-
Governing Through the Cloud: The Intermediary Role of Compute Providers in AI Regulation
Authors:
Lennart Heim,
Tim Fist,
Janet Egan,
Sihao Huang,
Stephen Zekany,
Robert Trager,
Michael A Osborne,
Noa Zilberman
Abstract:
As jurisdictions around the world take their first steps toward regulating the most powerful AI systems, such as the EU AI Act and the US Executive Order 14110, there is a growing need for effective enforcement mechanisms that can verify compliance and respond to violations. We argue that compute providers should have legal obligations and ethical responsibilities associated with AI development an…
▽ More
As jurisdictions around the world take their first steps toward regulating the most powerful AI systems, such as the EU AI Act and the US Executive Order 14110, there is a growing need for effective enforcement mechanisms that can verify compliance and respond to violations. We argue that compute providers should have legal obligations and ethical responsibilities associated with AI development and deployment, both to provide secure infrastructure and to serve as intermediaries for AI regulation. Compute providers can play an essential role in a regulatory ecosystem via four key capacities: as securers, safeguarding AI systems and critical infrastructure; as record keepers, enhancing visibility for policymakers; as verifiers of customer activities, ensuring oversight; and as enforcers, taking actions against rule violations. We analyze the technical feasibility of performing these functions in a targeted and privacy-conscious manner and present a range of technical instruments. In particular, we describe how non-confidential information, to which compute providers largely already have access, can provide two key governance-relevant properties of a computational workload: its type-e.g., large-scale training or inference-and the amount of compute it has consumed. Using AI Executive Order 14110 as a case study, we outline how the US is beginning to implement record keeping requirements for compute providers. We also explore how verification and enforcement roles could be added to establish a comprehensive AI compute oversight scheme. We argue that internationalization will be key to effective implementation, and highlight the critical challenge of balancing confidentiality and privacy with risk mitigation as the role of compute providers in AI regulation expands.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2024; v1 submitted 13 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Automating In-Network Machine Learning
Authors:
Changgang Zheng,
Mingyuan Zang,
Xinpeng Hong,
Riyad Bensoussane,
Shay Vargaftik,
Yaniv Ben-Itzhak,
Noa Zilberman
Abstract:
Using programmable network devices to aid in-network machine learning has been the focus of significant research. However, most of the research was of a limited scope, providing a proof of concept or describing a closed-source algorithm. To date, no general solution has been provided for mapping machine learning algorithms to programmable network devices. In this paper, we present Planter, an open…
▽ More
Using programmable network devices to aid in-network machine learning has been the focus of significant research. However, most of the research was of a limited scope, providing a proof of concept or describing a closed-source algorithm. To date, no general solution has been provided for mapping machine learning algorithms to programmable network devices. In this paper, we present Planter, an open-source, modular framework for mapping trained machine learning models to programmable devices. Planter supports a wide range of machine learning models, multiple targets and can be easily extended. The evaluation of Planter compares different mapping approaches, and demonstrates the feasibility, performance, and resource efficiency for applications such as anomaly detection, financial transactions, and quality of experience.
The results show that Planter-based in-network machine learning algorithms can run at line rate, have a negligible effect on latency, coexist with standard switching functionality, and have no or minor accuracy trade-offs.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
IIsy: Practical In-Network Classification
Authors:
Changgang Zheng,
Zhaoqi Xiong,
Thanh T Bui,
Siim Kaupmees,
Riyad Bensoussane,
Antoine Bernabeu,
Shay Vargaftik,
Yaniv Ben-Itzhak,
Noa Zilberman
Abstract:
The rat race between user-generated data and data-processing systems is currently won by data. The increased use of machine learning leads to further increase in processing requirements, while data volume keeps growing. To win the race, machine learning needs to be applied to the data as it goes through the network. In-network classification of data can reduce the load on servers, reduce response…
▽ More
The rat race between user-generated data and data-processing systems is currently won by data. The increased use of machine learning leads to further increase in processing requirements, while data volume keeps growing. To win the race, machine learning needs to be applied to the data as it goes through the network. In-network classification of data can reduce the load on servers, reduce response time and increase scalability. In this paper, we introduce IIsy, implementing machine learning classification models in a hybrid fashion using off-the-shelf network devices. IIsy targets three main challenges of in-network classification: (i) mapping classification models to network devices (ii) extracting the required features and (iii) addressing resource and functionality constraints. IIsy supports a range of traditional and ensemble machine learning models, scaling independently of the number of stages in a switch pipeline. Moreover, we demonstrate the use of IIsy for hybrid classification, where a small model is implemented on a switch and a large model at the backend, achieving near optimal classification results, while significantly reducing latency and load on the servers.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2022; v1 submitted 17 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Filling gaps in trustworthy development of AI
Authors:
Shahar Avin,
Haydn Belfield,
Miles Brundage,
Gretchen Krueger,
Jasmine Wang,
Adrian Weller,
Markus Anderljung,
Igor Krawczuk,
David Krueger,
Jonathan Lebensold,
Tegan Maharaj,
Noa Zilberman
Abstract:
The range of application of artificial intelligence (AI) is vast, as is the potential for harm. Growing awareness of potential risks from AI systems has spurred action to address those risks, while eroding confidence in AI systems and the organizations that develop them. A 2019 study found over 80 organizations that published and adopted "AI ethics principles'', and more have joined since. But the…
▽ More
The range of application of artificial intelligence (AI) is vast, as is the potential for harm. Growing awareness of potential risks from AI systems has spurred action to address those risks, while eroding confidence in AI systems and the organizations that develop them. A 2019 study found over 80 organizations that published and adopted "AI ethics principles'', and more have joined since. But the principles often leave a gap between the "what" and the "how" of trustworthy AI development. Such gaps have enabled questionable or ethically dubious behavior, which casts doubts on the trustworthiness of specific organizations, and the field more broadly. There is thus an urgent need for concrete methods that both enable AI developers to prevent harm and allow them to demonstrate their trustworthiness through verifiable behavior. Below, we explore mechanisms (drawn from arXiv:2004.07213) for creating an ecosystem where AI developers can earn trust - if they are trustworthy. Better assessment of developer trustworthiness could inform user choice, employee actions, investment decisions, legal recourse, and emerging governance regimes.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Toward Trustworthy AI Development: Mechanisms for Supporting Verifiable Claims
Authors:
Miles Brundage,
Shahar Avin,
Jasmine Wang,
Haydn Belfield,
Gretchen Krueger,
Gillian Hadfield,
Heidy Khlaaf,
Jingying Yang,
Helen Toner,
Ruth Fong,
Tegan Maharaj,
Pang Wei Koh,
Sara Hooker,
Jade Leung,
Andrew Trask,
Emma Bluemke,
Jonathan Lebensold,
Cullen O'Keefe,
Mark Koren,
Théo Ryffel,
JB Rubinovitz,
Tamay Besiroglu,
Federica Carugati,
Jack Clark,
Peter Eckersley
, et al. (34 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
With the recent wave of progress in artificial intelligence (AI) has come a growing awareness of the large-scale impacts of AI systems, and recognition that existing regulations and norms in industry and academia are insufficient to ensure responsible AI development. In order for AI developers to earn trust from system users, customers, civil society, governments, and other stakeholders that they…
▽ More
With the recent wave of progress in artificial intelligence (AI) has come a growing awareness of the large-scale impacts of AI systems, and recognition that existing regulations and norms in industry and academia are insufficient to ensure responsible AI development. In order for AI developers to earn trust from system users, customers, civil society, governments, and other stakeholders that they are building AI responsibly, they will need to make verifiable claims to which they can be held accountable. Those outside of a given organization also need effective means of scrutinizing such claims. This report suggests various steps that different stakeholders can take to improve the verifiability of claims made about AI systems and their associated development processes, with a focus on providing evidence about the safety, security, fairness, and privacy protection of AI systems. We analyze ten mechanisms for this purpose--spanning institutions, software, and hardware--and make recommendations aimed at implementing, exploring, or improving those mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2020; v1 submitted 15 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Partitioned Paxos via the Network Data Plane
Authors:
Huynh Tu Dang,
Pietro Bressana,
Han Wang,
Ki Suh Lee,
Noa Zilberman,
Hakim Weatherspoon,
Marco Canini,
Fernando Pedone,
Robert Soulé
Abstract:
Consensus protocols are the foundation for building fault-tolerant, distributed systems, and services. They are also widely acknowledged as performance bottlenecks. Several recent systems have proposed accelerating these protocols using the network data plane. But, while network-accelerated consensus shows great promise, current systems suffer from an important limitation: they assume that the net…
▽ More
Consensus protocols are the foundation for building fault-tolerant, distributed systems, and services. They are also widely acknowledged as performance bottlenecks. Several recent systems have proposed accelerating these protocols using the network data plane. But, while network-accelerated consensus shows great promise, current systems suffer from an important limitation: they assume that the network hardware also accelerates the application itself. Consequently, they provide a specialized replicated service, rather than providing a general-purpose high-performance consensus that fits any off-the-shelf application.
To address this problem, this paper proposes Partitioned Paxos, a novel approach to network-accelerated consensus. The key insight behind Partitioned Paxos is to separate the two aspects of Paxos, agreement, and execution, and optimize them separately. First, Partitioned Paxos uses the network forwarding plane to accelerate agreement. Then, it uses state partitioning and parallelization to accelerate execution at the replicas. Our experiments show that using this combination of data plane acceleration and parallelization, Partitioned Paxos is able to provide at least x3 latency improvement and x11 throughput improvement for a replicated instance of a RocksDB key-value store.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
LaKe: An Energy Efficient, Low Latency, Accelerated Key-Value Store
Authors:
Yuta Tokusashi,
Hiroki Matsutani,
Noa Zilberman
Abstract:
Key-value store is a popular type of cloud computing applications. The performance of key-value store applications have been shown to be very sensitive to load within the data center, and in particular to latency. As load within data center increases, it is becoming hard to maintain key-value store applications' performance, without exceeding both the processing capacity of hosts and the power bud…
▽ More
Key-value store is a popular type of cloud computing applications. The performance of key-value store applications have been shown to be very sensitive to load within the data center, and in particular to latency. As load within data center increases, it is becoming hard to maintain key-value store applications' performance, without exceeding both the processing capacity of hosts and the power budgets of racks. In this paper, we present LaKe: a low latency, power efficient key-value store design for cloud applications. LaKe is a modular design, combining multiple cores and cache layering, both in hardware and software. LaKe achieves full line rate throughput, while maintaining a latency of 1.1us and better power efficiency than existing hardware based memcached designs. Using the modularity of our design, we study trade-offs in the use of on-chip memory, SRAM and DRAM in accelerated designs and provide insights for future architectures.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Extending programs with debug-related features, with application to hardware development
Authors:
Nik Sultana,
Salvator Galea,
David Greaves,
Marcin Wojcik,
Noa Zilberman,
Richard Clegg,
Luo Mai,
Richard Mortier,
Peter Pietzuch,
Jon Crowcroft,
Andrew W Moore
Abstract:
The capacity and programmability of reconfigurable hardware such as FPGAs has improved steadily over the years, but they do not readily provide any mechanisms for monitoring or debugging running programs. Such mechanisms need to be written into the program itself. This is done using ad hoc methods and primitive tools when compared to CPU programming. This complicates the programming and debugging…
▽ More
The capacity and programmability of reconfigurable hardware such as FPGAs has improved steadily over the years, but they do not readily provide any mechanisms for monitoring or debugging running programs. Such mechanisms need to be written into the program itself. This is done using ad hoc methods and primitive tools when compared to CPU programming. This complicates the programming and debugging of reconfigurable hardware. We introduce Program-hosted Directability (PhD), the extension of programs to interpret direction commands at runtime to enable debugging, monitoring and profiling. Normally in hardware development such features are fixed at compile time. We present a language of directing commands, specify its semantics in terms of a simple controller that is embedded with programs, and implement a prototype for directing network programs running in hardware. We show that this approach affords significant flexibility with low impact on hardware utilisation and performance.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Prototyping RISC Based, Reconfigurable Networking Applications in Open Source
Authors:
Jong Hun Han,
Noa Zilberman,
Bjoern A. Zeeb,
Andreas Fiessler,
Andrew W. Moore
Abstract:
In the last decade we have witnessed a rapid growth in data center systems, requiring new and highly complex networking devices. The need to refresh networking infrastructure whenever new protocols or functions are introduced, and the increasing costs that this entails, are of a concern to all data center providers. New generations of Systems on Chip (SoC), integrating microprocessors and higher b…
▽ More
In the last decade we have witnessed a rapid growth in data center systems, requiring new and highly complex networking devices. The need to refresh networking infrastructure whenever new protocols or functions are introduced, and the increasing costs that this entails, are of a concern to all data center providers. New generations of Systems on Chip (SoC), integrating microprocessors and higher bandwidth interfaces, are an emerging solution to this problem. These devices permit entirely new systems and architectures that can obviate the replacement of existing networking devices while enabling seamless functionality change. In this work, we explore open source, RISC based, SoC architectures with high performance networking capabilities. The prototype architectures are implemented on the NetFPGA-SUME platform. Beyond details of the architecture, we also describe the hardware implementation and the porting of operating systems to the platform. The platform can be exploited for the development of practical networking appliances, and we provide use case examples.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Setting the Foundations for PoP-Based Internet Evolution Models
Authors:
Noa Zilberman,
Yuval Shavitt
Abstract:
Developing an evolution model of the Internet has been a long standing research challenge. Such a model can improve the design and placement of communication infrastructure, reducing costs and improving users' quality of experience. While communication infrastructure is tightly coupled to geographical locations, Internet modelling and forecasting in the last decade used network elements that are o…
▽ More
Developing an evolution model of the Internet has been a long standing research challenge. Such a model can improve the design and placement of communication infrastructure, reducing costs and improving users' quality of experience. While communication infrastructure is tightly coupled to geographical locations, Internet modelling and forecasting in the last decade used network elements that are only loosely bounded to any geographical location. In this paper we set the foundations for developing an evolution model of the Internet based on the Point of Presence (PoP) level. As PoPs have a strong geographical grip they can better represent the evolution of the Internet. We annotate the PoP topologies of the Internet with geographical, economic and demographic information to achieve an understanding of the dynamics of the Internet's structure, in order to identify the constitutive laws of Internet evolution. We identify GDP as the strongest indicator on the country level, and the size of the TV market as the strongest indicator on the US metropolitan level. Finally, we draw attention to the limitations of developing a world-wide evolution model.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2016; v1 submitted 13 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
A Study of Geolocation Databases
Authors:
Yuval Shavitt,
Noa Zilberman
Abstract:
The geographical location of Internet IP addresses has an importance both for academic research and commercial applications. Thus, both commercial and academic databases and tools are available for mapping IP addresses to geographic locations. Evaluating the accuracy of these mapping services is complex since obtaining diverse large scale ground truth is very hard. In this work we evaluate mapping…
▽ More
The geographical location of Internet IP addresses has an importance both for academic research and commercial applications. Thus, both commercial and academic databases and tools are available for mapping IP addresses to geographic locations. Evaluating the accuracy of these mapping services is complex since obtaining diverse large scale ground truth is very hard. In this work we evaluate mapping services using an algorithm that groups IP addresses to PoPs, based on structure and delay. This way we are able to group close to 100,000 IP addresses world wide into groups that are known to share a geo-location with high confidence. We provide insight into the strength and weaknesses of IP geolocation databases, and discuss their accuracy and encountered anomalies.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2010; v1 submitted 31 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
