Guardian Weekly

Disabled villains: the trope that won’t die

IDECIDED, SOME YEARS AGO, TO READ ALL OF IAN FLEMING’S James Bond novels. It may have been a fit of nostalgia for the Roger Moore films I grew up watching, or perhaps I was bored with writing short stories for a minuscule readership and wanted to know what mass-market success read like. It was quite an experience – and one I found myself recalling when I found out that Fleming’s books were being revised, chiefly in order to remove some, though not all, of the casual racism. Also some of the misogyny, though probably not all of that either.

My first question, on reading the news, was what kind of reader exactly was Ian Fleming Publications Ltd envisioning. Presumably someone who would, were it not for the most explicit slurs, really enjoy the ethnic stereotypes. Or someone who would, were it not for the full-on rapes, really enjoy the pervasive sexism. The other question that struck me was this: what on earth are they going to do about disability?

As a wheelchair user, I could not help noticing that the original Bond books had, shall we say, an interesting relationship to embodied difference. It was a feature of Fleming’s writing that would be all but impossible to alter through the interventions of a sensitivity reader. Fleming’s attitude to disability was encoded not only in words and phrases, but in characterisation and plot. It is not a novel observation that Bond villains tend to be, to use a less sensitive register, disfigured and deformed. Dr No with his steel pincers instead of hands, Blofeld with his scars, Hugo Drax, the villain from Moonraker, with his facial disfigurement and his pathetic attempt to conceal it with a “bushy reddish beard”. Were they not successfully self-employed, most of Bond’s enemies would probably qualify for disability benefits.

Even as Fleming’s storylines have in the Bond films been progressively stripped of their racism and misogyny, disability has remained an essential aspect of their characterisation. This is particularly jarring in is. And that is the main function of disability in these stories – an outwardly visible sign of an inner quality.

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Guardian Weekly

Guardian Weekly2 min read
Are Smoke Signals Telling Me To Make An Oil Change In The Kitchen?
Should you (that is, not can you) cook with extra-virgin olive oil? Antonio, Atlanta, Georgia, US There’s no blanket “should” to most things culinary, and the short answer is, it depends. There’s personal preference: budget (extra-virgin olive oil [e
Guardian Weekly3 min readInternational Relations
Stormy Waters
Hopes that tensions in the South China Sea might ease have been short lived. Just weeks after the Philippines and China struck a deal to try to stop dangerous confrontations at Second Thomas Shoal, a new flashpoint has emerged. Over recent weeks, Man
Guardian Weekly2 min readInternational Relations
IDF Holds Self-investigation After Shooting Of US Activist
US officials last weekend insisted that a ceasefire in Gaza is close even as fighting raged unabated in the block-aded Palestinian territory and violence spirals in the occupied West Bank, where witnesses said an American-Turkish dual national was ki

Related Books & Audiobooks