California Criminal Syndicalism Act: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
No edit summary
Citation bot (talk | contribs)
Added publisher. | Use this bot. Report bugs. | Suggested by Whoop whoop pull up | Category:Industrial Workers of the World in California | #UCB_Category 3/12
 
(44 intermediate revisions by 23 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{Short description|1919 law prohibiting certain leftist politics}}
The '''California Criminal Syndicalism Act''' ([[California Penal Code]] §§ 11400 et seq.) was a [[law of California]] in 1919 under Governor [[William Stephens]] criminalizing [[syndicalism]].<ref>Added by California Stats. 1919, c. 188, p. 281. Renumbered by California Stats 1953, c. 32.</ref> It was repealed in 1991.<ref>Repealed by California Stats. 1991, c. 186 (A.B. 436).</ref> One of the Act's most well-known convictions was that of [[Charlotte Anita Whitney]], which led to the Act being upheld by the [[Supreme Court of the United States]] in ''[[Whitney v. California]]'' (1927), which was itself explicitly overturned in ''[[Brandenburg v. Ohio]]'' (1969), effectively declaring the Act unconstitutional.<ref name="encyclopedia"/>
{{Infobox U.S. State legislation
| State = California
| Full_name =
| Introduced =
| Assembly_Voted =
| Senate_Voted =
| Signed = {{font color|green|Yes}}
| Sponsors =
| Governor =
| Code =
| Section =
| Associated_bills =
| URL =
| Status = repealed
}}
{{California law}}
The '''California Criminal Syndicalism Act''' ([https://web.archive.org/web/20111002140955/http://192.234.213.35/clerkarchive/archive/Statutes/1919/19Vol1_Chapters.pdf Stats. 1919], c. 188, p. 281; it was [[codification (law)|codified]] at [[California Penal Code]] §§ 11400 et seq.)<ref>Added by California Stats. 1919, c. 188, p. 281. Renumbered by California Stats 1953, c. 32.</ref> was a [[law of California]] in 1919 under Governor [[William Stephens (American politician)|William Stephens]] criminalizing [[syndicalism]]. It was enacted on April 30, 1919, and repealed in 1991.<ref>Repealed by California Stats. 1991, c. 186 (A.B. 436).</ref> The law stated that "any person who was a member of any organization that advocated criminal syndicalism was guilty of a [[felony]] and punishable by up to 14 years in the [[Prisons in California|state prison]]. The law is significant, and controversial, because it made certain beliefs illegal. A person did not have to commit any overt act. Simple advocacy of a certain belief or membership in a group that advocated syndicalism was enough to secure a conviction".{{sfnp|McClellan|2011|page=91}}
 
The '''California Criminal Syndicalism Act''' ([[California Penal Code]] §§ 11400 et seq.) was a [[law of California]] in 1919 under Governor [[William Stephens]] criminalizing [[syndicalism]].<ref>Added by California Stats. 1919, c. 188, p. 281. Renumbered by California Stats 1953, c. 32.</ref> It was repealed in 1991.<ref>Repealed by California Stats. 1991, c. 186 (A.B. 436).</ref> One of the Act's most wellbest-known convictions was that of [[Charlotte Anita Whitney]], which led to the Act being upheld by the [[Supreme Court of the United States]] in ''[[Whitney v. California]]'' (1927), which was itself explicitly overturned in ''[[Brandenburg v. Ohio]]'' (1969), effectively declaring the Act unconstitutional.<ref name{{sfn|Green|2009|p="encyclopedia"/>85}}
The Act must be viewed in the context of the [[First Red Scare]] and the turbulent [[labor history of the United States]] in the early [[20th Century]].{{sfn|Whitten|1969|p=4}} From 1910–1920, 20 states enacted laws criminalizing syndicalism.<ref name="encyclopedia">{{cite book | title= Encyclopedia of Censorship | first= Jonathon | last= Green | editor-first= Nicholas J | editor-last= Karolides | year= 2009 | page= 85 | publisher= [[Infobase Publishing]] | series= Facts on File Library of World History | isbn= 0-8160-4464-3 | url= http://books.google.com/books?id=bunHURgi7FcC&pg=PA85}}</ref>
 
The Act must be viewed in the context of the [[First Red Scare]] and the turbulent [[labor history of the United States]] in the early 20th century.{{sfn|Whitten|1969|p=4}} From 1910 to 1920, 20 states enacted laws [[criminal syndicalism|criminalizing syndicalism]].{{sfn|Green|2009|p=85}}
 
==Convictions==
One of the Act's most wellbest-known convictions was that of [[Charlotte Anita Whitney]] in 1920, which led to the Act being upheld by the [[Supreme Court of the United States]] in ''[[Whitney v. California]]'' (1927), which was itself explicitly overturned in ''[[Brandenburg v. Ohio]]'' (1969), effectively declaring the Act unconstitutional.<ref name="encyclopedia"/>
 
In April 1930, meetings of the [[Agricultural Workers' Industrial League]] (AWIL) across [[Imperial Valley]] but centered around [[El Centro, California|El Centro]] were raided by the [[Imperial County, California|Imperial County]] [[Sheriff]].{{sfn|Daniel|1981|p=121}} Of the hundreds arrested, 16 were charged by the [[Imperial County, California|Imperial County]] [[Grand Jury]] with violations of the Criminal Syndicalism Act,{{sfn|Daniel|1981|p=121}} and 8 were convicted on {{date|13 June 1930}} and received sentences ranging from deportation to 42 years in prison.{{sfn|Daniel|1981|p=124}} In 1931, the conviction of Frank Spector was reversed by the [[California Court of Appeal for the Fourth District]] in [[Fresno, California]].{{sfn|Daniel|1981|p=125}} All of the convicts were [[parole]]d by 1933.{{sfn|Daniel|1981|p=126}}
 
According to journalist and historian [[Carey McWilliams (journalist)|Carey McWilliams]], there were 531 indictments for violation of the Criminal Syndicalism Act between 1919 and 1924, and "Of those arrested, 264 were tried, 164 convicted, and 128 were sentenced to [[San Quentin Prison]] for terms of from one to fourteen years. A large part of these prosecutions arose in Southern California."{{sfnp|McWilliams|1973|pp=290–291}}
 
==Notes==
{{reflist|2}}
 
==References==
{{reflist}}
{{refbegin}}
* {{cite journalbook | title= CriminalBitter SyndicalismHarvest: andA theHistory Law inof California: 1919–1927Farmworkers, | first= Woodrow C.1870–1941 | last= WhittenDaniel | journalfirst= [[TransactionsCletus of the American Philosophical Society]]E. | volumeyear= 591981 | issuepublisher= 2Cornell | date= MarchUniversity 1969Press | pagesisbn= 3–730-8014-1284-6 | jstoroclc= 10060216915093 | refurl= harvhttps://archive.org/details/bitterharvesthis0000dani }}
The* Act must be viewed in the context of the [[First Red Scare]] and the turbulent [[labor history of the United States]] in the early [[20th Century]].{{sfn|Whitten|1969|p=4}} From 1910–1920, 20 states enacted laws criminalizing syndicalism.<ref name="encyclopedia">{{cite book | title= Encyclopedia of Censorship | first= Jonathon | last= Green | editor-first= Nicholas J | editor-last= Karolides | year= 2009 | page= 85 | publisher= [[Infobase Publishing]] | series= Facts on File Library of World History | isbn= 978-0-8160-4464-31 | url= httphttps://books.google.com/books?id=bunHURgi7FcC&pg=PA85 }}</ref>
* {{cite book | title= Helen Hosmer: A Radical Critic of California Agribusiness in the 1930s | last1= Hosmer | first1= Helen | last2= Jarrell | first2= Randall | authorlink2= Randall Jarrell | url= http://content.cdlib.org/view?docId=hb4b69n74p&brand=calisphere&doc.view=entire_text | oclc= 647238738}}
* {{cite book | title= BitterHelen HarvestHosmer: A HistoryRadical Critic of California Farmworkers,Agribusiness 1870-1941in the 1930s | lastlast1= DanielHosmer | firstfirst1= Cletus E.Helen | yearlast2= 1981Jarrell | isbnfirst2= 0-8014Randall |author-1284-6link2= Randall Jarrell | oclcurl= 6915093http://content.cdlib.org/view?docId=hb4b69n74p&brand=calisphere&doc.view=entire_text | refoclc= harv647238738}}
* {{cite thesis |last=McClellan |first=Scott Allen |date=2011 |title=Policing the Red Scare: The Los Angeles Police Department's Red Squad and the Repression of Labor Activism in Los Angeles, 1900–1940 |work= |publisher=University of California, Irvine |location= |page= |url= |access-date= |isbn= |issn= |oclc= |id={{ProQuest|3442998}} }}
* {{cite book |last=McWilliams |first=Carey |author-link=Carey McWilliams (journalist) |title=Southern California Country: An Island on the Land |chapter=Chapter XIV. The Politics of Utopia |series=[[American Folkways Series]] |date=1973 |edition=Reprint |publisher=Peregrine Smith Books |location=Salt Lake City, Utah |isbn=0-87905-007-1 |lccn=73077787 |orig-date=1946}}
* {{cite journal | title= Criminal Syndicalism and the Law in California: 1919–1927 | first= Woodrow C. | last= Whitten | journal= [[Transactions of the American Philosophical Society]] | volume= 59 | issue= 2 | date= March 1969 | pages= 3–73 | doi= 10.2307/1006021 | jstor= 1006021 }}
{{refend}}
 
[[Category:California statutes|Criminal Syndicalism Act]]
 
{{US-law-stub}}
 
[[Category:California statutes]]
[[Category:Syndicalism]]
[[Category:1919 in American law]]
[[Category:1919 in California|Criminal Syndicalism Act]]
[[Category:1991 in American law]]
[[Category:1991 in California|Criminal Syndicalism Act]]
[[Category:History of labor relations in the United States]]
[[Category:Industrial Workers of the World in California]]
[[Category:Anti-communism in the United States]]
[[Category:Anti-anarchism in the United States]]
[[Category:Political repression in the United States]]
[[Category:Censorship in the United States]]