-
A Multi-Agent Model for Opinion Evolution under Cognitive Biases
Authors:
Mário S. Alvim,
Artur Gaspar da Silva,
Sophia Knight,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
We generalize the DeGroot model for opinion dynamics to better capture realistic social scenarios. We introduce a model where each agent has their own individual cognitive biases. Society is represented as a directed graph whose edges indicate how much agents influence one another. Biases are represented as the functions in the square region $[-1,1]^2$ and categorized into four sub-regions based o…
▽ More
We generalize the DeGroot model for opinion dynamics to better capture realistic social scenarios. We introduce a model where each agent has their own individual cognitive biases. Society is represented as a directed graph whose edges indicate how much agents influence one another. Biases are represented as the functions in the square region $[-1,1]^2$ and categorized into four sub-regions based on the potential reactions they may elicit in an agent during instances of opinion disagreement. Under the assumption that each bias of every agent is a continuous function within the region of receptive but resistant reactions ($\mathbf{R}$), we show that the society converges to a consensus if the graph is strongly connected. Under the same assumption, we also establish that the entire society converges to a unanimous opinion if and only if the source components of the graph-namely, strongly connected components with no external influence-converge to that opinion. We illustrate that convergence is not guaranteed for strongly connected graphs when biases are either discontinuous functions in $\mathbf{R}$ or not included in $\mathbf{R}$. We showcase our model through a series of examples and simulations, offering insights into how opinions form in social networks under cognitive biases.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Unified Opinion Dynamic Modeling as Concurrent Set Relations in Rewriting Logic
Authors:
Carlos Olarte,
Carlos Ramírez,
Camilo Rocha,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
Social media platforms have played a key role in weaponizing the polarization of social, political, and democratic processes. This is, mainly, because they are a medium for opinion formation. Opinion dynamic models are a tool for understanding the role of specific social factors on the acceptance/rejection of opinions because they can be used to analyze certain assumptions on human behaviors. This…
▽ More
Social media platforms have played a key role in weaponizing the polarization of social, political, and democratic processes. This is, mainly, because they are a medium for opinion formation. Opinion dynamic models are a tool for understanding the role of specific social factors on the acceptance/rejection of opinions because they can be used to analyze certain assumptions on human behaviors. This work presents a framework that uses concurrent set relations as the formal basis to specify, simulate, and analyze social interaction systems with dynamic opinion models. Standard models for social learning are obtained as particular instances of the proposed framework. It has been implemented in the Maude system as a fully executable rewrite theory that can be used to better understand how opinions of a system of agents can be shaped. This paper also reports an initial exploration in Maude on the use of reachability analysis, probabilistic simulation, and statistical model checking of important properties related to opinion dynamic models.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Fairness and Consensus in Opinion Models (Technical Report)
Authors:
Jesús Aranda,
Sebastián Betancourt,
Juan Fco. Díaz,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
We introduce a DeGroot-based model for opinion dynamics in social networks. A community of agents is represented as a weighted directed graph whose edges indicate how much agents influence one another. The model is formalized using labeled transition systems, henceforth called opinion transition systems (OTS), whose states represent the agents' opinions and whose actions are the edges of the influ…
▽ More
We introduce a DeGroot-based model for opinion dynamics in social networks. A community of agents is represented as a weighted directed graph whose edges indicate how much agents influence one another. The model is formalized using labeled transition systems, henceforth called opinion transition systems (OTS), whose states represent the agents' opinions and whose actions are the edges of the influence graph. If a transition labeled $(i,j)$ is performed, agent $j$ updates their opinion taking into account the opinion of agent $i$ and the influence $i$ has over $j$. We study (convergence to) opinion consensus among the agents of strongly-connected graphs with influence values in the interval $(0,1)$. We show that consensus cannot be guaranteed under the standard strong fairness assumption on transition systems. We derive that consensus is guaranteed under a stronger notion from the literature of concurrent systems; bounded fairness. We argue that bounded-fairness is too strong of a notion for consensus as it almost surely rules out random runs and it is not a constructive liveness property. We introduce a weaker fairness notion, called $m$-bounded fairness, and show that it guarantees consensus. The new notion includes almost surely all random runs and it is a constructive liveness property. Finally, we consider OTS with dynamic influence and show convergence to consensus holds under $m$-bounded fairness if the influence changes within a fixed interval $[L,U]$ with $0<L<U<1$. We illustrate OTS with examples and simulations, offering insights into opinion formation under fairness and dynamic influence.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2024; v1 submitted 19 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Counting and Computing Join-Endomorphisms in Lattices (Revisited)
Authors:
Carlos Pinzón,
Santiago Quintero,
Sergio Ramírez,
Camilo Rueda,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
Structures involving a lattice and join-endomorphisms on it are ubiquitous in computer science. We study the cardinality of the set $\mathcal{E}(L)$ of all join-endomorphisms of a given finite lattice $L$. In particular, we show for $\mathbf{M}_n$, the discrete order of $n$ elements extended with top and bottom, $| \mathcal{E}(\mathbf{M}_n) | =n!\mathcal{L}_n(-1)+(n+1)^2$ where $\mathcal{L}_n(x)$…
▽ More
Structures involving a lattice and join-endomorphisms on it are ubiquitous in computer science. We study the cardinality of the set $\mathcal{E}(L)$ of all join-endomorphisms of a given finite lattice $L$. In particular, we show for $\mathbf{M}_n$, the discrete order of $n$ elements extended with top and bottom, $| \mathcal{E}(\mathbf{M}_n) | =n!\mathcal{L}_n(-1)+(n+1)^2$ where $\mathcal{L}_n(x)$ is the Laguerre polynomial of degree $n$. We also study the following problem: Given a lattice $L$ of size $n$ and a set $S\subseteq \mathcal{E}(L)$ of size $m$, find the greatest lower bound ${\large\sqcap}_{\mathcal{E}(L)} S$. The join-endomorphism ${\large\sqcap}_{\mathcal{E}(L)} S$ has meaningful interpretations in epistemic logic, distributed systems, and Aumann structures. We show that this problem can be solved with worst-case time complexity in $O(mn)$ for distributive lattices and $O(mn + n^3)$ for arbitrary lattices. In the particular case of modular lattices, we present an adaptation of the latter algorithm that reduces its average time complexity. We provide theoretical and experimental results to support this enhancement. The complexity is expressed in terms of the basic binary lattice operations performed by the algorithm.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
On the Computation of Distributed Knowledge as the Greatest Lower Bound of Knowledge
Authors:
Santiago Quintero,
Carlos Pinzón,
Sergio Ramírez,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
Let $L$ be a finite lattice and $\mathcal{E}(L)$ be the set of join endomorphisms of $L$. We consider the problem of given $L$ and $f,g \in \mathcal{E}(L)$, finding the greatest lower bound $f \sqcap_{{\scriptsize \mathcal{E}(L)}} g$ in the lattice $\mathcal{E}(L)$. (1) We show that if $L$ is distributive, the problem can be solved in time $O(n)$ where $n=| L |$. The previous upper bound was…
▽ More
Let $L$ be a finite lattice and $\mathcal{E}(L)$ be the set of join endomorphisms of $L$. We consider the problem of given $L$ and $f,g \in \mathcal{E}(L)$, finding the greatest lower bound $f \sqcap_{{\scriptsize \mathcal{E}(L)}} g$ in the lattice $\mathcal{E}(L)$. (1) We show that if $L$ is distributive, the problem can be solved in time $O(n)$ where $n=| L |$. The previous upper bound was $O(n^2)$. (2) We provide new algorithms for arbitrary lattices and give experimental evidence that they are significantly faster than the existing algorithm. (3) We characterize the standard notion of distributed knowledge of a group as the greatest lower bound of the join-endomorphisms representing the knowledge of each member of the group. (4) We show that deciding whether an agent has the distributed knowledge of two other agents can be computed in time $O(n^2)$ where $n$ is the size of the underlying set of states. (5) For the special case of $S5$ knowledge, we show that it can be decided in time $O(nα_{n})$ where $α_{n}$ is the inverse of the Ackermann function.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2022; v1 submitted 14 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
A Formal Model for Polarization under Confirmation Bias in Social Networks
Authors:
Mário S. Alvim,
Bernardo Amorim,
Sophia Knight,
Santiago Quintero,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
We describe a model for polarization in multi-agent systems based on Esteban and Ray's standard family of polarization measures from economics. Agents evolve by updating their beliefs (opinions) based on an underlying influence graph, as in the standard DeGroot model for social learning, but under a confirmation bias; i.e., a discounting of opinions of agents with dissimilar views. We show that ev…
▽ More
We describe a model for polarization in multi-agent systems based on Esteban and Ray's standard family of polarization measures from economics. Agents evolve by updating their beliefs (opinions) based on an underlying influence graph, as in the standard DeGroot model for social learning, but under a confirmation bias; i.e., a discounting of opinions of agents with dissimilar views. We show that even under this bias polarization eventually vanishes (converges to zero) if the influence graph is strongly-connected. If the influence graph is a regular symmetric circulation, we determine the unique belief value to which all agents converge. Our more insightful result establishes that, under some natural assumptions, if polarization does not eventually vanish then either there is a disconnected subgroup of agents, or some agent influences others more than she is influenced. We also prove that polarization does not necessarily vanish in weakly-connected graphs under confirmation bias. Furthermore, we show how our model relates to the classic DeGroot model for social learning. We illustrate our model with several simulations of a running example about polarization over vaccines and of other case studies. The theoretical results and simulations will provide insight into the phenomenon of polarization.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023; v1 submitted 17 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
On the impossibility of non-trivial accuracy under fairness constraints
Authors:
Carlos Pinzón,
Catuscia Palamidessi,
Pablo Piantanida,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
One of the main concerns about fairness in machine learning (ML) is that, in order to achieve it, one may have to trade off some accuracy. To overcome this issue, Hardt et al. proposed the notion of equality of opportunity (EO), which is compatible with maximal accuracy when the target label is deterministic with respect to the input features.
In the probabilistic case, however, the issue is mor…
▽ More
One of the main concerns about fairness in machine learning (ML) is that, in order to achieve it, one may have to trade off some accuracy. To overcome this issue, Hardt et al. proposed the notion of equality of opportunity (EO), which is compatible with maximal accuracy when the target label is deterministic with respect to the input features.
In the probabilistic case, however, the issue is more complicated: It has been shown that under differential privacy constraints, there are data sources for which EO can only be achieved at the total detriment of accuracy, in the sense that a classifier that satisfies EO cannot be more accurate than a trivial (i.e., constant) classifier. In our paper we strengthen this result by removing the privacy constraint. Namely, we show that for certain data sources, the most accurate classifier that satisfies EO is a trivial classifier. Furthermore, we study the trade-off between accuracy and EO loss (opportunity difference), and provide a sufficient condition on the data source under which EO and non-trivial accuracy are compatible.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2021; v1 submitted 14 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
A Multi-Agent Model for Polarization under Confirmation Bias in Social Networks
Authors:
Mário S. Alvim,
Bernardo Amorim,
Sophia Knight,
Santiago Quintero,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
We describe a model for polarization in multi-agent systems based on Esteban and Ray's standard measure of polarization from economics. Agents evolve by updating their beliefs (opinions) based on an underlying influence graph, as in the standard DeGroot model for social learning, but under a confirmation bias; i.e., a discounting of opinions of agents with dissimilar views. We show that even under…
▽ More
We describe a model for polarization in multi-agent systems based on Esteban and Ray's standard measure of polarization from economics. Agents evolve by updating their beliefs (opinions) based on an underlying influence graph, as in the standard DeGroot model for social learning, but under a confirmation bias; i.e., a discounting of opinions of agents with dissimilar views. We show that even under this bias polarization eventually vanishes (converges to zero) if the influence graph is strongly-connected. If the influence graph is a regular symmetric circulation, we determine the unique belief value to which all agents converge. Our more insightful result establishes that, under some natural assumptions, if polarization does not eventually vanish then either there is a disconnected subgroup of agents, or some agent influences others more than she is influenced. We also show that polarization does not necessarily vanish in weakly-connected graphs under confirmation bias. We illustrate our model with a series of case studies and simulations, and show how it relates to the classic DeGroot model for social learning.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Enhancing User' s Income Estimation with Super-App Alternative Data
Authors:
Gabriel Suarez,
Juan Raful,
Maria A. Luque,
Carlos F. Valencia,
Alejandro Correa-Bahnsen
Abstract:
This paper presents the advantages of alternative data from Super-Apps to enhance user' s income estimation models. It compares the performance of these alternative data sources with the performance of industry-accepted bureau income estimators that takes into account only financial system information; successfully showing that the alternative data manage to capture information that bureau income…
▽ More
This paper presents the advantages of alternative data from Super-Apps to enhance user' s income estimation models. It compares the performance of these alternative data sources with the performance of industry-accepted bureau income estimators that takes into account only financial system information; successfully showing that the alternative data manage to capture information that bureau income estimators do not. By implementing the TreeSHAP method for Stochastic Gradient Boosting Interpretation, this paper highlights which of the customer' s behavioral and transactional patterns within a Super-App have a stronger predictive power when estimating user' s income. Ultimately, this paper shows the incentive for financial institutions to seek to incorporate alternative data into constructing their risk profiles.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2021; v1 submitted 12 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Polarization and Belief Convergence of Agents in Strongly-Connected Influence Graphs
Authors:
Mário S. Alvim,
Bernardo Amorim,
Sophia Knight,
Santiago Quintero,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
We describe a model for polarization in multi-agent systems based on Esteban and Ray's classic measure of polarization from economics. Agents evolve by updating their beliefs (opinions) based on the beliefs of others and an underlying influence graph. We show that polarization eventually disappears (converges to zero) if the influence graph is strongly-connected. If the influence graph is a circul…
▽ More
We describe a model for polarization in multi-agent systems based on Esteban and Ray's classic measure of polarization from economics. Agents evolve by updating their beliefs (opinions) based on the beliefs of others and an underlying influence graph. We show that polarization eventually disappears (converges to zero) if the influence graph is strongly-connected. If the influence graph is a circulation we determine the unique belief value all agents converge to. For clique influence graphs we determine the time after which agents will reach a given difference of opinion. Our results imply that if polarization does not disappear then either there is a disconnected subgroup of agents or some agent influences others more than she is influenced. Finally, we show that polarization does not necessarily vanish in weakly-connected graphs, and illustrate the model with a series of case studies and simulations giving some insights about polarization.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Algebraic Structures from Concurrent Constraint Programming Calculi for Distributed Information in Multi-Agent Systems
Authors:
Michell Guzmán,
Sophia Knight,
Santiago Quintero,
Sergio Ramírez,
Camilo Rueda,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
Spatial constraint systems (scs) are semantic structures for reasoning about spatial and epistemic information in concurrent systems. We develop the theory of scs to reason about the distributed information of potentially infinite groups. We characterize the notion of distributed information of a group of agents as the infimum of the set of join-preserving functions that represent the spaces of th…
▽ More
Spatial constraint systems (scs) are semantic structures for reasoning about spatial and epistemic information in concurrent systems. We develop the theory of scs to reason about the distributed information of potentially infinite groups. We characterize the notion of distributed information of a group of agents as the infimum of the set of join-preserving functions that represent the spaces of the agents in the group. We provide an alternative characterization of this notion as the greatest family of join-preserving functions that satisfy certain basic properties. For completely distributive lattices, we establish that distributed information of a group is the greatest information below all possible combinations of information in the spaces of the agents in the group that derive a given piece of information. We show compositionality results for these characterizations and conditions under which information that can be obtained by an infinite group can also be obtained by a finite group. Finally, we provide an application on mathematical morphology where dilations, one of its fundamental operations, define an scs on a powerset lattice. We show that distributed information represents a particular dilation in such scs.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2021; v1 submitted 20 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
A Rewriting Logic Approach to Stochastic and Spatial Constraint System Specification and Verification
Authors:
Miguel Romero,
Sergio Ramírez,
Camilo Rocha,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
This paper addresses the issue of specifying, simulating, and verifying reactive systems in rewriting logic. It presents an executable semantics for probabilistic, timed, and spatial concurrent constraint programming -- here called stochastic and spatial concurrent constraint systems (SSCC) -- in the rewriting logic semantic framework. The approach is based on an enhanced and generalized model of…
▽ More
This paper addresses the issue of specifying, simulating, and verifying reactive systems in rewriting logic. It presents an executable semantics for probabilistic, timed, and spatial concurrent constraint programming -- here called stochastic and spatial concurrent constraint systems (SSCC) -- in the rewriting logic semantic framework. The approach is based on an enhanced and generalized model of concurrent constraint programming (CCP) where computational hierarchical spaces can be assigned to belong to agents. The executable semantics faithfully represents and operationally captures the highly concurrent nature, uncertain behavior, and spatial and epistemic characteristics of reactive systems with flow of information. In SSCC, timing attributes -- represented by stochastic duration -- can be associated to processes, and exclusive and independent probabilistic choice is also supported. SMT solving technology, available from the Maude system, is used to realize the underlying constraint system of SSCC with quantifier-free formulas over integers and reals. This results in a fully executable real-time symbolic specification that can be used for quantitative analysis in the form of statistical model checking. The main features and capabilities of SSCC are illustrated with examples throughout the paper. This contribution is part of a larger research effort aimed at making available formal analysis techniques and tools, mathematically founded on the CCP approach, to the research community.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2022; v1 submitted 9 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Semantic Structures for Spatially-Distributed Multi-Agent Systems
Authors:
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
Spatial constraint systems (scs) are semantic structures for reasoning about spatial and epistemic information in concurrent systems. They have been used to reason about beliefs, lies, and group epistemic behaviour inspired by social networks. They have also been used for proving new results about modal logics and giving semantics to process calculi. In this paper we will discuss the theory and ma…
▽ More
Spatial constraint systems (scs) are semantic structures for reasoning about spatial and epistemic information in concurrent systems. They have been used to reason about beliefs, lies, and group epistemic behaviour inspired by social networks. They have also been used for proving new results about modal logics and giving semantics to process calculi. In this paper we will discuss the theory and main results about scs.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Reducing Weak to Strong Bisimilarity in CCP
Authors:
Andrés Aristizábal,
Filippo Bonchi,
Luis Pino,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
Concurrent constraint programming (ccp) is a well-established model for concurrency that singles out the fundamental aspects of asynchronous systems whose agents (or processes) evolve by posting and querying (partial) information in a global medium. Bisimilarity is a standard behavioural equivalence in concurrency theory. However, only recently a well-behaved notion of bisimilarity for ccp, and a…
▽ More
Concurrent constraint programming (ccp) is a well-established model for concurrency that singles out the fundamental aspects of asynchronous systems whose agents (or processes) evolve by posting and querying (partial) information in a global medium. Bisimilarity is a standard behavioural equivalence in concurrency theory. However, only recently a well-behaved notion of bisimilarity for ccp, and a ccp partition refinement algorithm for deciding the strong version of this equivalence have been proposed. Weak bisimiliarity is a central behavioural equivalence in process calculi and it is obtained from the strong case by taking into account only the actions that are observable in the system. Typically, the standard partition refinement can also be used for deciding weak bisimilarity simply by using Milner's reduction from weak to strong bisimilarity; a technique referred to as saturation. In this paper we demonstrate that, because of its involved labeled transitions, the above-mentioned saturation technique does not work for ccp. We give an alternative reduction from weak ccp bisimilarity to the strong one that allows us to use the ccp partition refinement algorithm for deciding this equivalence.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Partition Refinement for Bisimilarity in CCP
Authors:
Andrés Aristizábal,
Filippo Bonchi,
Luis Pino,
Frank D. Valencia
Abstract:
Saraswat's concurrent constraint programming (ccp) is a mature formalism for modeling processes (or programs) that interact by telling and asking constraints in a global medium, called the store. Bisimilarity is a standard behavioural equivalence in concurrency theory, but a well-behaved notion of bisimilarity for ccp has been proposed only recently. When the state space of a system is finite, the…
▽ More
Saraswat's concurrent constraint programming (ccp) is a mature formalism for modeling processes (or programs) that interact by telling and asking constraints in a global medium, called the store. Bisimilarity is a standard behavioural equivalence in concurrency theory, but a well-behaved notion of bisimilarity for ccp has been proposed only recently. When the state space of a system is finite, the ordinary notion of bisimilarity can be computed via the well-known partition refinement algorithm, but unfortunately, this algorithm does not work for ccp bisimilarity. In this paper, we propose a variation of the partition refinement algorithm for verifying ccp bisimilarity. To the best of our knowledge this is the first work providing for the automatic verification of program equivalence for ccp
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Hide and New in the Pi-Calculus
Authors:
Marco Giunti,
Catuscia Palamidessi,
Frank D. Valencia
Abstract:
In this paper, we enrich the pi-calculus with an operator for confidentiality (hide), whose main effect is to restrict the access to the object of the communication, thus representing confidentiality in a natural way. The hide operator is meant for local communication, and it differs from new in that it forbids the extrusion of the name and hence has a static scope. Consequently, a communication c…
▽ More
In this paper, we enrich the pi-calculus with an operator for confidentiality (hide), whose main effect is to restrict the access to the object of the communication, thus representing confidentiality in a natural way. The hide operator is meant for local communication, and it differs from new in that it forbids the extrusion of the name and hence has a static scope. Consequently, a communication channel in the scope of a hide can be implemented as a dedicated channel, and it is more secure than one in the scope of a new. To emphasize the difference, we introduce a spy context that represents a side-channel attack and breaks some of the standard security equations for new. To formally reason on the security guarantees provided by the hide construct, we introduce an observational theory and establish stronger equivalences by relying on a proof technique based on bisimulation semantics.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Proceedings 18th International Workshop on Expressiveness in Concurrency
Authors:
Bas Luttik,
Frank Valencia
Abstract:
This volume contains the proceedings of the 18th International Workshop on Expressiveness in Concurrency (EXPRESS 2011), which took place on 5th September 2011 in Aachen, as a satellite workshop of CONCUR 2011. The EXPRESS workshop series aim at bringing together researchers who are interested in the expressiveness and comparison of formal models that broadly relate to concurrency. In particular,…
▽ More
This volume contains the proceedings of the 18th International Workshop on Expressiveness in Concurrency (EXPRESS 2011), which took place on 5th September 2011 in Aachen, as a satellite workshop of CONCUR 2011. The EXPRESS workshop series aim at bringing together researchers who are interested in the expressiveness and comparison of formal models that broadly relate to concurrency. In particular, this also includes emergent fields such as logic and interaction, game-theoretic models, and service-oriented computing.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Proceedings 17th International Workshop on Expressiveness in Concurrency
Authors:
Sibylle Fröschle,
Frank D. Valencia
Abstract:
This volume contains the proceedings of the 17th International Workshop on Expressiveness in Concurrency (EXPRESS'10), which took place on 30th August 2010 in Paris, co-located with CONCUR'10. The EXPRESS workshop series aim at bringing together researchers who are interested in the expressiveness and comparison of formal models that broadly relate to concurrency. In particular, this also includes…
▽ More
This volume contains the proceedings of the 17th International Workshop on Expressiveness in Concurrency (EXPRESS'10), which took place on 30th August 2010 in Paris, co-located with CONCUR'10. The EXPRESS workshop series aim at bringing together researchers who are interested in the expressiveness and comparison of formal models that broadly relate to concurrency. In particular, this also includes emergent fields such as logic and interaction, game-theoretic models, and service-oriented computing.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
