Selection of Electrical Equipment in Hazardous Areas
Selection of Electrical Equipment in Hazardous Areas
Selection of Electrical Equipment in Hazardous Areas
SELECTION OF ELECTRICAL
EQUIPMENT IN
HAZARDOUS AREAS
FLOPPY NO : TCE.M6-EL-CD-DOC-003
FILE NAME : M6-700-001.DOC
REV.NO R0 R1 ISSUE
CONTENT
1.0 SCOPE 1
1
2.0 CODES AND STANDARDS
2
3.0 INTRODUCTION
ISSUE
R1
REVISION
ISSUE
R1
1.0 SCOPE
The scope of this design guide is to provide an indepth information useful for the
proper selection of electrical equipment in hazardous areas.
ISSUE
R1
National Electric Code of USA – Articles 500, 501, 502, 503, 510, 511, 513, 514,
515, 516.
3.0 INTRODUCTION
The example of such areas are industries like petrochemical plants, oil refineries,
pharmaceutical plants, fertiliser plants etc. where hazardous chemicals are present
during normal/abnormal operating conditions.
IS: 5572 (part-I) – 1994 deals in detail with classification of hazardous areas, which
is as summarised below.
This classification is applicable only where a fire explosion hazard is unlikely and
may be caused only by simultaneous and improbable occurrence of an arc or spark
from an electrical failure and a hazardous atmosphere arising through failure of the
conditions of control. It presupposes that any hazardous atmosphere resulting from
ISSUE
R1
an abnormal occurrence is rapidly dispersed so that its possible contact with the
electrical apparatus is of minimum duration.
There are the areas where hazard is not present at all and as such ordinary electrical
equipment are used. These are also called safe areas.
Indian Standard classifies hazardous areas for flammable gases and vapours only.
For combustible dust and fibre, only American National Electric codes are most
comprehensive.
In order to asses the hazard potential, it is necessary to know the following four
properties of gases/liquids:
a) Flash Point
b) Ignition Temperature
c) Flammable limits
This applies only to gases and vapours. This is a limit within which they
form flammable mixture with air or oxygen. The LEL (lower explosion
limit) is the concentration of vapour or gas in air below which flame can not
propogate. Mixture below LEL is too lean to support combustion.
The UEL is the concentration of vapour or gases in air above which flame
can not propogate.
d) Vapour density
This is the ratio of weight of volume of gas or vapour to the weight of equal
volume of dry air at NTP.
Lighter than air gases usually move upwards and disperse fast because of
low vapour density. Only in a poorly ventilated space, they produce hazard.
Hydrocarbons, which are most commonly used, have vapours heavier than
air. These disperse in all directions and are sufficient in quantity to create
hazard.
ISSUE
R1
As per National Electric Code (USA), combustible dusts are classified under Class
II and Class III covered in both Division I and II areas.
a) Particle Size
Generally finer the dust greater is the chance of explosion. The most
explosive dust are finer than 200 mesh. Larger than 100 mesh dust is
usually not hazardous. Any dust finer than 60 mesh can be thereon into
suspension by the turbulence ahead of all explosion flame and so propogate
a dust explosion.
Explosives are most violent when the concentration of dust slightly exceed
that required for stoichiometric reaction with oxygen in an atmosphere.
They are least violent at the minimum explosive concentration. Turbulence
that intimately mixes the dust and air greatly increases the violency.
ISSUE
R1
Minimum ignition energy for the spark ignition of dust cloud ranges
between 10 to 40 millijoules, about 50 times that for a flammable vapour or
gas to air mixture. These minimum ignition energies are so small that any
spark or arc from electrical equipment of higher voltage can ignite the
combustible dust.
There are many ways in which electrical equipment can be designed or protected so
that it may be used in situations where the presence of a flammable gas could
constitute a hazard. Some methods offer a higher degree of protection than others,
but this does not necessarily imply that only techniques offering maximum
protection must be used in all circumstances.
Immersed in oil o
Encapsulated m
General principles have been laid down in IS:5571-1970 for the selection of
electrical equipment in hazardous areas. In Zone 1 area flameproof or pressurised
type equipment should be used, whereas in Zone 2 area increased safety type
equipment are permitted.
This is defined as an enclosure for electrical apparatus that will withstand (when the
covers or other access doors are properly secured) an internal explosion of the
flammable gas or vapour which may enter or which may originate inside the
enclosure, without suffering damage and without communicating the internal
inflammation (or explosion) to the external flammable gas or vapour in which it is
designed to be used through any joint or other structural openings in the enclosures.
For the purpose of flameproof enclosure the gases and vapours have been divided
into four groups and sub-groups, the grouping being determined by the safe
maximum dimensions of the joints of enclosures for use in them. These are the gap
lengths and the flange breadth; the gap length being the distance between the two
faces of a flange and the breadth being the distance across the face of the flange.
Gas groupings are according to IS:2148-68. Group I contains one gas only –
Methane – and this group is reserved exclusively for flameproof electric apparatus
for use in coal mines. Group IIA & IIB covers the hazardous atmospheres normally
ISSUE
R1
The exclusion of the use of gaskets on the flanges of flameproof enclosure makes it
almost impossible to make a normally designed enclosure completely weatherproof.
A liberal application of grease or non-hardening compound to the flanges will give
a certain amount of weatherproofing for a limited period. Therefore an additional
protection by a canopy is recommended for motors installed in the open.
In general, direct entry of external circuit conductors into the main enclosure is not
permitted. The flame-proof apparatus must consist of a main enclosure and one or
more terminal chambers. The cable should enter this terminal chamber through a
sealing box or through conduit or a packing gland.
Motor vibration level is likely to be particularly high in a mine and thus the danger
of premature fracture of the conduit (which is normally weak at the end of the
thread) is equally high.
For this reason conduit is always excluded for Group I motors and a sealing box
with armour clamps, almost invariably, used.
The increased safety concept is of German origin. This form of protection has been
applied extensively to motors and light fittings both in coal mining and
chemical/petro-chemical industries throughout Europe. The salient features are:
ISSUE
R1
Whereas in the case of a flameproof motor, all parts likely to ignite an explosive
mixture are enclosed in a housing which inhibits transmission of flame to the
ignitable atmospheres, the type of protection ‘e’ reduces the likelihood of ignition
thereby increasing the safety aspect by means of additional mechanical, electrical
and thermal protection methods.
In other words, sources of ignition are permissible inside a ‘d’ type enclosure,
provided the ignition is contained within the enclosure, but with in an ‘e’ type
enclosure the occurrence of the ignition is minimised from the outset.
The cost of type ‘e’ motor is substantially less than flameproof motor of equal
output rating. The other important advantage is that increased safety can be applied
to virtually any size of machine where as flameproof enclosures cease to become a
practicable proposition over 750 kW.
IEC 79-7 covers type ‘e’ enclosure, the equivalent Indian Standard being IS:6381-
1992.
a) The enclosure must have a high protection category to exclude dust and
water or moisture. The minimum degree of protection specified is IS 54,
according to IS:4691-1968.
ISSUE
R1
d) The insulation must meet certain specified requirements and the temperature
rise of the windings attained at rated output must be atleast 10 deg.c. lower
than the value permitted for similar insulation material in normal machines.
T1 4500C
T2 3000C
T3 2000C
T4 1350C
T5 1000C
T6 850C
ISSUE
R1
These motors are similar, in basic concept, to type ‘e’ motors, but with some
relaxation in requirements because of the lower risk in Division 2 areas to which
their application is limited.
The clauses relating to spark-free operation and mechanical clearances are similar
to type ‘e’ motors but those parts of the specifications covering terminals and their
clearances, also operating temperatures, are somewhat less stringent than for type
‘e’. The mechanical tightness of rotor bars on squirrel cage motors and general
method of construction to eliminate the risk of sparking during starting and running
is stipulated. The surface temperature of the motor is restricted to 200 Deg.C.
(assuming an ambient of 40 Deg.C). A reasonably high quality insulation system is
required on stator winding (random or “mush” windings are not permissible on 3.3
kV motors).
Attention is also paid to terminal assemblies, all h.v. cable boxes having a specified
through-fault capacity, properly short circuit tested.
Frame sizes of type ‘n’ motors are generally the same as for general purpose
motors, at least when the flammable atmosphere is limited to gases in temperature
classes T1, T2 and T3. Thus they tend to be smaller and less costly than type ‘e’
motors of equal output.
In the case of large electrical machines a totally enclosed dual circuit type of
enclosure is normally used such that the motor interior is pressurised with air or
nitrogen to about 75 mm water gauge above that of the atmosphere surrounding the
enclosure. The enclosure is sealed and the leakage rate controlled to about 250
litre/min. Purging inlet and outlet parts are provided and it is usual to purge with
five or six times the motor air volume.
Usually, the equipment is fitted with interlocks to ensure that, should the internal
pressure or flow rate of air or inert gas fall below a certain minimum, the supply is
cut off. The normal safety devices provided are:
ISSUE
R1
6.5 Appendix-2 gives the summary of protective methods, their advantages and
disadvantages.
In an intrinsically safe system, safety is offered by the design of the system and not
by subsequent addition of protective measures. Safety, therefore, exists throughout
the life of equipment, during maintenance and inspite of maintenance. Whereas
safety obtained by application of say explosion proof enclosures will be readily lost
as a result of carelessness after any maintenance break.
A circuit in which any spark or thermal effect produced either under normal
conditions or in specified fault conditions is incapable, in the test conditions
prescribed in this standard, of causing ignition of a prescribed gas or vapour.
Intrinsically safe and associated apparatus are specified in either of the following
groups:
Group II is further sub-divided in group IIA, IIB or IIC according to the nature of
explosive atmosphere for which the apparatus is intended.
ISSUE
R1
Intrinsically safe apparatus and parts of the associated apparatus are placed in one
of the following two categories:
Category “ia”
Category “ib”
Category “ib”
For detailed guidelines IS 5780 – 1980 shall be referred which describes in detail
the constructional requirements, test procedures, temperature classification and
components.
ISSUE
R1
The extent of limits of hazard is covered in detail, in ‘Guideline for Hazardous Area
Classification-R0, covered under document number M9-PCS-87 and is depicted in
sheet No. 8 to 13 of above document.
The safest electrical installation in a hazardous location, of course, is the one that
doesn’t exist. Electrical equipment, as much as possible should be situated outside
the hazardous area. It may, however, be difficult to locate all electrical equipment
outside the hazardous area.
The numerous options available as answers to above questions are depicted in the
diagram shown in Annexure-V.
In India, the Central Mining Research Station, Dhanbad carries out testing of
Flameproof Motors and there are three statutory authorities viz. Directorate Central
Mines Safety, Dhanbad. Chief Controller of Explosives, Nagpur and Directorate
General of Factory Advice Service and Labour Institute, Bombay, whose approval
is necessary for installation and operation of any electrical equipment in the
hazardous areas falling under their jurisdiction. These authorities may specify
constructional requirements for the apparatus and make regulations for its
installation and operation.
NFPA Publications
C/o National Fire Protection Association
470, Atlantic Avenue
Boston, MA 02210.
ISSUE
R1
APPENDIX-1
ISSUE
R1
APPENDIX-2
ISSUE
R1
APPENDIX-3
FIRE HAZARD PROPERTIES OF SELECTED LIQUIDS, GASES, AND VOLATILE SOLIDS*
ISSUE
R1
ISSUE
R1
ISSUE
R1
ISSUE
R1
ISSUE
R1
ISSUE
R1
APPENDIX-4
Arbonaceous:
Coal, Ky., Breek, Volatile content 40.6% 610 0.060 0.055 Strong
ISSUE
R1
Coal, W.Va., No.2 Gas, volatile content 600 0.060 0.060 Moderate
37.1%
Pitch, coal tar, volatile content 58.1% 710 0.020 0.036 Severe
Metals :
Lead 710
Nickel 950+
Selenium 950+
ISSUE
R1
Tellurium 550
Tungsten 950+
ISSUE
R1
Agricultural:
ISSUE
R1
Plastics:
ISSUE
R1
ISSUE
R1
ISSUE
R1
* Adapted from Wellington Sears Handbook of Industrial Textiles, Published 1963 by Wellington
Sears Co. Inc., 111 W. 40th St., New York, NY 10017
ISSUE
R1