Sky marginalization in black hole spectroscopy and tests of the area theorem
Authors:
Alex Correia,
Collin D. Capano
Abstract:
Direct observation of gravitational waves from binary black hole (BBH) mergers has made it possible to test the laws of black hole thermodynamics using real astrophysical sources. These tests rely on accurate and unbiased parameter estimates from the pre and postmerger portions of a signal. Due to numerical complications, previous analyses have fixed the sky location and coalescence time when inde…
▽ More
Direct observation of gravitational waves from binary black hole (BBH) mergers has made it possible to test the laws of black hole thermodynamics using real astrophysical sources. These tests rely on accurate and unbiased parameter estimates from the pre and postmerger portions of a signal. Due to numerical complications, previous analyses have fixed the sky location and coalescence time when independently estimating the parameters of the pre and postmerger signal. Here we overcome the numerical complications and present a novel method of marginalizing over sky location and coalescence time. Doing so, we find that it is not possible to model only the pre or postmerger portions of the signal while marginalizing over timing uncertainty. We surmount this problem by simultaneously yet independently modeling the pre and postmerger signal, with only the sky location and coalescence time being shared between the models. This allows us to marginalize over all parameters. We use our method to measure the change in area $ΔA_{\rm measured} = A_f - A_i$ between the final and initial black holes in the BBH merger GW150914. To measure the final black hole's area $A_f$ we do an analysis using quasinormal modes (QNMs) to model the postmerger signal, and another analysis using the postmerger portion of an inspiral-merger-ringdown (IMR) template. We find excellent agreement with expectations from general relativity. The Hawking area theorem (which states that $A_f \geq A_i$) is confirmed to $95.4\%$ and $99.5\%$ confidence using the QNM and IMR postmerger models, respectively. Both models yield $ΔA_{\rm measured} / ΔA_{\rm expected} \sim 1$, where $ΔA_{\rm expected}$ is the expected change in area derived from fits to numerical relativity simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2024; v1 submitted 22 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
Low evidence for ringdown overtone in GW150914 when marginalizing over time and sky location uncertainty
Authors:
Alex Correia,
Yi-Fan Wang,
Julian Westerweck,
Collin D. Capano
Abstract:
Tests of the no-hair theorem using astrophysical black holes involve the detection of at least two quasi-normal modes (QNMs) in the gravitational wave emitted by a perturbed black hole. A detection of two modes -- the dominant, $(\ell, m, n) = (2,2,0)$, mode and its first overtone, the $(2,2,1)$ mode -- in the post-merger signal of the binary black hole merger GW150914 was claimed in Isi et al. [a…
▽ More
Tests of the no-hair theorem using astrophysical black holes involve the detection of at least two quasi-normal modes (QNMs) in the gravitational wave emitted by a perturbed black hole. A detection of two modes -- the dominant, $(\ell, m, n) = (2,2,0)$, mode and its first overtone, the $(2,2,1)$ mode -- in the post-merger signal of the binary black hole merger GW150914 was claimed in Isi et al. [arXiv:1905.00869], with further evidence provided in Isi & Farr [arXiv:2202.02941]. However, Cotesta et al. [arXiv:2201.00822] disputed this claim, finding that evidence for the overtone only appeared if the signal was analyzed before merger, when a QNM description of the signal is not valid. Due to technical challenges, both of these analyses fixed the merger time and sky location of GW150914 when estimating the evidence for the overtone. At least some of the contention can be attributed to fixing these parameters. Here, we surmount this difficulty and fully marginalize over merger time and sky-location uncertainty while doing a post-merger QNM analysis of GW150914. We find that marginalizing over all parameters yields low evidence for the presence of the overtone, with a Bayes factor of $1.10\pm 0.03$ in favor of a QNM model with the overtone versus one without. The arrival time uncertainty of GW150914 is too large to definitively claim detection of the $(2,2,1)$ mode.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2024; v1 submitted 21 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
Cassini states for black hole binaries
Authors:
Alexandre C. M. Correia
Abstract:
Cassini states correspond to the equilibria of the spin axis of a body when its orbit is perturbed. They were initially described for planetary satellites, but the spin axes of black hole binaries also present this kind of equilibria. In previous works, Cassini states were reported as spin-orbit resonances, but actually the spin of black hole binaries is in circulation and there is no resonant mot…
▽ More
Cassini states correspond to the equilibria of the spin axis of a body when its orbit is perturbed. They were initially described for planetary satellites, but the spin axes of black hole binaries also present this kind of equilibria. In previous works, Cassini states were reported as spin-orbit resonances, but actually the spin of black hole binaries is in circulation and there is no resonant motion. Here we provide a general description of the spin dynamics of black hole binary systems based on a Hamiltonian formalism. In absence of dissipation the problem is integrable and it is easy to identify all possible trajectories for the spin for a given value of the total angular momentum. As the system collapses due to radiation reaction, the Cassini states are shifted to different positions, which modifies the dynamics around them. This is why the final spin distribution may differ from the initial one. Our method provides a simple way of predicting the distribution of the spin of black hole binaries at the end of the inspiral phase.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2016; v1 submitted 5 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
