Exercise robustly increases the glucose demands of skeletal muscle. This demand is met not only by muscle glycogenolysis, but also by accelerated liver glucose production from hepatic glycogenolysis and gluconeogenesis to fuel mechanical work and prevent hypoglycemia during exercise. Hepatic gluconeogenesis during exercise is dependent on highly coordinated responses within and between muscle and liver. Specifically, exercise increases the rate at which gluconeogenic precursors such as pyruvate/lactate or amino acids are delivered from muscle to the liver, extracted by the liver, and channeled into glucose. Herein, we examined the effects of interrupting gluconeogenic efficiency and capacity on exercise performance by deleting hepatic mitochondrial pyruvate carrier 2 (MPC2) and/or alanine transaminase 2 (ALT2) in mice. We found that deletion of MPC2 or ALT2 alone did not significantly affect time to exhaustion or post-exercise glucose concentrations in treadmill exercise tests, but mice lacking both MPC2 and ALT2 in liver (DKO) reached exhaustion faster and exhibited lower circulating glucose during and after exercise. Use of ²H/¹³C metabolic flux analyses demonstrated that DKO mice exhibited lower endogenous glucose production owing to decreased glycogenolysis and gluconeogenesis at rest and during exercise. The decreased gluconeogenesis was accompanied by lower anaplerotic, cataplerotic, and TCA cycle fluxes. Collectively, these findings demonstrate that the transition of the liver to the gluconeogenic mode is critical for preventing hypoglycemia and sustaining performance during exercise. The results also illustrate the need for interorgan crosstalk during exercise as described by the Cahill and Cori cycles.