List of freedom indices

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by DaisyGeekyTransGirl (talk | contribs) at 01:20, 7 May 2022 (2022 scores are out.). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

This article contains a list of freedom indices produced by several non-governmental organizations that publish and maintain assessments of the state of freedom in the world, according to their own various definitions of the term, and rank countries as being free, partly free, or using various measures of freedom, including civil liberties, political rights and economic rights.

Prominent indices

The indices and their origins.

  • Kanada
    • The Economic Freedom of the World Index is a report published by Canada-based Fraser Institute in conjunction with the Economic Freedom Network, a group of independent research and educational institutes in 90 nations and territories worldwide. It is a numeric index, and its results are not currently included in the table below.
  • Kanada, Vereinigte Staaten, Deutschland
    • The Human Freedom Index presents the state of human freedom in the world based on a broad measure that encompasses personal, civil, and economic freedom.[1] The index presents a broad measure of human freedom, understood as the absence of coercive constraint. It uses 79 distinct indicators of personal and economic freedom. The index covers the following areas: Rule of Law, Security and Safety, Movement, Religion, Association, Assembly, Civil Society, Expression, Relationships, Size of Government, Legal System and Property Rights, Access to Sound Money, Freedom to Trade Internationally, and Regulation of Credit, Labor, and Business. The Human Freedom Index was created in 2015, covering 152 countries for years 2008–2012. The Human Freedom Index 2016 was published in November 2016, covering 159 countries for years 2008–2015. The report is co-published by the Cato Institute, the Fraser Institute, and the Liberales Institut at the Friedrich Naumann Foundation for Freedom. Co-authors of the report are Ian Vásquez and Tanja Porčnik.
    • The Index of Freedom in the World was a predecessor to the Human Freedom Index. It measured classical civil liberties and was published in 2013 by Canada's Fraser Institute, Germany's Liberales Institute, and the U.S. Cato Institute.[2] It is not currently included in the table below.
  • Frankreich
    • Worldwide Press Freedom Index, is published each year since 2002 (except that 2011 was combined with 2012) by France-based Reporters Without Borders. Countries are assessed as having a good situation, a satisfactory situation, noticeable problems, a difficult situation, or a very serious situation.[3]
  • Spanien
    • The World Index of Moral Freedom was first published on 2 April 2016, by the Foundation for the Advancement of Liberty, based in Madrid, Spain. This index ranks 160 countries by five categories of indicators: religious freedom, bioethical freedom, drugs freedom, sexuality freedom and family and gender freedom. The index aims at establishing the degree of individual freedom or state control on decisions pertaining to the great moral debates of our time.[4]
  • Schweden
    • MaxRange, developed by Max Rånge, and maintained by Mikael Sandberg and Max Rånge, political scientists at Halmstad University, Sweden, is a data set defining a country's level of democracy and institutional structure (regime-type) on a 1000-point graded scale. Values are sorted based on level of democracy and political accountability. MaxRange defines the value corresponding to all states every month from 1789 to the present.[5]
    • Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) Institute, the V-Dem Institute, the Department of Political Science at the University of Gothenburg, Sweden, is an approach to conceptualizing and measuring democracy. It provides a multidimensional and disaggregated dataset that reflects the complexity of the concept of democracy as a system of rule that goes beyond the simple presence of elections. The V-Dem project distinguishes between five high-level principles of democracy: electoral, liberal, participatory, deliberative, and egalitarian, and collects data to measure these principles. With six Principal Investigators (PIs), seventeen Project Managers (PMs) with special responsibility for issue areas, more than thirty Regional Managers (RMs), 170 Country Coordinators (CCs), Research Assistants, and 3,000 Country Experts (CEs), the V-Dem project is one of the largest social science data collection projects focusing on research.[6]
  • UK
    • The Democracy Index, published by the UK-based Economist Intelligence Unit, is an assessment of countries' democracy. Countries are rated as full democracies, flawed democracies, hybrid regimes, or authoritarian regimes. The index is based on 60 indicators grouped in five different categories measuring pluralism, civil liberties, and political culture.[7]
  • US

Annual assessments

Here is a table of the assessments by four indices, for most countries of the world. For exact rankings rather than assessments, refer to the individual index articles.

Index Scale
Freedom in the World[11] free partly free not free
Index of Economic Freedom[12] free mostly free moderately free mostly unfree repressed
Press Freedom Index[3] good situation satisfactory situation noticeable problems difficult situation very serious situation
Democracy Index[14] full democracy flawed democracy hybrid regime authoritarian regime authoritarian regime


List by country

Land Freedom in the World 2022[11] 2022 Index of Economic Freedom[12] 2022 Press Freedom Index[3] 2021 Democracy Index[14]
  Afghanistan 5 not free n/a 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Albanien 3 partly free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Algerien 5 not free 5 repressed 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Andorra 1 free n/a 3 noticeable problems n/a
  Angola 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Antigua und Barbuda 1 free n/a 3 noticeable problems n/a
  Argentinien 1 free 4 mostly unfree 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Armenien 3 partly free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Australien 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Österreich 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Aserbaidschan 5 not free 3 moderately free 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Bahamas 1 free 3 moderately free n/a n/a
  Bahrain 5 not free 3 moderately free 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Bangladesch 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 5 very serious situation 4 hybrid regime
  Barbados 1 free 2 mostly free n/a n/a
  Weißrussland 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Belgien 1 free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Belize 1 free 4 mostly unfree 2 satisfactory situation n/a
  Benin 3 partly free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  Bhutan 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 2 satisfactory situation 4 hybrid regime
  Bolivien 3 partly free 5 repressed 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  Bosnien und Herzegowina 3 partly free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Botswana 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Brasilien 1 free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Brunei 5 not free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation n/a
  Bulgarien 1 free 2 mostly free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Burkina Faso 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 2 satisfactory situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Burma 5 not free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Burundi 5 not free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Kambodscha 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Kamerun 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Kanada 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Kap Verde 1 free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Zentralafrikanische Republik 5 not free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Tschad 5 not free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Chile 1 free 2 mostly free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  China 5 not free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Kolumbien 3 partly free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 2 flawed democracy
  Komoren 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Costa Rica 1 free 3 moderately free 1 good situation 1 full democracy
  Congo, Democratic Republic of the 5 not free 5 repressed 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Congo, Republic of the 5 not free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Kroatien 1 free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Cuba 5 not free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Zypern 1 free 2 mostly free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Tschechische Republik 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Dänemark 1 free 2 mostly free 1 good situation 1 full democracy
  Dschibuti 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Dominica 1 free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems n/a
  Dominikanische Republik 3 partly free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Osttimor 1 free 5 repressed 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Ecuador 1 free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Ägypten 5 not free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  El Salvador 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  Äquatorial-Guinea 5 not free 5 repressed 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Eritrea 5 not free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Estland 1 free 1 free 1 good situation 2 flawed democracy
  Eswatini 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Äthiopien 5 not free 5 repressed 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Fidschi 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Finnland 1 free 2 mostly free 1 good situation 1 full democracy
  Frankreich 1 free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Gabun 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Gambia 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Georgien 3 partly free 2 mostly free 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Deutschland 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Ghana 1 free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Griechenland 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Grenada 1 free n/a 3 noticeable problems n/a
  Guatemala 3 partly free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  Guinea 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Guinea-Bissau 3 partly free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Guyana 1 free 4 mostly unfree 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Haiti 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Honduras 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 5 very serious situation 4 hybrid regime
  Hongkong 3 partly free n/a 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  Ungarn 3 partly free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Island 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Indien 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 2 flawed democracy
  Indonesien 3 partly free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 2 flawed democracy
  Iran 5 not free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Iraq 5 not free n/a 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Irland 1 free 1 free 1 good situation 1 full democracy
  Israel 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Italien 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Ivory Coast 3 partly free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation 4 hybrid regime
  Jamaika 1 free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Japan 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 1 full democracy
  Jordanien 5 not free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Kasachstan 5 not free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Kenia 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Kiribati 1 free 4 mostly unfree n/a n/a
  North Korea 5 not free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Südkorea 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Kosovo 3 partly free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems n/a
  Kuwait 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Kirgisistan 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Laos 5 not free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Lettland 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Libanon 3 partly free 5 repressed 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Lesotho 3 partly free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Liberia 3 partly free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Libyen 5 not free n/a 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Liechtenstein 1 free n/a 2 satisfactory situation n/a
  Litauen 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Luxemburg 1 free 1 free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Madagaskar 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Malawi 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Malaysia 3 partly free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 2 flawed democracy
  Malediven 3 partly free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems n/a
  Mali 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Malta 1 free 2 mostly free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Marshallinseln 1 free n/a n/a n/a
  Mauretanien 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Mauritius 1 free 2 mostly free 3 noticeable problems 1 full democracy
  Mexiko 3 partly free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  Micronesia, Federated States of 1 free 3 moderately free n/a n/a
  Moldawien 3 partly free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Monaco 1 free n/a n/a n/a
  Mongolei 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Montenegro 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Marokko 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  Mosambik 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Namibia 1 free 4 mostly unfree 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Nauru 1 free n/a n/a n/a
    Nepal 3 partly free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Niederlande 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Neuseeland 1 free 1 free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Nicaragua 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Niger 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Nigeria 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  North Macedonia 3 partly free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Norwegen 1 free 2 mostly free 1 good situation 1 full democracy
  Oman 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Pakistan 3 partly free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 4 hybrid regime
  Palau 1 free n/a n/a n/a
  Palestine 5 not free n/a 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Panama 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Papua-Neuguinea 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Paraguay 3 partly free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Peru 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Philippinen 3 partly free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 2 flawed democracy
  Polen 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Portugal 1 free 2 mostly free 1 good situation 2 flawed democracy
  Katar 5 not free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Rumänien 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Russland 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Ruanda 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  St. Kitts und Nevis 1 free n/a 3 noticeable problems n/a
  St. Lucia 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems n/a
  St. Vincent und die Grenadinen 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems n/a
  Samoa 1 free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation n/a
  San Marino 1 free n/a n/a n/a
  São Tomé and Príncipe 1 free 3 moderately free n/a n/a
  Saudi-Arabien 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Senegal 3 partly free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Serbien 3 partly free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Seychellen 1 free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation n/a
  Sierra Leone 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 2 satisfactory situation 4 hybrid regime
  Singapur 3 partly free 1 free 4 difficult situation 2 flawed democracy
  Slowakei 1 free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Slowenien 1 free 2 mostly free 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Salomonen 1 free 4 mostly unfree n/a n/a
  Somalia 5 not free n/a 4 difficult situation n/a
  Südafrika 1 free 4 mostly unfree 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  South Sudan 5 not free n/a 4 difficult situation n/a
  Spanien 1 free 3 moderately free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Sri Lanka 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 2 flawed democracy
  Sudan 5 not free 5 repressed 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Surinam 1 free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems 2 flawed democracy
  Schweden 1 free 2 mostly free 1 good situation 1 full democracy
   Schweiz 1 free 1 free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Syria 5 not free n/a 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Taiwan 1 free 1 mfree 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Tadschikistan 5 not free 5 repressed 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Tansania 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  Thailand 5 not free 3 moderately free 4 difficult situation 2 flawed democracy
  Togo 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 5 authoritarian regime
  Tonga 1 free 3 moderately free 3 noticeable problems n/a
  Trinidad und Tobago 1 free 4 mostly unfree 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Tunesien 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Türkei 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  Turkmenistan 5 not free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Tuvalu 1 free n/a n/a n/a
  Uganda 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 4 hybrid regime
  Ukraine 3 partly free 4 mostly unfree 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Vereinigte Arabische Emirate 5 not free 2 mostly free 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Vereinigtes Königreich 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Vereinigte Staaten 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 2 flawed democracy
  Uruguay 1 free 2 mostly free 2 satisfactory situation 1 full democracy
  Usbekistan 5 not free 4 mostly unfree 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Vanuatu 1 free 3 moderately free n/a n/a
  Venezuela 5 not free 5 repressed 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Vietnam 5 not free 3 moderately free 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Jemen 5 not free n/a 5 very serious situation 5 authoritarian regime
  Sambia 3 partly free 5 repressed 3 noticeable problems 4 hybrid regime
  Simbabwe 5 not free 5 repressed 4 difficult situation 5 authoritarian regime

Disputed territories

Land Freedom in the World 2022[11] 2022 Index of Economic Freedom[12] 2022 Press Freedom Index[3] 2021 Democracy Index[14]
  Abkhazia 3 partly free n/a n/a n/a
  Crimea 5 not free n/a n/a n/a
  Gaza Strip 5 not free n/a n/a n/a
  Jammu and Kashmir 5 not free n/a n/a n/a
  Azad Kashmir 5 not free n/a n/a n/a
  Nagorno-Karabakh 3 partly free n/a n/a n/a
  Northern Cyprus 1 free n/a 3 noticeable problems n/a
  Novorossiya 5 not free n/a n/a n/a
  Somaliland 3 partly free n/a n/a n/a
  South Ossetia 5 not free n/a n/a n/a
  Tibet 5 not free n/a n/a n/a
  Transnistria 5 not free n/a n/a n/a
  West Bank 5 not free n/a n/a n/a
  Westsahara 5 not free n/a n/a n/a

See also

Notes and references

  1. ^ "Human Freedom Index". www.cato.org/human-freedom-index. Archived from the original on September 14, 2016. Retrieved September 16, 2016.
  2. ^ Craggs, Ryan (January 14, 2013). "World Freedom Index 2013: Canadian Fraser Institute Ranks Countries". Huffington Post. Archived from the original on October 19, 2017. Retrieved March 26, 2013.
  3. ^ a b c d "Press Freedom Index 2022" Archived 2015-10-30 at the Wayback Machine, Reporters Without Borders, May 2022.
  4. ^ World Index of Moral Freedom 2016 Archived 2020-02-21 at the Wayback Machine, published by the Foundation for the Advancement of Liberty
  5. ^ "MaxRange: Analyzing political regimes and democratization processes". Sweden: School of Education, Humanities and Social Sciences, Halmstad University. April 30, 2015. Archived from the original on August 17, 2018. Retrieved May 2, 2015.
  6. ^ "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 2015-01-07. Retrieved 2020-04-29.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
  7. ^ "Democracy index 2012: Democracy at a standstill" (PDF). Economist Intelligence Unit. 14 March 2013. Archived (PDF) from the original on 20 March 2017. Retrieved 26 January 2017.
  8. ^ "CIRI Human Rights Data Project". humanrightsdat.com. Archived from the original on April 8, 2020. Retrieved October 25, 2013.
  9. ^ Michael Kirk (December 10, 2010). "Annual International Human Rights Ratings Announced". University of Connecticut. Archived from the original on October 29, 2013. Retrieved October 25, 2013.
  10. ^ "Human Rights in 2011: The CIRI Report". CIRI Human Rights Data Project. August 29, 2013. Archived from the original on October 29, 2013. Retrieved October 25, 2013.
  11. ^ a b c d Archived 2020-10-03 at the Wayback Machine, Freedom House, March 2021. Retrieved 20 April 2021.
  12. ^ a b c d e Heritage Foundation (2021). "Country Rankings". 2021 Index of Economic Freedom. Archived from the original on 2017-09-16. Retrieved 2014-08-07.
  13. ^ "Polity IV Project". Table footnote. Archived from the original on 4 May 2020. Retrieved 11 Jan 2020.
  14. ^ a b c [1] Archived 2021-03-03 at the Wayback Machine, Economist, January 2021. Retrieved 20 April 2021.