The objective of this study was to examine the prevalence, characteristics, and outcomes of spine surgery among a membership of American orthopaedic surgeons with a particular interest in spine care [North American Spine Society (NASS)] and a general membership of Canadian orthopaedic surgeons [Canadian Orthopaedic Association (COA)]. A 25-item multiple choice questionnaire was developed and mailed to both memberships. The COA response rate was 45.9%; the NASS response rate was 45.8%. Of those who replied, 17.2% had undergone spinal surgery, and the results differed significantly between the COA at 12.9% and NASS at 21.9%. As a percentage of the total mailing, 7.7% had undergone spinal surgery. These results differed significantly between the COA at 5.9% and NASS at 9.7%. Although the surgery rate for NASS respondents was more than 1.5 times that of COA respondents, they had strikingly similar outcomes. They are a highly motivated, self-employed group who missed little work before and after having surgery.