Purpose: To study retrospectively the long-term prognostic significance of HER-2 oncoprotein expression in breast cancer (BC).
Patients and methods: Two hundred nine consecutive female patients with invasive operable BC from a defined urban population were observed for a median of 30 years. Tissue expression of HER-2 oncoprotein was demonstrated by using an immunoperoxidase procedure.
Results: Fifty-five (26%) patients had cancer and a positive HER-2 oncoprotein stain reaction. They had significantly worse 10- and 25-year survival rates than those patients who had a negative stain reaction in their cancer (31% v 48% and 31% v 39%, respectively; P = .004). HER-2 expression was also associated with a poorer survival among patients who had axillary nodal metastases (P = .003; n = 104), but not among those patients who did not have metastases. HER-2 expression was related to the ductal histologic type, poor histologic grade, and high mitotic count, but not to tumor size, axillary nodal status, DNA ploidy, or S-phase fraction (SPF). In a multivariate analysis among patients with nodal metastases, HER-2 expression was an independent prognostic factor (P = .04) that predicted poor survival. However, if the entire series was entered onto the analysis, it did not emerge as an independent factor.
Conclusions: HER-2 oncoprotein expression has long-term prognostic significance for predicting poor survival in BC, and it has an independent prognostic value among patients who presented with axillary nodal metastases. This result is contradictory to the argument that HER-2 expression is only a marker for drug resistance because the patients were not given adjuvant drug therapy.