Water adsorption/desorption cyclability of porous materials is a prerequisite for diverse applications, including atmospheric water harvesting (AWH), humidity autocontrol (HAC), heat pumps and chillers, and hydrolytic catalysis. However, unambiguous molecular insights into the correlation between underlying building blocks and the cyclability are still highly elusive. In this work, by taking advantage of the well-established isoreticular synthetic principle in Zr(IV) metal-organic frameworks (Zr-MOFs), we show that the inherent density of hydrogen atoms in the organic skeleton can play a key role in regulating the water sorption cyclability of MOFs. The ease of isoreticular practice of Zr-MOFs enables the successful syntheses of two pairs of isostructural Zr-MOFs (NU-901 and NU-903, NU-950 and SJTU-9) from pyrene- or benzene-cored carboxylate linkers, which feature scu and sqc topological nets, respectively. NU-901 and NU-950 comprised of pyrene skeletons carrying more hydrogen-bonding anchoring sites show distinctly inferior cyclability as compared with NU-903 and SJTU-9 built of benzene units. Single-crystal X-ray crystallography analysis of the hydrated structure clearly unveils the water molecule-involved interactions with the hydrogen-bonding donors of benzene moieties. Remarkably, NU-903 and SJTU-9 isomers exhibit outstanding water vapor sorption capacities as well as working capacities at the desired humidity range with potential implementations covering indoor humidity control and water harvesting. Our findings uncover the importance of hydrogen-bonding anchoring site engineering of organic scaffold in manipulating the framework durability toward water sorption cycle and will also likely facilitate the rational design and development of highly robust porous materials.