Over recent years, the mattress-in-a-box trend has taken the sleep industry by storm. With countless options available, we understand the challenge of finding an option that suits your needs. That’s why we’ve rigorously tested and evaluated nine of the top contenders to bring you the most insightful and informed recommendations for the best mattress-in-a-box.
Our selection process draws upon our expertise as certified sleep science coaches ( 1 ), industry experts, and expert product reviewers, combined with valuable consumer insights. We considered the most renowned brands, assessed sleeper preferences such as price, sleep style, and comfort, and employed our knowledge to identify the mattresses that truly stand out. Additionally, our team has researched and compiled a comprehensive guide on the best mattresses , providing a list of top performers.
Best mattress in-a-box overall
The Nectar Original is available in an all-foam or a hybrid foam and spring construction. It’s suitable for a wide range of individuals, including side sleepers, back sleepers, and those with shoulder or hip pain. Even with the plush foam layers, you won’t feel like you’re sinking into the mattress—instead, you’ll feel supported, and your spine will remain in proper alignment throughout the night.
Our picks for the best mattresses-in-a-box
- Best overall : Nectar Original
- Best luxury: Helix Midnight Luxe
- Best memory foam: Emma Original
- Best cooling: WinkBed Original
- Best for heavy people: Titan Plus
- Best soft: Nolah Evolution
- Best hybrid: Bear Elite Hybrid
- Best value: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid
- Best organic: Birch Natural
Compare mattresses
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Nectar Original | Helix Midnight Luxe | Emma Original | WinkBed Original | Titan Plus | Nolah Evolution | Bear Elite Hybrid | Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid | Birch Natural | |
| Rating | |||||||||
| Best for | Back sleepers, side sleepers | Luxury shoppers, hot sleepers | Heavier-weight people, budget shoppers | Hot sleepers, people who want a bed that lasts | Heavier-weight people, stomach sleepers | Back sleepers, luxury shoppers | People with joint pain, athletes | Budget shoppers, hot sleepers | Eco-conscious shoppers, people who prefer organic beds |
| Material | Foam or hybrid (coils and foam) | Hybrid (coils and foam) | Foam | Hybrid (coils and foam) | Hybrid (coils and foam) | Hybrid (coils and foam) | Hybrid (coils and foam) | Hybrid (coils and foam) | Hybrid (coils and latex) |
| Trial period | 365 nights | 100 nights | 365 nights | 120 nights | 120 nights | 120 nights (optional) | 120 nights | 120 nights | 100 nights |
| Shipping cost | Free | Free | Free | Free | Free | Free (mattress removal and setup available for additional cost) | Free | Free | Free |
| Firmness | Medium-firm | Medium | Medium | Softer, luxury firm, firmer, plus | Firm | Plush, luxury firm, firm | Soft, medium, firm | Soft, medium, firm | Medium firm |
| Warranty | Forever | 15 years | 10 years | Lifetime | 10 years | Lifetime | Lifetime | 10 years | 25 years |
| Price range (queen) | $1,099 (foam), $1,199 (hybrid) | $2,373.80 | $1,159 | $1,799-$1,999 | $1,249 | $2,499 | $2,305 | $1,332 | $2,123.80 |
*Prices do not include sales or promotions
Best overall mattress-in-a-box: Nectar Original
Key product features
What you should know
The Nectar Original mattress stands out as our top pick due to its exceptional combination of affordability, comfort, and support for all sleep styles, backed by our thorough research and testing. Its innovative design offers significant relief for pressure points and ensures minimal disturbances from movement.
- The mattress’s gel-infused memory foam layer and dynamic response layer can further help reduce pressure points.
- Nectar offers promotions and sales throughout the year that can knock hundreds of dollars off the cost. But even without those discounts, the Nectar Original is still a cost-effective option.
- With a medium-firm feel, it’s an ideal choice for multiple sleep styles, including back and side sleepers.
- Due to its body contouring features, it can also be a great choice for individuals with shoulder and hip pain.
Why we like Nectar Original as best overall
The Nectar Original mattress is our best overall pick for a mattress-in-a-box because it’s affordable, comfortable, and supportive. With a medium-firm feel, it’s an ideal choice for multiple sleep styles, including back and side sleepers. Due to its body contouring features, it can also be a great choice for individuals with shoulder and hip pain.
“Stomach sleepers should prioritize a firm mattress with a supportive core to maintain spinal alignment and prevent excessive sinking. Cushioning for pressure relief, edge support, and materials like memory foam or latex are crucial. Personal comfort matters, so a medium-firm mattress with these features is a good starting point for stomach sleepers.”
Dr. Raj Dasgupta, Fortune Recommends Chief Medical Advisor
One tester felt very supported while laying on the bed. “The foam offers a nice cushion for my joints. It’s very plush and my entire body was sinking in. However, my hips were definitely sinking in way more than the rest of my body.”
There are two options available: a multi-layered CertiPUR-US® memory foam construction or a hybrid, which incorporates innerspring coils. Whichever you choose, the mattress will contour to your body and provide the right level of support and pressure point relief. The mattress’s gel-infused memory foam layer and dynamic response layer can further help reduce pressure points.
Furthermore, the Nectar Original mattress boasts low-motion transfer. This means you can sleep soundly without being disturbed by movements from your sleeping partner or pets.
The original price of the memory foam mattress is $1,099, while the original price of the hybrid mattress is $1,199. Nectar offers promotions and sales throughout the year that can knock hundreds of dollars off the cost. But even without those discounts, the Nectar Original is still a cost-effective option. Most mattresses with similar materials can cost upward of $1,500.
What customers are saying
On Amazon, the Nectar Original received a over 7,000 ratings, averaging 4.3 stars out of five. Amazon customers appreciate the quality of the mattress for the price, saying it improves sleep and helps them sleep without pain.
“This is definitely the most comfortable bed I’ve ever bought. My joint and back pain is barely noticeable and I sleep like the dead,” begins verified Amazon customer, Jessie. “I did leave it sitting for two days, nothing in the paperwork said you have to, but it was recommended when I looked it up. I also haven’t had it more than a week, but I can tell you that I’ve noticed a huge change in how I sleep and feel in that short amount of time.”
Another Amazon customer, Jazmine, praised the mattress’s cooling technology, stating, “The reason I think this is a great product is because it has a cooling comfort technology which significantly improved my sleep quality. No more night sweats or waking up hot in the middle of the night. It’s just the right balance of firmness and comfort, providing a good night’s sleep every time.”
However, some Amazon customers noted the edge support is lacking.
“The edges of the mattress have zero support,” begins Amazon reviewer David Schoonmaker. “This is not a mattress you can sit on the edge of. My spouse sleeps close to the edge on her side. She fell off of the bed in the middle of the night. Although this was comical, it was the last straw before switching back to my old mattress.”
Specs
| Material | Foam or hybrid |
| Warranty | Forever |
| Firmness | Medium-firm |
| Trial period | 365 nights |
| Shipping | Free |
| Weight (Queen) | 66 lbs |
| Height | 12″ tall |
Best luxury mattress-in-a-box: Helix Midnight Luxe
Key product features
What you should know
The Helix Midnight Luxe emerges as our top luxury mattress choice, boasting superior comfort and performance with its plush memory foam and advanced cooling technology, tailored to individual sleep preferences through Helix’s customization quiz.
- It incorporates an additional layer of premium memory foam for an even plusher feel, making it ideal for those who crave an indulgent sleeping experience.
- You get the added luxury of enhanced materials and features, such as an additional copper gel memory foam layer for even better responsiveness and pressure relief.
- Customers say the mattress is an ideal medium firmness, which feels great when they sleep on their back or stomach.
- By taking a sleep quiz on Helix’s website, you can receive a mattress tailored to your specific needs.
Why we like Helix Midnight Luxe as best luxury
The Helix Midnight Luxe mattress is our best luxury pick due to its exceptional blend of comfort and performance. It takes all the great features of the standard Helix Midnight mattress and elevates them to a new level of luxury.
What sets the Helix Midnight Luxe apart from its counterpart is the added premium materials and enhanced features. It incorporates an additional layer of premium memory foam for an even plusher feel, making it ideal for those who crave an indulgent sleeping experience.
The Helix Midnight Luxe also comes standard with a quilted top for extra comfort. And, like the non-Luxe version, you have the option to add an advanced cooling cover designed to regulate temperature effectively. This cover can help ensure you stay comfortably cool throughout the night.
The Helix Midnight Luxe maintains the customizable aspect that Helix is known for. By taking a sleep quiz on Helix’s website, you can receive a mattress tailored to your specific needs. But you’ll also get the added luxury of enhanced materials and features, such as an additional copper gel memory foam layer for even better responsiveness and pressure relief.
While the added cushioning adds more comfort, it does take away some of the mattress’s ability to isolate motion. This means you may be more aware of your partner’s movements if they tend to toss and turn at night.
If you are looking for additional luxury mattress options, check out our full guide on the best luxury mattresses to find the right one for you!
What customers are saying
Reviewers on Reddit praise the mattress for it’s support, firmness, and edge support.
One Redditor with the username “silversum1” says, “So far we love it. It has helped alleviate back pain we both have felt. I noticed I don’t wake up in the middle of my sleep anymore. The firmness feels good, but not too much pressure on the shoulders or hips. I suppose this is where their coil system really kicks in.”
However, one Redditor with the username “paramedic999” notes the significant off-gassing.
“My only real complaint is that the off-gassing was much worse than they described. I didn’t sleep on it the first week. I let it air out and crawled all over it to try to help. But overall very happy with the purchase.”
Specs
| Material | Hybrid |
| Warranty | 15 years |
| Firmness | Medium |
| Trial period | 100 nights |
| Shipping | Free |
| Weight (Queen) | 120 lbs |
| Height | 13.5″ tall |
Best memory foam mattress-in-a-box: Emma Original
Key product features
What you should know
The Emma Original mattress delivers a balanced sleep experience, combining eco-friendly, supportive memory foam with advanced cooling technology, making it a top choice for those seeking comfort and pressure relief.
- The multi-layered memory foam construction provides the signature contouring and pressure relief that memory foam enthusiasts seek.
- If you’ve never owned an all-foam bed and are unsure whether one is worth trying, the Emma Original is a great option with a generous 365-night sleep trial.
- It adapts to the shape of your body, making it an ideal choice for those with joint or muscle discomfort.
- It uses top-of-the-line CertiPUR-US ® certified foams made without any ozone-depleting chemicals.
Why we like Emma Original as best memory foam
The Emma Original mattress delivers a truly comfortable memory foam sleeping experience without sacrificing support. It uses top-of-the-line CertiPUR-US® certified foams made without any ozone-depleting chemicals.
At the heart of the Emma Original mattress lies a multi-layered memory foam construction. This construction excels in providing the signature contouring and pressure relief that memory foam enthusiasts seek. It adapts to the shape of your body, cradling you in a cocoon-like embrace that effectively alleviates pressure points, making it an ideal choice for those with joint or muscle discomfort.
Our tester rated the mattress a four out of five for bounce and responsiveness. “It’s very easy to switch positions which I thought is unique for an all foam bed. However, there isn’t any bounce so it’s not as responsive.”
This mattress also delivers that classic memory foam sensation of sinking in without the feeling of being trapped, ensuring a more restorative night’s sleep.
Emma Original also prioritizes temperature regulation. Its breathable design and advanced, eco-friendly foams help dissipate heat, preventing the overheating issues that can sometimes plague traditional memory foam mattresses. If you’ve never owned an all-foam bed and are unsure whether one is worth trying, the Emma Original is a great option with a generous 365-night sleep trial.
Specs
| Material | Foam |
| Warranty | 10 years |
| Firmness | Medium |
| Trial period | 365 nights |
| Shipping | Free |
| Weight (Queen) | 65 lbs |
| Height | 10″ tall |
Best cooling mattress-in-a-box: WinkBed Original
Key product features
What you should know
The WinkBed Original mattress features cooling properties and tailored firmness options, ensuring an optimal sleep environment for a diverse range of sleep preferences.
- The mattress features a Tencel ™ cover, a naturally moisture-wicking fabric that helps dissipate heat and keep you cool.
- May not be a suitable option for budget shoppers.
- The individually wrapped coils also contribute to superior motion isolation, ensuring you remain undisturbed by your partner’s movements.
- The coil-on-coil construction allows for increased airflow, enhancing its breathability and heat dissipation.
Why we like WinkBed Original as best cooling
The WinkBed Original mattress stands out for its exceptional cooling features and overall sleep experience. It incorporates a combination of cooling materials and technologies to ensure a comfortable sleep temperature throughout the night.
The mattress features a Tencel ™ cover, a naturally moisture-wicking fabric that helps dissipate heat and keep you cool. Beneath the cover, a layer of gel-infused foam provides additional temperature regulation by dissipating excess warmth.
The coil-on-coil construction allows for increased airflow, enhancing its breathability and heat dissipation. The individually wrapped coils also contribute to superior motion isolation, ensuring you remain undisturbed by your partner’s movements. And with four firmness levels—softer, luxury firm, firmer, and plus—you’re bound to find the ideal bed for you.
“The mattress feels durable and long-lasting. I enjoy sleeping on it. My body feels lifted and my spine feels aligned. There is little sinkage with hips and lower body,” notes our product tester.
The only problem may be identifying which firmness option is best suited to your needs.
Side sleepers, for example, generally benefit from a mattress with a soft or medium feel to ensure enough give at sensitive pressure points, such as the shoulders and hips. Back sleepers could enjoy a softer to medium-firm mattress, depending on their preference.
Our product tester felt comfortable lying on their back, with significant pressure relief on the lumbar lower region. “It feels like I’m sleeping on top of the mattress rather than sinking in. It offers subtle pressure relief around the hips and shoulders.”
Stomach sleepers may fare better with a firm or firmer mattress. WinkBed’s “plus” firmness provides additional support and is best suited for heavier-weight people.
What customers are saying
Reviewers on Reddit appreciate the quality and softness of the mattress, depending on the firmness size.
“As soon as I tried it out, I worried that my WinkBed Luxury Firm was too soft—immediately planned to return it.,” begins Redditor with the username “general_frame_1912”. “Luckily I calmed down and gave it a couple months, and one and a half years later, I love the thing. My husband has back pain and normally prefers a firm mattress, so we have been really surprised at how well this has worked for us.”
Another Redditor with the username “anonmeplox” states the luxury firm mattress was really comfortable, but almost too soft.
“The luxury firm was wildly comfortable. I really wanted to like it. It was the type of bed where you get in and immediately feel comfortable. The problem was, it was very soft. Everyone’s scale is different but I thought the firm was an 8.5 and the luxury firm a 6 out of 10. After a week, my lower back did start acting up because I wasn’t getting the support I needed.”
Specs
| Material | Hybrid |
| Warranty | Lifetime |
| Firmness | Soft, luxury firm, firmer, plus |
| Trial period | 120 nights |
| Shipping | Free |
| Weight (Queen) | 135 lbs |
| Height | 13.5″ tall |
Best mattress-in-a-box for heavy people: Titan Plus
Key product features
What you should know
The Titan Plus Mattress is designed to offer support and firmness, ideal for plus-size individuals and those with back pain. It features a high-density foam core and responsive foams for a balance of comfort and support.
- An extra firm mattress like the Titan Plus is also a good option for plus-sized sleepers, who tend to need a firmer mattress.
- Only comes in extra-firm, which may be too firm for some sleepers.
- The mattress is beneficial for individuals with back pain or those who prefer sleeping on their stomachs.
- It features a high-density foam core that offers robust support to help maintain proper spinal alignment.
Why we like Titan Plus as best for heavy people
The Titan Plus delivers a supportive and firm sleep surface. It features a high-density foam core that offers robust support to help maintain proper spinal alignment. This can be particularly beneficial for individuals with back pain or those who prefer sleeping on their stomachs, as it prevents the body from sinking too deeply into the mattress.
An extra firm mattress like the Titan Plus is also a good option for plus-sized sleepers, who tend to need a firmer mattress.
Despite its firmness, the Titan Plus doesn’t compromise on comfort. It incorporates responsive foams that contour to your body, while still maintaining that essential firmness.
Our product tester rated the Titan Plus a five out of five regarding support and spinal alignment. “My body was incredibly supported. There is no sinkage whatsoever, and my entire body was lifted,” they note. Additionally, they felt very little sinkage, providing an incredibly comfortable feel. They note that it’s easy to get in and out of the bed, making it ideal for people who have mobility issues.
However, extra-firm mattresses tend to offer less-than-optimal pressure relief, which may make this bed a less desirable option for side sleepers.
Specs
| Material | Hybrid |
| Warranty | 10 years |
| Firmness | Firm |
| Trial period | 120 nights |
| Shipping | Free |
| Weight (Queen) | 95 lbs |
| Height | 11.25″ tall |
Best soft mattress-in-a-box: Nolah Evolution
Key product features
What you should know
The Nolah Evolution mattress excels with its plush AirFoam ™ technology, offering a cloud-like comfort that contours precisely for pressure relief, making it a great choice for side sleepers and those valuing softness and superior cooling.
- This AirFoam ™ technology offers an exceptional blend of comfort and support.
- The original price of $2,499 may put it out of range for budget shoppers
- Nolah Evolution is an ideal choice for individuals who prefer a soft, gentle sleeping surface as well as side sleepers who require ample cushioning for their shoulders and hips.
- A core of individually wrapped coils enhances responsiveness while maintaining motion isolation.
Why we like Nolah Evolution as best soft
The Nolah Evolution mattress offers a luxuriously soft and comfortable sleeping experience. Much of its plushness comes from its use of AirFoam ™ technology. This proprietary foam material offers an exceptional blend of comfort and support. It contours your body with precision, cradling you in a cloud-like embrace that relieves pressure points.
A core of individually wrapped coils enhances responsiveness while maintaining motion isolation. Together, these elements make the Nolah Evolution an ideal choice for individuals who prefer a soft, gentle sleeping surface as well as side sleepers who require ample cushioning for their shoulders and hips.
The Nolah Evolution doesn’t compromise on temperature regulation, either. An organic cotton cover and high-thermal conductivity Euro topper draw heat away from the body. The AirFoam ™ helps to dissipate heat and remain temperature neutral better than most memory foams.
During our evaluation, our product tester measured the mattress temperature at 68 degrees. After about five minutes of lying down, the mattress temperature climbed up to 78.1 degrees. It took around two minutes for the mattress to cool back down to the original temperature.
An additional AirBreathe ™ border gusset further maximizes airflow, allowing heat to escape and cool air to flow in. With three firmness levels, the Nolah Evolution is a great option for lovers of soft beds, even those who need a firmer mattress option.
What customers are saying
Reviewers on Reddit praise the Nolah Evolution for its cooling properties, support, and overall comfort.
“At my size (350lb 6′ tall), I find it very plush, but still supportive,” begins Redditor with the username “cyriouslysick.” “I can just barely feel the coils when I wake up in the morning after sleeping on my side (this could be from Fibromyalgia causing sensitive pressure points). I am dealing with some chronic health issues, but I do find I toss and turn very little once I fall asleep. The top layers of the mattress do a good job of cradling me in one position for most of the night.”
The same reviewer complains about the height of the mattress, stating, “The only thing about the mattress that caught me off guard is the height, and that’s mostly affecting my aging dogs. This mattress is closer to 17″ thick once it’s fully fluffed up. The 15″ measurement is only for the edge height; so the pups are having a harder time jumping up into bed. It would be a great mattress for a low profile bed frame because of the extra thickness.”
Specs
| Material | Hybrid |
| Warranty | Lifetime |
| Firmness | Plush, firm, luxury firm |
| Trial period | 120 nights |
| Shipping | Free |
| Weight (Queen) | 115 lbs |
| Height | 15″ tall |
Best hybrid mattress-in-a-box: Bear Elite Hybrid
Key product features
What you should know
The Bear Elite Hybrid stands out for its innovative fusion of memory foam comfort and innerspring support. It’s enhanced with copper cooling technology to help deliver a sleep experience that is supportive and temperature-regulated.
- At the core lies a responsive and individually wrapped coil system that provides robust support and helps maintain proper spinal alignment.
- Bear Elite Hybrid is an excellent choice for those who desire the benefits of both memory foam and innerspring in a single mattress.
- One of the comfort foam layers is infused with copper, a cooling technology that effectively helps regulate body temperature, making it great for hot sleepers.
- On top of the coils are multiple layers of foam, which provide excellent pressure relief and contouring, as well as zoned lumbar support.
Why we like Bear Elite Hybrid as best hybrid
The Bear Elite Hybrid mattress successfully blends the benefits of both memory foam and innerspring technologies, offering a well-rounded sleep experience. This hybrid mattress delivers an exceptional combination of support, comfort, and durability.
“A hybrid mattress is a special kind of mattress that combines the support of traditional springs with the comfort of modern foam,” notes Dr. Raj. “It aims to offer a balance between firmness and softness, making it suitable for various sleep preferences. It’s like a superhero of sleep comfort, providing the best of both worlds for a better night’s rest.”
At the core of the Bear Elite Hybrid lies a responsive and individually wrapped coil system that provides robust support and helps maintain proper spinal alignment. This is especially beneficial for those who seek the bounce and support of a traditional innerspring mattress. Our product tester appreciated the support from the coils, stating, “I felt supported the entire time I was laying on this mattress. Most body types and sleeping positions should feel comfortable on this mattress. This bed also feels durable and that it would last a long time.”
On top of the coils are multiple layers of foam, which provide excellent pressure relief and contouring, as well as zoned lumbar support, ensuring a comfortable and restorative night’s sleep.
One of the comfort foam layers is infused with copper, a cooling technology that effectively helps regulate body temperature. Along with providing the best temperature for sleep , the cooling technology in mattresses can prevent overheating during the night.
Overall, the combination of support, comfort, and temperature control makes the Bear Elite Hybrid an excellent choice for those who desire the benefits of both memory foam and innerspring in a single mattress.
Specs
| Material | Hybrid |
| Warranty | Lifetime |
| Firmness | Soft, medium, firm |
| Trial period | 120 nights |
| Shipping | Free |
| Weight (Queen) | 110 lbs |
| Height | 14″ tall |
Best value mattress-in-a-box: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid
Key product features
What you should know
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid offers a combination of quality, comfort, and affordability, making it an ideal choice for budget-conscious shoppers looking for a high-quality hybrid mattress.
- This mattress incorporates a hybrid design that combines the support of an innerspring system with the comfort of foam layers.
- At $1,332 (before promotions), it is notably more budget-friendly than many other hybrid mattresses
- It includes materials such as a transition foam for deeper compression support closer to the core.
- It’s also topped with a breathable quilted cover to help regulate temperature.
Why we like the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid as best value
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid mattress is an outstanding choice for budget-conscious shoppers seeking excellent value thanks to its combination of quality, features, and affordability.
This mattress incorporates a hybrid design that combines the support of an innerspring system with the comfort of foam layers. This blend offers a balanced and comfortable feel that appeals to a wide range of sleep preferences. And at $1,332 (before promotions), it is notably more budget-friendly than many other hybrid mattresses.
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid doesn’t compromise on features. It includes materials such as a transition foam for deeper compression support closer to the core and premium memory foam for responsiveness and contouring close to the sleep surface. It’s also topped with a breathable quilted cover to help regulate temperature.
During our testing, we noted the mattress provided exceptional support and spinal alignment. Our product tester appreciate the soft and plush feel. They noted that their body felt lifted and supported, while additionally doing a decent job at helping the pain in their back.
“My hips didn’t sink in as much as my back did and I definitely felt more pressure around my hips and shoulders. I don’t think it’s plush enough for side sleeping. It definitely feels like a true medium-firm mattress—not too plush and not enough contouring around the joints,” commented our product tester.
If you are looking for additional affordable mattress options, check out our full guide on other cheap mattress options or even the best mattresses under $1,000 to find the right one for you.
What customers are saying
Reviewers on Amazon love the comfort, quality, and firmness of the mattress. They mention that it’s soft but firm enough to support their back and facilitate side sleeping.
“Wow, this is a nice mattress,” boasts verified Amazon reviewer, Dan. “I got the medium firmness and it’s perfect for me. It’s nice and soft but still supportive. I’ve only slept a couple of nights on it but it’s a huge improvement over the old boxspring I had. I have no more pain in my back, neck, and shoulders when waking up. If you’re heavier or like a firmer mattress I would opt for the firm, but for me medium is perfect.”
Another verified Amazon reviewer, Christine, says, “Even though this is a bed-in-a-box item, it is very thick in depth like a store mattress. I got a soft one—you can select your firmness level. It cradles the body. This is the best mattress ever. The edges are very firm, so you can sit on the edge of the bed and not slide or roll off. Motion transfer is good too. You can move around on one side while the other side stays still. Also, it ‘inflated’ immediately—no waiting a day for it to get to its proper size.”
However, one customer complains it provides too much support.
“Yes, it’s comfortable. However, there is way too much support. It doesn’t sink in very much and is fairly comfortable but after about six hours my lower back and hips are screaming at me. I’ve never had pain in this area of my body before after sleeping. I’m buying a 3-inch mattress topper and praying that it helps. Customer Care from Brooklyn Bedding said it can take up to 1-2 months to settle in.”
Specs
| Material | Hybrid |
| Warranty | 10 years |
| Firmness | Soft, medium, firm |
| Trial period | 120 nights |
| Shipping | Free |
| Weight (Queen) | 90 lbs |
| Height | 13.25″ tall |
Best organic mattress-in-a-box: Birch Natural
Key product features
What you should know
The Birch Natural mattress embodies a commitment to sustainability and health, featuring organic materials like GOTS-certified cotton, New Zealand wool, and natural Talalay latex, offering an eco-friendly sleep solution without compromising on comfort or support.
- The Birch Natural mattress includes a Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) certified organic cotton cover that is both soft and breathable.
- Before sales or promotions, the mattress costs $2,123,80 for a queen, which is on the higher end of the price for a hybrid mattress.
- It’s a fantastic choice for those seeking an organic mattress that aligns with their values and offers a comfortable and restful night’s sleep
- The New Zealand wool acts as a natural flame retardant and provides temperature regulation, keeping you cool in the summer and warm in the winter.
Why we like Birch Natural as best organic
As a company, Birch has upheld an unwavering commitment to using natural and sustainable materials to create a healthy and environmentally friendly sleep environment. ( 2 ) Constructed with organic and eco-friendly materials, the Birch Natural mattress is a testament to this commitment.
The Birch Natural mattress includes a Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) ( 3 ) certified organic cotton cover that is both soft and breathable. Beneath the cover lies a layer of organic New Zealand wool, which acts as a natural flame retardant and provides temperature regulation, keeping you cool in the summer and warm in the winter.
The core of the Birch Natural mattress consists of natural Talalay latex, sourced from sustainable rubber tree plantations. This latex offers excellent support and durability while being free from harmful chemicals and synthetic additives.
Under all that natural goodness is an innerspring system with individually wrapped coils made from recycled steel. These coils provide robust support, promote proper spinal alignment, and contribute to the mattress’s durability.
It’s a fantastic choice for those seeking an organic mattress that aligns with their values and offers a comfortable and restful night’s sleep, but it also comes at a premium price. Before any sales or promotions, the mattress costs $2,123,80 for a queen, which is getting into the higher end of the price range for a hybrid mattress.
Specs
| Material | Hybrid |
| Warranty | 25 years |
| Firmness | Medium-firm |
| Trial period | 100 nights |
| Shipping | Free |
| Weight (Queen) | 105 lbs |
| Height | 11″ tall |
How we tested the best mattresses-in-a-box
Our team reviews trustworthy clinical trials and science-based data and puts each bed to the sleep test. The certified sleep science coaches, industry experts, and consumers who make up our expert review team physically test each product—and we have the images to prove it. We test each of the consumer-focused factors below so you can have faith in the accuracy of our results. Check out our mattress testing methodology for more information.
Our scoring methodology for mattresses
We assign each mattress a score of one through five for each of the 16 categories we test. Rather than simply average those scores together, we weigh them based on what’s most important. We then average them to create a cumulative score.
For example, when evaluating mattresses, it’s essential to consider a broad range of factors from the tangible—like firmness, support, and pressure relief—to the intangible, such as customer service and warranty options. A mattress with an exceptional warranty option is great as it provides a safety net for your investment while adding value and peace of mind. However, it doesn’t directly influence the core function of the mattress, which is to deliver a comfortable and supportive sleep, so it won’t impact the overall score as much as a product’s performance.
Using these individual scores, we create an overall score on a scale of one out of five. A score of five is the highest possible rating, and one is the lowest.
Testing criteria
Sleep experience—30%
A high-quality mattress should feel like it’s designed to provide you with the best sleep of your life. It should also deliver on the promise of a great sleep experience. Our sleep science coaches assess various factors to reflect the functional aspects of the mattress as well as the user’s sleep experience. Here’s what we’re looking for:
- Temperature regulation: A lot of people think how hot or cold they get at night ( 4 ) has more to do with their mattress than it actually does. Your sleep temperature has more to do with your personal physiology, sleep attire, and bedding than it does with how your mattress is constructed. But your mattress does play a role in temperature regulation. We test mattresses over a range of conditions so you can figure out for yourself if your sleep routine will have you sleeping hot, cold, or just right.
- Motion isolation: If you have a sleeping partner, especially one who sleeps lighter than you, knowing if you’ll disturb them when moving in or getting out of bed is critically important. We test for motion transfer and motion isolation at various distances from edge to center to give you the intel you need to understand if your movement will disturb your partner.
- Edge support: Everyone wants a comfortable mattress that helps them sleep well and doesn’t cause additional discomfort or aches and pains. This often means using materials that form your body and reduce friction points. But when getting in/out of bed, getting ready, or even working, having a mattress with edges that give too much or are too soft can be a real problem. We test mattress edges to find the ones that offer the greatest support.
- Technology: This may come as a surprise, but some mattresses come equipped with a range of technological features to enhance sleep quality and comfort ( 5 ) such as sleep tracking, temperature control via mobile app, smart home integration, and even vibration features. We evaluate them for effectiveness and whether they change the sleeping experience for the better.
Comfort and support—30%
Alongside the sleep experience, comfort and support are just as important for a healthy and restful sleep. A high-quality mattress should assist in providing relief with certain aches and pains a user may experience when sleeping. It should also help users wake up feeling energized and rested. Here’s what we’re looking for:
- Firmness: How firm you prefer the mattress is unique to you, but knowing if a mattress firmness rating matches your preference can be a bit trickier. Different manufacturers have different factors for determining firmness ratings. So, we’re measuring all mattresses with one central protocol to take out the guesswork.
- Pressure relief: Your unique body and sleep position(s) can determine if and how a mattress causes pressure ( 6 ) or relieves it. Our range of testers try out each mattress to give you the best information possible.
- Spinal alignment support: Spinal alignment is crucial for preventing back pain and ensuring a great night’s sleep. Our testers have a detailed process to examine how well a mattress maintains the spine in a natural position across various sleeping positions.
- Customization: Does the mattress offer adjustable firmness, removable cooling layers, split configurations, or removable covers?
Value—20%
Assessing value involves a meticulous examination of several key factors that contribute to a mattress’s worth. A mattress that is priced just within reach of its target audience, yet surpasses competitors in terms of materials, performance, and support, presents a compelling value proposition. However, value is not solely determined by the lowest price point. We also determine it by finding the balance between cost and the tangible benefits a mattress provides.
Customer experience—10%
Sometimes, the mattress can be great, but the overall shopping experience wasn’t. That could easily put a sour taste in a user’s mouth about the mattress they just purchased. We put in the hours to determine how well the entire process of buying a mattress matches users’ expectations and what options are available when something goes wrong.
- Shipping : Mattresses are big and heavy, making shipping especially more challenging. We rate mattresses by factors such as shipping times/speeds, delivery service, mattress haul away and setup, and more.
- Warranty : If the company offers generous warranty policies, if something goes wrong, that’s a good sign. We’ll read every line and see if it’s worth it.
- Customer service: Companies that offer multiple contact methods and have helpful, knowledgeable customer service reps earn higher marks.
- Sleep trial : We favor mattress companies that offer free trials and give you some time to, quite literally, sleep on it.
Health and safety—10%
It’s important to understand that a mattress is more than just a sleeping surface—it’s an environment where you spend a significant portion of your life. We meticulously assess critical aspects of mattresses that may directly impact your well-being and peace of mind.
Our factors in this rating include:
- Hypoallergenic materials: With their ability to deter allergies ( 7 ), it’s obvious why some users would find this an important factor when choosing a mattress if they have allergies or sensitivities. This factor ensures your sleeping environment is conducive to health rather than a source of irritation.
- Off-gassing and chemical exposure: There is a concern that the release of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) (8 ) from mattress materials, such as polyurethane foam (used in memory foam mattresses), may affect air quality. We evaluate the extent of off-gassing and the safety of materials used, aiming for mattresses that minimize chemical exposure.
- Safety certifications: These serve as a benchmark for quality and safety, verifying that a mattress has met vigorous health and environmental standards ( 9 ). Our testers look for certifications such as CertiPUR-US®, OEKO-TEX® Standard 100, and Made Safe®.
Types of mattresses-in-a-box
Mattresses-in-a-box come in various types, each with its own set of materials and features to cater to different sleep preferences and needs. Here are the most common types:
- Memory foam : Memory foam mattresses are known for their contouring and pressure-relieving properties. They conform to your body’s shape, offering excellent support and comfort. These mattresses are excellent for reducing pressure points and minimizing motion transfer.
- Latex : Latex mattresses use natural or synthetic latex foam. Natural latex is eco-friendly and provides a responsive and supportive surface. Latex mattresses are durable and known for their cooling properties.
- Innerspring : Innerspring mattresses feature a coil or spring system at their core. They offer good support and durability. Modern innerspring mattresses often include foam layers for added comfort and pressure relief.
- Hybrid : Hybrid mattresses combine elements of innerspring and foam or latex mattresses. They typically have a coil system for support and additional comfort layers made of foam or latex. Hybrid mattresses aim to offer the benefits of both worlds, such as support, bounce, and pressure relief.
- Adjustable air : Adjustable air mattresses allow you to customize the firmness level by inflating or deflating air chambers within the mattress. This feature is beneficial for couples with different firmness preferences.
- Organic/natural : Organic mattresses use materials like organic cotton, natural latex, and organic wool to reduce chemical exposure and promote environmental sustainability. ( 10 ) They are an ideal choice for those who prioritize natural and eco-friendly options.
How to unbox your mattress-in-a-box
Unboxing a mattress-in-a-box is a relatively simple process. Still, it’s important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions carefully to avoid damaging the mattress or risking injury. Here are the general steps to unbox a mattress-in-a-box:
- Prepare the space. Clear the area where you plan to set up the mattress. Ensure there’s enough room for the fully expanded mattress and that the space is clean and dry.
- Unbox in the bedroom. It’s best to unbox the mattress in the room where you intend to use it. Mattresses can be heavy and challenging to move once they’re fully expanded.
- Open the box. Carefully remove the mattress-in-a-box from its outer packaging. Use scissors or a utility knife to cut the box open along the seams, being cautious not to cut into the mattress itself. Be especially careful when using sharp tools to avoid damaging the mattress.
- Unroll the mattress. Once the box is open, carefully unroll the compressed mattress onto your bed frame or foundation. Make sure it’s oriented correctly with the top side up, as indicated by any labels or markings.
- Remove plastic packaging. The mattress will be tightly wrapped in plastic. Carefully cut or tear the plastic open, being cautious not to damage the mattress. As you cut the plastic, the mattress will start to expand.
- Wait for expansion. Give the mattress time to fully expand to its normal size and shape. How long this process takes depends on the mattress type and brand. Some mattresses may fully expand within minutes, while others may take longer.
- Allow for ventilation. It’s a good idea to allow the mattress to air out and ventilate for a few hours to dissipate any residual odors from the packaging. This is especially true for memory foam mattresses.
- Make the bed. Once the mattress has fully expanded and any initial odors have dissipated, you can make your bed with your preferred bedding.
- Dispose of packaging. Properly dispose of the cardboard box and plastic wrapping according to your local recycling guidelines.
Some mattresses may have specific unboxing instructions provided by the manufacturer, so always refer to those instructions first. Additionally, if possible, have someone assist you with the unboxing and setup, especially if the mattress is heavy or you have any mobility concerns.
How we chose the best mattresses-in-a-box
Our expert review team narrows its list of best mattresses-in-a-box based on a variety of consumer-focused criteria. These include:
- How well the bed transfers motion to minimize mattress movement
- Its ability to dissipate body heat and regulate body temperature
- How well it relieves pressure points at the hips, shoulders, and joints
- How well it keeps the spine aligned, preventing any morning kinks or lower back strain
Firmness is also a consideration, as different sleep positions call for different firmness preferences for optimal comfort.
We also consider the mattress’s construction. Quality materials ensure a more robust mattress that can withstand the test of time. For example, memory foam and latex tend to be more durable than polyfoam.
Finally, we look at factors that are outside comfort and performance but are just as important: customer service, sleep trial, and warranty. Mattresses are an investment, after all, and you want peace of mind knowing that any issues will be addressed quickly and efficiently.
FAQs
Are mattresses-in-a-box worth it?
The worthiness of a mattress-in-a-box varies depending on individual needs and preferences. These mattresses can be a practical choice for those who value convenience, as they are easy to purchase online and set up. They often come with generous trial periods and return policies. Mattresses-in-a-box can offer good value in terms of quality and features, making them cost-effective options compared to traditional in-store mattresses.
However, the decision ultimately hinges on personal comfort, as finding the right firmness, support, and additional features, such as cooling or motion isolation, is crucial.
Additionally, considering factors like durability and researching the brand’s reputation can help determine if a mattress-in-a-box is a worthwhile investment for a restful night’s sleep.
How much does a mattress-in-a-box cost?
The cost of a mattress-in-a-box can vary widely depending on several factors, including the brand, type of mattress, size, and specific features. On average, you can find budget-friendly options starting around $300 to $500 for a twin or twin XL size, while queen-sized mattresses typically range from $600 to $1,000. Premium or specialized mattresses with advanced features, organic materials, or smart technology can cost upwards of $1,000 to $2,500 or more.
How long do mattresses-in-a-box last?
The lifespan of a mattress-in-a-box can vary based on several factors, including the quality of materials, usage, and maintenance. On average, these mattresses can last between seven to 10 years. Higher-quality models, especially those with durable materials like latex or high-density foam, may last 12 to 15 years or more with proper care.
Regularly rotating the mattress, using a mattress protector, and maintaining a suitable foundation can help extend its longevity. It’s crucial to refer to the manufacturer’s warranty and care instructions for specific guidelines on how to maximize the lifespan of your mattress-in-a-box.
How long does it take to unbox a mattress?
Unboxing a mattress typically takes anywhere from a few minutes to several hours, depending on the specific mattress and its type. Memory foam and latex mattresses often expand and take shape within several minutes or up to a few hours. In contrast, some hybrid mattresses with thicker layers or innerspring components may require 24 hours or more to fully expand.
It’s important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions regarding the recommended wait time before using the mattress to ensure it reaches its intended size and comfort level.
Our experts
Dr. Raj Dasgupta, MD, FACP, FCCP, FAASM
Quadruple-board certified in pulmonary, sleep, internal, and critical care medicine. An active clinical researcher, Dr. Raj currently practices at the University of Southern California, where he’s been awarded the Excellence in Teaching award six years in a row. He’s also an associate professor of clinical medicine, assistant program director of the internal medicine residency program, and the associate program director of the sleep medicine fellowship at USC.
Krista Manning
Krista Manning is an accomplished medical copy editor and fact-checker who stands out in the pharmaceutical, health, and wellness domains. With a meticulous eye for detail and a command of medical language, Krista ensures the accuracy and clarity of content. Beyond her professional expertise, Krista is an advocate for mental health awareness. Recognizing the crucial intersection of psychological and physical well-being, she actively contributes to projects that promote mental health awareness within the healthcare narrative. Krista’s commitment extends beyond the pages she edits, emphasizing the holistic nature of health communication.
Jennifer Walker-Journey
Fortune Recommends Writer
About Author
Jennifer Walker-Journey writes on a variety of topics, from law, healthcare, and pharmaceutical products to food, travel, and consumer products. Her clients include law firms, healthcare systems, financial corporations, public health entities, and digital marketing firms. Her work has been featured online at USA Today, WebMD, HowStuffWorks, Psychedelic Spotlight, Health, AARP, Everyday Health, Women, Aging in Place, and in magazines such as Sea Island Life, Salamander, and Omni. When she isn’t writing, she runs, almost daily, in hopes that she’ll beat her last best time.