherein we seek to cover all nodes using $k$ paths starting at a prescribed root node, so as to minimize the sum of the node visiting times. Our combinatorial algorithm allows us to sidestep the part where we solve a preflow-based LP in the LP-rounding algorithms of Friggstand and Swamy (2017) for orienteering, and in the state-of-the-art $7.183$-approximation algorithm for $k$-MP in Post and Swamy (2015). Consequently, we obtain combinatorial implementations of these algorithms with substantially improved running times compared with the current-best approximation factors.
We report computational results for our resulting (combinatorial implementations of) orienteering algorithms, which show that the algorithms perform quite well in practice, both in terms of the quality of the solution they return, as also the upper bound they yield on the orienteering optimum (which is obtained by leveraging the workings of our PCW algorithm).
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
A Simple Approximation Algorithm for Vector Scheduling and Applications to Stochastic Min-Norm Load Balancing
Authors:
Sharat Ibrahimpur,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider the Vector Scheduling problem on identical machines: we have m machines, and a set J of n jobs, where each job j has a processing-time vector $p_j\in \mathbb{R}^d_{\geq 0}$. The goal is to find an assignment $σ:J\to [m]$ of jobs to machines so as to minimize the makespan $\max_{i\in [m]}\max_{r\in [d]}( \sum_{j:σ(j)=i}p_{j,r})$. A natural lower bound on the optimal makespan is lb…
▽ More
We consider the Vector Scheduling problem on identical machines: we have m machines, and a set J of n jobs, where each job j has a processing-time vector $p_j\in \mathbb{R}^d_{\geq 0}$. The goal is to find an assignment $σ:J\to [m]$ of jobs to machines so as to minimize the makespan $\max_{i\in [m]}\max_{r\in [d]}( \sum_{j:σ(j)=i}p_{j,r})$. A natural lower bound on the optimal makespan is lb $:=\max\{\max_{j\in J,r\in [d]}p_{j,r},\max_{r\in [d]}(\sum_{j\in J}p_{j,r}/m)\}$. Our main result is a very simple O(log d)-approximation algorithm for vector scheduling with respect to the lower bound lb: we devise an algorithm that returns an assignment whose makespan is at most O(log d)*lb.
As an application, we show that the above guarantee leads to an O(log log m)-approximation for Stochastic Minimum-Norm Load Balancing (StochNormLB). In StochNormLB, we have m identical machines, a set J of n independent stochastic jobs whose processing times are nonnegative random variables, and a monotone, symmetric norm $f:\mathbb{R}^m \to \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$. The goal is to find an assignment $σ:J\to [m]$ that minimizes the expected $f$-norm of the induced machine-load vector, where the load on machine i is the (random) total processing time assigned to it. Our O(log log m)-approximation guarantee is in fact much stronger: we obtain an assignment that is simultaneously an O(log log m)-approximation for StochNormLB with all monotone, symmetric norms. Next, this approximation factor significantly improves upon the O(log m/log log m)-approximation in (Ibrahimpur and Swamy, FOCS 2020) for StochNormLB, and is a consequence of a more-general black-box reduction that we present, showing that a $γ(d)$-approximation for d-dimensional vector scheduling with respect to the lower bound lb yields a simultaneous $γ(\log m)$-approximation for StochNormLB with all monotone, symmetric norms.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Approximation Algorithms for Stochastic Minimum Norm Combinatorial Optimization
Authors:
Sharat Ibrahimpur,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
Motivated by the need for, and growing interest in, modeling uncertainty in data, we introduce and study {\em stochastic minimum-norm optimization}. We have an underlying combinatorial optimization problem where the costs involved are {\em random variables} with given distributions; each feasible solution induces a random multidimensional cost vector, and given a certain objective function, the go…
▽ More
Motivated by the need for, and growing interest in, modeling uncertainty in data, we introduce and study {\em stochastic minimum-norm optimization}. We have an underlying combinatorial optimization problem where the costs involved are {\em random variables} with given distributions; each feasible solution induces a random multidimensional cost vector, and given a certain objective function, the goal is to find a solution (that does not depend on the realizations of the costs) that minimizes the expected objective value. For instance, in stochastic load balancing, jobs with random processing times need to be assigned to machines, and the induced cost vector is the machine-load vector. Recently, in the deterministic setting, Chakrabarty and Swamy \cite{ChakrabartyS19a} considered a fairly broad suite of objectives, wherein we seek to minimize the $f$-norm of the cost vector under a given {\em arbitrary monotone, symmetric norm} $f$. In stochastic minimum-norm optimization, we work with this broad class of objectives, and seek a solution that minimizes the {\em expected $f$-norm} of the induced cost vector.
We give a general framework for devising algorithms for stochastic minimum-norm combinatorial optimization, using which we obtain approximation algorithms for the stochastic minimum-norm versions of the load balancing and spanning tree problems. Two key technical contributions of this work are: (1) a structural result of independent interest connecting stochastic minimum-norm optimization to the simultaneous optimization of a (\emph{small}) collection of expected $\mathsf{Top}$-$\ell$-norms; and (2) showing how to tackle expected $\mathsf{Top}$-$\ell$-norm minimization by leveraging techniques used to deal with minimizing the expected maximum, circumventing the difficulties posed by the non-separable nature of $\mathsf{Top}$-$\ell$ norms.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2020; v1 submitted 10 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
A Constant-Factor Approximation for Directed Latency in Quasi-Polynomial Time
Authors:
Zachary Friggstad,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We give the first constant-factor approximation for the Directed Latency problem in quasi-polynomial time. Here, the goal is to visit all nodes in an asymmetric metric with a single vehicle starting at a depot $r$ to minimize the average time a node waits to be visited by the vehicle. The approximation guarantee is an improvement over the polynomial-time $O(\log n)$-approximation [Friggstad, Salav…
▽ More
We give the first constant-factor approximation for the Directed Latency problem in quasi-polynomial time. Here, the goal is to visit all nodes in an asymmetric metric with a single vehicle starting at a depot $r$ to minimize the average time a node waits to be visited by the vehicle. The approximation guarantee is an improvement over the polynomial-time $O(\log n)$-approximation [Friggstad, Salavatipour, Svitkina, 2013] and no better quasi-polynomial time approximation algorithm was known.
To obtain this, we must extend a recent result showing the integrality gap of the Asymmetric TSP-Path LP relaxation is bounded by a constant [Köhne, Traub, and Vygen, 2019], which itself builds on the breakthrough result that the integrality gap for standard Asymmetric TSP is also a constant [Svensson, Tarnawsi, and Vegh, 2018]. We show the standard Asymmetric TSP-Path integrality gap is bounded by a constant even if the cut requirements of the LP relaxation are relaxed from $x(δ^{in}(S)) \geq 1$ to $x(δ^{in}(S)) \geq ρ$ for some constant $1/2 < ρ\leq 1$. We also give a better approximation guarantee in the special case of Directed Latency in regret metrics where the goal is to find a path $P$ minimize the average time a node $v$ waits in excess of $c_{rv}$, i.e. $\frac{1}{|V|} \cdot \sum_{v \in V} (c_v(P)-c_{rv})$.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2020; v1 submitted 12 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Simpler and Better Algorithms for Minimum-Norm Load Balancing
Authors:
Deeparnab Chakrabarty,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
Recently, Chakrabarty and Swamy (STOC 2019) introduced the {\em minimum-norm load-balancing} problem on unrelated machines, wherein we are given a set $J$ of jobs that need to be scheduled on a set of $m$ unrelated machines, and a monotone, symmetric norm; We seek an assignment $\sg:J\mapsto[m]$ that minimizes the norm of the resulting load vector $\lvec_\sg\in\R_+^m$, where $\lvec_\sg(i)$ is the…
▽ More
Recently, Chakrabarty and Swamy (STOC 2019) introduced the {\em minimum-norm load-balancing} problem on unrelated machines, wherein we are given a set $J$ of jobs that need to be scheduled on a set of $m$ unrelated machines, and a monotone, symmetric norm; We seek an assignment $\sg:J\mapsto[m]$ that minimizes the norm of the resulting load vector $\lvec_\sg\in\R_+^m$, where $\lvec_\sg(i)$ is the load on machine $i$ under the assignment $\sg$. Besides capturing all $\ell_p$ norms, symmetric norms also capture other norms of interest including top-$\ell$ norms, and ordered norms. Chakrabarty and Swamy (STOC 2019) give a $(38+\ve)$-approximation algorithm for this problem via a general framework they develop for minimum-norm optimization that proceeds by first carefully reducing this problem (in a series of steps) to a problem called \minmax ordered load balancing, and then devising a so-called deterministic oblivious LP-rounding algorithm for ordered load balancing.
We give a direct, and simple $4$-approximation algorithm for the minimum-norm load balancing based on rounding a (near-optimal) solution to a novel convex-programming relaxation for the problem. Whereas the natural convex program encoding minimum-norm load balancing problem has a large non-constant integrality gap, we show that this issue can be remedied by including a key constraint that bounds the "norm of the job-cost vector." Our techniques also yield a (essentially) $4$-approximation for: (a) {\em multi-norm load balancing}, wherein we are given multiple monotone symmetric norms, and we seek an assignment respecting a given budget for each norm; (b) the best {\em simultaneous approximation factor} achievable for all symmetric norms for a given instance.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Approximation Algorithms for Distributionally Robust Stochastic Optimization with Black-Box Distributions
Authors:
Andre Linhares,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
Two-stage stochastic optimization is a framework for modeling uncertainty, where we have a probability distribution over possible realizations of the data, called scenarios, and decisions are taken in two stages: we make first-stage decisions knowing only the underlying distribution and before a scenario is realized, and may take additional second-stage recourse actions after a scenario is realize…
▽ More
Two-stage stochastic optimization is a framework for modeling uncertainty, where we have a probability distribution over possible realizations of the data, called scenarios, and decisions are taken in two stages: we make first-stage decisions knowing only the underlying distribution and before a scenario is realized, and may take additional second-stage recourse actions after a scenario is realized. The goal is typically to minimize the total expected cost. A criticism of this model is that the underlying probability distribution is itself often imprecise! To address this, a versatile approach that has been proposed is the {\em distributionally robust 2-stage model}: given a collection of probability distributions, our goal now is to minimize the maximum expected total cost with respect to a distribution in this collection.
We provide a framework for designing approximation algorithms in such settings when the collection is a ball around a central distribution and the central distribution is accessed {\em only via a sampling black box}.
We first show that one can utilize the {\em sample average approximation} (SAA) method to reduce the problem to the case where the central distribution has {\em polynomial-size} support. We then show how to approximately solve a fractional relaxation of the SAA (i.e., polynomial-scenario central-distribution) problem. By complementing this via LP-rounding algorithms that provide {\em local} (i.e., per-scenario) approximation guarantees, we obtain the {\em first} approximation algorithms for the distributionally robust versions of a variety of discrete-optimization problems including set cover, vertex cover, edge cover, facility location, and Steiner tree, with guarantees that are, except for set cover, within $O(1)$-factors of the guarantees known for the deterministic version of the problem.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2023; v1 submitted 15 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Approximate Multi-Matroid Intersection via Iterative Refinement
Authors:
André Linhares,
Neil Olver,
Chaitanya Swamy,
Rico Zenklusen
Abstract:
We introduce a new iterative rounding technique to round a point in a matroid polytope subject to further matroid constraints. This technique returns an independent set in one matroid with limited violations of the other ones. On top of the classical steps of iterative relaxation approaches, we iteratively refine/split involved matroid constraints to obtain a more restrictive constraint system, th…
▽ More
We introduce a new iterative rounding technique to round a point in a matroid polytope subject to further matroid constraints. This technique returns an independent set in one matroid with limited violations of the other ones. On top of the classical steps of iterative relaxation approaches, we iteratively refine/split involved matroid constraints to obtain a more restrictive constraint system, that is amenable to iterative relaxation techniques. Hence, throughout the iterations, we both tighten constraints and later relax them by dropping constrains under certain conditions. Due to the refinement step, we can deal with considerably more general constraint classes than existing iterative relaxation/rounding methods, which typically round on one matroid polytope with additional simple cardinality constraints that do not overlap too much.
We show how our rounding method, combined with an application of a matroid intersection algorithm, yields the first $2$-approximation for finding a maximum-weight common independent set in $3$ matroids. Moreover, our $2$-approximation is LP-based, and settles the integrality gap for the natural relaxation of the problem. Prior to our work, no better upper bound than $3$ was known for the integrality gap, which followed from the greedy algorithm. We also discuss various other applications of our techniques, including an extension that allows us to handle a mixture of matroid and knapsack constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Approximation Algorithms for Minimum Norm and Ordered Optimization Problems
Authors:
Deeparnab Chakrabarty,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
$ $In many optimization problems, a feasible solution induces a multi-dimensional cost vector. For example, in load-balancing a schedule induces a load vector across the machines. In $k$-clustering, opening $k…
▽ More
$ $In many optimization problems, a feasible solution induces a multi-dimensional cost vector. For example, in load-balancing a schedule induces a load vector across the machines. In $k$-clustering, opening $k$ facilities induces an assignment cost vector across the clients. In this paper we consider the following minimum norm optimization problem : Given an arbitrary monotone, symmetric norm, find a solution which minimizes the norm of the induced cost-vector. This generalizes many fundamental NP-hard problems.
We give a general framework to tackle the minimum norm problem, and illustrate its efficacy in the unrelated machine load balancing and $k$-clustering setting. Our concrete results are the following.
$\bullet$ We give constant factor approximation algorithms for the minimum norm load balancing problem in unrelated machines, and the minimum norm $k$-clustering problem. To our knowledge, our results constitute the first constant-factor approximations for such a general suite of objectives.
$\bullet$ In load balancing with unrelated machines, we give a $2$-approximation for the problem of finding an assignment minimizing the sum of the largest $\ell$ loads, for any $\ell$. We give a $(2+\varepsilon)$-approximation for the so-called ordered load-balancing problem.
$\bullet$ For $k$-clustering, we give a $(5+\varepsilon)$-approximation for the ordered $k$-median problem significantly improving the constant factor approximations from Byrka, Sornat, and Spoerhase (STOC 2018) and Chakrabarty and Swamy (ICALP 2018).
$\bullet$ Our techniques also imply $O(1)$ approximations to the best simultaneous optimization factor for any instance of the unrelated machine load-balancing and the $k$-clustering setting. To our knowledge, these are the first positive simultaneous optimization results in these settings.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Minimizing Latency in Online Ride and Delivery Services
Authors:
Abhimanyu Das,
Sreenivas Gollapudi,
Anthony Kim,
Debmalya Panigrahi,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
Motivated by the popularity of online ride and delivery services, we study natural variants of classical multi-vehicle minimum latency problems where the objective is to route a set of vehicles located at depots to serve request located on a metric space so as to minimize the total latency. In this paper, we consider point-to-point requests that come with source-destination pairs and release-time…
▽ More
Motivated by the popularity of online ride and delivery services, we study natural variants of classical multi-vehicle minimum latency problems where the objective is to route a set of vehicles located at depots to serve request located on a metric space so as to minimize the total latency. In this paper, we consider point-to-point requests that come with source-destination pairs and release-time constraints that restrict when each request can be served. The point-to-point requests and release-time constraints model taxi rides and deliveries. For all the variants considered, we show constant-factor approximation algorithms based on a linear programming framework. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first set of results for the aforementioned variants of the minimum latency problems. Furthermore, we provide an empirical study of heuristics based on our theoretical algorithms on a real data set of taxi rides.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Interpolating between $k$-Median and $k$-Center: Approximation Algorithms for Ordered $k$-Median
Authors:
Deeparnab Chakrabarty,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider a generalization of $k$-median and $k$-center, called the {\em ordered $k$-median} problem. In this problem, we are given a metric space $(\mathcal{D},\{c_{ij}\})$ with $n=|\mathcal{D}|$ points, and a non-increasing weight vector $w\in\mathbb{R}_+^n$, and the goal is to open $k$ centers and assign each point each point $j\in\mathcal{D}$ to a center so as to minimize…
▽ More
We consider a generalization of $k$-median and $k$-center, called the {\em ordered $k$-median} problem. In this problem, we are given a metric space $(\mathcal{D},\{c_{ij}\})$ with $n=|\mathcal{D}|$ points, and a non-increasing weight vector $w\in\mathbb{R}_+^n$, and the goal is to open $k$ centers and assign each point each point $j\in\mathcal{D}$ to a center so as to minimize $w_1\cdot\text{(largest assignment cost)}+w_2\cdot\text{(second-largest assignment cost)}+\ldots+w_n\cdot\text{($n$-th largest assignment cost)}$. We give an $(18+ε)$-approximation algorithm for this problem. Our algorithms utilize Lagrangian relaxation and the primal-dual schema, combined with an enumeration procedure of Aouad and Segev. For the special case of $\{0,1\}$-weights, which models the problem of minimizing the $\ell$ largest assignment costs that is interesting in and of by itself, we provide a novel reduction to the (standard) $k$-median problem showing that LP-relative guarantees for $k$-median translate to guarantees for the ordered $k$-median problem; this yields a nice and clean $(8.5+ε)$-approximation algorithm for $\{0,1\}$ weights.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Min-Max Theorems for Packing and Covering Odd $(u,v)$-trails
Authors:
Sharat Ibrahimpur,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We investigate the problem of packing and covering odd $(u,v)$-trails in a graph. A $(u,v)$-trail is a $(u,v)$-walk that is allowed to have repeated vertices but no repeated edges. We call a trail odd if the number of edges in the trail is odd. Let $ν(u,v)$ denote the maximum number of edge-disjoint odd $(u,v)$-trails, and $τ(u,v)$ denote the minimum size of an edge-set that intersects every odd…
▽ More
We investigate the problem of packing and covering odd $(u,v)$-trails in a graph. A $(u,v)$-trail is a $(u,v)$-walk that is allowed to have repeated vertices but no repeated edges. We call a trail odd if the number of edges in the trail is odd. Let $ν(u,v)$ denote the maximum number of edge-disjoint odd $(u,v)$-trails, and $τ(u,v)$ denote the minimum size of an edge-set that intersects every odd $(u,v)$-trail.
We prove that $τ(u,v)\leq 2ν(u,v)+1$. Our result is tight---there are examples showing that $τ(u,v)=2ν(u,v)+1$---and substantially improves upon the bound of $8$ obtained in [Churchley et al 2016] for $τ(u,v)/ν(u,v)$. Our proof also yields a polynomial-time algorithm for finding a cover and a collection of trails satisfying the above bounds.
Our proof is simple and has two main ingredients. We show that (loosely speaking) the problem can be reduced to the problem of packing and covering odd $(uv,uv)$-trails losing a factor of 2 (either in the number of trails found, or the size of the cover). Complementing this, we show that the odd-$(uv,uv)$-trail packing and covering problems can be tackled by exploiting a powerful min-max result of [Chudnovsky et al 2006] for packing vertex-disjoint nonzero $A$-paths in group-labeled graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Compact, Provably-Good LPs for Orienteering and Regret-Bounded Vehicle Routing
Authors:
Zachary Friggstad,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We develop polynomial-size LP-relaxations for {\em orienteering} and the {\em regret-bounded vehicle routing problem} (\rvrp) and devise suitable LP-rounding algorithms that lead to various new insights and approximation results for these problems. In orienteering, the goal is to find a maximum-reward $r$-rooted path, possibly ending at a specified node, of length at most some given budget $B$. In…
▽ More
We develop polynomial-size LP-relaxations for {\em orienteering} and the {\em regret-bounded vehicle routing problem} (\rvrp) and devise suitable LP-rounding algorithms that lead to various new insights and approximation results for these problems. In orienteering, the goal is to find a maximum-reward $r$-rooted path, possibly ending at a specified node, of length at most some given budget $B$. In \rvrp, the goal is to find the minimum number of $r$-rooted paths of {\em regret} at most a given bound $R$ that cover all nodes, where the regret of an $r$-$v$ path is its length $-$ $c_{rv}$.
For {\em rooted orienteering}, we introduce a natural bidirected LP-relaxation and obtain a simple $3$-approximation algorithm via LP-rounding. This is the {\em first LP-based} guarantee for this problem. We also show that {\em point-to-point} (\ptp) {\em orienteering} can be reduced to a regret-version of rooted orienteering at the expense of a factor-2 loss in approximation. For \rvrp, we propose two compact LPs that lead to significant improvements, in both approximation ratio and running time, over the approach in~\cite{FriggstadS14}. One of these is a natural modification of the LP for rooted orienteering; the other is an unconventional formulation that is motivated by certain structural properties of an \rvrp-solution, which leads to a $15$-approximation algorithm for \rvrp.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
On the Integrality Gap of the Prize-Collecting Steiner Forest LP
Authors:
Jochen Könemann,
Neil Olver,
Kanstantsin Pashkovich,
R. Ravi,
Chaitanya Swamy,
Jens Vygen
Abstract:
In the prize-collecting Steiner forest (PCSF) problem, we are given an undirected graph $G=(V,E)$, edge costs $\{c_e\geq 0\}_{e\in E}$, terminal pairs $\{(s_i,t_i)\}_{i=1}^k$, and penalties $\{π_i\}_{i=1}^k$ for each terminal pair; the goal is to find a forest $F$ to minimize $c(F)+\sum_{i: (s_i,t_i)\text{ not connected in }F}π_i$. The Steiner forest problem can be viewed as the special case where…
▽ More
In the prize-collecting Steiner forest (PCSF) problem, we are given an undirected graph $G=(V,E)$, edge costs $\{c_e\geq 0\}_{e\in E}$, terminal pairs $\{(s_i,t_i)\}_{i=1}^k$, and penalties $\{π_i\}_{i=1}^k$ for each terminal pair; the goal is to find a forest $F$ to minimize $c(F)+\sum_{i: (s_i,t_i)\text{ not connected in }F}π_i$. The Steiner forest problem can be viewed as the special case where $π_i=\infty$ for all $i$. It was widely believed that the integrality gap of the natural (and well-studied) linear-programming (LP) relaxation for PCSF is at most 2. We dispel this belief by showing that the integrality gap of this LP is at least $9/4$. This holds even for planar graphs. We also show that using this LP, one cannot devise a Lagrangian-multiplier-preserving (LMP) algorithm with approximation guarantee better than $4$. Our results thus show a separation between the integrality gaps of the LP-relaxations for prize-collecting and non-prize-collecting (i.e., standard) Steiner forest, as well as the approximation ratios achievable relative to the optimal LP solution by LMP- and non-LMP- approximation algorithms for PCSF. For the special case of prize-collecting Steiner tree (PCST), we prove that the natural LP relaxation admits basic feasible solutions with all coordinates of value at most $1/3$ and all edge variables positive. Thus, we rule out the possibility of approximating PCST with guarantee better than $3$ using a direct iterative rounding method.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Improved Algorithms for MST and Metric-TSP Interdiction
Authors:
André Linhares,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider the {\em MST-interdiction} problem: given a multigraph $G = (V, E)$, edge weights $\{w_e\geq 0\}_{e \in E}$, interdiction costs $\{c_e\geq 0\}_{e \in E}$, and an interdiction budget $B\geq 0$, the goal is to remove a set $R\subseteq E$ of edges of total interdiction cost at most $B$ so as to maximize the $w$-weight of an MST of $G-R:=(V,E\setminus R)$.
Our main result is a $4$-approx…
▽ More
We consider the {\em MST-interdiction} problem: given a multigraph $G = (V, E)$, edge weights $\{w_e\geq 0\}_{e \in E}$, interdiction costs $\{c_e\geq 0\}_{e \in E}$, and an interdiction budget $B\geq 0$, the goal is to remove a set $R\subseteq E$ of edges of total interdiction cost at most $B$ so as to maximize the $w$-weight of an MST of $G-R:=(V,E\setminus R)$.
Our main result is a $4$-approximation algorithm for this problem. This improves upon the previous-best $14$-approximation~\cite{Zenklusen15}. Notably, our analysis is also significantly simpler and cleaner than the one in~\cite{Zenklusen15}. Whereas~\cite{Zenklusen15} uses a greedy algorithm with an involved analysis to extract a good interdiction set from an over-budget set, we utilize a generalization of knapsack called the {\em tree knapsack problem} that nicely captures the key combinatorial aspects of this "extraction problem." We prove a simple, yet strong, LP-relative approximation bound for tree knapsack, which leads to our improved guarantees for MST interdiction. Our algorithm and analysis are nearly tight, as we show that one cannot achieve an approximation ratio better than 3 relative to the upper bound used in our analysis (and the one in~\cite{Zenklusen15}).
Our guarantee for MST-interdiction yields an $8$-approximation for {\em metric-TSP interdiction} (improving over the $28$-approximation in~\cite{Zenklusen15}). We also show that the {\em maximum-spanning-tree interdiction} problem is at least as hard to approximate as the minimization version of densest-$k$-subgraph.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Approximation Algorithms for Clustering Problems with Lower Bounds and Outliers
Authors:
Sara Ahmadian,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider clustering problems with {\em non-uniform lower bounds and outliers}, and obtain the {\em first approximation guarantees} for these problems. We have a set $\F$ of facilities with lower bounds $\{L_i\}_{i\in\F}$ and a set $\D$ of clients located in a common metric space $\{c(i,j)\}_{i,j\in\F\cup\D}$, and bounds $k$, $m$. A feasible solution is a pair…
▽ More
We consider clustering problems with {\em non-uniform lower bounds and outliers}, and obtain the {\em first approximation guarantees} for these problems. We have a set $\F$ of facilities with lower bounds $\{L_i\}_{i\in\F}$ and a set $\D$ of clients located in a common metric space $\{c(i,j)\}_{i,j\in\F\cup\D}$, and bounds $k$, $m$. A feasible solution is a pair $\bigl(S\sse\F,σ:\D\mapsto S\cup\{\mathsf{out}\}\bigr)$, where $σ$ specifies the client assignments, such that $|S|\leq k$, $|σ^{-1}(i)|\geq L_i$ for all $i\in S$, and $|σ^{-1}(\mathsf{out})|\leq m$. In the {\em lower-bounded min-sum-of-radii with outliers} (\lbksro) problem, the objective is to minimize $\sum_{i\in S}\max_{j\inσ^{-1}(i)}c(i,j)$, and in the {\em lower-bounded $k$-supplier with outliers} (\lbkso) problem, the objective is to minimize $\max_{i\in S}\max_{j\inσ^{-1}(i)}c(i,j)$.
We obtain an approximation factor of $12.365$ for \lbksro, which improves to $3.83$ for the non-outlier version (i.e., $m=0$). These also constitute the {\em first} approximation bounds for the min-sum-of-radii objective when we consider lower bounds and outliers {\em separately}. We apply the primal-dual method to the relaxation where we Lagrangify the $|S|\leq k$ constraint. The chief technical contribution and novelty of our algorithm is that, departing from the standard paradigm used for such constrained problems, we obtain an $O(1)$-approximation {\em despite the fact that we do not obtain a Lagrangian-multiplier-preserving algorithm for the Lagrangian relaxation}. We believe that our ideas have {broader applicability to other clustering problems with outliers as well.}
We obtain approximation factors of $5$ and $3$ respectively for \lbkso and its non-outlier version. These are the {\em first} approximation results for $k$-supplier with {\em non-uniform} lower bounds.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2016; v1 submitted 4 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Approximating Min-Cost Chain-Constrained Spanning Trees: A Reduction from Weighted to Unweighted Problems
Authors:
Andre Linhares,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We study the {\em min-cost chain-constrained spanning-tree} (abbreviated \mcst) problem: find a min-cost spanning tree in a graph subject to degree constraints on a nested family of node sets. We devise the {\em first} polytime algorithm that finds a spanning tree that (i) violates the degree constraints by at most a constant factor {\em and} (ii) whose cost is within a constant factor of the opti…
▽ More
We study the {\em min-cost chain-constrained spanning-tree} (abbreviated \mcst) problem: find a min-cost spanning tree in a graph subject to degree constraints on a nested family of node sets. We devise the {\em first} polytime algorithm that finds a spanning tree that (i) violates the degree constraints by at most a constant factor {\em and} (ii) whose cost is within a constant factor of the optimum. Previously, only an algorithm for {\em unweighted} \cst was known \cite{olver}, which satisfied (i) but did not yield any cost bounds. This also yields the first result that obtains an $O(1)$-factor for {\em both} the cost approximation and violation of degree constraints for any spanning-tree problem with general degree bounds on node sets, where an edge participates in a super-constant number of degree constraints.
A notable feature of our algorithm is that we {\em reduce} \mcst to unweighted \cst (and then utilize \cite{olver}) via a novel application of {\em Lagrangian duality} to simplify the {\em cost structure} of the underlying problem and obtain a decomposition into certain uniform-cost subproblems.
We show that this Lagrangian-relaxation based idea is in fact applicable more generally and, for any cost-minimization problem with packing side-constraints, yields a reduction from the weighted to the unweighted problem. We believe that this reduction is of independent interest. As another application of our technique, we consider the {\em $k$-budgeted matroid basis} problem, where we build upon a recent rounding algorithm of \cite{BansalN16} to obtain an improved $n^{O(k^{1.5}/ε)}$-time algorithm that returns a solution that satisfies (any) one of the budget constraints exactly and incurs a $(1+ε)$-violation of the other budget constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Hardness Results for Signaling in Bayesian Zero-Sum and Network Routing Games
Authors:
Umang Bhaskar,
Yu Cheng,
Young Kun Ko,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We study the optimization problem faced by a perfectly informed principal in a Bayesian game, who reveals information to the players about the state of nature to obtain a desirable equilibrium. This signaling problem is the natural design question motivated by uncertainty in games and has attracted much recent attention. We present new hardness results for signaling problems in (a) Bayesian two-pl…
▽ More
We study the optimization problem faced by a perfectly informed principal in a Bayesian game, who reveals information to the players about the state of nature to obtain a desirable equilibrium. This signaling problem is the natural design question motivated by uncertainty in games and has attracted much recent attention. We present new hardness results for signaling problems in (a) Bayesian two-player zero-sum games, and (b) Bayesian network routing games.
For Bayesian zero-sum games, when the principal seeks to maximize the equilibrium utility of a player, we show that it is NP-hard to obtain an additive FPTAS. Our hardness proof exploits duality and the equivalence of separation and optimization in a novel way. Further, we rule out an additive PTAS assuming planted clique hardness, which states that no polynomial time algorithm can recover a planted clique from an Erdős-Rényi random graph. Complementing these, we obtain a PTAS for a structured class of zero-sum games (where obtaining an FPTAS is still NP-hard) when the payoff matrices obey a Lipschitz condition. Previous results ruled out an FPTAS assuming planted-clique hardness, and a PTAS only for implicit games with quasi-polynomial-size strategy sets.
For Bayesian network routing games, wherein the principal seeks to minimize the average latency of the Nash flow, we show that it is NP-hard to obtain a (multiplicative) $(4/3 - ε)$-approximation, even for linear latency functions. This is the optimal inapproximability result for linear latencies, since we show that full revelation achieves a $(4/3)$-approximation for linear latencies.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2016; v1 submitted 11 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Computing Optimal Tolls in Routing Games without Knowing the Latency Functions
Authors:
Siddharth Barman,
Umang Bhaskar,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider the following question: in a nonatomic routing game, can the tolls that induce the minimum latency flow be computed without knowing the latency functions? Since the latency functions are unknown, we assume we are given an oracle that has access to the underlying routing game. A query to the oracle consists of tolls on edges, and the response is the resulting equilibrium flow. We show t…
▽ More
We consider the following question: in a nonatomic routing game, can the tolls that induce the minimum latency flow be computed without knowing the latency functions? Since the latency functions are unknown, we assume we are given an oracle that has access to the underlying routing game. A query to the oracle consists of tolls on edges, and the response is the resulting equilibrium flow. We show that in this model, it is impossible to obtain optimal tolls. However, if we augment the oracle so that it returns the total latency of the equilibrium flow induced by the tolls in addition to the flow itself, then the required tolls can be computed with a polynomial number of queries.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Learning Arbitrary Statistical Mixtures of Discrete Distributions
Authors:
Jian Li,
Yuval Rabani,
Leonard J. Schulman,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We study the problem of learning from unlabeled samples very general statistical mixture models on large finite sets. Specifically, the model to be learned, $\vartheta$, is a probability distribution over probability distributions $p$, where each such $p$ is a probability distribution over $[n] = \{1,2,\dots,n\}$. When we sample from $\vartheta$, we do not observe $p$ directly, but only indirectly…
▽ More
We study the problem of learning from unlabeled samples very general statistical mixture models on large finite sets. Specifically, the model to be learned, $\vartheta$, is a probability distribution over probability distributions $p$, where each such $p$ is a probability distribution over $[n] = \{1,2,\dots,n\}$. When we sample from $\vartheta$, we do not observe $p$ directly, but only indirectly and in very noisy fashion, by sampling from $[n]$ repeatedly, independently $K$ times from the distribution $p$. The problem is to infer $\vartheta$ to high accuracy in transportation (earthmover) distance.
We give the first efficient algorithms for learning this mixture model without making any restricting assumptions on the structure of the distribution $\vartheta$. We bound the quality of the solution as a function of the size of the samples $K$ and the number of samples used. Our model and results have applications to a variety of unsupervised learning scenarios, including learning topic models and collaborative filtering.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Linear-Programming based Approximation Algorithms for Multi-Vehicle Minimum Latency Problems
Authors:
Ian Post,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider various {\em multi-vehicle versions of the minimum latency problem}. There is a fleet of $k$ vehicles located at one or more depot nodes, and we seek a collection of routes for these vehicles that visit all nodes so as to minimize the total latency incurred, which is the sum of the client waiting times. We obtain an $8.497$-approximation for the version where vehicles may be located at…
▽ More
We consider various {\em multi-vehicle versions of the minimum latency problem}. There is a fleet of $k$ vehicles located at one or more depot nodes, and we seek a collection of routes for these vehicles that visit all nodes so as to minimize the total latency incurred, which is the sum of the client waiting times. We obtain an $8.497$-approximation for the version where vehicles may be located at multiple depots and a $7.183$-approximation for the version where all vehicles are located at the same depot, both of which are the first improvements on this problem in a decade. Perhaps more significantly, our algorithms exploit various LP-relaxations for minimum-latency problems. We show how to effectively leverage two classes of LPs---{\em configuration LPs} and {\em bidirected LP-relaxations}---that are often believed to be quite powerful but have only sporadically been effectively leveraged for network-design and vehicle-routing problems. This gives the first concrete evidence of the effectiveness of LP-relaxations for this class of problems. The $8.497$-approximation the multiple-depot version is obtained by rounding a near-optimal solution to an underlying configuration LP for the problem. The $7.183$-approximation can be obtained both via rounding a bidirected LP for the single-depot problem or via more combinatorial means. The latter approach uses a bidirected LP to obtain the following key result that is of independent interest: for any $k$, we can efficiently compute a rooted tree that is at least as good, with respect to the prize-collecting objective (i.e., edge cost + number of uncovered nodes) as the best collection of $k$ rooted paths. Our algorithms are versatile and extend easily to handle various extensions involving: (i) weighted sum of latencies, (ii) constraints specifying which depots may serve which nodes, (iii) node service times.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Improved Region-Growing and Combinatorial Algorithms for $k$-Route Cut Problems
Authors:
Guru Guruganesh,
Laura Sanita,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We study the {\em $k$-route} generalizations of various cut problems, the most general of which is \emph{$k$-route multicut} ($k$-MC) problem, wherein we have $r$ source-sink pairs and the goal is to delete a minimum-cost set of edges to reduce the edge-connectivity of every source-sink pair to below $k$. The $k$-route extensions of multiway cut ($k$-MWC), and the minimum $s$-$t$ cut problem ($k$-…
▽ More
We study the {\em $k$-route} generalizations of various cut problems, the most general of which is \emph{$k$-route multicut} ($k$-MC) problem, wherein we have $r$ source-sink pairs and the goal is to delete a minimum-cost set of edges to reduce the edge-connectivity of every source-sink pair to below $k$. The $k$-route extensions of multiway cut ($k$-MWC), and the minimum $s$-$t$ cut problem ($k$-$(s,t)$-cut), are similarly defined. We present various approximation and hardness results for these $k$-route cut problems that improve the state-of-the-art for these problems in several cases. (i) For {\em $k$-route multiway cut}, we devise simple, but surprisingly effective, combinatorial algorithms that yield bicriteria approximation guarantees that markedly improve upon the previous-best guarantees. (ii) For {\em $k$-route multicut}, we design algorithms that improve upon the previous-best approximation factors by roughly an $O(\sqrt{\log r})$-factor, when $k=2$, and for general $k$ and unit costs and any fixed violation of the connectivity threshold $k$. The main technical innovation is the definition of a new, powerful \emph{region growing} lemma that allows us to perform region-growing in a recursive fashion even though the LP solution yields a {\em different metric} for each source-sink pair. (iii) We complement these results by showing that the {\em $k$-route $s$-$t$ cut} problem is at least as hard to approximate as the {\em densest-$k$-subgraph} (DkS) problem on uniform hypergraphs.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Achieving Target Equilibria in Network Routing Games without Knowing the Latency Functions
Authors:
Umang Bhaskar,
Katrina Ligett,
Leonard J. Schulman,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
The analysis of network routing games typically assumes, right at the onset, precise and detailed information about the latency functions. Such information may, however, be unavailable or difficult to obtain. Moreover, one is often primarily interested in enforcing a desired target flow as the equilibrium by suitably influencing player behavior in the routing game. We ask whether one can achieve t…
▽ More
The analysis of network routing games typically assumes, right at the onset, precise and detailed information about the latency functions. Such information may, however, be unavailable or difficult to obtain. Moreover, one is often primarily interested in enforcing a desired target flow as the equilibrium by suitably influencing player behavior in the routing game. We ask whether one can achieve target flows as equilibria without knowing the underlying latency functions.
Our main result gives a crisp positive answer to this question. We show that, under fairly general settings, one can efficiently compute edge tolls that induce a given target multicommodity flow in a nonatomic routing game using a polynomial number of queries to an oracle that takes candidate tolls as input and returns the resulting equilibrium flow. This result is obtained via a novel application of the ellipsoid method. Our algorithm extends easily to many other settings, such as (i) when certain edges cannot be tolled or there is an upper bound on the total toll paid by a user, and (ii) general nonatomic congestion games. We obtain tighter bounds on the query complexity for series-parallel networks, and single-commodity routing games with linear latency functions, and complement these with a query-complexity lower bound. We also obtain strong positive results for Stackelberg routing to achieve target equilibria in series-parallel graphs.
Our results build upon various new techniques that we develop pertaining to the computation of, and connections between, different notions of approximate equilibrium; properties of multicommodity flows and tolls in series-parallel graphs; and sensitivity of equilibrium flow with respect to tolls. Our results demonstrate that one can indeed circumvent the potentially-onerous task of modeling latency functions, and yet obtain meaningful results for the underlying routing game.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Welfare Maximization and Truthfulness in Mechanism Design with Ordinal Preferences
Authors:
Deeparnab Chakrabarty,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We study mechanism design problems in the {\em ordinal setting} wherein the preferences of agents are described by orderings over outcomes, as opposed to specific numerical values associated with them. This setting is relevant when agents can compare outcomes, but aren't able to evaluate precise utilities for them. Such a situation arises in diverse contexts including voting and matching markets.…
▽ More
We study mechanism design problems in the {\em ordinal setting} wherein the preferences of agents are described by orderings over outcomes, as opposed to specific numerical values associated with them. This setting is relevant when agents can compare outcomes, but aren't able to evaluate precise utilities for them. Such a situation arises in diverse contexts including voting and matching markets.
Our paper addresses two issues that arise in ordinal mechanism design. To design social welfare maximizing mechanisms, one needs to be able to quantitatively measure the welfare of an outcome which is not clear in the ordinal setting. Second, since the impossibility results of Gibbard and Satterthwaite~\cite{Gibbard73,Satterthwaite75} force one to move to randomized mechanisms, one needs a more nuanced notion of truthfulness.
We propose {\em rank approximation} as a metric for measuring the quality of an outcome, which allows us to evaluate mechanisms based on worst-case performance, and {\em lex-truthfulness} as a notion of truthfulness for randomized ordinal mechanisms. Lex-truthfulness is stronger than notions studied in the literature, and yet flexible enough to admit a rich class of mechanisms {\em circumventing classical impossibility results}. We demonstrate the usefulness of the above notions by devising lex-truthful mechanisms achieving good rank-approximation factors, both in the general ordinal setting, as well as structured settings such as {\em (one-sided) matching markets}, and its generalizations, {\em matroid} and {\em scheduling} markets.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2014; v1 submitted 6 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Approximation Algorithms for Non-Single-minded Profit-Maximization Problems with Limited Supply
Authors:
Khaled Elbassioni,
Mahmoud Fouz,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider {\em profit-maximization} problems for {\em combinatorial auctions} with {\em non-single minded valuation functions} and {\em limited supply}.
We obtain fairly general results that relate the approximability of the profit-maximization problem to that of the corresponding {\em social-welfare-maximization} (SWM) problem, which is the problem of finding an allocation $(S_1,\ldots,S_n)$…
▽ More
We consider {\em profit-maximization} problems for {\em combinatorial auctions} with {\em non-single minded valuation functions} and {\em limited supply}.
We obtain fairly general results that relate the approximability of the profit-maximization problem to that of the corresponding {\em social-welfare-maximization} (SWM) problem, which is the problem of finding an allocation $(S_1,\ldots,S_n)$ satisfying the capacity constraints that has maximum total value $\sum_j v_j(S_j)$. For {\em subadditive valuations} (and hence {\em submodular, XOS valuations}), we obtain a solution with profit $\OPT_\swm/O(\log c_{\max})$, where $\OPT_\swm$ is the optimum social welfare and $c_{\max}$ is the maximum item-supply; thus, this yields an $O(\log c_{\max})$-approximation for the profit-maximization problem. Furthermore, given {\em any} class of valuation functions, if the SWM problem for this valuation class has an LP-relaxation (of a certain form) and an algorithm "verifying" an {\em integrality gap} of $\al$ for this LP, then we obtain a solution with profit $\OPT_\swm/O(\al\log c_{\max})$, thus obtaining an $O(\al\log c_{\max})$-approximation.
For the special case, when the tree is a path, we also obtain an incomparable $O(\log m)$-approximation (via a different approach) for subadditive valuations, and arbitrary valuations with unlimited supply. Our approach for the latter problem also gives an $\frac{e}{e-1}$-approximation algorithm for the multi-product pricing problem in the Max-Buy model, with limited supply, improving on the previously known approximation factor of 2.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Near-Optimal and Robust Mechanism Design for Covering Problems with Correlated Players
Authors:
Hadi Minooei,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider the problem of designing incentive-compatible, ex-post individually rational (IR) mechanisms for covering problems in the Bayesian setting, where players' types are drawn from an underlying distribution and may be correlated, and the goal is to minimize the expected total payment made by the mechanism. We formulate a notion of incentive compatibility (IC) that we call {\em support-base…
▽ More
We consider the problem of designing incentive-compatible, ex-post individually rational (IR) mechanisms for covering problems in the Bayesian setting, where players' types are drawn from an underlying distribution and may be correlated, and the goal is to minimize the expected total payment made by the mechanism. We formulate a notion of incentive compatibility (IC) that we call {\em support-based IC} that is substantially more robust than Bayesian IC, and develop black-box reductions from support-based-IC mechanism design to algorithm design. For single-dimensional settings, this black-box reduction applies even when we only have an LP-relative {\em approximation algorithm} for the algorithmic problem. Thus, we obtain near-optimal mechanisms for various covering settings including single-dimensional covering problems, multi-item procurement auctions, and multidimensional facility location.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2016; v1 submitted 27 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Approximation Algorithms for Regret-Bounded Vehicle Routing and Applications to Distance-Constrained Vehicle Routing
Authors:
Zachary Friggstad,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider vehicle-routing problems (VRPs) that incorporate the notion of {\em regret} of a client, which is a measure of the waiting time of a client relative to its shortest-path distance from the depot. Formally, we consider both the additive and multiplicative versions of, what we call, the {\em regret-bounded vehicle routing problem} (RVRP). In these problems, we are given an undirected comp…
▽ More
We consider vehicle-routing problems (VRPs) that incorporate the notion of {\em regret} of a client, which is a measure of the waiting time of a client relative to its shortest-path distance from the depot. Formally, we consider both the additive and multiplicative versions of, what we call, the {\em regret-bounded vehicle routing problem} (RVRP). In these problems, we are given an undirected complete graph $G=(\{r\}\cup V,E)$ on $n$ nodes with a distinguished root (depot) node $r$, edge costs $\{c_{uv}\}$ that form a metric, and a regret bound $R$. Given a path $P$ rooted at $r$ and a node $v\in P$, let $c_P(v)$ be the distance from $r$ to $v$ along $P$. The goal is to find the fewest number of paths rooted at $r$ that cover all the nodes so that for every node $v$ covered by (say) path $P$: (i) its additive regret $c_P(v)-c_{rv}$, with respect to $P$ is at most $R$ in {\em additive-RVRP}; or (ii) its multiplicative regret, $c_P(c)/c_{rv}$, with respect to $P$ is at most $R$ in {\em multiplicative-RVRP}.
Our main result is the {\em first} constant-factor approximation algorithm for additive-RVRP by devising rounding techniques for a natural {\em configuration-style LP}. This is a substantial improvement over the previous-best $O(\log n)$-approximation. Additive-RVRP turns out be a rather central vehicle-routing problem, whose study reveals insights into a variety of other regret-related problems as well as the classical {\em distance-constrained VRP} ({DVRP}). We obtain approximation ratios of $O\bigl(\log(\frac{R}{R-1})\bigr)$ for multiplicative-RVRP, and $O\bigl(\min\bigl\{\mathit{OPT},\frac{\log D}{\log\log D}\bigr\}\bigr)$ for DVRP with distance bound $D$ via reductions to additive-RVRP; the latter improves upon the previous-best approximation for DVRP.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Improved Approximation Algorithms for Matroid and Knapsack Median Problems and Applications
Authors:
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider the {\em matroid median} problem \cite{KrishnaswamyKNSS11}, wherein we are given a set of facilities with opening costs and a matroid on the facility-set, and clients with demands and connection costs, and we seek to open an independent set of facilities and assign clients to open facilities so as to minimize the sum of the facility-opening and client-connection costs. We give a simple…
▽ More
We consider the {\em matroid median} problem \cite{KrishnaswamyKNSS11}, wherein we are given a set of facilities with opening costs and a matroid on the facility-set, and clients with demands and connection costs, and we seek to open an independent set of facilities and assign clients to open facilities so as to minimize the sum of the facility-opening and client-connection costs. We give a simple 8-approximation algorithm for this problem based on LP-rounding, which improves upon the 16-approximation in \cite{KrishnaswamyKNSS11}. Our techniques illustrate that much of the work involved in the rounding algorithm of in \cite{KrishnaswamyKNSS11} can be avoided by first converting the LP solution to a half-integral solution, which can then be rounded to an integer solution using a simple uncapacitated-facility-location (UFL) style clustering step. We illustrate the power of these ideas by deriving: (a) a 24-approximation algorithm for matroid median with penalties, which is a vast improvement over the 360-approximation obtained in \cite{KrishnaswamyKNSS11}; and (b) an 8-approximation for the {\em two-matroid median} problem, a generalization of matroid median that we introduce involving two matroids. We show that a variety of seemingly disparate facility-location problems considered in the literature---data placement problem, mobile facility location, $k$-median forest, metric uniform minimum-latency UFL---in fact reduce to the matroid median or two-matroid median problems, and thus obtain improved approximation guarantees for all these problems. Our techniques also yield an improvement for the knapsack median problem.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2016; v1 submitted 29 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Local-Search based Approximation Algorithms for Mobile Facility Location Problems
Authors:
Sara Ahmadian,
Zachary Friggstad,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider the {\em mobile facility location} (\mfl) problem. We are given a set of facilities and clients located in a common metric space. The goal is to move each facility from its initial location to a destination and assign each client to the destination of some facility so as to minimize the sum of the movement-costs of the facilities and the client-assignment costs. This abstracts facility…
▽ More
We consider the {\em mobile facility location} (\mfl) problem. We are given a set of facilities and clients located in a common metric space. The goal is to move each facility from its initial location to a destination and assign each client to the destination of some facility so as to minimize the sum of the movement-costs of the facilities and the client-assignment costs. This abstracts facility-location settings where one has the flexibility of moving facilities from their current locations to other destinations so as to serve clients more efficiently by reducing their assignment costs.
We give the first {\em local-search based} approximation algorithm for this problem and achieve the best-known approximation guarantee. Our main result is $(3+ε)$-approximation for this problem for any constant $ε>0$ using local search. The previous best guarantee was an 8-approximation algorithm based on LP-rounding. Our guarantee {\em matches} the best-known approximation guarantee for the $k$-median problem. Since there is an approximation-preserving reduction from the $k$-median problem to \mfl, any improvement of our result would imply an analogous improvement for the $k$-median problem. Furthermore, {\em our analysis is tight} (up to $o(1)$ factors) since the tight example for the local-search based 3-approximation algorithm for $k$-median can be easily adapted to show that our local-search algorithm has a tight approximation ratio of 3. One of the chief novelties of the analysis is that in order to generate a suitable collection of local-search moves whose resulting inequalities yield the desired bound on the cost of a local-optimum, we define a tree-like structure that (loosely speaking) functions as a "recursion tree", using which we spawn off local-search moves by exploring this tree to a constant depth.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Learning Mixtures of Arbitrary Distributions over Large Discrete Domains
Authors:
Yuval Rabani,
Leonard Schulman,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We give an algorithm for learning a mixture of {\em unstructured} distributions. This problem arises in various unsupervised learning scenarios, for example in learning {\em topic models} from a corpus of documents spanning several topics. We show how to learn the constituents of a mixture of $k$ arbitrary distributions over a large discrete domain $[n]=\{1,2,\dots,n\}$ and the mixture weights, us…
▽ More
We give an algorithm for learning a mixture of {\em unstructured} distributions. This problem arises in various unsupervised learning scenarios, for example in learning {\em topic models} from a corpus of documents spanning several topics. We show how to learn the constituents of a mixture of $k$ arbitrary distributions over a large discrete domain $[n]=\{1,2,\dots,n\}$ and the mixture weights, using $O(n\polylog n)$ samples. (In the topic-model learning setting, the mixture constituents correspond to the topic distributions.) This task is information-theoretically impossible for $k>1$ under the usual sampling process from a mixture distribution. However, there are situations (such as the above-mentioned topic model case) in which each sample point consists of several observations from the same mixture constituent. This number of observations, which we call the {\em "sampling aperture"}, is a crucial parameter of the problem. We obtain the {\em first} bounds for this mixture-learning problem {\em without imposing any assumptions on the mixture constituents.} We show that efficient learning is possible exactly at the information-theoretically least-possible aperture of $2k-1$. Thus, we achieve near-optimal dependence on $n$ and optimal aperture. While the sample-size required by our algorithm depends exponentially on $k$, we prove that such a dependence is {\em unavoidable} when one considers general mixtures. A sequence of tools contribute to the algorithm, such as concentration results for random matrices, dimension reduction, moment estimations, and sensitivity analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2013; v1 submitted 6 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Truthful Mechanism Design for Multidimensional Covering Problems
Authors:
Hadi Minooei,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We investigate {\em multidimensional covering mechanism-design} problems, wherein there are $m$ items that need to be covered and $n$ agents who provide covering objects, with each agent $i$ having a private cost for the covering objects he provides. The goal is to select a set of covering objects of minimum total cost that together cover all the items.
We focus on two representative covering pr…
▽ More
We investigate {\em multidimensional covering mechanism-design} problems, wherein there are $m$ items that need to be covered and $n$ agents who provide covering objects, with each agent $i$ having a private cost for the covering objects he provides. The goal is to select a set of covering objects of minimum total cost that together cover all the items.
We focus on two representative covering problems: uncapacitated facility location (\ufl) and vertex cover (\vcp). For multidimensional \ufl, we give a black-box method to transform any {\em Lagrangian-multiplier-preserving} $ρ$-approximation algorithm for \ufl to a truthful-in-expectation, $ρ$-approx. mechanism. This yields the first result for multidimensional \ufl, namely a truthful-in-expectation 2-approximation mechanism.
For multidimensional \vcp (\mvcp), we develop a {\em decomposition method} that reduces the mechanism-design problem into the simpler task of constructing {\em threshold mechanisms}, which are a restricted class of truthful mechanisms, for simpler (in terms of graph structure or problem dimension) instances of \mvcp. By suitably designing the decomposition and the threshold mechanisms it uses as building blocks, we obtain truthful mechanisms with the following approximation ratios ($n$ is the number of nodes): (1) $O(r^2\log n)$ for $r$-dimensional \vcp; and (2) $O(r\log n)$ for $r$-dimensional \vcp on any proper minor-closed family of graphs (which improves to $O(\log n)$ if no two neighbors of a node belong to the same player). These are the first truthful mechanisms for \mvcp with non-trivial approximation guarantees.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2013; v1 submitted 13 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Improved Approximation Guarantees for Lower-Bounded Facility Location
Authors:
Sara Ahmadian,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider the {\em lower-bounded facility location} (\lbfl) problem (also sometimes called {\em load-balanced facility location}), which is a generalization of {\em uncapacitated facility location} (\ufl), where each open facility is required to serve a certain {\em minimum} amount of demand. More formally, an instance $\I$ of \lbfl is specified by a set $\F$ of facilities with facility-opening…
▽ More
We consider the {\em lower-bounded facility location} (\lbfl) problem (also sometimes called {\em load-balanced facility location}), which is a generalization of {\em uncapacitated facility location} (\ufl), where each open facility is required to serve a certain {\em minimum} amount of demand. More formally, an instance $\I$ of \lbfl is specified by a set $\F$ of facilities with facility-opening costs $\{f_i\}$, a set $\D$ of clients, and connection costs $\{c_{ij}\}$ specifying the cost of assigning a client $j$ to a facility $i$, where the $c_{ij}$s form a metric. A feasible solution specifies a subset $F$ of facilities to open, and assigns each client $j$ to an open facility $i(j)\in F$ so that each open facility serves {\em at least $M$ clients}, where $M$ is an input parameter. The cost of such a solution is $\sum_{i\in F}f_i+\sum_j c_{i(j)j}$, and the goal is to find a feasible solution of minimum cost. The current best approximation ratio for \lbfl is 448 \cite{Svitkina08}. We substantially advance the state-of-the-art for \lbfl by devising an approximation algorithm for \lbfl that achieves a significantly-improved approximation guarantee of 82.6. Our improvement comes from a variety of ideas in algorithm design and analysis, which also yield new insights into \lbfl.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2012; v1 submitted 15 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Facility Location with Client Latencies: Linear-Programming based Techniques for Minimum-Latency Problems
Authors:
Deeparnab Chakrabarty,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We introduce a problem that is a common generalization of the uncapacitated facility location and minimum latency (ML) problems, where facilities need to be opened to serve clients and also need to be sequentially activated before they can provide service. Formally, we are given a set \F of n facilities with facility-opening costs {f_i}, a set of m clients, and connection costs {c_{ij}} specifying…
▽ More
We introduce a problem that is a common generalization of the uncapacitated facility location and minimum latency (ML) problems, where facilities need to be opened to serve clients and also need to be sequentially activated before they can provide service. Formally, we are given a set \F of n facilities with facility-opening costs {f_i}, a set of m clients, and connection costs {c_{ij}} specifying the cost of assigning a client j to a facility i, a root node r denoting the depot, and a time metric d on \F\cup{r}. Our goal is to open a subset F of facilities, find a path P starting at r and spanning F to activate the open facilities, and connect each client j to a facility φ(j)\in F, so as to minimize \sum_{i\in F}f_i +\sum_{clients j}(c_{φ(j),j}+t_j), where t_j is the time taken to reach φ(j) along path P. We call this the minimum latency uncapacitated facility location (MLUFL) problem.
Our main result is an O(\log n\max{\log n,\log m})-approximation for MLUFL. We also show that any improvement in this approximation guarantee, implies an improvement in the (current-best) approximation factor for group Steiner tree. We obtain constant approximations for two natural special cases of the problem: (a) related MLUFL (metric connection costs that are a scalar multiple of the time metric); (b) metric uniform MLUFL (metric connection costs, unform time-metric). Our LP-based methods are versatile and easily adapted to yield approximation guarantees for MLUFL in various more general settings, such as (i) when the latency-cost of a client is a function of the delay faced by the facility to which it is connected; and (ii) the k-route version, where k vehicles are routed in parallel to activate the open facilities. Our LP-based understanding of MLUFL also offers some LP-based insights into ML, which we believe is a promising direction for obtaining improvements for ML.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
Fault-Tolerant Facility Location: a randomized dependent LP-rounding algorithm
Authors:
Jaroslaw Byrka,
Aravind Srinivasan,
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We give a new randomized LP-rounding 1.725-approximation algorithm for the metric Fault-Tolerant Uncapacitated Facility Location problem. This improves on the previously best known 2.076-approximation algorithm of Swamy & Shmoys. To the best of our knowledge, our work provides the first application of a dependent-rounding technique in the domain of facility location. The analysis of our algorith…
▽ More
We give a new randomized LP-rounding 1.725-approximation algorithm for the metric Fault-Tolerant Uncapacitated Facility Location problem. This improves on the previously best known 2.076-approximation algorithm of Swamy & Shmoys. To the best of our knowledge, our work provides the first application of a dependent-rounding technique in the domain of facility location. The analysis of our algorithm benefits from, and extends, methods developed for Uncapacitated Facility Location; it also helps uncover new properties of the dependent-rounding approach. An important concept that we develop is a novel, hierarchical clustering scheme. Typically, LP-rounding approximation algorithms for facility location problems are based on partitioning facilities into disjoint clusters and opening at least one facility in each cluster. We extend this approach and construct a laminar family of clusters, which then guides the rounding procedure. It allows to exploit properties of dependent rounding, and provides a quite tight analysis resulting in the improved approximation ratio.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Algorithms for Probabilistically-Constrained Models of Risk-Averse Stochastic Optimization with Black-Box Distributions
Authors:
Chaitanya Swamy
Abstract:
We consider various stochastic models that incorporate the notion of risk-averseness into the standard 2-stage recourse model, and develop novel techniques for solving the algorithmic problems arising in these models. A key notable feature of our work that distinguishes it from work in some other related models, such as the (standard) budget model and the (demand-) robust model, is that we obtai…
▽ More
We consider various stochastic models that incorporate the notion of risk-averseness into the standard 2-stage recourse model, and develop novel techniques for solving the algorithmic problems arising in these models. A key notable feature of our work that distinguishes it from work in some other related models, such as the (standard) budget model and the (demand-) robust model, is that we obtain results in the black-box setting, that is, where one is given only sampling access to the underlying distribution. Our first model, which we call the risk-averse budget model, incorporates the notion of risk-averseness via a probabilistic constraint that restricts the probability (according to the underlying distribution) with which the second-stage cost may exceed a given budget B to at most a given input threshold ρ. We also a consider a closely-related model that we call the risk-averse robust model, where we seek to minimize the first-stage cost and the (1-ρ)-quantile of the second-stage cost.
We obtain approximation algorithms for a variety of combinatorial optimization problems including the set cover, vertex cover, multicut on trees, min cut, and facility location problems, in the risk-averse budget and robust models with black-box distributions. We obtain near-optimal solutions that preserve the budget approximately and incur a small blow-up of the probability threshold (both of which are unavoidable). To the best of our knowledge, these are the first approximation results for problems involving probabilistic constraints and black-box distributions. A major component of our results is a fully polynomial approximation scheme for solving the LP-relaxation of the risk-averse problem.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2008;
originally announced May 2008.
