Jump to content

Miriam Naveira: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous edit
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
m copyediting
No edit summary
 
(46 intermediate revisions by 30 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{short description|Chief Justice of Puerto Rico}}
⚫
'''Miriam Naveira Merly''' (born July 28, 1934 in [[Santurce, Puerto Rico]]) is a [[Puerto Rico|Puerto Rican]] [[jurist]] who served in the [[Supreme Court of Puerto Rico]] from 1985 to 2004.<ref name=swears>{{cite web| url = http://www.puertorico-herald.org/issues/2004/vol8n33/Media2-en.html | title = Puerto Rico Swears In New Chief Justice Of Supreme Court | accessdate = 2010-07-25 | date = 2004-08-10 | publisher = ''Puerto Rico Herald''}}</ref> Naveira was the first woman to serve on the court as well as the first female [[Chief Justice]] (2003-2004).
{{Infobox officeholder
| honorific_prefix =
| name = Miriam Naveira
| honorific_suffix =
| image =
| alt =
| caption =
| office = 14th [[Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico]]
| term_start = 2003
| term_end = 2004
| nominator = <!--Can be repeated up to 16 times by changing the number-->
| appointer = Sila Calderón
| predecessor = [[José Andreu García]]
| successor = [[Federico Hernández Denton]]
| birth_date = {{Birth date|1934|07|28}}
| birth_place = [[Santurce, Puerto Rico]]
| death_date = {{Death date and age|2018|04|15|1934|07|28}}
| death_place = [[San Juan, Puerto Rico]]
| education = [[College of Mount Saint Vincent]] ([[Bachelor's degree|BA]])<br>[[University of Puerto Rico School of Law]] ([[Juris Doctor|JD]])<br>[[Columbia Law School]] ([[Master of Laws|LL.M.]])
}}

⚫
'''Miriam Naveira de Merly''' (July 28, 1934 – April 15, 2018) was a [[Puerto Rico|Puerto Rican]] [[jurist]] who served in the [[Supreme Court of Puerto Rico]] from 1985 to 2004.<ref name=swears>{{cite web| url = http://www.puertorico-herald.org/issues/2004/vol8n33/Media2-en.html | title = Puerto Rico Swears In New Chief Justice Of Supreme Court | access-date = 2010-07-25 | date = 2004-08-10 | publisher = Puerto Rico Herald}}</ref> Naveira was the first woman to serve on the court as well as the first female [[chief justice of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico]] (2003–2004). She was also the first female to serve as the [[Solicitor General of Puerto Rico]] (1973-1976).<ref>{{Cite web |last=Cesario |first=Angelica |date=2019-10-15 |title=The Firsts: Latinx Attorneys Who Paved the Way for Generations to Come - Page 5 of 6 - Above the Law CLEAbove the Law CLE |url=https://abovethelaw.com/lawline-cle/2019/10/15/the-firsts-latinx-attorneys-who-paved-the-way-for-generations-to-come/5/ |access-date=2023-09-07 |language=en-US}}</ref>


==Biography==
==Biography==
Naveira was born in [[Santurce, Puerto Rico]] in 1934. She obtained her Bachelor's Degree in [[chemistry]] from the [[College of Mount Saint Vincent]] and her [[law degree]] from the [[University of Puerto Rico]].
Naveira was born in [[Santurce, Puerto Rico]], in 1934. She obtained her bachelor's degree in [[chemistry]] from the [[College of Mount Saint Vincent]] and her [[law degree]] from the [[University of Puerto Rico School of Law]].


Naveira was appointed to the Supreme Court in 1985 by then Governor [[Rafael Hernández Colón]] becoming the first woman on that court. During her tenure, Naveira was known as a pragmatic and moderate justice.
Naveira was appointed to the Supreme Court in 1985 by Governor [[Rafael Hernández Colón]], becoming the first woman on that court. During her tenure, Naveira was known as a pragmatic and moderate justice.


After the retirement of Chief Justice [[José Andreu García]] in 2003, Governor [[Sila Calderón]] elevated Justice Naveira to the post of [[Chief Justice]].<ref name=chief>{{cite web| url = http://www.puertorico-herald.org/issues/2004/vol8n01/Media2-en.html | title = Naveira Becomes First Female Chief Justice Of The Supreme Court | accessdate = 2010-07-25 | date = 2003-12-30 | publisher = ''Puerto Rico Herald''}}</ref> However, her tenure lasted only seven months since the [[Constitution of Puerto Rico]] states that Supreme Court Justices must retire at the age of seventy.<ref name=chief/> She was succeeded by her colleague [[Federico Hernández Denton]].<ref name=swears/>
After the retirement of Chief Justice [[José Andreu García]] in 2003, Governor [[Sila Calderón]] elevated Justice Naveira to the post of [[Chief Justice]].<ref name=chief>{{cite web| url = http://www.puertorico-herald.org/issues/2004/vol8n01/Media2-en.html | title = Naveira Becomes First Female Chief Justice Of The Supreme Court | access-date = 2010-07-25 | date = 2003-12-30 | publisher = Puerto Rico Herald}}</ref> However, her tenure lasted only seven months since the [[Constitution of Puerto Rico]] states that Supreme Court Justices must retire at the age of seventy. Chief Justice Miriam Naveira retired in July 2004.<ref name=chief/> She was succeeded by her colleague [[Federico Hernández Denton]].<ref name=swears/>


Her daughter [[Miriam Rodón Naveira]] is an [[environmental science|environmental scientist]] working at the [[federal government of the United States]] which was awarded a [[Awards and decorations of the United States government|Silver Medal for Superior Service]] and a Suzanne Olive EEO and Diversity Award both by the [[Environmental Protection Agency|EPA]].<ref>[http://theavtimes.com/2013/06/18/nasa-dryden-funding-supports-valley-fever-research/ ''NASA Dryden funding supports Valley Fever research.''] Beth Hagenauer. Antelope Valley Times. 18 June 2013.</ref> She was also the first [[Hispanic]] woman to serve as branch chief of the [[EPA]]'s [[National Exposure Research Laboratory]] (NERL) and later the first Hispanic woman to become deputy director of NERL's Environmental Sciences Division.<ref name="latinawomen.nasa.gov">{{cite web|url=http://latinawomen.nasa.gov/hep/lwon/LWONbios/dfrc-MRodonNaveira.html|title=Miriam Rodon-Naveira, Ph.D.: NASA Dryden Flight Research Center|publisher=Latina Women of NASA|date=April 2009|url-status=dead|archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20160127190051/http://latinawomen.nasa.gov/hep/lwon/LWONbios/dfrc-MRodonNaveira.html|archivedate=2016-01-27}}</ref>
== Criticisms of the Supreme Court from the perspective of the legal academy of Puerto Rico ==
According to Professor of Constitutional Right [[David Helfeld|David M Helfeld]] of the highest court in [[Puerto Rico]]'s jurisdiction, the current Supreme Court is a [[Conservatism|conservative]], slow entity, a fragmented thinking, which relies too much on the [[United States Constitution|US Constitution]], when the Puerto Rico constitution contains more extensive rights, and whose integrity is threatened by the inaction of the Governor to fill the vacancy.


==See also==
Helfeld describes the supreme court in this way in an article published in the legal journal of the [[University of Puerto Rico]] (UPR). Other law professors at [[University of Puerto Rico|UPR]] created critiques of the supreme court in a recent continued education activity of which hundreds of [[Lawyer|lawyers]] were in attendance. The Supreme Court said that they would not answer questions posed by "Primera Hora" about the points of analysis of the professors. This resulted in the delay of the study of this referendum by the secretary of the Judicial Conference.
{{Portal|Puerto Rico|Biography}}

*[[List of Hispanic and Latino American jurists]]
Helfeld also presented statistics that revealed, according to his analisis, that in 2005 and 2006 the proportion of presented cases could become resolved cases before ending with a lower number of pending cases in 2006 than in 2005.
*[[List of Puerto Ricans]]

*[[History of women in Puerto Rico]]
'''Regarding the vacancy, open since [[Baltasar Corrada del Río|Baltasar Corrada del Rio]] retired in April of 2005, and for which there is going to be another vacancy after the retirement of Judge [[Francisco Rebollo López|Francisco Rebollo]] in August of 2008, they are limited to say only that the Governor will make the appointment "when ready."'''
{{Clear}}

Regarding the slowness, Helfeld remarked that "without a doubt, the excessive delays significantly diminish the quality of justice" and that "for too long, the judges have not even mentioned the problem of the excessive delays, as if they do not exist," therefore they requested a study from which may arise "a new judicial policy committed to efficient justice."

Regarding the vacancy, according to the professor, it is treated as a balance problem both in the legal thinking and in the ideological thinking of the six current judges, of which only two are [[statesman]]. In fact, the next one to retire is a statesman so that without someone appointed to follow him, the tribunal will be composed of four "independent statesmen" and a statesman.

'''The third remark, "fragmentación del pensamiento" or "fragmentation of though" is credited to the Chief Justice [[Federico Hernández Denton|Federico Hernandez Denton]], since he is the first at his post to call to create a consensus, for example, none of the 13 cases decided in 2006 regarding the constitutional right will be resolved unanimously. This responsibility of the Chief Justice is the same as in the federal Supreme Court, where the new head [[John Roberts]] has said in interviews that their primary task is to accommodate the views of his colleagues for the court to speak with a strong voice instead of with fragile majorities that can't lay down a respected precedent.'''

The last three points of analysis of Helfeld are directly pertain to each [[Puerto Ricans|Puerto Rican]] in regard to their rights. The professor accused the court of relying too heavily on the Constitution and federal legal sources to interpret provisions of the [[Constitution of Puerto Rico]], and with having a lack of drive to articulate broader rights granted to citizens by the constitution.

This occurs at the same time the Supreme appeals more to inaction than action to resolve disputes. The current Supreme "is not activist: and should not be waited on to create new rights. It is a conservative court", he said while speculating that this may be a reaction to the" political partisanship, without a headquarters" that the island suffers from.

Finally, and in spite of this, the writing of Helfeld raises the hope that the conservative approach is not going to produce powerlessness and that "when it is necessary to resolve a dispute between the branches of government," the court will act.

The criticism was joined by Guillermo Figueroa Prieto, a professor of ethics who called attention to the fact that the Supreme Court almost always resolves ethical complaints in a Per Curiam form, i.e. without knowing which of the members was the one who wrote the decision.

"Saying to proceed reflects a lack of interest of the Supreme Court in the development of this discipline and a lack of rigor with which the same one must be attended," said the professor about one of the powers of the court that is unique to them throughout the government.

"Nor paid to the development of the discipline of the discipline the mere expressions of dissent or concurrency without such votes being accompanied with proper opinions explaining the way of thinking of the judge. Being the court of greater hierarchy in our jurisdiction, with the exclusive responsibility of establishing precedents and advertising the law, the men and women judges that make up the Supreme Court should disclose to the robed class the fundamentals as to why they had to vote against the opinion of the majority," it is argued.


==References==
==References==
Line 41: Line 45:
{{s-legal}}
{{s-legal}}
{{s-bef|before=[[José Andreu García]]}}
{{s-bef|before=[[José Andreu García]]}}
{{s-ttl|title=[[Supreme Court of Puerto Rico|14th Chief Justice of Puerto Rico]]|years=2003–2004}}
{{s-ttl|title=[[Supreme Court of Puerto Rico|Chief Justice of Puerto Rico]]|years=2003–2004}}
{{s-aft|after=[[Federico Hernández Denton]]}}
{{s-aft|after=[[Federico Hernández Denton]]}}
|-
|-
Line 48: Line 52:
{{s-aft|after=[[Liana Fiol Matta]]}}
{{s-aft|after=[[Liana Fiol Matta]]}}
{{s-end}}
{{s-end}}

{{authority control}}


{{DEFAULTSORT:Naveira, Miriam}}
{{DEFAULTSORT:Naveira, Miriam}}
[[Category:1934 births]]
[[Category:1934 births]]
[[Category:Living people]]
[[Category:2018 deaths]]
[[Category:American women judges]]
[[Category:20th-century American judges]]
[[Category:20th-century Puerto Rican lawyers]]
[[Category:20th-century American women judges]]
[[Category:Associate Justices of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico]]
[[Category:Associate Justices of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico]]
[[Category:Chief Justices of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico]]
[[Category:Chief Justices of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico]]
[[Category:College of Mount Saint Vincent alumni]]
[[Category:Constitutional court women judges]]
[[Category:Constitutional court women judges]]
[[Category:Hispanic and Latino American judges]]
[[Category:People from Santurce, Puerto Rico]]
[[Category:People from Santurce, Puerto Rico]]
[[Category:University of Puerto Rico alumni]]
[[Category:Women chief justices]]
[[Category:Women chief justices]]
[[Category:20th-century Puerto Rican women lawyers]]
[[Category:20th-century American women lawyers]]
[[Category:20th-century American lawyers]]

Latest revision as of 22:15, 12 April 2024

Miriam Naveira
14th Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico
In office
2003–2004
Appointed bySila Calderón
Preceded byJosé Andreu García
Succeeded byFederico Hernández Denton
Personal details
Born(1934-07-28)July 28, 1934
Santurce, Puerto Rico
DiedApril 15, 2018(2018-04-15) (aged 83)
San Juan, Puerto Rico
EducationCollege of Mount Saint Vincent (BA)
University of Puerto Rico School of Law (JD)
Columbia Law School (LL.M.)

Miriam Naveira de Merly (July 28, 1934 – April 15, 2018) was a Puerto Rican jurist who served in the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico from 1985 to 2004.[1] Naveira was the first woman to serve on the court as well as the first female chief justice of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico (2003–2004). She was also the first female to serve as the Solicitor General of Puerto Rico (1973-1976).[2]

Biography

[edit]

Naveira was born in Santurce, Puerto Rico, in 1934. She obtained her bachelor's degree in chemistry from the College of Mount Saint Vincent and her law degree from the University of Puerto Rico School of Law.

Naveira was appointed to the Supreme Court in 1985 by Governor Rafael Hernández Colón, becoming the first woman on that court. During her tenure, Naveira was known as a pragmatic and moderate justice.

After the retirement of Chief Justice José Andreu García in 2003, Governor Sila Calderón elevated Justice Naveira to the post of Chief Justice.[3] However, her tenure lasted only seven months since the Constitution of Puerto Rico states that Supreme Court Justices must retire at the age of seventy. Chief Justice Miriam Naveira retired in July 2004.[3] She was succeeded by her colleague Federico Hernández Denton.[1]

Her daughter Miriam Rodón Naveira is an environmental scientist working at the federal government of the United States which was awarded a Silver Medal for Superior Service and a Suzanne Olive EEO and Diversity Award both by the EPA.[4] She was also the first Hispanic woman to serve as branch chief of the EPA's National Exposure Research Laboratory (NERL) and later the first Hispanic woman to become deputy director of NERL's Environmental Sciences Division.[5]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ a b "Puerto Rico Swears In New Chief Justice Of Supreme Court". Puerto Rico Herald. 2004-08-10. Retrieved 2010-07-25.
  2. ^ Cesario, Angelica (2019-10-15). "The Firsts: Latinx Attorneys Who Paved the Way for Generations to Come - Page 5 of 6 - Above the Law CLEAbove the Law CLE". Retrieved 2023-09-07.
  3. ^ a b "Naveira Becomes First Female Chief Justice Of The Supreme Court". Puerto Rico Herald. 2003-12-30. Retrieved 2010-07-25.
  4. ^ NASA Dryden funding supports Valley Fever research. Beth Hagenauer. Antelope Valley Times. 18 June 2013.
  5. ^ "Miriam Rodon-Naveira, Ph.D.: NASA Dryden Flight Research Center". Latina Women of NASA. April 2009. Archived from the original on 2016-01-27.
Legal offices
Preceded by Chief Justice of Puerto Rico
2003–2004 		Succeeded by
Preceded by Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico
1985–2003 		Succeeded by
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Miriam_Naveira&oldid=1218639100"