Background: Tibial baseplates were occasionally reported with clinical fatigue failures. This study postulated that tibial baseplate of a specific mobile bearing design with a uniform thickness across the baseplate offers more fatigue resistance than the fixed-bearing design. Tibial baseplates of a fixed bearing and a mobile bearing design were fatigue-tested in vitro to study their fatigue resistance.
Methods: Five samples of each design were tested under a sinusoidal loading between 90 N and 900 N at 30 Hz till failure or 10 million cycles. Experimental setup followed a standard published test method. Scanning electron microscope was used for inspecting the fracture surface of the failed baseplate.
Findings: Two baseplates of fixed bearing design failed before 10 million cycles. Fatigue crack advancement marks were visible on the fractured surface of the failed samples. The fractured cross-section showed that the failure started near the end of the fin, it was likely due to the stress concentration as stress singularity existed at a point of sudden geometrical change. Five mobile bearing baseplates passed the test. Design of the tibial baseplate without fin structure and with a uniform thickness across the whole baseplate could help reducing the incidence of fatigue failure.
Interpretation: The prosthesis survival rate was influenced by the long-term integrity of the metallic part of the prostheses such as the tibial baseplate. This study revealed that the tibial baseplate of a mobile bearing design with a uniform thickness provided better fatigue resistance than fixed bearing one. Standardized fatigue screening of the tibial baseplate was considered important in designing knee prostheses.