Background: At present, atypical as well as anatomic liver resections are recommended as the surgical therapy for gallbladder cancer (GC) at stages > or = T 2. The aim of this study was to compare atypical with anatomic resections (mostly resections of segments IV b / V with selective vascular occlusion using the round ligament approach).
Patients and methods: Between November 1994 and January 2007, n = 56 patients were treated for GC. The staging, operative and histological results and the postoperative course were recorded. In addition, the survivals at a mean follow-up of 13 (range: 3-54) months were estimated and compared between the two study groups.
Results: We performed 28 liver resections for GC (n = 14 atypical and n = 14 anatomic resections). In the anatomic resection group, there was one extended right hepatectomy as well as thirteen segment IV b / V resections. The volume of the resected liver specimen, the frequency of the Pringle manoeuvre, the transfusion requirements, and the duration of the operation did not differ between the two study groups. However, in only 64 % of the atypical resections, the recommended resection margin of at least 3 cm could be achieved. One patient died after extended hepatectomy. There were no other major complications. The mean follow-up was 16 +/- 5 months in the anatomic and 22 +/- 7 months in the atypical resection group. Survival was not statistically different between the two study groups.
Conclusion: Segment IV b / V resections are attractive procedures to treat GC due to their lower invasiveness in spite oncological adequacy. However, we could not demonstrate any superiority in terms of survival for the segment IV b / V liver resections. Nevertheless, extended liver resections are rarely necessary in the operative treatment of GC.