Many animals moving through fluids exhibit highly coordinated group movement that is thought to reduce the cost of locomotion. However, direct energetic measurements demonstrating the energy-saving benefits of fluid-mediated collective movements remain elusive. By characterizing both aerobic and anaerobic metabolic energy contributions in schools of giant danio (Devario aequipinnatus), we discovered that fish schools have a concave upward shaped metabolism-speed curve, with a minimum metabolic cost at ~1 body length s-1. We demonstrate that fish schools reduce total energy expenditure (TEE) per tail beat by up to 56% compared to solitary fish. When reaching their maximum sustained swimming speed, fish swimming in schools had a 44% higher maximum aerobic performance and used 65% less non-aerobic energy compared to solitary individuals, which lowered the TEE and total cost of transport by up to 53%, near the lowest recorded for any aquatic organism. Fish in schools also recovered from exercise 43% faster than solitary fish. The non-aerobic energetic savings that occur when fish in schools actively swim at high speed can considerably improve both peak and repeated performance which is likely to be beneficial for evading predators. These energetic savings may underlie the prevalence of coordinated group locomotion in fishes.
Keywords: bioenergetics; biomechanics; collective behaviour; fish; locomotion; metabolic rate; physics of living systems.
Schools of fish, flocks of birds flying in a V-formation and other collective movements of animals are common and mesmerizing behaviours. Moving as a group can have many benefits including helping the animals to find food and reproduce and protecting them from predators. Collective movements may also help animals to save energy as they travel by altering the flow of air or water around individuals. Computational models based on the flow of water suggest several possible mechanisms for how fish swimming in schools may use less energy compared to fish swimming on their own. However, few studies have directly measured how much energy fish schools actually use while they swim compared to a solitary individual. Zhang and Lauder used a device called a respirometer to directly measure the energy used by small tropical fish, known as giant danio, swimming in schools and on their own in an aquatic treadmill. The experiments found that the fish swimming in schools used 53% less energy compared with fish swimming on their own, and that fish in schools recovered from a period of high-speed swimming 43% quicker than solitary fish. By adjusting the flow of the water in the tanks, the team were able to study the fish schools swimming at different speeds. This revealed that the fish used more energy when they hovered slowly, or swam fast, than when they swam at a more moderate speed. Previous studies have found that many fish tend to swim at a moderate speed of around one body length per second while they travel long distances. Zhang and Lauder found that the giant danio used the least energy when they swam at this ‘migratory’ speed. These findings show that swimming in schools can help fish save energy compared with swimming alone. Along with furthering our understanding of how collective movement benefits fish and other animals, this work may help engineers to design robots that can team up with other robots to move more efficiently through the water.
© 2023, Zhang and Lauder.