2024 NFL Draft best bets: Take a chance on Dallas Turner and fading Jayden Daniels and J.J. McCarthy

AUBURN, ALABAMA - NOVEMBER 25:  Dallas Turner #15 of the Alabama Crimson Tide reacts after a defensive stop against the Auburn Tigers during the fourth quarter at Jordan-Hare Stadium on November 25, 2023 in Auburn, Alabama. (Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images)
By Austin Mock
Apr 24, 2024

The Athletic has live coverage of NFL Draft Rounds 4-7. Follow along with our picks tracker, best available and The Beast

When everyone has an opinion on a topic, the sports betting market usually takes a stab at posting odds for said topic. And considering everyone has an opinion on the NFL Draft, the oddsmakers have posted a ton of markets.

Anzeige

My process for betting on the NFL Draft is a little different than my process on, say, the NFL. I’m not modeling the draft, per se, but I am taking a data-driven approach to betting on the draft. For instance, I’m using our consensus big boards, NFL Draft insiders including our Dane Brugler’s information, and many other sources within the industry to make informed decisions. There are a million rumors between the combine and the actual draft and sifting through what is real and what is smoke and mirrors.

Another thing to note is that a lot of the “one-way” markets have a ton of “vig” and it’s hard to find value. A one-way market is when there is just a “yes” price attached to a player like “odds to be drafted in the first round“. I tend to stay away from these as the vig is too much to overcome unless information comes to light and you can win a race to place the bet.

My last thought is that most drafts have a ton of variance and this one is no different. I am confident that not many people know what’s happening with the second overall pick and that affects the third overall pick and so on. I’ve seen a few different times this week say that the second, third, fourth, sixth and eighth picks are turning points in the draft. In other words, nobody knows anything.

All odds from BetMGM.

Best Bets

Jayden Daniels Third QB Drafted (+475)

There will be a theme here and that has to do with what was noted above. I’m not sure anyone knows what is happening with the Commanders at the second pick outside of the Washington front office. Jayden Daniels is now the significant favorite to go second overall and I just don’t know how that’s possible with all of the uncertainty. I’ve talked to our draft team and looked at our overall consensus big board and Maye is the better prospect. Sure, the Commanders could think differently but Daniels is closer to J.J. McCarthy than Maye on a majority of boards. If this market isn’t available, I think Drake Maye Drafted Second Overall is good at any price better than +150.

Anzeige

Worst price to bet: +150

Dallas Turner Draft Position Under 9.5 (+130)

There has been a lot of steam with Byron Murphy II and Laiatu Latu this week and I’m going to take a good price with Turner here. I think he can go eighth or ninth here so we have two shots to get this home. Turner is rated higher than both on the consensus big board and he’s an edge rusher which gives him a positional edge over Murphy II and has a better track record when it comes to health versus Latu.

Worst price to bet: Under 9.5 (+120)

J.J. McCarthy Draft Position Over 5.5 (+118)

Quarterback inflation is a thing so someone could fall in love with McCarthy and select him in the top five or trade into to lose this bet. But I just think a guy who is graded more as a late first-round or early second-round prospect is more likely to fall out of the top five than be selected in it.

Total Quarterbacks selected in Round 1 Under 4.5 (+280)

Sticking with the quarterbacks here. I don’t think Bo Nix or Michael Penix Jr. is likely to go in the first round. Nix is favored to go in the second round so the worry here seems to be Penix Jr.. My issue with him is that he has some injury history and will be 24 this season. An older quarterback prospect with injury concerns is something that will scare teams off from using a first-round pick on — or at least it should. At this price, it’s a no-brainer for me to take a stab that the Washington signal-caller falls to the second round.

The Pulse Newsletter
The Pulse Newsletter

Free, daily sports updates direct to your inbox. Sign up

Free, daily sports updates direct to your inbox. Sign up

BuyBuy The Pulse Newsletter

Other Best Bets

Blake Corum First Running Back Drafted +500 (risk 0.5 units)

Worst price to bet: +400

Jaylen Wright First Running Back Drafted +1600 (risk 0.1 units)

Worst price to bet: +1500

Junior Colson First Linebacker Drafted +150

Worst price to bet: -150

Jaden Hicks First Safety Drafted +380

Worst price to bet: +200

Theo Johnson Second Tight End Drafted +300 (risk 0.25 units)

Worst price to bet: +300

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Final 2024 NFL mock draft: Caleb Williams No. 1, five QBs in top 13

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Why drafting a successful NFL quarterback remains 'an inexact science'

(Photo of Dallas Turner: Kevin C. Cox / Getty Images)

Get all-access to exclusive stories.

Subscribe to The Athletic for in-depth coverage of your favorite players, teams, leagues and clubs. Try a week on us.

Austin Mock

Austin Mock uses advanced statistical models and simulations to predict outcomes and rate performances in the NFL, college football, MLB and other sports. Follow Austin on Twitter @amock419