Thiocarboxamide chelates are known to assemble [2Mn2S] diamond core complexes via μ-S bridges that connect two MnI(CO)3 fragments. These can exist as syn- and anti-isomers and interconvert via 16-electron, monomeric intermediates. Herein, we demonstrate that reduction of such Mn2 derivatives leads to a loss of one thiocarboxamide ligand and a switch of ligand binding mode from an O- to N-donor of the amide group, yielding a dianionic butterfly rhomb with a short Mn0-Mn0 distance, 2.52 Å. Structural and chemical analyses suggest that reduction of the Mn(I) centers is dependent on the protonation state of the amide-H, as total deprotonation followed by reduction does not result in the reduction of the Mn2 core. Partial deprotonation followed by reduction suggests a pathway that involves monomeric Mn(CO)3(S-O) and Mn(CO)3(S-N) intermediates. Ligand modifications to tertiary amides that remove the possibility of amide-H reduction led to complexes that preserve the [2Mn2S] diamond core during chemical reduction. Further comparison with the tethered system, linking the Mn(CO)3(S-O) sites together, suggests that dimer dissociation is necessary for the overall reductive transformation. These results highlight organomanganese carbonyl chemistry to establish illustrations of peptide fragment binding modes in the uptake of low-valent metal carbonyls related to binuclear active sites of biocatalysts.