Lateral neck dissection surgeon volume and complications in head and neck endocrine malignancy

Background: Increased surgeon volume is associated with decreased complications for many surgeries, including thyroidectomy. We sought to use two national databases to assess for associations between surgeon volume and complications in patients undergoing lateral neck dissection for thyroid or parathyroid malignancy.

Methods: Lateral neck dissections for thyroid and parathyroid cancer from the Nationwide Inpatient Sample and State Inpatient Database were analyzed. The primary outcome was any inpatient complication common to thyroidectomy, parathyroidectomy, or lateral neck dissection. The principle independent variable was surgeon volume. Multivariable analysis was then performed on this retrospective cohort study.

Results: The 1,094 Nationwide Inpatient Sample discharges had a 28% (305/1,094) complication rate. After adjustment, surgeons with volumes between 3-34 neck dissections/year demonstrated a surgeon volume-complication rate association [adjusted odds ratio: 1.03; 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.01-1.05]. The 1,235 State inpatient Database discharges had a 21% (258/1,235) overall complication rate, and no association between surgeon volume and complication rates (P=0.25).

Conclusions: This retrospective review of 2,329 discharges for patients undergoing lateral neck dissection for thyroid or parathyroidectomy demonstrated somewhat conflicting results. The Nationwide Inpatient Sample demonstrated increasing complication rates for increasing surgeon volume among intermediate volume surgeons, while the State Inpatient Database demonstrated no surgeon volume-complication association. Given these disparate results, and further limitations with these databases, conclusions regarding surgical volume and clinical decision making based on these data should be assessed cautiously.