Where and what damage occurs at the acromial undersurface in patients with rotator cuff tears?

Background: The gross pathology of the acromial undersurface in shoulders with rotator cuff tears with subacromial impingement is not completely understood. Many researchers have focused on damage to the anterior one-third area of the acromial undersurface, but few have studied the middle and posterior one-third areas. The purpose of this study was to clarify where and what damage occurs at the acromial undersurface in patients with rotator cuff tears.

Methods: We performed arthroscopic shoulder (n = 182, all with rotator cuff tears; mean age, 64.9 ± 8.4 years) and cadaveric shoulder (n = 23, 14 intact cuffs and 9 rotator cuff tears; mean age, 74.8 years) evaluations to observe the extent and degree of damage to the acromial undersurface. We statistically analyzed the association between the severity of the damage to the acromial undersurface (assessed using the Copeland-Levy classification as A0, normal; A1, minor scuffing; A2, major damage; or A3, visualization of bare bone area) and rotator cuff tear size (assessed using the classification of DeOrio and Cofield as partial; small, <1 cm; medium, 1-3 cm; or large or massive, >3 cm).

Results: The anterior, middle, and posterior one-thirds of the acromial undersurface were somewhat damaged (class A1-A3) in 92.6%, 90.1%, and 78.6% of shoulders with rotator cuff tears, respectively, according to arthroscopic evaluation. Increasing cuff tear size was significantly associated with worsening degree of damage to the acromial undersurface (P < .001). In the 9 cadaveric shoulders with rotator cuff tears, class A1-A3 damage was identified in the anterior one-third area in 100%, in the middle one-third area in 88.9%, and in the posterior one-third area in 33.3%. In the 14 cadaveric shoulders with a normal rotator cuff, class A1-A3 damage was identified in the anterior one-third area in 35.7%, in the middle one-third area in 14.3%, and in the posterior one-third area in 0.71%.

Conclusion: Damage to the acromial undersurface in patients with rotator cuff tears occurred at the middle, posterior, and anterior one-third areas, and the degree of damage was related to cuff tear size. Surgeons should evaluate the entire acromial undersurface to check for subacromial impingement damage at the middle and posterior one-third areas as well as the anterior one-third area of the acromial undersurface; this might aid in the treatment of patients with rotator cuff disease or subacromial impingement syndrome.