Jump to content

Ranks and insignia of NATO: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
→‎Rank codes: Fixed typo
Tags: canned edit summary Mobile edit Mobile app edit Android app edit
JurKo22 (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Line 6: Line 6:
The rank scale is used for specifying posts within NATO.
The rank scale is used for specifying posts within NATO.


== Rank codes ==
== Rank codes by STANAG 2116 / APersP-01 ==
NATO maintains a "standard rank scale" which is also known as a "standardized reference system" in an attempt to match every member country's military ranks to corresponding ranks used by the other members.{{sfn|NATO|2021|p=1-1}} The NATO rank reference code categories were established in a 1978 document entitled [[STANAG]] 2116 (formally titled ''NATO Codes for Grades of Military Personnel'').
NATO maintains a "standard rank scale" which is also known as a "standardized reference system" in an attempt to standardize NATO codes of rank for military personnel and indicate correspondence with nations ranks.{{sfn|NATO:NSO|2021|p=1}} The NATO rank reference code categories were established in a 1978 document entitled [[STANAG]] 2116 (formally titled ''NATO Codes for Grades of Military Personnel''). The current 7th edition dated January 13, 2021 (supersedes Edition 6, dated February 25, 2010) is just the cover, and the core of the standard is in APersP-01, Edition A{{sfn|NATO:NSO|2021|p=1}}.


NATO rank codes are not the same as military ranks (US Army examples: Private, Corporal, Warrant Officer 1, Chief Warrant Officer 5, Captain, Major, Colonel, etc.) and military pay grades (US military examples: E-1, W-1, CW-5, O-1, O-1e, O-10, etc.). They are rank codes that allow for interoperability among NATO member nations.
NATO rank codes are not the same as military ranks (US Army examples: Private, Corporal, Warrant Officer 1, Chief Warrant Officer 5, Captain, Major, Colonel, etc.) and military pay grades (US military examples: E-1, W-1, CW-5, O-1, O-1e, O-10, etc.). They are rank codes that allow for interoperability among NATO member nations.

=== Typical errors/inaccuracies related to STANAG 2116 ===

Errors/inaccuracies related to STANAG 2116 can be grouped by the following features:

* STANAG 2116 does not contain criteria according to which a particular rank has a particular code

* lack of completeness of information in STANAG 2116 regarding all branches of the US Armed Forces

* use of sources that appear authoritative, but which are either not official or contain an inaccuracy or typo

* lack of public access to a number of official sources

* application of NATO ranks to countries that are not NATO members

For example, the Ukrainian Minister of Defense issued an order to confirm the conformity of military ranks with NATO codes{{sfn|rubryka.com|2021}}, but the order had a confidential status.<ref>Among the orders of the Minister of Defense for 2019, posted on the website of the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, order No. 1 is missing</ref>. This, in particular, led to the Ukrainian Wikipedia incorrectly indicating the codes of sergeants for 3 years after this order and to establish the truth it was necessary to use [[OSINT]] methods, analyzing other orders and/or publications{{sfn|Kosinsky|2021|p=5,6}}.

In connection with the above, the article is supplemented with a special section, which lists the currently known ones, and a number of errors or inaccuracies are commented on in other sections.<ref name=active>The article is currently under active development: necessary efforts are being made to find certain errors/misconceptions and correct them. Only the information that has been carefully checked is provided.</ref><ref name=JurKo22>[[Copyleft]] JurKo22 2024. [[All rights reversed|All the right ones are in reserve…]]</ref>


=== Officer rank codes ===
=== Officer rank codes ===
OF-1 – OF-10 (lowest rank code to highest) are used for [[commissioned officer]]s:{{sfn|NATO|2021|p=1-1}}
OF-1 – OF-10 (lowest rank code to highest) are used for [[commissioned officer]]s:{{sfn|NATO:NSO|2022|p=1-1}}
* OF-6 – OF-10: [[Flag officer]]s, [[general officer]]s, or [[air officer]]s
* OF-6 – OF-10: [[General officer]]s
* OF-3 – OF-5: [[Field officer|Senior officer]]s
* OF-3 – OF-5: [[Field officer|Senior officer]]s
* OF-1 – OF-2: [[Junior officer]]s
* OF-1 – OF-2: [[Junior officer]]s


In [[US Forces]] the [[Warrant Officer]] is a separate and distinct category of officers. This officer rank and precedence is below those of officer personnel, but above that of non-officer personnel. Warrant Officer grades are as follows:{{sfn|NATO|2022|p=А-10}}
In [[US Forces]] the [[Warrant Officer]] is a separate and distinct category of officers. This officer rank and precedence is below those of officer personnel, but above that of non-officer personnel, therefore has a special group of codes (W-1 – W-5).{{sfn|NATO:NSO|2022|p=А-10}}
* W-5: Chief Warrant Officer 5 ([[US Army]], [[US Marine Corps]], [[US Navy]])
* W-4: Chief Warrant Officer 4 ([[US Army]], [[US Marine Corps]], [[US Navy]])
* W-3: Chief Warrant Officer 3 ([[US Army]], [[US Marine Corps]], [[US Navy]])
* W-2: Chief Warrant Officer 2 ([[US Army]], [[US Marine Corps]], [[US Navy]])
* W-1: Warrant Officer 1 ([[US Army]], [[US Marine Corps]]; no longer used in [[US Navy]])


The [[warrant officer]]s are the highest other ranks in [[British Armed Forces]] and [[Canadian Armed Forces]].{{sfn|NATO|2022|p=D-1, D-3}}
In [[British Armed Forces]] and [[Canadian Armed Forces]] warrant officers are the highest other ranks.{{sfn|NATO:NSO|2022|p=D-1, D-3}}


=== Other rank codes ===<!-- Other ranks (NATO) redirects here -->
=== Other rank codes ===
OR1–OR9 (lowest rank code to highest) are used for other ranks:{{sfn|NATO|2021|p=1-1}}
OR1–OR9 (lowest rank code to highest) are used for other ranks:{{sfn|NATO:NSO|2022|p=1-1}}
* OR-5 – OR-9: [[Non-commissioned officer]]s (for NATO purposes)
* OR-5 – OR-9: [[Non-commissioned officer]]s (for NATO purposes)
* OR-1 – OR-4: [[Enlisted rank]]s (usually)
* OR-1 – OR-4: [[Enlisted rank]]s (usually)


At the same time, there are exceptions, for example:
At the same time, in certain branches of the armed forces, OR-4 and even OR-3 can also serve as non-commissioned officers (NCOs), for example:
* Non-Commissioned officers in [[British Armed Forces]] are called Senior Non-Commissioned Officers in OR-5 to OR-7 inclusive and Junior Non-Commissioned Officers in OR-3 and OR-4.{{sfn|NATO|2022|p=D-8, Е-7, F-7}}
* NCOs in [[British Armed Forces]] are called Senior NCOs in OR-5 to OR-7 inclusive and Junior NCOs in OR-3 and OR-4.{{sfn|NATO:NSO|2022|p=D-8, Е-7, F-7}}


This is not a new feature: it was present in previous editions of STANAG 2116, but was sometimes overlooked.
This is not a new feature: it was present in previous editions of STANAG 2116, but was sometimes overlooked.
Line 57: Line 70:
|}
|}


== NATO rank codes outside NATO<ref name=active /><ref name=JurKo22 /> ==
== Ranks and insignia of member armed forces ==
'''Army'''
* [[Ranks and insignia of NATO armies officers|Ranks and insignia of NATO member army officers]]
* [[Ranks and insignia of NATO armies enlisted|Ranks and insignia of NATO member army enlisted]]


Based on the intentions of Bosnia and Herzegovina, as well as Ukraine, to join NATO, NATO codes for military ranks have been officially introduced in these countries. Bosnia and Herzegovina did so by adopting a corresponding law in 2005.{{sfn|PSBiH|2005|p=33,34}} In Ukraine, the introduction of NATO codes for military ranks took place in two stages:
'''Air Force'''
* [[Ranks and insignia of NATO air forces officers|Ranks and insignia of NATO member air force officers]]
* [[Ranks and insignia of NATO air forces enlisted|Ranks and insignia of NATO member air force enlisted]]


* in 2020, the Ukrainian parliament amended the structure of military ranks{{sfn|Rada|2020}}
'''Navy'''

* [[Ranks and insignia of NATO navies' officers|Ranks and insignia of NATO member navy officers]]
* in January 2021, the Minister of Defense of Ukraine approved the compliance of military ranks with NATO codes by his order{{sfn|rubryka.com|2021}}

Such European countries as Austria{{sfn|bundesheer.at|2023}} and Ireland{{sfn|De Barra|2022}} use NATO rank codes to determine the equivalent of their ranks, but either explicitly warn that this is unofficial information{{sfn|bundesheer.at|2023}}, or it is unclear whether some official source was used to compile the correspondence.

== Officer ranks and criteria for them<ref name=active /><ref name=JurKo22 /> ==
{{See also|Officer (armed forces)}}

The lack of clear criteria in STANAG 2116, according to which a particular code corresponds to a particular position, leads to errors in interpreting this standard. First of all, this applies to countries that are NATO partners and therefore are not reflected in the standard. A good example is the lack of consensus on the equivalence of non-commissioned officer ranks in the [[Israel Defense Forces]] with those in the US Army:

{| class="wikitable" align=center
|- align="center"
! Rank
! Web site [[Israel Defense Forces|IDF]]<br>(2007-2012){{sfn|idf.il|2007}}
! Asher Shafrir's<br/>article (2013){{sfn|Shafrir|2013}}{{sfn|Shafrir*|2013}}
! Reot Gross's<br/> dictionary (2021){{sfn|Gross|2021}}
|- align="center"
| {{lang|he|רב-סמל}}<br />{{lang|he-Latn|Rav samal}}
| Sergeant First Class<br>(OR-7)
| Sergeant First Class<br>(OR-7)
| Sergeant First Class<br>(OR-7)
|- align="center"
| {{lang|he|רב-סמל ראשון}}<br />{{lang|he-Latn|Rav samal rishon}}
| Master Sergeant<br>(OR-8)
| Master Sergeant<br>(OR-8)
| Master Sergeant<br>(OR-8)
|- align="center"
| {{lang|he|רב-סמל מתקדם}}<br />{{lang|he-Latn|Rav samal mitkadem}}
| Sergeant Major<br>(OR-9)
| Sergeant Major<br>(OR-9)
| Sergeant Major<br>(OR-9)
|- align="center"
|{{lang|he|רב-סמל בכיר}}<br />{{lang|he-Latn|Rav samal bakhír}}
| Warrant Officer<br>(W-1)
| Command Sergeant Major<br>(OR-9)
| ---
|- align="center"
| {{lang|he| רב-נגד משנה}}<br />{{lang|he-latn|Rav nagad mishne}}{{sfn|israelhayom.co.il|2012}}
| ---<br>(Master Warrant Officer{{sfn|israelhayom.co.il|2012}}<ref>The rank of Master Warrant Officer does not exist in the US Army, but does exist in the Canadian Army with the code OR-8)</ref>)
| Warrant Officer<br>(W-1)
| ---
|- align="center"
| {{lang|he|רב-נגד}}<br />{{lang|he-Latn|Rav nagad}}
| Chief Warrant Officer<br>(W-2)
| Chief Warrant Officer<br>(W-2)
| Command Sergeant Major<br>(OR-9)
|}
{{See also|Israel Defense Forces ranks#Enlisted ranks}}

This problem is related to the fact that the ranks of IDF unserial officers do not depend on the position held, but on length of service, so their relationship with NATO codes is a debatable issue. Each of the above points of view has its own comments, which are given in the corresponding comments to the sources. The most widely disseminated point of view was that of the professor Asher Shafrir{{sfn|Campbell|2018}}{{sfn|Tennyson|2018}}, although he is a linguist and not a military specialist. The Dictionary of Acronyms in Foreign Armies{{sfn|Gross|2021}} is closer to the truth, but because it is in Hebrew, its position is currently little known.

In order to correct/prevent such errors, this Wikipedia article has been supplemented with this section, where the corresponding analysis is carried out.

=== Army/marine/air force officer ranks ===


[[US Army]], [[US Air Force]] and [[US Marine Corps]] officers are called company grade officers in in OF-1/OF-2, field grade officers in OF-3 to OF-5 and general officers in OF-6 and higher.{{sfn|defense.gov|2020}}

Appendix B of the APP-06 standard{{sfn|NATO:NSO|2023|p=795 - 826}} lists 11 formation/unit groups and identifies the commanders of 7 of them:

{| class="wikitable"
|- style="vertical-align:top; "
! align=left | [[NATO Joint Military Symbology|NATO Symbol]]
! align=left | Basic designation
! align=left | Canadian aviation designation
! align=left | Usually commanded by
|- style="vertical-align:top;"
| align=center | [[Image:NATO Map Symbol - Unit Size - Corps.svg|64px| ]]
| [[Corps]]
| [[Corps]]<ref name=can>Non-existent in the Canadian armed forces</ref>
| OF-8
|- style="vertical-align:top;"
| align=center | [[Image:NATO Map Symbol - Unit Size - Division.svg|64px| ]]
| [[Division (military)|Division]]
| [[Division (military)|Division]]<ref name=can />
| OF-7
|- style="vertical-align:top;"
| align=center | [[Image:NATO Map Symbol - Unit Size - Brigade.svg|64px| ]]
| [[Brigade]]
| [[Group (military unit)|Aviation group]]
| OF-5 or 6
|- style="vertical-align:top;"
| align=center | [[Image:NATO Map Symbol - Unit Size - Regiment or Group.svg|64px| ]]
| [[Regiment]]
| [[Wing (military unit)|Wing]]
| OF-4, 5 or 6
|- style="vertical-align:top;"
| align=center | [[Image:NATO Map Symbol - Unit Size - Battalion.svg|64px| ]]
| [[Batalion]]
| [[Squadron (aviation)|Squadron]]
| OF-3 or 4
|- style="vertical-align:top;"
| align=center | [[Image:NATO Map Symbol - Unit Size - Company or Squadron or Battery.svg|64px| ]]
| [[Company (military unit)|Company]]
| [[Flight (military unit)|Flight]]
| OF-2 or 3
|- style="vertical-align:top;"
| align=center | [[Image:NATO Map Symbol - Unit Size - Platoon or Troop.svg|64px]]
| [[Platoon]]
| [[Section (military unit)#Air forces|Section]]
| OF-1/OF-2 or OR-7/OR-8
|}

=== Navy officer ranks ===
{{See also|Naval officer|Ranks and insignia of NATO navies' officers}}

[[US Navy]] officers are called junior grade officers in OF-1/OF-2, mid-grade officers in OF-3 to OF-5 and [[flag officer]]s in OF-6 and higher.{{sfn|defense.gov|2020}} As practice shows, these groups occupy the following positions:
* [[flag officer]]s command ship formations
* mid-grade officers command ships
* junior grade officers usually serve as officers on ships, but can also command very small ships

=== [[Warrant officer]] ranks ===
In [[US Forces]] Warrant Officer grades are as follows:{{sfn|NATO:NSO|2022|p=А-10}}:
* W-5: Chief Warrant Officer 5 ([[US Army]], [[US Marine Corps|USMC]], [[US Navy]])
* W-4: Chief Warrant Officer 4 ([[US Army]], [[US Marine Corps|USMC]], [[US Navy]])
* W-3: Chief Warrant Officer 3 ([[US Army]], [[US Marine Corps|USMC]], [[US Navy]])
* W-2: Chief Warrant Officer 2 ([[US Army]], [[US Marine Corps|USMC]], [[US Navy]])
* W-1: Warrant Officer 1 ([[US Army]], [[US Marine Corps|USMC]]; no longer used in [[US Navy]])

=== [[Non-commissioned officer]] (NCO) ranks ===
According to Bi-SC Directive 040-002{{sfn|NATO:Bi-SC|2023|p=8,9}} NATO rank Indicators for NCOs are as follows:

* OR-1 through OR-3: These are the basic entry ranks into the military structure. NATO personnel are expected to uphold national standards of conduct and follow the orders of supervisors and regulations. These members will be expected to learn and adapt to national and NATO standards on their way to occupational proficiency. Leaders will challenge these ranks commensurate with their rank.

* OR-4: The first level of leadership within the NATO NCO ranks. Is responsible for the good order and discipline, training, personal appearance and general welfare of their subordinate personnel.

* OR-5: The OR-5 is the first NATO designated NCO grade and the level of leadership with the greatest impact on subordinate ranks. Practices leadership-by-example, demonstrating personal compliance with standards while enforcing those standards in order to ensure the good order and discipline, training, personal appearance and general welfare of subordinate personnel. Unquestionably competent to execute tasks correctly, exercise leadership, care for assigned personnel and support mission accomplishment with minimal supervision.

* OR-6: Based on greater experience or longevity, the OR-6 is assigned to positions requiring increased responsibilities and a broader scope. The OR-6 is responsible for managing subordinates and equipment, and uses greater experience and leadership to ensure proper and effective use of resources under their control. This is the first grade at which OR should be considered for Staff NCO duties at NATO higher headquarters employment. (As such some NATO nations may recognize OR-6 through OR-9 as Senior NCOs (SNCO) or Warrant Officers (WO). Additionally, at this point some NATO nations distinguish technical expertise from institutional leadership.)

* OR-7: The OR-7 is empowered and considered a key element within the command structure. They focus their increased experience and leadership skills toward collective mission accomplishment and are responsible for the effective management of larger numbers of personnel and equipment. At this level, SNCOs are expected to be able to provide sound advice to their leadership. While no formal mandate exists, this is the level at which, when consistent with their national authorities, SNCOs start to provide mentorship/assistance for Junior Officers (OF-1/OF-2); this relationship forms the basis for building a robust Command Team or Command Group in their future careers.

* OR-8: Uses enhanced leadership skills and broad operational experience to advise unit/element leaders and commanders on organizational effectiveness. They educate and empower the enlisted force through effective standards and training, while developing subordinates and themselves through professional enhancement opportunities. OR-Bs are expected to merge subordinates talents, skills, and resources with other NATO crossfunctional team(s) and organization(s) to implement planning and management processes for collective mission accomplishment.

* OR-9: The most experienced SNCO within the NATO NCO structure. They use enhanced leadership skills and broad experience in a greater capacity to successfully implement planning and management for collective mission accomplishment. Advises staff element, instructs and mentors subordinates, and coordinates and supervises training. Monitors unit effectiveness and upholds standards. Additionally, OR-9s monitor unit effectiveness, morale and welfare, OR PD, and upholds standards. The OR-9 serves as role model for all NCOs/ORs, as well as Junior Officers. This grade is normally utilized in an advisory capacity when assigned to a higher headquarters.

This directive leaves it to the NATO member state's discretion which positions are held by which OR rank, and whether an NCO may have a rank below OR-5. This means that even within a single country there may be different approaches for different branches of the armed forces. This is especially true for the US armed forces:

* In [[US Army]] E–5(OR-5) through E–6 (OR-6) are junior NCO; E–7 (OR-7) through E–9 (OR-9) are senior NCO{{sfn|DoA|2010|p=43 (52)}}

* In [[US Marine Corps]] E-4 (OR-4) and E-5 (OR-5) are NCOs; E-6 (OR-6) through E-9 (OR-9) are Staff NCOs{{sfn|marines.mil|2020}}

== Ranks and insignia of NATO member enlisted ==
* [[Ranks and insignia of NATO armies enlisted|Ranks and insignia of NATO member armies enlisted]]
* [[Ranks and insignia of NATO air forces enlisted|Ranks and insignia of NATO member air force enlisted]]
* [[Ranks and insignia of NATO navies enlisted|Ranks and insignia of NATO member navy enlisted]]
* [[Ranks and insignia of NATO navies enlisted|Ranks and insignia of NATO member navy enlisted]]


== See also ==
== See also ==
* [[Air officer]]
* [[list of comparative military ranks|Comparative military ranks]]
* [[list of comparative military ranks|Comparative military ranks]]
* [[Flag officer]]
* [[Military rank]]
* [[Military star ranking]]


== References ==
== References ==
=== Official documents and publications ===
=== Citations ===
{{Reflist}}

=== Sources ===
{{refbegin}}
{{refbegin}}

* {{cite book |author1=NATO |title=STANAG 2116 |date=13 January 2021 |publisher=NATO Standardization Agency |edition=7th |location=Brussels, Belgium}}
* {{cite book |author1=NATO |title=APersP-01 Еd.A Ver.3 |date=16 June 2022 |publisher=NATO Standardization Agency |location=Brussels, Belgium}}
* {{cite book |author1=NATO:NSO |title=STANAG 2116 |date=January 2021 |edition=7th |publisher=[[NATO Standardization Office]] |location=Brussels, Belgium}}
* {{cite book |author1=NATO |title=APP-06 Еd.E Ver.1 |date=11 October 2023 |publisher=NATO Standardization Agency |location=Brussels, Belgium}}
* {{cite book |author1=NATO:NSO |title=APersP-01 (Еd.A Ver.3) |date=June 2022 |publisher=[[NATO Standardization Office]] |location=Brussels, Belgium}}
* {{cite book |author1=NATO:NSO |title=APP-06 (Еd.E Ver.1) |date=October 2023 |publisher=[[NATO Standardization Office]] |location=Brussels, Belgium}}
* {{cite book |author1=NATO:MSA |title=STANAG 2116 (5th ed.) |date=March 1996 |publisher=[[NATO Standardization Office|Military Agency for Standardization]] |url=https://hhk.uni-nke.hu/document/hhk-uni-nke-hu/NATO_CODES_OF_RANKS.pdf |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20240313155730/https://hhk.uni-nke.hu/document/hhk-uni-nke-hu/NATO_CODES_OF_RANKS.pdf |archive-date=2024-03-13}}
* {{cite book |author1=NATO:Bi-SC |title=Directive 040-002 |date=December 2023 |publisher=[[Allied Command Operations]], [[Allied Command Transformation]] |url=https://shape.nato.int/resources/site7234/General/BISCD040-002%20NATO%20NCO_JO%20Employment%20and%20Development%20Strat.pdf }}
* {{cite book |last1=DoA |title=Army Regulation 220-1 |url=https://history.army.mil/html/forcestruc/docs/r220_1.pdf |publisher=Department of the Army |location=Washington, DC |date=April 2010 }}
* {{cite book |last1=DoD |title=Visual Information Style Guide |date=January 2020 |publisher=[[U.S. Department of Defense]] |url=https://www.dimoc.mil/Portals/64/VIStyleGuide2020_1.pdf |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20220305175613/https://www.dimoc.mil/Portals/64/VIStyleGuide2020_1.pdf |archive-date=2022-03-05 }}
* {{cite web |last1=PSBiH |language=Bosnian |title=Zakon o službi u Oružanim snagama Bosne i Hercegovine |trans-title=Law on Service in the Armed Forces of Bosnia and Herzegovina |date=October 2005 |website=www.mod.gov.ba |url=http://www.mod.gov.ba/files/file/zakoni/Zakon-o-sluzbi-bs.pdf |access-date=2024-07-04 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20240618222544/http://www.mod.gov.ba/files/file/zakoni/Zakon-o-sluzbi-bs.pdf |archive-date=2024-06-18 }}
* {{cite web |last1=Rada |language=Ukrainian |title=Zakon Ukrainy vid 04.06.2020 № 680-IX. Pro vnesennia zmin do deiakykh zakonodavchykh aktiv Ukrainy shchodo viiskovykh zvan viiskovosluzhbovtsiv |trans-title=Law of Ukraine dated 04.06.2020 No. 680-IX. On amendments to some legislative acts of Ukraine regarding the military ranks of military personnel |date=2020 |publisher=[[Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine]] |url=https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/680-20?lang=en#Text |access-date=2024-07-04 }}

=== Official websites ===

* {{cite web |last=defense.gov |title=U.S. Military Rank Insignia |date=2020 |url=https://www.defense.gov/Resources/Insignia/ |publisher=[[U.S. Department of Defense]] |website=www.defense.gov |access-date=2024-06-30 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200414165713/https://www.defense.gov/Resources/Insignia/ |archive-date=2020-04-14}}
* {{cite web |last=defense.gov |title=Military Units: Marine Corps |date= May 2022 |url=https://www.defense.gov/Multimedia/Experience/Military-Units/Marine-Corps/#units |publisher=[[U.S. Department of Defense]] |website=www.defense.gov |access-date=2024-06-30 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20220523164816/https://www.defense.gov/Multimedia/Experience/Military-Units/Marine-Corps/#units |archive-date=2022-05-23 }}
* {{cite web |last=army.mil |title=U.S. Army Ranks |date=2018 |url=https://www.army.mil/ranks/ |publisher=[[U.S. Army]] |website=www.army.mil |access-date=2024-06-30 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20180627000342/https://www.army.mil/ranks/ |archive-date=2018-06-27}}
* {{cite web |last=marines.mil |title=Ranks |date=2020 |url=https://www.marines.mil/Ranks.aspx |publisher=[[U.S. Marine Corps]] |website=www.marines.mil |access-date=2024-06-30 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200930195648/https://www.marines.mil/Ranks.aspx |archive-date=2020-09-30}}
* {{cite web |last=bundesheer.at |title=Rank Insignias |date=2023 |url=https://www.bundesheer.at/en/rank-insignias |publisher=[[Ministry of Defence (Austria)]] |website=www.bundesheer.at |access-date=2024-06-30 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20230627211346/https://www.bundesheer.at/en/rank-insignias |archive-date=2023-06-27}}
* {{cite web |editor-last=Gross |editor-first=Reot |title=Dictionary of Acronyms in Foreign Armies |url=https://www.idf.il/media/5cjkltup/20-05-21-%D7%9E%D7%99%D7%9C%D7%95%D7%9F-%D7%94%D7%A7%D7%99%D7%A6%D7%95%D7%A8%D7%99%D7%9D-%D7%95%D7%A8%D7%90%D7%A9%D7%99-%D7%94%D7%AA%D7%99%D7%91%D7%95%D7%AA-%D7%A2%D7%93%D7%9B%D7%95%D7%9F-%D7%9C%D7%93%D7%99%D7%92%D7%99%D7%98%D7%9C.pdf |language=he |website=idf.il |publisher=[[Israel Defense Forces]] |date=2021 }}

=== Mass media ===

* {{cite web |last=israelhayom.co.il |title=New rank for IDF officers - Master Warrant Officer |url=https://www.israelhayom.co.il/article/25636 |website=www.israelhayom.co.il |publisher=[[Israel Hayom]] |date=22 April 2012 }}
* {{cite web |last=rubryka.com |title=Ukrainian military ranks replaced with NATO military rank codes |date=6 January 2021 |url=https://rubryka.com/en/2021/01/06/ukrayinski-vijskovi-zvannya-perevely-na-kody-vijskovyh-rangiv-nato |website=rubryka.com |publisher=IA "Rubric" LLC. }}
* {{cite web |last=Skorostetskyi |first=Volodymyr |date=6 January 2021 |title=Yakyi «kod NATO» v serzhanta, abo Pro zaprovadzhenyi STANAG 2116 |trans-title=What is the “NATO code” for a sergeant, or of the introduction of STANAG 2116 |language=Ukrainian |url=https://armyinform.com.ua/2021/01/06/yakyj-kod-nato-v-serzhanta-abo-pro-zaprovadzhenyj-stanag-2116 |website=armyinform.com.ua |publisher=АрміяInform }}

=== Publications by professional military personnel ===

* {{cite web |last=Heitzman |first=Deana |title=AF enlisted rank structure 101 |date=2015 |url=https://www.aviano.af.mil/News/Display/Article/724063/af-enlisted-rank-structure-101/ |publisher=[[Aviano Air Base]] |website=www.aviano.af.mil |access-date=2024-07-01 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20240701122421/https://www.aviano.af.mil/News/Display/Article/724063/af-enlisted-rank-structure-101/ |archive-date=2024-07-01}}
* {{cite magazine |last=De Barra |first=Ruairi |title=From Aspiration to Action. Exploring New Horizons for the Defence Forces Senior Enlisted Leaders |magazine=Defence Forces review 2022 |date=2022 |pages=97-104 |url=https://www.military.ie/en/members-area/members-area-files/defence-forces-review-2022-digital.pdf }}
* {{cite web |last=[unknown sergeant] |title=[research essay on career development of NCOs in the Irish Defence Forces] |date=2021 |url=https://www.gov.ie/pdf/?file=https://assets.gov.ie/194177/6850a097-5d5e-4c51-8584-8d0972e77a89.pdf#page=null |website=gov.ie |access-date=2024-07-06 }}
* {{cite magazine |last=Kosinsky |first=O.Yu. |title=Profesiinyi serzhant – fundament armii |trans-title=Professional sergeant is the foundation of the army |language=Ukrainian |magazine=Defense Bulletin |issue=3 |date=2021 |pages=4-15 |url=https://www.calameo.com/read/006678074ff3589cf0c9c }}

=== Sources that contain typos, inaccuracies etc. (see comments) ===
* {{cite web |last1=idf.il |date=2007 |title=Ranks |url=http://dover.idf.il/IDF/English/about/insignia/ranks.htm |website=idf.il |publisher=[[Israel Defense Forces]] |language=en |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20121029014837/http://dover.idf.il/IDF/English/about/insignia/ranks.htm |archive-date=2012-10-29 |url-status=dead}}<ref name="W1/W-2">NCO IDF vs W1/W-2 US Arny comparison</ref>
* {{cite journal |last1=Shafrir |first1=Asher |date=2013 |title=THE NAMES OF ISRAELI MILITARY RANKS AND THEIR LINGUISTIC ANALYSIS |url=https://www.ceeol.com/search/article-detail?id=509310 |journal=Redefining Community in Intercultural Context |volume=2 |issue=1 |pages=155-160}}<ref name="W1/W-2" /><ref name="NCO">Staff Sergeant and Sergeant are NCO</ref>
* {{cite web |last1=Shafrir* |first1=Asher |title=The Names of Israeli Military Ranks and their linguistic analysis.pdf |url=https://www.academia.edu/38217681/The_Names_of_Israeli_Military_Ranks_and_their_linguistic_analysis_pdf |website=Academia.edu |date=2013 }}<ref name="W1/W-2" /><ref name="NCO" />
* {{cite book |last1=Campbell |first1=David |title=Israeli Paratroopers 1954–2016 [Osprey Elite 224] |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=7hlpDwAAQBAJ&pg=PA65&hl=ru&source=gbs_toc_r&cad=2#v=onepage&q&f=false |publisher=Osprey Publishing Ltd. (Bloomsbury Publishing Plc) |date=2018 }}<ref name="W1/W-2" />
* {{cite magazine |editor-last=Tennyson |editor-first=Matt |title=Rank Structure - IDF |url=https://www.militarydespatches.co.za/Vol%2016%20October%202018.pdf |magazine=Military Despatches |date=October 2018 |volume=16 |location=South Africa, Tokai |publisher=Hipe Media |pages=24-26}}<ref name="W1/W-2" />

* {{cite web |last1=FMTB |title=FMSO 1101. Rank Structure of Armed Forces Personnel |date=2008 |location=Camp Lejeune, North Carolina |publisher=Field Medical Training Battalion - East |website=www.trngcmd.marines.mil |url=https://www.trngcmd.marines.mil/Portals/207/Docs/FMTBE/rank.doc |format=DOC |access-date=2024-07-07 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20240703160019/https://www.trngcmd.marines.mil/Portals/207/Docs/FMTBE/rank.doc |archive-date=2024-07-03 }}<ref name="E-4">In US Arny/Us Ar Force E-4 (OR-4) is not NCO</ref>
* {{cite web |last1=FMTB |title=FMST 1101. Identify the Rank and Rate Structure of Armed Forces Personnel
|date=2010 |location=Camp Lejeune, North Carolina |publisher=Field Medical Training Battalion - East |website=www.tecom.marines.mil |url=https://www.tecom.marines.mil/Portals/120/Docs/Student%20Materials/FMST%20Manual/Rank_Structure_FMST-1101.doc |format=DOC |access-date=2024-07-07 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20161224010405/https://www.tecom.marines.mil/Portals/120/Docs/Student%20Materials/FMST%20Manual/Rank_Structure_FMST-1101.doc |archive-date=2016-12-24 }}<ref name="E-4" />
* {{cite web |last1=FMTB |title=Field Medical Service Officer Student Handbook |date=2013 |location=Camp Pendleton, California |publisher=Field Medical Training Battalion - West |website=www.tecom.marines.mil |url=https://www.tecom.marines.mil/portals/131/docs/fmsohand.pdf |access-date=2024-07-07 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20240629201820/https://www.tecom.marines.mil/Portals/131/Docs/fmsohand.pdf |archive-date=2024-06-29 }}<ref name="E-4" />

* {{cite web |last1=Rusnak |first1=Ivan |last2=etc. |title=The White Book 2019-2020: The Armed Forces of Ukraine and the State Special Transpor Service |date=2021 |publisher=[[Ministry of Defence of Ukraine]] |website=www.mil.gov.ua |url=https://www.mil.gov.ua/content/files/whitebook/WB_2019_2020_eng.pdf |access-date=2024-07-07 }}<ref>Typo on the last illustration on page 80</ref>

{{refend}}
{{refend}}

=== References/Citations/Comments ===
{{Reflist}}


== External links ==
== External links ==
* {{cite web |url=https://nso.nato.int/nso/nsdd/main/standards/ap-details/3319/EN |title=NATO Standard STANAG 2116 / APersP-01, NATO Codes for Grades of Military Personnel |website=nso.nato.int |access-date=2024-06-24 }}
* {{cite web |url=https://nso.nato.int/nso/nsdd/main/standards/ap-details/3169/EN |title=NATO Standard STANAG 2019 / APP-06, NATO Joint Military Symbology (current ed./ver.) |website=nso.nato.int |access-date=2024-06-30 }}
* {{cite web |url=https://nso.nato.int/nso/nsdd/main/standards/ap-details/3169/EN |title=NATO Standard STANAG 2019 / APP-06, NATO Joint Military Symbology |website=nso.nato.int |access-date=2024-06-24 }}
* {{cite web |url=https://nso.nato.int/nso/nsdd/main/standards/ap-details/3319/EN |title=NATO Standard STANAG 2116 / APersP-01, NATO Codes for Grades of Military Personnel (current ed./ver.) |website=nso.nato.int |access-date=2024-06-30 }}
* {{cite web |url=https://shape.nato.int/resources/site7234/General/BISCD040-002%20NATO%20NCO_JO%20Employment%20and%20Development%20Strat.pdf |title=Bi-SC Directive 040-002, NATO Non-Commissioned Officer and Junior Officer Bi-Strategic Command Employment and Development Strategy |website=shape.nato.int |date=19 December 2023 |access-date=2024-06-24 }}


{{-}}
{{-}}
{{NATO}}
{{NATO}}


[[Category:Military ranks of NATO| ]]
<!--[[Category:NATO Armies ranks and insignia templates|*]]-->
<!--[[Category:NATO Armies ranks and insignia templates|*]]-->

Revision as of 19:12, 7 July 2024

Ranks and insignia of NATO affiliated nations are combined military ranks and insignia used by the member countries (and other affiliated nations) of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization.

The rank scale is used for specifying posts within NATO.

Rank codes by STANAG 2116 / APersP-01

NATO maintains a "standard rank scale" which is also known as a "standardized reference system" in an attempt to standardize NATO codes of rank for military personnel and indicate correspondence with nations ranks.[1] The NATO rank reference code categories were established in a 1978 document entitled STANAG 2116 (formally titled NATO Codes for Grades of Military Personnel). The current 7th edition dated January 13, 2021 (supersedes Edition 6, dated February 25, 2010) is just the cover, and the core of the standard is in APersP-01, Edition A[1].

NATO rank codes are not the same as military ranks (US Army examples: Private, Corporal, Warrant Officer 1, Chief Warrant Officer 5, Captain, Major, Colonel, etc.) and military pay grades (US military examples: E-1, W-1, CW-5, O-1, O-1e, O-10, etc.). They are rank codes that allow for interoperability among NATO member nations.

Errors/inaccuracies related to STANAG 2116 can be grouped by the following features:

  • STANAG 2116 does not contain criteria according to which a particular rank has a particular code
  • lack of completeness of information in STANAG 2116 regarding all branches of the US Armed Forces
  • use of sources that appear authoritative, but which are either not official or contain an inaccuracy or typo
  • lack of public access to a number of official sources
  • application of NATO ranks to countries that are not NATO members

For example, the Ukrainian Minister of Defense issued an order to confirm the conformity of military ranks with NATO codes[2], but the order had a confidential status.[3]. This, in particular, led to the Ukrainian Wikipedia incorrectly indicating the codes of sergeants for 3 years after this order and to establish the truth it was necessary to use OSINT methods, analyzing other orders and/or publications[4].

In connection with the above, the article is supplemented with a special section, which lists the currently known ones, and a number of errors or inaccuracies are commented on in other sections.[5][6]

Officer rank codes

OF-1 – OF-10 (lowest rank code to highest) are used for commissioned officers:[7]

In US Forces the Warrant Officer is a separate and distinct category of officers. This officer rank and precedence is below those of officer personnel, but above that of non-officer personnel, therefore has a special group of codes (W-1 – W-5).[8]

In British Armed Forces and Canadian Armed Forces warrant officers are the highest other ranks.[9]

Other rank codes

OR1–OR9 (lowest rank code to highest) are used for other ranks:[7]

At the same time, in certain branches of the armed forces, OR-4 and even OR-3 can also serve as non-commissioned officers (NCOs), for example:

This is not a new feature: it was present in previous editions of STANAG 2116, but was sometimes overlooked.

Comparison to US system

The numbers in the system broadly correspond to the U.S. uniformed services pay grades, with OR-x replacing E-x. The main difference is in the commissioned officer ranks, where the US system recognises two ranks at OF-1 level (O-1 and O-2), meaning that all O-x numbers after O-1 are one point higher on the US scale than they are on the NATO scale (e.g. a major is OF-3 on the NATO scale and O-4 on the US scale).

Officer ranks
Rank group General / flag officers Senior officers Junior officers Officer cadet
NATO code OF-10 OF-9 OF-8 OF-7 OF-6 OF-5 OF-4 OF-3 OF-2 OF-1 OF(D) Student officer
Uniformed services pay grade Special grade O-10 O-9 O-8 O-7 O-6 O-5 O-4 O-3 O-2 O-1 Officer candidate/Cadet
Other ranks
Rank group Non-commissioned officers Enlisted
NATO code OR-9 OR-8 OR-7 OR-6 OR-5 OR-4 OR-3 OR-2 OR-1
Uniformed services pay grade Special E-9 E-8 E-7 E-6 E-5 E-4 E-3 E-2 E-1

NATO rank codes outside NATO[5][6]

Based on the intentions of Bosnia and Herzegovina, as well as Ukraine, to join NATO, NATO codes for military ranks have been officially introduced in these countries. Bosnia and Herzegovina did so by adopting a corresponding law in 2005.[11] In Ukraine, the introduction of NATO codes for military ranks took place in two stages:

  • in 2020, the Ukrainian parliament amended the structure of military ranks[12]
  • in January 2021, the Minister of Defense of Ukraine approved the compliance of military ranks with NATO codes by his order[2]

Such European countries as Austria[13] and Ireland[14] use NATO rank codes to determine the equivalent of their ranks, but either explicitly warn that this is unofficial information[13], or it is unclear whether some official source was used to compile the correspondence.

Officer ranks and criteria for them[5][6]

The lack of clear criteria in STANAG 2116, according to which a particular code corresponds to a particular position, leads to errors in interpreting this standard. First of all, this applies to countries that are NATO partners and therefore are not reflected in the standard. A good example is the lack of consensus on the equivalence of non-commissioned officer ranks in the Israel Defense Forces with those in the US Army:

Rank Web site IDF
(2007-2012)[15]
Asher Shafrir's
article (2013)[16][17]
Reot Gross's
dictionary (2021)[18]
רב-סמל
Rav samal
Sergeant First Class
(OR-7)
Sergeant First Class
(OR-7)
Sergeant First Class
(OR-7)
רב-סמל ראשון
Rav samal rishon
Master Sergeant
(OR-8)
Master Sergeant
(OR-8)
Master Sergeant
(OR-8)
רב-סמל מתקדם
Rav samal mitkadem
Sergeant Major
(OR-9)
Sergeant Major
(OR-9)
Sergeant Major
(OR-9)
רב-סמל בכיר
Rav samal bakhír
Warrant Officer
(W-1)
Command Sergeant Major
(OR-9)
---
רב-נגד משנה
Rav nagad mishne[19]
---
(Master Warrant Officer[19][20])
Warrant Officer
(W-1)
---
רב-נגד
Rav nagad
Chief Warrant Officer
(W-2)
Chief Warrant Officer
(W-2)
Command Sergeant Major
(OR-9)

This problem is related to the fact that the ranks of IDF unserial officers do not depend on the position held, but on length of service, so their relationship with NATO codes is a debatable issue. Each of the above points of view has its own comments, which are given in the corresponding comments to the sources. The most widely disseminated point of view was that of the professor Asher Shafrir[21][22], although he is a linguist and not a military specialist. The Dictionary of Acronyms in Foreign Armies[18] is closer to the truth, but because it is in Hebrew, its position is currently little known.

In order to correct/prevent such errors, this Wikipedia article has been supplemented with this section, where the corresponding analysis is carried out.

Army/marine/air force officer ranks

US Army, US Air Force and US Marine Corps officers are called company grade officers in in OF-1/OF-2, field grade officers in OF-3 to OF-5 and general officers in OF-6 and higher.[23]

Appendix B of the APP-06 standard[24] lists 11 formation/unit groups and identifies the commanders of 7 of them:

NATO Symbol Basic designation Canadian aviation designation Usually commanded by
Corps Corps[25] OF-8
Division Division[25] OF-7
Brigade Aviation group OF-5 or 6
Regiment Wing OF-4, 5 or 6
Batalion Squadron OF-3 or 4
Unternehmen Flight OF-2 or 3
Platoon Section OF-1/OF-2 or OR-7/OR-8

US Navy officers are called junior grade officers in OF-1/OF-2, mid-grade officers in OF-3 to OF-5 and flag officers in OF-6 and higher.[23] As practice shows, these groups occupy the following positions:

  • flag officers command ship formations
  • mid-grade officers command ships
  • junior grade officers usually serve as officers on ships, but can also command very small ships

In US Forces Warrant Officer grades are as follows:[8]:

According to Bi-SC Directive 040-002[26] NATO rank Indicators for NCOs are as follows:

  • OR-1 through OR-3: These are the basic entry ranks into the military structure. NATO personnel are expected to uphold national standards of conduct and follow the orders of supervisors and regulations. These members will be expected to learn and adapt to national and NATO standards on their way to occupational proficiency. Leaders will challenge these ranks commensurate with their rank.
  • OR-4: The first level of leadership within the NATO NCO ranks. Is responsible for the good order and discipline, training, personal appearance and general welfare of their subordinate personnel.
  • OR-5: The OR-5 is the first NATO designated NCO grade and the level of leadership with the greatest impact on subordinate ranks. Practices leadership-by-example, demonstrating personal compliance with standards while enforcing those standards in order to ensure the good order and discipline, training, personal appearance and general welfare of subordinate personnel. Unquestionably competent to execute tasks correctly, exercise leadership, care for assigned personnel and support mission accomplishment with minimal supervision.
  • OR-6: Based on greater experience or longevity, the OR-6 is assigned to positions requiring increased responsibilities and a broader scope. The OR-6 is responsible for managing subordinates and equipment, and uses greater experience and leadership to ensure proper and effective use of resources under their control. This is the first grade at which OR should be considered for Staff NCO duties at NATO higher headquarters employment. (As such some NATO nations may recognize OR-6 through OR-9 as Senior NCOs (SNCO) or Warrant Officers (WO). Additionally, at this point some NATO nations distinguish technical expertise from institutional leadership.)
  • OR-7: The OR-7 is empowered and considered a key element within the command structure. They focus their increased experience and leadership skills toward collective mission accomplishment and are responsible for the effective management of larger numbers of personnel and equipment. At this level, SNCOs are expected to be able to provide sound advice to their leadership. While no formal mandate exists, this is the level at which, when consistent with their national authorities, SNCOs start to provide mentorship/assistance for Junior Officers (OF-1/OF-2); this relationship forms the basis for building a robust Command Team or Command Group in their future careers.
  • OR-8: Uses enhanced leadership skills and broad operational experience to advise unit/element leaders and commanders on organizational effectiveness. They educate and empower the enlisted force through effective standards and training, while developing subordinates and themselves through professional enhancement opportunities. OR-Bs are expected to merge subordinates talents, skills, and resources with other NATO crossfunctional team(s) and organization(s) to implement planning and management processes for collective mission accomplishment.
  • OR-9: The most experienced SNCO within the NATO NCO structure. They use enhanced leadership skills and broad experience in a greater capacity to successfully implement planning and management for collective mission accomplishment. Advises staff element, instructs and mentors subordinates, and coordinates and supervises training. Monitors unit effectiveness and upholds standards. Additionally, OR-9s monitor unit effectiveness, morale and welfare, OR PD, and upholds standards. The OR-9 serves as role model for all NCOs/ORs, as well as Junior Officers. This grade is normally utilized in an advisory capacity when assigned to a higher headquarters.

This directive leaves it to the NATO member state's discretion which positions are held by which OR rank, and whether an NCO may have a rank below OR-5. This means that even within a single country there may be different approaches for different branches of the armed forces. This is especially true for the US armed forces:

  • In US Army E–5(OR-5) through E–6 (OR-6) are junior NCO; E–7 (OR-7) through E–9 (OR-9) are senior NCO[27]
  • In US Marine Corps E-4 (OR-4) and E-5 (OR-5) are NCOs; E-6 (OR-6) through E-9 (OR-9) are Staff NCOs[28]

Ranks and insignia of NATO member enlisted

See also

References

Official documents and publications

  • NATO:NSO (January 2021). STANAG 2116 (7th ed.). Brussels, Belgium: NATO Standardization Office.
  • NATO:NSO (June 2022). APersP-01 (Еd.A Ver.3). Brussels, Belgium: NATO Standardization Office.
  • NATO:NSO (October 2023). APP-06 (Еd.E Ver.1). Brussels, Belgium: NATO Standardization Office.
  • NATO:MSA (March 1996). STANAG 2116 (5th ed.) (PDF). Military Agency for Standardization. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2024-03-13.
  • NATO:Bi-SC (December 2023). Directive 040-002 (PDF). Allied Command Operations, Allied Command Transformation.
  • DoA (April 2010). Army Regulation 220-1 (PDF). Washington, DC: Department of the Army.
  • DoD (January 2020). Visual Information Style Guide (PDF). U.S. Department of Defense. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2022-03-05.
  • PSBiH (October 2005). "Zakon o službi u Oružanim snagama Bosne i Hercegovine" [Law on Service in the Armed Forces of Bosnia and Herzegovina] (PDF). www.mod.gov.ba (in Bosnian). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2024-06-18. Retrieved 2024-07-04.
  • Rada (2020). "Zakon Ukrainy vid 04.06.2020 № 680-IX. Pro vnesennia zmin do deiakykh zakonodavchykh aktiv Ukrainy shchodo viiskovykh zvan viiskovosluzhbovtsiv" [Law of Ukraine dated 04.06.2020 No. 680-IX. On amendments to some legislative acts of Ukraine regarding the military ranks of military personnel] (in Ukrainian). Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. Retrieved 2024-07-04.

Official websites

Mass media

Publications by professional military personnel

Sources that contain typos, inaccuracies etc. (see comments)

References/Citations/Comments

  1. ^ a b NATO:NSO 2021, p. 1.
  2. ^ a b rubryka.com 2021.
  3. ^ Among the orders of the Minister of Defense for 2019, posted on the website of the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, order No. 1 is missing
  4. ^ Kosinsky 2021, p. 5,6.
  5. ^ a b c The article is currently under active development: necessary efforts are being made to find certain errors/misconceptions and correct them. Only the information that has been carefully checked is provided.
  6. ^ a b c Copyleft JurKo22 2024. All the right ones are in reserve…
  7. ^ a b NATO:NSO 2022, p. 1-1.
  8. ^ a b NATO:NSO 2022, p. А-10.
  9. ^ NATO:NSO 2022, p. D-1, D-3.
  10. ^ NATO:NSO 2022, p. D-8, Е-7, F-7.
  11. ^ PSBiH 2005, p. 33,34.
  12. ^ Rada 2020.
  13. ^ a b bundesheer.at 2023.
  14. ^ De Barra 2022.
  15. ^ idf.il 2007.
  16. ^ Shafrir 2013.
  17. ^ Shafrir* 2013.
  18. ^ a b Gross 2021.
  19. ^ a b israelhayom.co.il 2012.
  20. ^ The rank of Master Warrant Officer does not exist in the US Army, but does exist in the Canadian Army with the code OR-8)
  21. ^ Campbell 2018.
  22. ^ Tennyson 2018.
  23. ^ a b defense.gov 2020.
  24. ^ NATO:NSO 2023, p. 795 - 826.
  25. ^ a b Non-existent in the Canadian armed forces
  26. ^ NATO:Bi-SC 2023, p. 8,9.
  27. ^ DoA 2010, p. 43 (52).
  28. ^ marines.mil 2020.
  29. ^ a b c d e NCO IDF vs W1/W-2 US Arny comparison
  30. ^ a b Staff Sergeant and Sergeant are NCO
  31. ^ a b c In US Arny/Us Ar Force E-4 (OR-4) is not NCO
  32. ^ Typo on the last illustration on page 80