Contestado War: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
Citation bot (talk | contribs)
Add: doi, jstor. | Use this bot. Report bugs. | Suggested by Superegz | Category:Conflicts in 1914 | #UCB_Category 74/135
 
(44 intermediate revisions by 24 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{Short description|Guerrilla war for land between settlers and landowners, in Brazil}}
{{multiple issues|
{{essay|date=October 2012}}
{{more footnotes needed|date=November 2014}}
{{Infobox military conflict
| image = Aviação na Guerra do Contestado.jpg
| image_size = 300px
| caption = Aviation of the Brazilian Army in the Contestado War, in 1915.
| conflict = Contestado War
| casus = Social Conflictsunrest, Religious Fanaticism, Proclamation of the Republic
| date = October, 1912 – August, 1916
| place = [[Santa Catarina (state)|Santa Catarina]] and [[Paraná (state)|Paraná]], Southern Brazil
| result = Government victory
| combatant1 =[[Image: {{flagicon image|Bandeira do Contestado.svg|border|25px]]}} Celestial Monarchy RebelsComune
| combatant2 = {{plainlist |
*{{flag|First Brazilian Republic|name=Brazil}}
}}
*[[Brazilian Army in the First Republic|Brazilian Army]]
 
{{plainlist |
{{Infobox War
*{{Flagiconflagicon image|Bandeira estadual do Paraná|name=Paraná 1905.svg}} [[Paraná (state)|Paraná State]]
|image=Aviação na Guerra do Contestado.jpg
|image_size=300px
|caption= Aviation of the Brazilian Army in the Contestado War, in 1915.
|conflict=Contestado War
|casus=Social Conflicts, Religious Fanaticism, Proclamation of the Republic
|date=October, 1912 – August, 1916
|place=[[Santa Catarina (state)|Santa Catarina]] and [[Paraná (state)|Paraná]], Southern Brazil
|result=Governist Victory
|combatant1=[[Image:Bandeira do Contestado.svg|border|25px]] Rebels
|combatant2=[[Image:Flag of Brazil (1889-1960).svg|border|25px]] [[First Brazilian Republic]]
*[[File:Coat of arms of the Brazilian Army.svg|15px]] [[Brazilian Army]]
**[[File:Roundel of Brazil.svg|15px]] [[Brazilian Air Force|Army Aviation]]
{{Flagicon|Paraná|name=Paraná}} [[Paraná (state)|Paraná State]]
*[[File:Brasão Nacional PPMM.PNG|15px]] [[Military Police of Paraná State|Regiment of Security of Paraná State]]
|commander1=[[Image:Bandeira do Contestado.svg|border|25px]] [[José Maria de Santo Agostinho]]{{KIA}}<br>[[Image:Bandeira do Contestado.svg|border|25px]] Maria Rosa {{KIA}}<br>[[Image:Bandeira do Contestado.svg|border|25px]] Adeodato {{surrendered}}
|commander2={{Flagicon|Brazil|1889}} Marechal [[Hermes da Fonseca]]<br>{{Flagicon|Brazil|1889}} Gen. [[Carlos Frederico de Mesquita]]<br>{{Flagicon|Brazil|1889}} Gen. Setembrino de Carvalho <br>{{Flagicon|Brazil|1889}} Col. Estillac <br>{{Flagicon|Paraná|name=Paraná}}Col. Gomes de Sá Filho {{KIA}}<br> {{Flagicon|Brazil|1889}} Major Tertuliano Potiguara
|strength1=10,000 rebels
|strength2=7,000 Army soldiers <br> 1,000 local police<br>1,000 civil militiamen<br>3 aircraft
|casualties1=5,000 – 8,000 dead, wounded or disappeared
|casualties2=800 – 1,000 dead, wounded, deserted or disappeared
}}
*[[Military Police of Paraná State|Police]]
The '''Contestado War''' ({{lang-pt|Guerra do Contestado}}), broadly speaking, was a guerrilla war for land between settlers and landowners, the latter supported by the Brazilian state's police and military forces, that lasted from October 1912 to August 1916.
| commander1 = {{plainlist |
*{{flagicon image|Bandeira do Contestado.svg|border}} [[José Maria de Santo Agostinho|José M. Agostinho]]{{KIA}}
*{{flagicon image|Bandeira do Contestado.svg|border}} {{interlanguage link|Maria Rosa (Contestado)|pt|lt=Maria Rosa}}{{KIA}}
*{{flagicon image|Bandeira do Contestado.svg|border}} Adeodato{{surrendered}}
}}
| commander2 = {{plainlist |
*{{flagicon|Brazil|1889}} [[Hermes da Fonseca]]
*{{flagicon|Brazil|1889}} [[Carlos Frederico de Mesquita|Carlos de Mesquita]]
*{{flagicon|Brazil|1889}} {{interlanguage link|Setembrino de Carvalho|pt|lt=S. de Carvalho}}
*{{flagicon|Brazil|1889}} [[Francisco Raul Estillac Leal|Francisco Estillac]]
*{{flagicon|Brazil|1889}} [[Tertuliano Potiguara]]
*{{flagicon image|Bandeira estadual do Paraná 1905.svg|border}} Gomes de Sá Filho{{KIA}}
}}
| strength1 = 10,000 rebels
| strength2 = 7,000 Army soldiers <br> 1,000 local police<br>1,000 civil militiamen<br>3 aircraft
| casualties1 = 5,000 – 8000–8,000 dead, wounded or disappeared
| casualties2=800 1 = 800–1,000 dead, wounded, deserted or disappeared
}}
The '''Contestado War''' ({{lang-pt|Guerra do Contestado}}), broadly speaking, was a guerrilla war for land between settlers and landowners, the latter supported by the Brazilian state's police and military forces, that lasted from October 1912 to August 1916.<ref name=":0">{{Cite book |last=Welch |first=Cliff |title=Fifty years of peasant wars in Latin America |publisher=Berghahn |year=2020 |isbn=978-1-78920-561-9 |editor-last=Binford |editor-first=Leigh |edition=1st |series=Dislocations |location=New York |pages=147–148 |editor-last2=Gill |editor-first2=Lesley |editor-last3=Striffler |editor-first3=Steve}}</ref>
 
It was fought in an inland southern region of the country, rich in wood and [[yerba mate]],<ref name=":2">{{Cite book |last=Pinheiro Machado |first=Roberto |url=https://www.worldcat.org/title/on1007557996 |title=Brazilian history: culture, society, politics 1500-2010 |publisher=Cambridge Scholars Publishing |year=2018 |isbn=978-1-5275-0349-6 |location=Newcastle upon Tyne, UK |pages=147 |oclc=on1007557996}}</ref> that was called Contestado because it was contested by the states of [[Paraná (state)|Paraná]] and [[Santa Catarina (state)|Santa Catarina]] as well as [[Argentina]]. The war had its casus belli in the social conflicts in the region, the result of local disobediences, particularly regarding the regularization of [[land ownership]] on the part of the [[caboclo]]s. The conflict was permeated by religious fanaticism expressed by the messianism and faith of the rebellious caboclos that they were engaged in a [[religious war]]; at the same time, it reflected the dissatisfaction of the population with its material situation.<ref name=":0" />
 
==Background==
 
===Societal prominence of monks===
The origins of the Contestado War canis beoften understoodconsidered bestto byhave beginningmany aroots little earlier and consideringin the influence of three [[monk]]s of the region. The first one who rose to prominence was [[João Maria D'Agostini]], a man of Italian origin, who wandered, preaching and attending to the sick, from 1844 to 1870. He lived a very simple life, and his ethics and lifestyle attracted thousands of followers. Although many sources say he died in 1870, he actually left Brazil in 1852; after traveling in Mexico, Cuba, and Canada, he was killed in April, 1869; in Mesilla, New Mexico, USA in April, 1869.<ref name=Thomas2014>{{cite book|first=David G.|last=Thomas|year=2014|title=Giovanni Maria de Agostini, Wonder of the Century: The Astonishing World Traveler Who Was A Hermit |publisher=Doc45 Publishing|asinisbn=0692247408978-0692247402 }}</ref>
 
The second monk also adopted the alias of João Maria, although his real name was [[Atanás Marcaf]], probably of [[Syria]]n origin. He appeared to the public during the [[Federalist Revolution]] of 1893; where he belonged to the [[Maragato (Brazil)|Maragato]] faction, and projected a firm and even messianic stature. He even made prophecies about the political events of his time. He was active in the region between the [[Rio Iguaçu|Iguaçu]] and [[Uruguay River|Uruguay]] rivers.{{Citation Asneeded|date=March a2024}} signIn ofaddition to his unquestionedreligious influence over the faithfulactivities, ahe portionwould ofalso themgain waiteda forreputation hisas returna byhealer resurrectionbefore afterdisappearing hisfrom disappearancethe region in 1908.<ref name=":0" />
 
TheIn wait1912, ofA thethird faithfulmonk endedcame in 1912, whento the figurenotice of the thirdpublic monkin appearedthe in publicregion. He was initially known as an herbal healer, having presented himself under the name of José Maria de Santo Agostinho.<ref name=":1">{{Cite book |last=Diacon |first=Todd A. |title=Millenarian vision, capitalist reality: Brazil's Contestado rebellion, 1912-1916 |publisher=Duke University Press |year=1991 |isbn=978-0-8223-1157-7 |location=Durham |pages=1–2}}</ref> However, according to a report of the police of Vila de Palmas, Paraná state, he was, in reality, an army deserter who had been convicted of [[rape]], by the name of Miguel Lucena de Boaventura.{{Citation needed|date=March 2024}}
The second monk also adopted the alias of João Maria, although his real name was [[Atanás Marcaf]], probably of [[Syria]]n origin. He appeared to the public during the Federalist Revolution of 1893; he belonged to the [[Maragato (Brazil)|Maragato]] faction, and projected a firm and even messianic stature. He even made prophecies about the political events of his time. He was active in the region between the [[Rio Iguaçu|Iguaçu]] and [[Uruguay River|Uruguay]] rivers. As a sign of his unquestioned influence over the faithful, a portion of them waited for his return by resurrection after his disappearance in 1908.
 
BecauseDue noin onepart knewto his origins,claimed andassociation becausewith hethe livedregionally aknown straightfigure andof honestJoão lifeMaria, itthe wasanonymity notof difficulthis forpast, himand tohis achieveconduct theas people'sa admirationherbal andhealer, confidenceJosé inMaria soon became a shortrespected periodand ofinfluential timefigure in the region. OneHe ofwould hissoon claimsamass toa famereligious wasfollowing from the accountlocals, ofand hisit resurrectionwould ofbe claimed he performed a youngnumber ladyof (whomiracles, probablyone wasof justthe amost victimprominent being the claimed resurrection of [[catalepsy]])another individual.<ref name=":1" /> He was also said to have cured the colonel Francisco de Almeida's wife of a previously uncurable illness. After this event the monk won even more fame and trust by declining the land and significant quantity of gold that the grateful colonel offered him.{{Citation needed|date=March 2024}}
The wait of the faithful ended in 1912, when the figure of the third monk appeared in public. He was initially known as an herbal healer, having presented himself under the name of José Maria de Santo Agostinho. However, according to a report of the police of Vila de Palmas, Paraná state, he was, in reality, an army deserter who had been convicted of [[rape]], by the name of Miguel Lucena de Boaventura.
 
From this point on, José Maria began to be considered a [[saint]]: a man who had come to Earth only to heal the sick and aid the needy. Methodical and organized, he was quite different from the familiar healers. He knew how to read and write and he described in his notebooks the medical properties of the plants found in the region. With the permission of Colonel Almeida, he set up what was known as the "people's [[pharmacy]]" at the ranch of one of the foremen, where he stored up medicinal herbs that he used in his daily medical consultations with anyone who wished to visit him, until the late hours of the night.{{Citation needed|date=March 2024}}
Because no one knew his origins, and because he lived a straight and honest life, it was not difficult for him to achieve the people's admiration and confidence in a short period of time. One of his claims to fame was the account of his resurrection of a young lady (who probably was just a victim of [[catalepsy]]). He was also said to have cured the colonel Francisco de Almeida's wife of a previously uncurable illness. After this event the monk won even more fame and trust by declining the land and significant quantity of gold that the grateful colonel offered him.
 
José Maria's preaching displayed acutely Monarchist sentiments and adopting a highly adversarial stance towards the existing national government of Brazil. This intense endorsement of monarchy as a form of government would come to inform the shape of the Contestado war's partisan movement.<ref name=":1" />
From this point on, José Maria began to be considered a [[saint]]: a man who had come to Earth only to heal the sick and aid the needy. Methodical and organized, he was quite different from the familiar healers. He knew how to read and write and he described in his notebooks the medical properties of the plants found in the region. With the permission of Colonel Almeida, he set up what was known as the "people's [[pharmacy]]" at the ranch of one of the foremen, where he stored up medicinal herbs that he used in his daily medical consultations with anyone who wished to visit him, until the late hours of the night.
 
===Railroad===
[[Image:08 tory railtrack ubt.jpeg|right|thumb|300px|The railroad, one of the causes of the Contestado War]]
 
A foreign companyConstruction was commissionedunderway toon finisha the railroadrailway that waswould to have been begun in 1890 by the engineer [[João Teixeira Soares]]. This railroad wouldrun connectbetween the cities of [[São Paulo (city)|São Paulo]] to [[Santa Maria, Rio Grande do Sul|Santa Maria]], in the southern Brazilian state [[Rio Grande do Sul]], statemuch of which ran through the contested territory. AsThe Teixeiraconstruction didof not,this orrailroad couldwas not,commissioned takeby onPresident theAfonso projectPena in 1908, and the responsibilitytask waswould transferredbe in 1908contracted to a North American based company known as the ''[[Brazil Railway Company]]'', aunder north-Americanthe companyownership owned byof [[Percival Farquhar]].<ref name=":2" />
 
BesidesIn addition to the right to finish the project, the company also obtained from the government the right to explore a strip of land 15&nbsp;km (9.32&nbsp;mi) wide on each side of the railroad. The Company thus legally seized ownership of the land that it bordered and offered work to local families during the construction of the railroad. A number of communities in the region, living off subsistence agriculture, existed in the path of this newly privatized strip of land leading to the expulsion of many farmers of the region from the land they occupied.<ref name=":3">{{Cite journal |last=Diacon |first=Todd A. |date=Jul 1, 1991 |title=The Search for Meaning in an Historical Context: Popular Religion, Millenarianism, and the Contestado Rebellion |url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/3513282 |journal=Luso-Brazilian Review |volume=28 |issue=1 |pages=50–51 |jstor=3513282 |via=JSTOR}}</ref>
 
At the same time, the concession guaranteed that another associated company of the trust, the Southern Brazil Lumber & Colonization, would have the rights to extract lumber and later resell the land.<ref name=":2" />
 
It was estimated that 8000 men had worked for the railroad at the time;<ref name=":3" /> with the workers coming largely from the urban populations of cities Rio de Janeiro and Pernambuco.<ref name=":4">{{Cite journal |last=Siegel |first=Bernard J. |date=Jul 1, Santos1977 |title=The Contestado Rebellion, Salvador1912-16: andA RecifeCase attractedStudy byin theBrazilian possibilityMessianism and Regional Dynamics |url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/3629739 |journal=Journal of highAnthropological wagesResearch and|volume=33 other|issue=2 advantages|pages=205 |doi=10.1086/jar.33.2.3629739 |jstor=3629739 |via=JSTOR}}</ref>
 
However, by the time the construction work was finished a large number of people were left without work or a place to go (as much land around the railroad was legally owned by the Trust) adding to unrestthe amidlocal dissatisfactionunrest.<ref name=":3" />
 
<!--
==The conflict start==
'''Thousands of the''' workers that were laid off once the railroad construction work was finished, joined with '''A large portion of''' local peasants '''that had been evicted from the land they had lived on, led by José Maria.'''<ref name=":4" />
The local peasants that lost the rights to use the land where they once lived, as well as the workers that were laid off once the railroad construction work was finished, eventually became José Maria's followers and set up a community under his leadership.
 
[[Image:VeluweTreeTrunk.jpg|thumb|300px|Lumber, one of the commodities extracted by the railroad company during the Contestado uprising]]
The "holy monk" José Maria rose against the recently created Republic of Brazil (1889), effectively declaring his community to be ruled by an independent government. He also declared the Republic to be "the devil's law".<ref>Diacon, ''Millenarian Vision,'' 116</ref> He appointed an illiterate farmer to be "Emperor of Brazil", founded the community of Quadro Santo and created a personal guard corps of 12 men, in an allusion to [[Charlemagne]]'s knights.{{Citation needed|date=March 2024}}
 
Peasants followed him around, founding more communities, each one with an assigned patron saint in hopes of creating a "heavenly monarchy" similar to Antonio Conselheiro (the messianic leader from the [[Canudos]] rebellion in [[Bahia]] during the late 1890s).
 
The monk's popularity by then was at its peak. He was invited to the Senhor do Bom Jesus celebrations in Taquaruçu (modern-day [[Curitibanos]]) whereby he was followed by about 300 supporters. He also treated people and prescribed herbal medication to them.
 
Wary of the developments in Taquaruçu and afraid of losing influence in the local affairs around the town of Curitibanos, Colonel Franciso de Albuquerque, a rival of Col. Almeida, sent a telegram to the state capital requesting assistance against "rebels that proclaimed a new monarchy in Taquaruçu".
-->
 
==The first casualties==
[[File:HermesFonseca.jpg|right|thumb|200px|Marshal Hermes da Fonseca, President of Brazil]]
[[File:Contestado tropas em marcha.jpg|thumb|left|250px200px|Infantry of the Police Corps marching towards the battle. Commander João Gualberto (mounted on the horse), leading the troop, was killed in combat soon after the photograph]]
 
The Brazilian government, then led by Marshal [[Hermes da Fonseca]] who was responsible for the policy of military interventions in other states in order to eliminate political adversaries, decided to send federal troops to that region in order to quell the rebellion.
 
Foreseeing what was coming, José Maria ([[Miguel Lucena Boaventura]]) left immediately for the border town of Irani with his followers. Irani at the time belonged to the municipality of [[Palmas, Paraná|Palmas]] which was within the jurisdiction of the state of Paraná. As Paraná and Santa Catarina then had unresolved land disputes, the government of Paraná regarded this mass relocation of people as a strategy by the State of Santa Catarina to occupy and claim those lands. So the Contestado war began there in October 1912. In order to prevent the sudden mass occupation of that land, some troops of the [[Military Police of Paraná State|Regiment of Security of Paraná State]] were sent out to force the invaders to return to Santa Catarina.
[[File:Contestado tropas em marcha.jpg|thumb|left|250px|Infantry of the Police Corps marching towards the battle.]]
So the Contestado war began there in October 1912. In order to prevent the sudden mass occupation of that land, some troops of the [[Military Police of Paraná State|Regiment of Security of Paraná State]] were sent out to force the invaders to return to Santa Catarina.
 
But things did not go as planned. A bloody confrontation started between government troops and followers of the Contestado at a place called Banhado Grande. At the end of the battle, dozens of people from both sides were dead, and the rebels seized a large number of guns and amounts of ammunition from the Paraná police forces. Among those killed were Colonel Gualberto João, who commanded the troops, and also the Monk Jose Maria, but the partisans of the Contestado had obtained their first victory.
Line 82 ⟶ 94:
Jose Maria was buried by his followers, who hoped for his resurrection (in similar fashion to the legend of the king Sebastian of Portugal, who was revered by some messianic followers of [[Sebastianism]]).
 
The federal government sent in 200 federal troops on December 29, 1913, in order to deal with the rebellion. Once again, the government was upset by the fierce opposition. For some historians, this is considered to be the official beginning of the war, despite the initial confrontations back in 1912.
 
==More conflicts,Further attacksArmed Conflict and counter-attacksViolence ==
On February 8, 1914, the federal and state governments sent 700 men to Taquaruçu, supported by artillery and machine guns. Caraguatá was a more remote location where 2,000 other people had already settled. The followers in Caraguatá were led by Maria Rosa, a 15-year-old girl who led the 6000-strong armed rebellion after the death of José Maria.
[[File:Contestado tropa Exército.jpg|thumb|left|250px200px|Army soldiers garrisoningdefending locksmithsawmill during rebel attack in Três Barras (SC).]]
In March and May of that year other expeditions were sent out,; however, they were all unsuccessful. As the social order degraded quickly in the region, the central government appointed General Carlos Frederico de Mesquita (a veteran of the Canudos rebellion) to lead a new operation against the rebels. He led an assault on the village of Santo Antônio da Platina, causing the rebels to flee. The hamlet of Caraguatá where the federal troops were first chased from by the rebels was now struck by [[typhoid fever]]. General Mesquita mistakenly believed the rebels were finally dispersed and declared the war was over.
 
However, peace was to be short-lived. The rebels quickly regrouped and organized around Santa Maria, intensifying the attacks: they took and set fire to the Calmon rail station; destroyed the village of São João (present-day Matos Costa), they attacked Curitibanos and threatened Porto União, causing the population to flee. There were rumours that they were on their way to invade the city of [[Ponta Grossa]] and some believed the rebels and their army would march all the way to [[Rio de Janeiro]] in order to oust the President. The rebels at the time already controlled 25,000&nbsp;km<sup>2</sup>.
Line 94 ⟶ 106:
 
==Change of strategy and the war's end==
[[File:Combate no Contestado.jpg|thumb|left|200px|Brazilian Army soldiers in combat]]
At this point in the war Deodato Manuel Ramos (also known as Adeodato) became a prominent figure, and he is considered by historians to be the last leader of the Contestadores. Adeodato moved the capital of the rebellious territory over to the Santa Maria valley, where he amassed about 5,000 men. As food and other shortages increased, he became more ruthless in dealing orders, including the execution of those willing to turn themselves in.
[[File:José Maria Monge do Contestado 2.jpg|right|thumb|230px|José Maria (died 1912), monk who led the Contestado revolt, with three followers.]]
Line 119 ⟶ 132:
*Population living in the combat area: about 40,000 inhabitants
*Municipalities of Paraná (at the time): [[Rio Negro, Brazil|Rio Negro]], [[Itaiópolis]], [[Timbó]], [[Três Barras]], [[União da Vitória]] and [[Palmas, Paraná|Palmas]]
*Municipalities of Santa Catarina (at the time): [[Lages]], [[Curitibanos]], [[Campos Novos]], [[Canoinhas]] and [[CanoinhasTimbó Grande]]
<!--
==Alguns Antecedentes e Precedentes==
Line 187 ⟶ 200:
 
==External links==
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20120728075050/http://www.onwar.com/aced/data/bravo/brazil1914.htm Onwar]
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20040421120901/http://www.scscertified.com/PDFS/forest_madepar_eng.pdf Article]
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20040805123124/http://www.unc.edu/depts/geog/people/faculty/wolford/AnnalsMST.PDF UNC article with a brief mention]
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20060904083734/http://research.yale.edu/ycias/database/files/MESV6-1.pdf Brief mention on a Yale site].
 
{{Authority control}}
 
[[Category:First Brazilian Republic]]
[[Category:Rebellions in Brazil]]
[[Category:Conflicts in 1912]]