-
Testing the simplicity of strategy-proof mechanisms
Authors:
Alexander L. Brown,
Daniel G. Stephenson,
Rodrigo A. Velez
Abstract:
This paper experimentally evaluates four mechanisms intended to achieve the Uniform outcome in rationing problems (Sprumont, 1991). Our benchmark is the dominant-strategy, direct-revelation mechanism of the Uniform rule. A strategically equivalent mechanism that provides non-binding feedback during the reporting period greatly improves performance. A sequential revelation mechanism produces modest…
▽ More
This paper experimentally evaluates four mechanisms intended to achieve the Uniform outcome in rationing problems (Sprumont, 1991). Our benchmark is the dominant-strategy, direct-revelation mechanism of the Uniform rule. A strategically equivalent mechanism that provides non-binding feedback during the reporting period greatly improves performance. A sequential revelation mechanism produces modest improvements despite not possessing dominant strategies. A novel, obviously strategy-proof mechanism, devised by Arribillaga et al. (2023), does not improve performance. We characterize each alternative to the direct mechanism, finding general lessons about the advantages of real-time feedback and sequentiality of play as well as the potential shortcomings of an obviously strategy-proof mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Balanced House Allocation
Authors:
Xinghua Long,
Rodrigo A. Velez
Abstract:
We introduce balancedness a fairness axiom in house allocation problems. It requires a mechanism to assign the top choice, the second top choice, and so on, on the same number of profiles for each agent. This axiom guarantees equal treatment of all agents at the stage in which the mechanism is announced when all preference profiles are equally likely. We show that, with an interesting exception fo…
▽ More
We introduce balancedness a fairness axiom in house allocation problems. It requires a mechanism to assign the top choice, the second top choice, and so on, on the same number of profiles for each agent. This axiom guarantees equal treatment of all agents at the stage in which the mechanism is announced when all preference profiles are equally likely. We show that, with an interesting exception for the three-agent case, Top Trading Cycles from individual endowments is the only mechanism that is balanced, efficient, and group strategy-proof.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Advancing Data for Street-level Flood Vulnerability: Extraction of Variables from Google Street View in Quito, Ecuador
Authors:
Raychell Velez,
Diana Calderon,
Lauren Carey,
Christopher Aime,
Carolynne Hultquist,
Greg Yetman,
Andrew Kruczkiewicz,
Yuri Gorokhovich,
Robert S. Chen
Abstract:
Data relevant to flood vulnerability is minimal and infrequently collected, if at all, for much of the world. This makes it difficult to highlight areas for humanitarian aid, monitor changes, and support communities in need. It would be time consuming and resource intensive to do an exhaustive study for multiple flood relevant vulnerability variables using a field survey. We use a mixed methods ap…
▽ More
Data relevant to flood vulnerability is minimal and infrequently collected, if at all, for much of the world. This makes it difficult to highlight areas for humanitarian aid, monitor changes, and support communities in need. It would be time consuming and resource intensive to do an exhaustive study for multiple flood relevant vulnerability variables using a field survey. We use a mixed methods approach to develop a survey on variables of interest and utilize an open-source crowdsourcing technique to remotely collect data with a human-machine interface using high-resolution satellite images and Google Street View. This paper focuses on Quito, Ecuador as a case study, but the methodology can be quickly replicated to produce labelled training data in other areas. The overall project goal is to build training datasets that in the future will allow us to automate the mapping of flood vulnerability for urban areas in geographic regions.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
A polynomial algorithm for maxmin and minmax envy-free rent division on a soft budget
Authors:
Rodrigo A. Velez
Abstract:
The current practice of envy-free rent division, lead by the fair allocation website Spliddit, is based on quasi-linear preferences. These preferences rule out agents' well documented financial constraints. To resolve this issue we consider piece-wise linear budget constrained preferences. These preferences admit differences in agents' marginal disutility of paying rent below and above a given ref…
▽ More
The current practice of envy-free rent division, lead by the fair allocation website Spliddit, is based on quasi-linear preferences. These preferences rule out agents' well documented financial constraints. To resolve this issue we consider piece-wise linear budget constrained preferences. These preferences admit differences in agents' marginal disutility of paying rent below and above a given reference, i.e., a soft budget. We construct a polynomial algorithm to calculate a maxmin utility envy-free allocation, and other related solutions, in this domain.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Empirical strategy-proofness
Authors:
Rodrigo A. Velez,
Alexander L. Brown
Abstract:
We study the plausibility of sub-optimal Nash equilibria of the direct revelation mechanism associated with a strategy-proof social choice function. By using the recently introduced empirical equilibrium analysis (Velez and Brown, 2019, arXiv:1804.07986) we determine that this behavior is plausible only when the social choice function violates a non-bossiness condition and information is not inter…
▽ More
We study the plausibility of sub-optimal Nash equilibria of the direct revelation mechanism associated with a strategy-proof social choice function. By using the recently introduced empirical equilibrium analysis (Velez and Brown, 2019, arXiv:1804.07986) we determine that this behavior is plausible only when the social choice function violates a non-bossiness condition and information is not interior. Analysis of the accumulated experimental and empirical evidence on these games supports our findings.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2020; v1 submitted 29 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Expressive mechanisms for equitable rent division on a budget
Authors:
Rodrigo A. Velez
Abstract:
We study the incentive properties of envy-free mechanisms for the allocation of rooms and payments of rent among financially constrained roommates. Each agent reports her values for rooms, her housing earmark (soft budget), and an index that reflects the difficulty the agent experiences from having to pay over this amount. Then an envy-free allocation for these reports is recommended. The complete…
▽ More
We study the incentive properties of envy-free mechanisms for the allocation of rooms and payments of rent among financially constrained roommates. Each agent reports her values for rooms, her housing earmark (soft budget), and an index that reflects the difficulty the agent experiences from having to pay over this amount. Then an envy-free allocation for these reports is recommended. The complete information non-cooperative outcomes of each of these mechanisms are exactly the envy-free allocations with respect to true preferences if and only if the admissible budget violation indices have a bound.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2020; v1 submitted 7 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Diffusion-based neuromodulation can eliminate catastrophic forgetting in simple neural networks
Authors:
Roby Velez,
Jeff Clune
Abstract:
A long-term goal of AI is to produce agents that can learn a diversity of skills throughout their lifetimes and continuously improve those skills via experience. A longstanding obstacle towards that goal is catastrophic forgetting, which is when learning new information erases previously learned information. Catastrophic forgetting occurs in artificial neural networks (ANNs), which have fueled mos…
▽ More
A long-term goal of AI is to produce agents that can learn a diversity of skills throughout their lifetimes and continuously improve those skills via experience. A longstanding obstacle towards that goal is catastrophic forgetting, which is when learning new information erases previously learned information. Catastrophic forgetting occurs in artificial neural networks (ANNs), which have fueled most recent advances in AI. A recent paper proposed that catastrophic forgetting in ANNs can be reduced by promoting modularity, which can limit forgetting by isolating task information to specific clusters of nodes and connections (functional modules). While the prior work did show that modular ANNs suffered less from catastrophic forgetting, it was not able to produce ANNs that possessed task-specific functional modules, thereby leaving the main theory regarding modularity and forgetting untested. We introduce diffusion-based neuromodulation, which simulates the release of diffusing, neuromodulatory chemicals within an ANN that can modulate (i.e. up or down regulate) learning in a spatial region. On the simple diagnostic problem from the prior work, diffusion-based neuromodulation 1) induces task-specific learning in groups of nodes and connections (task-specific localized learning), which 2) produces functional modules for each subtask, and 3) yields higher performance by eliminating catastrophic forgetting. Overall, our results suggest that diffusion-based neuromodulation promotes task-specific localized learning and functional modularity, which can help solve the challenging, but important problem of catastrophic forgetting.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2017; v1 submitted 19 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
