Content deleted Content added
→IDL rollback: Reply |
→IDL rollback: Reply |
||
Line 267:
:#Snyder's book received acclaim in the general press, but severe criticism by many scholars of the time period in question. Thus mentioning the scholarly criticism is essential
:You did fix some overlinking issues, which I've restored ([[User talk:Buidhe|t]] · [[Special:Contributions/Buidhe|c]]) '''[[User:buidhe|<span style="color: black">buidhe</span>]]''' 06:49, 2 March 2024 (UTC)
::oh let's see. First of all, none of that is the sort of vandalism that would make it appropriate to roll back seven (7) edits, each with a detailed justification. I will get to my own issues with the article but first let's address your points.
::#You assumed I was never coming here. I should not have not remind you to AGF, but then I should not have to point out that these edits are far from vandalism
::#I am fairly certain this happened under the Soviets. Possibly I am wrong about that and if I am mistaken then so be it, but I would like to see a source that isn't from the popular press, please. I do not dispute that this happened, nor the rest of the sentence. There is nothing "incorrect" about this.
::#Re typo: of so my bad but this is not an excuse to rollback seven (7) edits. Re page range: yes, a range is specified. A '''very large''' range. This is hand-waving.
::#Call him a linguist then. "Scholar" is an appeal to authority and thus fallacious
::#this text amounts to "etc", which I always remove per MoS. If they are important mention them also, at least in a note.
::#I am very familiar with the book. I will get to the due weight issues but for now I will just say that academic criticism should be cited by academic sources, which are in any event required by the December Arbcom decision.
::The mobile interface tends to scramble the text window if a post gets too long so...there is my answer to your post. I have more comments that I would have posted but I will come back to those. [[User:Elinruby|Elinruby]] ([[User talk:Elinruby|talk]]) 07:40, 2 March 2024 (UTC)
| |||