-
A Duality Based 2-Approximation Algorithm for Maximum Agreement Forest
Authors:
Neil Olver,
Frans Schalekamp,
Suzanne van der Ster,
Leen Stougie,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
We give a 2-approximation algorithm for the Maximum Agreement Forest problem on two rooted binary trees. This NP-hard problem has been studied extensively in the past two decades, since it can be used to compute the rooted Subtree Prune-and-Regraft (rSPR) distance between two phylogenetic trees. Our algorithm is combinatorial and its running time is quadratic in the input size. To prove the approx…
▽ More
We give a 2-approximation algorithm for the Maximum Agreement Forest problem on two rooted binary trees. This NP-hard problem has been studied extensively in the past two decades, since it can be used to compute the rooted Subtree Prune-and-Regraft (rSPR) distance between two phylogenetic trees. Our algorithm is combinatorial and its running time is quadratic in the input size. To prove the approximation guarantee, we construct a feasible dual solution for a novel linear programming formulation. In addition, we show this linear program is stronger than previously known formulations, and we give a compact formulation, showing that it can be solved in polynomial time
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Layers and Matroids for the Traveling Salesman's Paths
Authors:
Frans Schalekamp,
András Sebő,
Vera Traub,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
Gottschalk and Vygen proved that every solution of the subtour elimination linear program for traveling salesman paths is a convex combination of more and more restrictive "generalized Gao-trees". We give a short proof of this fact, as a layered convex combination of bases of a sequence of increasingly restrictive matroids. A strongly polynomial, combinatorial algorithm follows for finding this co…
▽ More
Gottschalk and Vygen proved that every solution of the subtour elimination linear program for traveling salesman paths is a convex combination of more and more restrictive "generalized Gao-trees". We give a short proof of this fact, as a layered convex combination of bases of a sequence of increasingly restrictive matroids. A strongly polynomial, combinatorial algorithm follows for finding this convex combination, which is a new tool offering polyhedral insight, already instrumental in recent results for the $s-t$ path TSP.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2017; v1 submitted 21 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
The Salesman's Improved Paths: 3/2+1/34 Integrality Gap and Approximation Ratio
Authors:
András Sebő,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
We give a new, strongly polynomial-time algorithm and improved analysis for the metric $s-t$ path TSP. It finds a tour of cost less than 1.53 times the optimum of the subtour elimination LP, while known examples show that 1.5 is a lower bound for the integrality gap.
A key new idea is the deletion of some edges of Christofides' trees, which is then accompanied by novel arguments of the analysis:…
▽ More
We give a new, strongly polynomial-time algorithm and improved analysis for the metric $s-t$ path TSP. It finds a tour of cost less than 1.53 times the optimum of the subtour elimination LP, while known examples show that 1.5 is a lower bound for the integrality gap.
A key new idea is the deletion of some edges of Christofides' trees, which is then accompanied by novel arguments of the analysis: edge-deletion disconnects the trees, which are then partly reconnected by `parity correction'. We show that the arising `connectivity correction' can be achieved for a minor extra cost.
On the one hand this algorithm and analysis extend previous tools such as the best-of-many Christofides algorithm. On the other hand, powerful new tools are solicited, such as a flow problem for analyzing the reconnection cost, and the construction of a set of more and more restrictive spanning trees, each of which can still be found by the greedy algorithm. We show that these trees can replace the convex combination of spanning trees in the best-of-may Christofides algorithm.
These new methods lead to improving the integrality ratio and approximation guarantee below 1.53, as it is already sketched in the preliminary shortened version of this article that appeared in FOCS 2016. The algorithm and analysis have been significantly simplified in the current article, and details of proofs and explanations have been added.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2018; v1 submitted 8 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
A Duality Based 2-Approximation Algorithm for Maximum Agreement Forest
Authors:
Frans Schalekamp,
Anke van Zuylen,
Suzanne van der Ster
Abstract:
We give a 2-approximation algorithm for the Maximum Agreement Forest problem on two rooted binary trees. This NP-hard problem has been studied extensively in the past two decades, since it can be used to compute the Subtree Prune-and-Regraft (SPR) distance between two phylogenetic trees. Our result improves on the very recent 2.5-approximation algorithm due to Shi, Feng, You and Wang (2015). Our a…
▽ More
We give a 2-approximation algorithm for the Maximum Agreement Forest problem on two rooted binary trees. This NP-hard problem has been studied extensively in the past two decades, since it can be used to compute the Subtree Prune-and-Regraft (SPR) distance between two phylogenetic trees. Our result improves on the very recent 2.5-approximation algorithm due to Shi, Feng, You and Wang (2015). Our algorithm is the first approximation algorithm for this problem that uses LP duality in its analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2016; v1 submitted 18 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Improved Approximations for Cubic and Cubic Bipartite TSP
Authors:
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
We show improved approximation guarantees for the traveling salesman problem on cubic graphs, and cubic bipartite graphs. For cubic bipartite graphs with n nodes, we improve on recent results of Karp and Ravi (2014) by giving a simple "local improvement" algorithm that finds a tour of length at most 5/4 n - 2. For 2-connected cubic graphs, we show that the techniques of Moemke and Svensson (2011)…
▽ More
We show improved approximation guarantees for the traveling salesman problem on cubic graphs, and cubic bipartite graphs. For cubic bipartite graphs with n nodes, we improve on recent results of Karp and Ravi (2014) by giving a simple "local improvement" algorithm that finds a tour of length at most 5/4 n - 2. For 2-connected cubic graphs, we show that the techniques of Moemke and Svensson (2011) can be combined with the techniques of Correa, Larre and Soto (2012), to obtain a tour of length at most (4/3-1/8754)n.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2016; v1 submitted 25 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Scheduling over Scenarios on Two Machines
Authors:
Esteban Feuerstein,
Alberto Marchetti-Spaccamela,
Frans Schalekamp,
Rene Sitters,
Suzanne van der Ster,
Leen Stougie,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
We consider scheduling problems over scenarios where the goal is to find a single assignment of the jobs to the machines which performs well over all possible scenarios. Each scenario is a subset of jobs that must be executed in that scenario and all scenarios are given explicitly. The two objectives that we consider are minimizing the maximum makespan over all scenarios and minimizing the sum of…
▽ More
We consider scheduling problems over scenarios where the goal is to find a single assignment of the jobs to the machines which performs well over all possible scenarios. Each scenario is a subset of jobs that must be executed in that scenario and all scenarios are given explicitly. The two objectives that we consider are minimizing the maximum makespan over all scenarios and minimizing the sum of the makespans of all scenarios. For both versions, we give several approximation algorithms and lower bounds on their approximability. With this research into optimization problems over scenarios, we have opened a new and rich field of interesting problems.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
An Upper Bound on the Number of Circular Transpositions to Sort a Permutation
Authors:
Anke van Zuylen,
James Bieron,
Frans Schalekamp,
Gexin Yu
Abstract:
We consider the problem of upper bounding the number of circular transpositions needed to sort a permutation. It is well known that any permutation can be sorted using at most $n(n-1)/2$ adjacent transpositions. We show that, if we allow all adjacent transpositions, as well as the transposition that interchanges the element in position 1 with the element in the last position, then the number of tr…
▽ More
We consider the problem of upper bounding the number of circular transpositions needed to sort a permutation. It is well known that any permutation can be sorted using at most $n(n-1)/2$ adjacent transpositions. We show that, if we allow all adjacent transpositions, as well as the transposition that interchanges the element in position 1 with the element in the last position, then the number of transpositions needed is at most $n^2/4$. This answers an open question posed by Feng, Chitturi and Sudborough (2010).
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
On Some Recent MAX SAT Approximation Algorithms
Authors:
Matthias Poloczek,
David P. Williamson,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
Recently a number of randomized 3/4-approximation algorithms for MAX SAT have been proposed that all work in the same way: given a fixed ordering of the variables, the algorithm makes a random assignment to each variable in sequence, in which the probability of assigning each variable true or false depends on the current set of satisfied (or unsatisfied) clauses. To our knowledge, the first such a…
▽ More
Recently a number of randomized 3/4-approximation algorithms for MAX SAT have been proposed that all work in the same way: given a fixed ordering of the variables, the algorithm makes a random assignment to each variable in sequence, in which the probability of assigning each variable true or false depends on the current set of satisfied (or unsatisfied) clauses. To our knowledge, the first such algorithm was proposed by Poloczek and Schnitger; Van Zuylen subsequently gave an algorithm that set the probabilities differently and had a simpler analysis. She also set up a framework for deriving such algorithms. Buchbinder, Feldman, Naor, and Schwartz, as a special case of their work on maximizing submodular functions, also give a randomized 3/4-approximation algorithm for MAX SAT with the same structure as these previous algorithms. In this note we give a gloss on the Buchbinder et al. algorithm that makes it even simpler, and show that in fact it is equivalent to the previous algorithm of Van Zuylen. We also show how it extends to a deterministic LP rounding algorithm; such an algorithm was also given by Van Zuylen.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Split Scheduling with Uniform Setup Times
Authors:
Frans Schalekamp,
Rene Sitters,
Suzanne van der Ster,
Leen Stougie,
Victor Verdugo,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
We study a scheduling problem in which jobs may be split into parts, where the parts of a split job may be processed simultaneously on more than one machine. Each part of a job requires a setup time, however, on the machine where the job part is processed. During setup a machine cannot process or set up any other job. We concentrate on the basic case in which setup times are job-, machine-, and se…
▽ More
We study a scheduling problem in which jobs may be split into parts, where the parts of a split job may be processed simultaneously on more than one machine. Each part of a job requires a setup time, however, on the machine where the job part is processed. During setup a machine cannot process or set up any other job. We concentrate on the basic case in which setup times are job-, machine-, and sequence-independent. Problems of this kind were encountered when modelling practical problems in planning disaster relief operations. Our main algorithmic result is a polynomial-time algorithm for minimising total completion time on two parallel identical machines. We argue why the same problem with three machines is not an easy extension of the two-machine case, leaving the complexity of this case as a tantalising open problem. We give a constant-factor approximation algorithm for the general case with any number of machines and a polynomial-time approximation scheme for a fixed number of machines. For the version with objective minimising weighted total completion time we prove NP-hardness. Finally, we conclude with an overview of the state of the art for other split scheduling problems with job-, machine-, and sequence-independent setup times.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
On the Integrality Gap of the Subtour LP for the 1,2-TSP
Authors:
Jiawei Qian,
Frans Schalekamp,
David P. Williamson,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
In this paper, we study the integrality gap of the subtour LP relaxation for the traveling salesman problem in the special case when all edge costs are either 1 or 2. For the general case of symmetric costs that obey triangle inequality, a famous conjecture is that the integrality gap is 4/3. Little progress towards resolving this conjecture has been made in thirty years. We conjecture that when a…
▽ More
In this paper, we study the integrality gap of the subtour LP relaxation for the traveling salesman problem in the special case when all edge costs are either 1 or 2. For the general case of symmetric costs that obey triangle inequality, a famous conjecture is that the integrality gap is 4/3. Little progress towards resolving this conjecture has been made in thirty years. We conjecture that when all edge costs $c_{ij}\in \{1,2\}$, the integrality gap is $10/9$. We show that this conjecture is true when the optimal subtour LP solution has a certain structure. Under a weaker assumption, which is an analog of a recent conjecture by Schalekamp, Williamson and van Zuylen, we show that the integrality gap is at most $7/6$. When we do not make any assumptions on the structure of the optimal subtour LP solution, we can show that integrality gap is at most $5/4$; this is the first bound on the integrality gap of the subtour LP strictly less than $4/3$ known for an interesting special case of the TSP. We show computationally that the integrality gap is at most $10/9$ for all instances with at most 12 cities.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2014; v1 submitted 8 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
-
A Proof of the Boyd-Carr Conjecture
Authors:
Frans Schalekamp,
David P. Williamson,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
Determining the precise integrality gap for the subtour LP relaxation of the traveling salesman problem is a significant open question, with little progress made in thirty years in the general case of symmetric costs that obey triangle inequality. Boyd and Carr [3] observe that we do not even know the worst-case upper bound on the ratio of the optimal 2-matching to the subtour LP; they conjecture…
▽ More
Determining the precise integrality gap for the subtour LP relaxation of the traveling salesman problem is a significant open question, with little progress made in thirty years in the general case of symmetric costs that obey triangle inequality. Boyd and Carr [3] observe that we do not even know the worst-case upper bound on the ratio of the optimal 2-matching to the subtour LP; they conjecture the ratio is at most 10/9. In this paper, we prove the Boyd-Carr conjecture. In the case that a fractional 2-matching has no cut edge, we can further prove that an optimal 2-matching is at most 10/9 times the cost of the fractional 2-matching.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
