Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Myth of Equality in Making A New Status For The Freedmen in The Reconstruction Period
The Myth of Equality in Making A New Status For The Freedmen in The Reconstruction Period
Mentouri University-Constantine
Master degree in
October 2010
Dedication
my truthful appreciation for her unrelenting assistance and notably for the time she
devoted to me and my work even in her hard times. Needless to say that thanks to
her care and patience, I was able to complete this work and to learn more through
my research.
tight schedule, was kind enough to evaluate my modest work. His comments are
warmly welcomed.
mother for her endless support and sacrifice. I also owe a special debt to my elder
brother Hakim, who has always been my model of success and wisdom, and my
The present work probes into some of significant events that led to crystallize the
Reconstruction Era (1865- 1877), where slaves obtained their freedom as a result
through a legal proclamation that was spelled out in January 1st, 1863.That
amendments of 1865. This work also examines the goals of reconstruction and its
that, it focuses on the efforts that were made on the part of the states to improve
اﻟﺪراﺳﺔ اﻟﺘﻲ ﺑﯿﻦ أﯾﺪﯾﻨﺎ ﺗﺴﻠﻂ اﻟﻀﻮء ﻋﻠﻰ اﻷﺣﺪاث اﻟﻤﮭﻤﺔ اﻟﺘﻲ أدت إﻟﻰ ﺗﺒﻠﻮر ﺧﺮاﻓﺔ اﻟﻤﺴﺎواة ﻣﻦ ﺧﻼل ﺧﻠﻖ وﺿﻌﯿﺔ
ﺟﺪﯾﺪة ﻟﻠﻌﺒﯿﺪ اﻟﻤﺤﺮرﯾﻦ ﺧﻼل و ﺑﻌﺪ اﻟﺤﺮب اﻷھﻠﯿﺔ أي ﻓﻲ ﻣﺮﺣﻠﺔ اﻟﺒﻨﺎء ﺑﺪاء ﻣﻦ 1863إﻟﻰ , 1877ﺣﯿﺚ ﺗﻢ ﺗﺤﺮﯾﺮ
ﻋﺒﯿﺪ اﻟﺠﻨﻮب ﺑﻨﺎء ﻋﻠﻰ ﻗﺮار ﻣﻦ اﻟﺮﺋﯿﺲ اﻷﻣﺮﯾﻜﻲ ا ﺑﺮاھﻢ ﻟﯿﻨﻜﻮن ﻋﺒﺮ وﺛﯿﻘﺔ رﺳﻤﯿﺔ ﺗﻢ اﻟﻤﺼﺎدﻗﺔ ﻋﻠﯿﮭﺎ ﻓﻲ اﻟﻔﺎﺗﺢ ﻣﻦ ﺷﮭﺮ
ﺟﺎﻧﻔﻲ 1863و اﻟﺘﻲ أﺗﺖ ﻛﺨﻄﻮة ﺗﻤﮭﺪﯾﮫ ﻟﻠﺘﻌﺪﯾﻞ اﻟﺪﺳﺘﻮري اﻟﺜﺎﻟﺚ ﻋﺸﺮ ﻋﺎم . 1865ﺗﺘﻤﺤﻮر ھﺬه اﻟﺪراﺳﺔ ﺣﻮل أھﺪاف
ﻣﺮﺣﻠﺔ اﻟﺒﻨﺎء وﻣﺪى ﺷﺮﻋﯿﺘﮭﺎ ﺑﺎﻟﻨﺴﺒﺔ ﻟﻠﻮﻻﯾﺎت اﻟﻤﺘﺤﺪة ﻣﻦ ﺧﻼل ﺗﻄﻮر اﻟﺤﯿﺎة اﻻﺟﺘﻤﺎﻋﯿﺔ ،اﻟﺴﯿﺎﺳﯿﺔ ،اﻻﻗﺘﺼﺎدﯾﺔ ﻟﻠﻌﺒﯿﺪ
اﻟﻤﺤﺮرﯾﻦ و ﻣﺪى ﺗﻘﺒﻞ اﻟﺒﯿﺾ ﻟﮭﺬه اﻟﻮﺿﻌﯿﺔ.ﺑﺈﻻﺿﺎﻓﺔ إﻟﻰ ذﻟﻚ ﻣﺎ ھﻲ اﻹﻣﻜﺎﻧﯿﺔ اﻟﻤﺘﺎﺣﺔ ﻣﻦ ﻃﺮف اﻟﺪوﻟﺔ إﻟﻰ اﻹرﺗﻘﺎء
1. Background…………………………………………………………………………..………..4
1.1The Impact of the Civil War on the Changing Course of the Issue of
Slavery…………………………………………………………………………...……….…........4
Conclusion…………………………………………………….……………………..................16
Introduction…………………….………………...……..…………….……....…....................17
2 -Economic Adjustment……………..………………………………….………...….…… 28
Conclusion………………………………………… . .. …………………………..................34
Conclusion……………………………………..………….……….…………..….……....49
Bibliography……………………………...……………………………………..……......54
Introduction:
Starting from 1863 to 1877, The United States of America got on one of the
greatest experiments in social transformation ever attempted in human history. This period,
known as Reconstruction, is often called the second American Revolution, for its far-
reaching effort to fulfill the political and social promise of the first. Started during the Civil
War and ended in the decades that followed, Reconstruction saw the near total, albeit short-
Union, the punishment of the southerners who had fought in opposition to their country in the
Civil War, and the conflict between congress and the White House for political dominance.
Above all, Reconstruction was the story of African Americans’ struggle for integration into the
and proponents. The proponents tried tiredly to defend and to guarantee the right of the African
Americans through legislation; such as Thirteen, Fourteen, and Fifteen amendments that aimed
to break the color line and make all American whites and blacks equal under the law of the
United States, whereas the opponents, especially the confederate masters, didn’t miss any
opportunity to show and express their hatred toward African Americans. They created violent
organizations, such as the Klu Klux Klan, and racial laws such as the black codes, that worked
for restricting the freedmen’s right which was granted to them by legislation and placed them
conflicting goal in order to rise up the status of the freedmen. The freedmen status was
considered among the major goals that the federal government had to deal with, at that time,
1
throughout achieving economic independence, securing the physical protection from abuse and
terror by local whites, obtaining equal right under the law, and commencing political
The most significant changes that took place at that period were the
transformation of slaves into free laborers and citizens; this was the most dramatic example of
the social and political changes or reconstruction, unleashed by the Civil War and emancipation
after three hundred years of eagerness to freedom and relief from the bondage of servitude. Thus,
the reconstruction period is the time where African Americans begun to plant the seeds of their
unfinished struggle and not to harvest the fruit; it was the beginning of revolution, and not the
This research aims to investigate into the status of the freedmen during the
reconstruction era and to explore the extent to which the status of the freedmen had changed.
Moreover, it probes the American policy of freedom without equality and the reason of its
references, archives and academic publications. Here then, I used some books such as
Reconstruction, American Unfinished Revolutions , The Pelican History Of The United States
Of America and articles such as: “Law Creating the Freedmen Bureau: march 31, 1865” to reach
The course of this study includes three interrelated chapters exposing the events
in a chronological order .I used a historical approach because its fits in the nature of the work:
the first chapter is a historical background on the role of the Civil War to reach a radical change
2
in the status of the freedmen; from slavery to freedom. The war resulted into an important
document, the Emancipation Proclamation, that was considered the keystone of civil rights in the
U.S. constitution, and the first steps of justice and freedom .The war also gave birth to a series
of three amendments, Thirteen, Fourteen, and Fifteen amendments that are of an extreme
importance to African American’s equal status in a widely stratified society. The aim to study
this aspect is to know how these features helped to shape Reconstruction policies toward African
Americans.
Then, the second chapter tackles Reconstruction policies and the efforts to
improve the status of the freedmen in the Reconstruction period on the basis of these questions:
What should be the place of blacks politically and socially in the South and America at large?
What was the effort that had been made to build the new black community?, and did the system
that substituted slave plantation in the south have noteworthy effects on economy?
Finally, the third chapter studies the result of Reconstruction; to what extent
did Reconstruction change the status of the freedmen and did the freedmen really enjoy their
freedom? This chapter deals with the challenges that faced the freedmen and the abolishers
during the process of Reconstruction to achieve the whole goals of making the myth of equality
In conclusion, the overriding goal of this research is to reveal the fact behind
freeing the slaves after three hundred years of servitude in a war of five years. In order to
improve the status of freed men, American white decision makers simply followed the policy of
“freedom equals equality” in order to give a gloomy hope to a nation whose people lived in
3
Chapter one:
My paramount object in this struggle is to save the Union, and is not either to
save or to destroy slavery. If I could save the Union without freeing any slave I
would do it, and if I could save it by freeing all slaves I would do it; and if I
could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that.
What I do about slavery and the colored race, I do because I believe it helps to
save the Union; and what I forbear, I forbear because I don't believe it would
Introduction:
Slavery Saga was the darkest point r in the U.S history and human history at
large. Slavery was an unfavorable project that was documented in the United States’
Constitution wherein slaves were counted as three fifths of a person for representation in
the U.S. House of Representatives, and for direct taxation. However, by the end of the
19thcentury, when the Civil War took place (1860 - 1865), the issue of slavery transformed
from being an accepted behaviour to be a forbidden sin. The Civil War started by removing
all the chains of southern slaves and ended with liberation of all the United States’ slaves.
1. Background
The Civil War was a time of a change in the chapter of African American’s
history, in which, more than four millions of blacks were freed from the chains of slavery after a
long endurance in the twilight of bondage and servitude. It had begun as a fight over whether one
4
nation or two would succeed in coexisting in the United States territory. Originally, the
American President Abraham Lincoln and thousands of northern leaders acknowledged that the
main cause of the war was not the existence of slavery, but was for safeguarding the union.
Brogan Huge, In his book The Pelican History Of The United States Of America ,quoted that in
August 1862, President Lincoln said: “My paramount object in this struggle is to save the Union,
Yet, when the union failed to defeat the confederacy of the eleven states, the
demand rose not only for the fresh sources but for manpower. These facts pushed President
Lincoln to admit that the war is a fight over slavery. Thus, as slavery was considered as the cause
of war, the only solution was to destroy it. Slavery had caused a great rebellion; it has poisoned
the political life for more than thirty years. And he assured that the only way to get rid of this
Much like the president, African Americans believed that the war is their
golden opportunity to get their long waited freedom. That freedom would be guaranteed by the
end of the war. This idea became visible in the words of one of African American’s prominent
abolitionist Frederick Douglass who said: “Who would be free themselves must strike the
blow....I urge you to fly to arms and smite death the power that would bury the Government and
your liberty in the same hopeless grave. This is your golden opportunity” (Frederick Douglass,
1863).
In March 1863, in his paper Douglass’ Monthly, Frederick Douglass issued a call to
arms for colored men. He argued that the time demanded is not discussion but action, and that
the Civil War had become as much the black man’s war as the white man’s. Using his powerful
rhetorical skills, Douglass pushed the free blacks to enlist in the Union Army and to fight for the
5
liberation of their enslaved brothers and sisters in appeal to the names of such memorable
Throughout the war, the president set a plan with different goals. These goals
had an overlapping segment; the first goal was that the president had to find the means of
triumph to convince his supporters that victory was more valuable than it price. The second goal
was that he had to achieve harmony and peace. According to this plan, president Lincoln had
issued the Preliminary Emancipation proclamation in which he had been mediating such steps
The Emancipation Proclamation finally was given birth after several months of
thought and designing. It added a page of redemption to the chapter of the Africans American’s
history which aimed to destroy the chattel of slavery which followed them from a century to
another. Eric Foner, in his famous book , Reconstruction, American Unfinished Revolutions ,
expresses the importance of this document to African Americans by saying that the
Emancipation Proclamation meant more than culminated decades of struggle .It evoked a
Christian vision of resurrection and redemption of unbounded era of the nation of progress .For
them Emancipation meant more than the end of the labor system , more than the uncompensated
By and large, with the coming of the Emancipation Proclamation, black and
white abolitionists reached what they wanted from the beginning. President Lincoln and
American policy makers thought that by the end of slavery, which is considered as the central
issue of the war, the war will inevitably end. He imagined that when the southerners heard about
the threat of the emancipation, they will certainly put their arms and return to the union. Heather
6
Freund, in his work The War for Freedom, point ed out that having the status of president,
Lincoln’s authority extended to the proclamation because he regarded it as the only way to
safeguard the union or speed up the end of the Civil War . Also he added that for a better
solution, President Lincoln determined that it is time to free the slaves in order to protect the
union. The plan was well under way in which he has issued two different versions of the
President Abraham Lincoln was optimistic with his plan seeking to hold the
political middle ground. He was searching for a formula that would initiate the emancipation
process but would not alienate or be set against the conservatives and southern unionists. John
Hope Franklin wrote in his well known book, From Slavery to Freedom, that President Lincoln
wanted to achieve emancipation by compensating the owners for the loss of their human
property; but he found no taker. In addition to that, he was looking for the colonization of freed
slaves in some parts of the world. He encouraged the emigration of the freed man to other places
However, this plan found little support especially from the abolitionists, who
believed that the southern slave possessors do not have the right to be paid for something not
theirs from the beginning. John Hope Franklin assert that president Lincoln met with an
assembly of black leaders in the district of Colombia in an attempt to convince them that race
should be physically separated with the emigration of blacks to Central America (189).
Gradually, the war reduced slavery in the southern states because it made it
possible for the slaves to escape since their masters were out of the conflict. Heather Freund
pointed out that slaves headed by thousands to the union lines as the union army occupied the
7
territory of the confederacy. These circumstances left the frontier states in a dilemma of
After the bloody union victory in the battle of Antietam, Maryland, the
Preliminary Emancipation proclamation released but it functioned only after January, 1863. Eric
Foner said that the president Lincoln declared that: “Where shall be in the rebellion against in the
United States, shall be then, forward and forever” (190). Maldwyn also stated in his work, the
limits of Liberty, that the emancipation did not operate in the four union slave states of the north
democrats charged the Emancipation as unconstitutional and that it was designed to extend the
war, equally as some whites were doubtful for the real reason behind entering the war. Maldwyn
assert think that this decision of emancipating the slaves was followed by violent reactions such
as the New York Draft riots of July18461 (229). In the other side, African Americans were glad
for the first steps of justice, especially the abolitionists who welcomed the emancipations as a
beginning of change. These reactions led to the creation of the second or the finial provision
(Franklin, 190).
role in paving the way for reaching real changes at that unchangeable period. For African
Americans, It glowed a candle beyond the darkness of slavery and gave hope of freedom to more
1
- In April 1864, the Confederates killed captured black Union soldiers. At Fort Pillow, an
earthen fort on the Mississippi River about forty miles north of Memphis, Tennessee,
Confederate raiders under Nathan Bedford Forrest surprised and overwhelmed a garrison of
African Americans and Tennessee Unionists guarding the Fort. Several hundred black soldiers
were killed in that incident, many of them after they allegedly tried to surrender.
8
than four million blacks. Yet, it created real challenges for president Lincoln and U.S. policy
makers. The latter found unpleasant reactions and harsh criticism from white politicians, such as
democrats and civilians, toward their policy of emancipating their human property.
freeing the slaves by signing the final Emancipation Proclamation in January 1st, 1863. This
version was different from the previous one; it came up with the employment of freed men into
the military services on behalf of the Union. In her work. The Destruction of Slave y in the
Confederate Territories’’. Ira Berlin Frederick Douglass had argued that basically a moderate
share of sagacity was essential to witness that the arm of the slave was the best protection against
Like the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation, The final one also applied
only for the confederate states, but it welcomed the escaping slaves into the Union army.
Vorenberg, Michael quoted President Lincoln: “You southern men will soon reach the point
where bonds will be a more valuable possession than bondsmen. Nothing is more uncertain now
than two-legged property” (31). Therefore, the emancipation fell too short of the goal of a
Unlike the Preliminary Emancipation, According to Halpern, the final draft includes
nothing about compensation, gradualism, or colonization which had been always Lincoln’s
projects (280). Yet In 1863, initial steps had been taken because from the time when the army
moved into the south; it required apparently everlasting flood of laborers to accomplish
reinforcement and an additional soldier safeguard. Shaffer thinks that the reservoir of the black
man power could not be ignored, but only with the Emancipation Proclamation that the
9
enlistment of the black man begun in earnest (45). That idea was confirmed by President Lincoln
who declared it as an act of justice that persons of suitable condition will be received into the
The effects of these provisions were felt immediately after the release of the
Emancipation Proclamation when thousands of blacks enlisted in the army. African Americans
were very delighted when they knew about the document but the abolitionists were disappointed
because the proclamation was circulating out of the military requirement. McPherson, James, M.
assumed that the opportunity to enlist in the army gave to the ex-slaves a chance to earn their
freedom with their hands and to prove that they deserve to be respected as Americans. Men,
women and children felt that they have to seize this chance in the war efforts because it may
force the white to reconsider their racial prejudices and stereotypes (62).
political warfare. John hope, Franklin assumed that as a war measure, the president saw
emancipation as a primary means of weakening the southern rebels by withdrawing slave labor
from the confederate economy, which is basically depended on slave plantation (191).
When the Emancipation Proclamation opened the doors for blacks to enlist in
the union army, blacks seized the opportunity to prove their loyalty and patriotism to serve their
country in its hard time. During 1863, thousands of black men volunteered for service on behalf
of the union; some traveled the long distance across the confederate territory risking their lives in
the effort of the war. Eric Forner emphasized that military services for the black soldiers meant
more than the opportunity to serve the union, even more than their own freedom and the
10
destruction of slavery as an institution. For talent and ambition, the army flung opened a door to
success ; more than 186,000 had enrolled in the union army by the end of the war, and from the
seceded states came 93.000 and from the boarded slave states 40.000. The remainders,
approximately 53.000, were from the free states and possibly the total figure was larger (196).
Carolina. However, the war department created a segregated unit called the United States
Colored Troops (USCT) in order to distinguish them from the white soldiers and, for the most
part, they were led by the white officers with some black noncommissioned officers. in early
1863, nearly two years after the black men had begun petition to join the union war effort, the
war department authorized Rhode Island, Massachusetts, and Connecticut to organize blacks’
regiments. Black men in the confederacy waged no such campaign, although a few dozen to a
The Confederates did what they could to deny black solider respect as worthy
opponents. In Saffer Donald R stated that in May 1863, the confederacy announced its intention
to kill or sell into slavery the black prisoner of the war. During 1864, reports surfaced repeatedly
of confederates murdering black prisoners of the war. The worst instance of murder occurred in
April1 864 at Fort Pillow, Tennessee. The confederates committed the massacre and founded
the Ku Klux Klan one year after the war (saffer, 69).
The summer of 1863 brought a turning point on the combat zone as well as in
the politics of the war. Maldwyn also stated in his work, the limits of Liberty ,that in the battles
of Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, and Vicksburg, Mississippi, the union blocked the confederate’s
push into northern territory and assumed command of the Mississippi river; the major artery of
11
transportation and trade. Union forces at that time proscribed the entire of Tennessee and were
valiant fighting troops in the mid 1863. Brogan Huge said: “the armies of the armies were
correspondingly strengthened .Slaves and contrabands proved to be invaluable spies, guides for
the advancing northerners” (342). In addition to that, Lardas Mark said that the famous assault of
Fort Wagner’s, South Carolina, the Massachusetts 54th regiment astonished the world for this act
of bravery, but it lost half of its men. Despite the significant importance of African Americans in
the battle field black soldiers were not exempt from discrimination. They could not achieve high
officer’s ranks and they earned lower wages than their white counterparts (Lardas, 46).
advanced the union and enlisted inside and around the organized armed forces. Without their
active support, the union would not have won this war on southern territory. The enslaved were
not given their freedom; they earned it through their heroic fight in the war. Ira Berlin
emphasized that the importance of Freedmen for being soldiers in the civil army, and she said
that military services had provided black men with legal freedom and overturned the
embarrassing outcome of southern slavery and northern prejudice (quoted in Halpern, 398).
their position to emphasize their right to end discriminated attitudes toward them. Eric Forner
thinks that regardless of how well educated or experienced or successful they were as soldiers,
black men could not rise through the ranks to be commissioned officers (8).
The campaign for equal pay became part of the battle; enlisted men or
noncommissioned officers received; pay of 7$ per month. this rate prevailed whether or not the
soldier had been before the war and regardless of his level of education or military experience.
12
White enlisted men received $13 per month plus a $3 clothing allowance. White sergeant
received $21 per month, but white commissioned officers received a few dollars more per
Black soldiers and their abolitionist supporters protested against the injustice
of discriminatory payments. Lower pay insulted black soldiers and imposed dire hardship upon
their families. Lardas Mark supposed that the Massachusetts 54th and 55th regiments refused to
accept the lower rate of the pay as a matter of honor. They even resisted the equalization offer
from the start on the ground that they fought for the union, and the union, not the state, should
pay them fair wages. In the late1863 the 3rd South Carolina volunteers regiment of former
slaves, stacked their arms, and refused to serve until granted equal pay and the army executed
4. Slavery Destroyed
Enslaved African Americans like their freedom. Northern black and white
allies knew immediately that slavery lays sat the basis of the war and that if the union won, they
would be free. The dramatic and bright ways, African American began seizing their freedom as
soon as fighting broke out. Slavery gave away freedom in many different ways, depending upon
individuals, families, and the circumstance of the servitude and warfare (Saffer, 48).
of slavery destruction, above any other measure; it defined the Civil War as a war for black
freedom. Nearly, all Americans today would depict the Emancipation Proclamation as the most
significant result of the war. Vorenberg, Michael stated that as if this original document had not
been damaged by fire in 1871; it would no doubt have resided at the side of the Declaration of
Independence and the Constitution as one of the U.S. national treasures. Yet, even those who
13
argued that slaves did more than white commanders and politicians to put an end to slavery
leaned to see the Emancipation Proclamation as the brightest attainment of slaves labors on
It was factual that, the Emancipation Proclamation did not free a single slave, but
it gave freedom as an ethical acknowledgment.This act of justice led the slaves to call president
Abraham Lincoln “Father Abraham” as a thankful l acknowledgment for his acts against slavery.
Many Americans during this period would have considered today’s respect for the proclamation
as misplaced. They knew that the proclamation freed slaves in only some areas –the southern
states that were under the confederate control – leaving open the possibility that it might never
Even when the union forces were far away, owners began to notice changes
in their workers. Sometimes the change was obvious in displays of independence or anger; both
were forbidden in the slave regime. Vorenberg, Michael considers that more often the enslaved
ran away from their master, especially when owners sought to move their workers away from
hostilities. As soon as the union forces came anywhere near, black men, women and children
volunteered as workers, and if possible, as soldiers. Such act inspired the confiscation acts of
Georgia, Florida, and Louisiana, thousands of fugitive slaves made themselves effectively free
2
- First Confiscation Act, which allowed federal authorities to Confiscate slaves used by Confederates for military
purposes
3
- Second Confiscation Act, which emancipated all slaves owned by rebel masters
14
By and large, the road of proceedings leading from the Emancipation
Proclamation to the Thirteenth Amendment was everything but expectable. After Lincoln issued
the Emancipation Proclamation. The policymaker, politician, and ordinary Americans measured
amendment was basically the principal choice. Simply throughout the line of political struggles,
in late 1863 and early 1864, that the amendment came out as the most popular of the abolition
alternatives. By mid of 1864, the amendment had become a principal policy of the Republican
Party, which planed the measure into its national platform (2).
subjected political battle of 1864, but the unpredicted conditions and varying party policies drove
the measure from civic debate. Nevertheless, followers of the amendment claimed the
Republican triumphs of 1864 as a mandate for the amendment, and they successfully approved
the amendment. According to Vorenberg Michael, Congress in January 1865a number of states
rapidly ratified the measure, and ratification was complete by the end of that year. The cycle of
actions was vital: the amendment turned into party guidelines before its value or importance was
specifically understood. For historians in quest of recovering one unique meaning of the
Thirteenth Amendment, the early change of the measure into a party strategy symbolizes an
actual trouble. As a party strategy, the amendment attracted support from people with
comparable political objectives but dissimilar notions of freedom. Because of the varied
constituencies behind the amendment, some of its followers permitted the meaning of the
measure to stay vague. If they had instead appointed an accurate sense to the amendment, they
Would have separated some of those constituencies and put at risk the measure’s agreement
15
In short, the release of Thirteen Amendment gave a dramatic end to the Civil
War after a long battle to restore the union. The way toward the thirteen amendments was
paved through the two important versions of the Emancipation Proclamation, the preliminary
and the final version. These were the documents of redemption; for blacks from chains of
slavery and for the states form the war with no more casualties. Thus, the fight for equality
started within the civil war, when African Americans first tested freedom as a result of the
Emancipation Proclamation of 1863. African Americans and their supporters the abolitionists’
of slavery started preparing themselves for a new era of freedom blended with equality.
Fazit
The union victory of April 1865 resulted in the legal emancipation that
black and white abolitionists had demanded from the beginning. During the Civil War, black
men, women and children had to seize their freedom by serving as soldiers, sailors, scouts,
nurses, and laborers. Black men, from Maine and Vermont, joined the tens of thousands from
the Confederacy on the side of the Union. They and their families saw, their service as a
payment of their freedom. The Civil War ended in emancipation, but making freedom real
demands a series of struggles that would last for another hundred years and more. That
16
Chapter two:
Reconstruction Era.
now, our feet on the rock of freedom, we must drag our brethren from the slimy
depths of slavery, ignorance, and ruin. The wrongs of our brethren should be our
constant theme...We ask you to devote yourselves to this cause, as one of the
first and most successful means of self improvement.. You will learn your own
rights, and comprehend your own responsibilities, and, scan through the vista of
coming time, your high and God-appointed destiny (Frederick Douglass, 127).
Einführung
By the end of the Civil War the experience of bondage and servitude remained
deeply fixed in the blacks’ collective memory. With the beginning of a new period, the
Reconstruction Era, African Americans sought to achieve independence, autonomy and freedom
from white people both as individuals and as members of community. Legal freedom meant that
those who had been enslaved could marry, earn wages, change employers and own property. They
were no longer mere extensions of other people’s will. Making freedom real meant more than a
changed legal and economic status. For many freed people families and land of their own came
first. They also made freedom real by creating their own educational and religious institutions.
Only men could vote but the whole of the community took interest in politics.
17
1. Social and Political Adjustment:
As the war clouds left the United States, the country entered a new period
known as Reconstruction. The southerners emancipated blacks and sought firstly to reunite their
families, parents, and children, who had been separated by sale, by their owner’s migration, and
by the disorder of hostilities. Eric Forner believed that the emancipation proclamation was an
important instrument to stabilize and strengthen the black family; it changes many things in their
life style. The most significant one was that the slave families divided much of the time because
their numbers belonged to different owners and they could now live together (84, 5).
In addition to that, the freedmen bureau monopolized the effort to reunite the
black family; the bureau received many letters of thanks about finding the information about the
needed persons such as Mr. Jacob Galloway who thanks Jackson, the director of the freedmen
bureau, for information about his son. Freedom had more personal meanings as well for freed
people wanted to appear more attractive than they had been as ragged slaves. They cast off the
slave clothing of degraded drudges and adorned themselves as handsomely as possible. Their
improved appearance confused and outraged observers as much as their new sense of
For the reasons of reuniting their families and searching for new methods of
life, blacks migrated to other places for a better life. Hundreds of thousands men and women
made their freedom a legal process that begun with white soldiers during the war. Slaves had
not been able to marry legally, and slave sales together with the disorder of the war had further
disrupted relationships. Eric Forner adds that: « with freedom came developments that
18
strengthened patriarchy within the black family and institutionalized the notion that women and
men should inhabit separate spheres » (87). People who had never expected to see their partners
again after many years of separation had taken new spouses. In such a situation, freedom and
Earlier than the end of the Civil War, the U.S policy maker, President
Abraham Lincoln, and Congress admitted that the government must give a proposal as a support
to newly emancipated slaves. The proposal was simply The Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, and
Abandoned Lands, commonly known as the Freedmen's Bureau; this was as federal
government’s agency that aided distressed refuges and freed men during the period of 1865-
1872. During the Reconstruction era, this agency operated under the supervision of the War
After deep thoughts over the duties and the capacity of the agency, Congress
passed a bill to empower the creation of the Freedmen's Bureau on March 3, 1865. Besides,
President Lincoln signed the bill in the same day: « Be it enacted by the Senate and House of
Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, that there is hereby
established in the War Department, to continue during the present war of rebellion, and for one
In his famous work Du Bois, William Edward Burghardt believe that President
Andrew Johnson was frightened from building a dependent class of white and blacks and
vetoed a bill to renew the bureau in 1866 and to increase its power. Congress ignored the veto;
however, the bill prolonged its life until the summer of 1872 (Du Bois, 354-5).
direct the bureau. Lincoln’s past choice, President Johnson, agreed to follow his predecessor's
19
wish and he appointed Major General Oliver Otis1 Howard. To aid Howard, ten assistant
commissioners directed agency work at the state and local level (Du Bois, 354-5).
and the bureau established a number of freedmen's schools. Attendance at the schools soared as
freedmen of all ages flocked at restricted buildings to learn basic reading, writing, and
mathematical skills. Du Bois assumed that violent acts, such as the burning of schools and
vicious threats against teachers and students, flared after the Memphis riots of May 1866, and
tested the dedication of the freedmen and their instructors. Courageous blacks continued to
enrol in schools, and a vast number of eager pupils required more teachers. In January 1866,
assisted by the American Missionary Association and the Western Freedmen's Aid
Commission, Fisk organized a school in Nashville. The following year, this school became Fisk
University and offered a program to train black teachers for the freedmen’s schools. The
greatest success of the Freedmen's Bureau lays in the planting of free schools among blacks,
and the idea of free elementary education among all classes in the South (354-5).
between the ex-slaves and white employers and even provided legal guidance. The bureau also
programmed hospitals, orphanages, and elderly homes. Whites in Tennessee, particularly in the
middle and western parts of the state, strongly opposed the goals of the Freedmen's Bureau.
White animosity stemmed from a belief that the freedmen's schools functioned as incubators of
Radical Republicanism. In some areas of the state, the Ku Klux Klan scared black citizens and
galvanized the whites by broadcasting the bureau's efforts to achieve black suffrage (
Cement, 101).
1
- - General Oliver Howards was the freedmen bureau commissioner, who was a graduate in Bowdoin College and
20
Fisk's term ended on September 1st, 1866, and General J. R. Lewis, who had
fulfilled the duties of an assistant commissioner in Middle Tennessee, held the post as an
interim. After three months, Major General W. P. Carlin took the helm. By the time he
accepted the office, the bureau's primary responsibility involved schools for the freedmen;
when the state assumed the management of the black schools in February 1867, the activity of
the bureau was moderate until it was gradually phased out by Brevet-Major L. N. Clark in
1869. The Freedmen's Bureau guided the states’ blacks on the journey from slavery to freedom
by providing education, lobbying for political equality, and meeting physical needs (Du Bois,
354-5).
As slaves, southern people had been kept uneducated, and they rightly
regarded their ignorance as a badge of servitude. In 1860, more than 90 percent of the adults’
southern black population was illiterate. After emancipation, education became one of their
priorities and earliest preoccupation. Eric Forner assured that, by the end of the war, the black
community had founded more than 120 schools, serving some 13,000 students (Forner, 86).
The black southerners were eager to educate themselves and their children
without caring about the cost or the place of the schools and that obviously appeared in the
words of Bookert Washington, one of the blacks’ prominent leaders, who said: « it was a whole
race trying to go to school» (quote in Eliot, 82). also he added : « few were too trying and none
too old to make the attempt to learn , as fast as , any kind of teachers could be secured , not only
were day schools filled .But night as well The great ambition of the older people was to try to
learn to read the bible before they died » (Eliot, 82). In some places many blacks left their houses
in search for education because access for education for themselves and their children was the
point. Eric Forner thinks that the desire to learn led the blacks’ parents to migrate to the towns
21
and cities in search for education for their children, and for plantation works to make the
In addition to that, several societies contributed in the effort to found the first
black schools such as the freedmen bureau, and white radicals. These societies played a
considerable role in building the black school houses, providing them with teachers and helping
their educational objective. Fuke Paul, Richard, in his famous book, Imperfect Equality: African
Americans and Whites Racial Attitudes in Post Emancipation Maryland, asserted in November
1864, immediately after the state Emancipation Proclamation, that a group of prominent white
Quakers, businessmen, and lawyers commited themselves to the black education (199).
Fuke Paul Richard also adds that by the end of 1865, many northern societies
had provided many schools, such as Maryland schools with teachers; their sponsors were New
England’s. Freedmen’s Aid Society, the National Freedman’s Relief Association, the
Pennsylvania Freedman’s Relief Association, and the American Missionary Association paid
their transportation and part of their salaries .Along with other African American church
Carolina which begun as a barker bible institute in Charleston in 1866. At that period, the
association had opened seven schools in Baltimore and eighteen in the rural countries in the
South (89).
Despite all the difficulties, the blacks poor or wealthy co-operated to found
schools that are important in the building of the structure of the black community. In his book,
The Imperfect Equality, Richard Paul highlighted that the learning objective engaged an essential
position in the post-emancipation agenda of the countryside black society and regardless of the
many difficulties in their course, mothers, fathers, and children struggled tremendously to make
22
In different states, exactly in the north, black people felt ties toward the
southern blacks; those ties after the war were translated in going south as teachers. Those ties
did not concern only blacks; whites also arrived to the south as teachers by the help of human
association. Most of the teachers were middle class; white women and the majorities were from
New England, sent to the south by human association aid (Forner, 44).
Much like any new society, the black community faced many problems in the
process of finding the schools. Among those difficulties were the poor and primitive conditions
of the schools; the lack of sufficient books and materials and classes of 100 or more children in
one class. Forner argued that equally disheartened is the great problem among teachers; the male
dominated aid societies and thus denied woman teachers a role in decisions, and expected from
them to meet their own travel and living expenses on salaries that were lower than what they
could have earned by remaining in the north. Some female teachers resigned in protest to the
rules that barred them from becoming school principals and super intendents (85).
complexity. For the body of formal education knowledge in the United States conveyed its
assumption that African Americans were ignorant and inferior as a race. In pursuit of
knowledge, particularly higher education, black educators continually had to negotiate between
In addition to that, the school was not the only institution that the freed men
could gain knowledge in, the church also could be a place where one could obtain knowledge
and enlightment. Eric Forner said: “the teachers employed by the American missionary
Eric Forner thinks that the church operated as a “religious court house”, raising
moral values, as well as punishing persons intended for adultery and other illegal performance.
23
In each district, priests were along with the most appreciated persons, in favor of their respect for
their vocalization skills, directorial capacity, furthermore for their high-quality ruling of both
civic and private issues. Certainly, preachers arrived to play an essential position in black politics
In the process of building the black community, southern blacks either in large
cities or in rural places continued to throw the chains of servitude by freeing themselves from the
white control and designing for local autonomy, self determination and redrawing a new map for
the south. Many of such institutions achieved a considerable degree, even though the law required
that the posters be white (Forner, 89). In addition to that, among the factors that led to the creation
of blacks’ independence church was the refusal of whites to offer blacks an equal place within
their congregation. That clearly appears in the words of Eric Forner: “Reconstruction was a time
of Consolidation and transformation for the black religion and for the creation of independence
religious” (98).
Throughout the south the black churches offered spaces where African
Americans could confer and worship as they were pleased; free of white surveillance. As black
people’s largest public meeting places, churches also frequently housed schools and voluntary
associations. Eric Forner said that meeting in church, women and children could participate in
political discussions and thus influence politics without being able to vote. Along with schools,
reconstruction, where education, politics, and social life are all converged (89).
Tens of thousands of African Americans, who as slaves had lacked their own
church which, belonged to predominantly white congregation, now, withdrew to their own
places of worship. As a result, the first black religious institution came to birth in mid
Charleston’s town, in Calhoun Street, by 1866and then others had been constructed. In rural
24
areas, former slave preachers and missionaries from the north spurred the creation of religious
affected the way blacks understood the momentous events around them and the very language in
While some white abolitionists declared their mission accomplished with the
passage of the thirteen amendment outlawing slavery, some conservatives, including most
white southerners, northern Democrats, and some northern Republicans, opposed black voting.
Some northern states had referendums on the subject limiting the ability of their own small
populations of blacks to vote .Fredrik Douglass thought that the work was only half done:
“Slavery is not abolished until the black man has the ballot”. Black men in the north as well as
the south needed the vote; before the ratification of the fourteen and Fifteen Amendments; only
in New England could northern black men vote or hold office (Franklin, 231).
Before the end of the war, black and white abolishers had seen black men’s
enfranchisement as the only way to protect African American’s freedom as a necessary right in
the south. Richard Paul wrote, in 1864, that black men met in Syracuse, New York, to form a
national equal rights league and demand the vote for a range of civil rights that northern states
had denied. Frederick Douglass stirred a black audience in Baltimore with the claim that: "if
the Negro is called upon to take his share of the toils and danger of warfare . . . he should also
have the privileges of elective franchise." The subject failed to surface in the 1864 state
constitutional convention, and several petitions from blacks seeking the vote received scant
25
Northern as well as southern whites opposed enfranchised black men. In
1864, President Abraham Lincoln had argued to limit suffrage for black men upon the leaders
of the conquered and readmitted state of Louisiana. Lincoln had supported a middle position to
allow some black men to vote, especially army veterans. Johnson also believed that such
service should be rewarded with citizenship. Lincoln proposed giving the vote to "the very
intelligent, and especially those who have fought gallantly in our ranks." The new, all white
reconstruction after the war would only tinker with the south’s power structure, not overturn it
to the degree necessary to permit black suffrage (Suffrage during the reconstruction era,
(Wikipedia).
Ultimately, southern black men gained the vote before northern blacks.
Without southern black men, who supported the republicans, the southern states could not be
readmitted into the union. That is to say, the former confederacy could not be reconstructed as a
loyal part of the United States. Without the blacks’ voters, the southern states would return to the
control of the democrats who had taken the confederacy out of the union in the first place.
Congressional republicans faced a tough choice: either they would need to enfranchise black
southerners, who would be republicans, or they would see the south revert to control by the
in late 1866 and impeached him, taking control of the process of readmitting the states of the
former confederacy. Black men were allowed to elect and to be elected as delegates to the
constitutional convention that would reconstruct the southern states. In January 1867, black men
throughout the former Confederate States and the District of Columbia voted and held office for
the first time, all as republicans. The union army oversaw the process of registering 735.000
black and 635.000 white men. Five states – Mississippi, South Carolina, Louisiana, Alabama,
26
and Florida – had black electoral majorities. Before the 1868 ratification of the fourteenth
amendment, the southern states’ constitutional conventions abolished property qualifications for
voting and holding office, providing for the full enfranchisement of poor men, white and black
areas of heavy blacks. Maldwyn, A Jones said that in New Jersey and Georgia, African
Americans went south after the war by the prospect of helping the freed people and enlarging
In State legislatures of 1867, black men held the majority only in South
Carolina; South Carolina’s first congressional reconstruction legislature had a black majority,
although whites always controlled the states senates. (Suffrage during the reconstruction era,
Wikipedia).
27
To sum up, the Fifteenth Amendment did not give only the right to vote for
African Americans for participating in political courses, but, it guaranteed their total freedom
from the white control and obliged the white race, via legal document, to respect the freedmen as
Americans.
2. Economic Adjustment:
In the course of reconstruction, economic adjustment was the only thing that
can prove the ambiguity of freedom and the short-term relief of the freedmen as guidance along
the road of economic stability and independence. The release from the bondage of servitude of
four million people had serious implications for the economic structure of the South at that time.
By the end of the war, reconstruction of the South was not very difficult
because its economy depended on agriculture; everything might be destroyed but the land
remained. Maldwyn, A Jones assumed that for blacks ,at that point ,freedom meant more than
received wages but it was to take control of the conditions under which the labourers are not
deprived of the fruit of their labour. Contemporaries believed that the Civil War had resulted into
the breakup of the plantation system into small farms (Maldwyn, 263). The freedmen rejected
gang labour work patterns that had been used in slavery. In the famous book, The Growth of the
American Republic, Morison, Eliot Samuel wrote with a strong backing of the Freedman's
Bureau, which forced planters to bargain for their labor. Such bargaining soon led to the
could obtain labor without paying wages and lands without paying rents. Instead of
interchanging money for labor and rents, there was a sharing of crops. This system gave the
freedmen some of economic independence and social autonomy more than gang labor; however,
28
Acres per worker on white and black family cotton
The amount of the land acreage available to African-American farmers was consistently less
Because they lacked capital and the planters continued to own the means of
production (tools, draft animals and land), the freedmen were forced into producing cash crops
(mainly cotton) for the land-owners and merchants, and they entered into a crop-lien system.
Gable Kate wrote in her work, Political Contribution to Racism during the Civil War and
Reconstruction, that under this system the farmer mortgaged his ingrown crop in order to obtain
surplus for a year. Thus, black land owners were few in number and generally possessed small
holdings. The Prevalence of poverty, the disruption of an agricultural economy and the falling
price of cotton led, within decades, to the routine indebtedness of the majority of the freedmen,
29
African American Land Ownership in The Rural Georgia , 1870’s
During the 1870’s, African Americans made up just under half of the population of
Georgia. Not surprisingly, however, they owned almost none of the lands and held very
City/town 2.7%
Furniture 5.2%
Livestock 1.1%
Tools 4.9%
To deal with these new circumstances, the postwar southern state governments
largely run by planters and their sympathizers passed a series of strict new laws governing the
freed population. The so-called Black Codes were intended to return the social and economic
order of the south to the way it had been lived under slavery.
30
The Black Codes
Apprentice Law
All freedmen under 18 years who are orphans or financially unprovided for by their
If apprentice escapes and its caught, master may reclaim him .apprentice faces
Employer is legally allowed to punish the freedmen in any way or guardian might their own
Children or reward
.
Apprentice shall be indentured until 21years of age if male and 18years female.
Freedmen are forbidden to marry any white persons upon penalty of life imprisonment.
Reward offered to any person who catches freedmen who quits their employer’s service
prior
to official termination.
.
Penalty of up to $200 for any white man who employs or aid a run-away freedman.
Vagrancy Law
All freedmen over the age of 18 who do not have written proof of employment at the
31
Beginnings of each year are vagrants.
If freedmen cannot pay the fine, he shall be hired out to any white man how will pay it
If freedmen between 18and 60 years of age will pay a tax up to$ 1 per year toward the
If a freedmen cannot pay a tax, he is a vagrant and be hired out to any white men
Penal code
Illegal for freedmen to carry firearms.
Illegal for freedmen to sell liquor, participate in riots, use insulting languages or gestures, or
Freedmen are liable for fines for the above, and if a freedman refuses to pay, he will hire out
Source: James, ciment, the atlas of the African American History. (90)
32
Franklin thought that the black codes represent the effort of the South to
solve problems created by the presence of the freedmen, as the freedmen bureau represents the
effort of the federal government to achieve the same end (Franklin, 212). These codes simply
were the implication of the white opinion to control the right of the freedmen.
Following the end of the war, southerners were looking for a solution to
economic recovery from the war devastation, especially by the end of slavery plantation system
that led to the decline of agriculture. Many southerners were convinced that their economic
salvation lies in industrialization. At that period, most of blacks were living in rural areas and
were working in sharecropping system; however, significant numbers joined their followers in
urban cities and took the advantage to join this revolution. They migrated to urban cities not
because they knew their industrial development, but because of hatred to plantation life, which
During that period, the manufacturers were looking for cheap labor. Franklin
assumed that they did not hesitate to employ the black’s labor in order to undermine the white
labor and secure eight-hour ‘workers. In the postwar period, blacks were not welcomed into
labor organizations, especially the locals, on the ground that local autonomy must be preserved.
Some admitted them, such as the carpenters, in 1866 and the national labor union invited blacks
to cooperate in the general movement (Eliot, 215). Eliot Samuel added that by the 1980s,
foreigners and northern businessmen were investing in the south; much of this investment was
for: rebuilding, modernization and expanding the railroads. At that period, no less than 23.000
miles much of the railroads in Taxes, but it were over 14.000miles east of the Mississippi (96).
33
The south had manufactured most of the nation’s tobacco even before the
War; it enjoyed the advantages of a proximity raw material, low transportation costs, and cheap
labor. Several companies reached prosperity such as the gigantic American tobacco company,
whose operation conducted in New York City, arranged from tobacco fields of the American
south to Europe, Egypt, India, and China. Some other industries flourished in the South, in the
eighties such as the coal and iron industry which centered in Birmingham, Alabama (Eliot, 98).
Besides, the most remarkable development exists, then again, in the textile
industry. Southern cotton manufacturing got underway before the Civil War; yet in the 1880s the
movement to bring the spindles to cotton took on the public crusade. In the famous book Elliot
asserted that the number of the south cotton mills, between 1880 and 1900, principally in the
Carolinas, Georgia, and Alabama grew up from 158 to 416. The amount of capital invests in
southern textile mills increased seven folds, and the number of workers rose from 17.000 to
Though the growth of industry give a more diversified economy, progress was
less remarkable than it seemed. Moreover, the southern industry was not the most profitable.
Therefore, the combination of a new agriculture system with the industrial one was aimed to
build a strong economy where the freedmen have the lion share of the process of economic
reconstruction. Thus, the breakup in the old plantation system caused economic problems that
Fazit
It seemed that the reconstruction era came as a God mercy to change the status
of freedmen and give them the chance to thatch the real freedom by contributing in the process
of reconstructing the south. The desire to forget the days of bondage and servitude led blacks to
34
search for local autonomy in order to escape from white supervision. However, the whites
wanted to keep their superiority on the freedmen by restricting their freedom through many ways
in order to prove the absence of equality in the new south and put them in front of real challenges
for equality
35
Chapter Three:
To a far great extent than in the civil war, Reconstruction left a legacy of
sectional and racial bitterness. For the south-or at any rate the white south -
reconstruction was a traumatic ordeal, ‘a long dark, night’ that left a lasting
mark on the region’s of psychology .Moreover, along with the civil war, it
provided a facile explanation for all the south’s ills (Maldwyn, A Jones, 259).
Introduction:
Americans ‘status after the long and heroic fight for their civil rights. By the end of the Civil
War, the freedmen thought that they reached what they wanted by the end of war, but reality is
too far from the dreams. The whites sooner repented and worried about the too much freedom
that had been granted to the newly freedmen and, as a result to that, they determined to give a
new definition to that freedom. These circumstances led the freedmen to face challenges against
For African Americans, reconstruction was the period of hope and a great
promise of freedom which was drawn closer to conclude the saga of slavery and bring to fruition
their incomplete freedom .In his book, Witness for Freedom ,Peter Ripley asserted that African
Americans expected that reconstruction would devastate every vestige of southern slavery and
36
reconstruct the American society. In the wake of thirty-five years of abolitionist labor and five
years of national sacrifice and war, black leaders were unwilling to see democracy postponed
again (278) .
However, their hopes and wills went with the wind; reconstruction brought a new
bondage to African Americans. It succeeded only to restore the power to the white men after
being guaranteed the success of the union to restore the country by freeing the slaves. Brogan
Hugh argued that the federates who pardoned members of the pre-war political and ruling class
were soon re-elected as state legislators, governors, Congressmen, and Senators .These leaders
had no intention of extending political equality and the right to vote to the freedmen. All the
southern state legislatures sooner passed Black Codes. These laws restricted the freedoms of
African Americans and limited the economic options of the freed; many freedmen were tied to
the plantations. By enforcing labor contracts and anti-vagrancy laws, the cruel Black Codes kept
it came to view that the confederate leaders created restricting laws and
systems, such as the black codes and the sharecropping system, which was a live testimony to
the original exploitation and bondage to the newly freedmen, in order to eliminate any chance of
equality between the two races and to offer a new designation to the meaning of freedom for the
ex-slaves by establishing racial segregation. In 1882, ex-slave Frederick Douglass wrote that
even if slavery was abolished, the problems of my folks were endless. No men are capable of
being really free, and his liberty is in need of notion, mood and deed of the others. Freedmen
were free from the individual master but they were slaves of society (the end of reconstruction,
history center).
Ripley also added that, all the way through the war, African Americans were
not in favor of the acceptance of incomplete freedom and they were the first to comprehend the
disastrous nature of the federal policies designed to return power to the southern white .Without
37
land, economic opportunity, protection of their civil rights, and the vote, African Americans
In his work, Rise from Slavery, the prominent leader Booker T. Washington
concludes that the Northerners turned against African-Americans not for the reason of racism,
while they were undoubtedly racist. Northerners turned against freed people after the Civil War
because African Americans symbolize a notion of civilization and government that would
devastate the free labor world. Black society, it looked as if it endangered the foundation of the
As a plan, Reconstruction had many goals to achieve in the south after the war.
The first goal of the 12 years of Reconstruction was to set up a lifestyle of social equality for
all African Americans living in the south. This was the first time the South had been enforced
to place the equal opportunity of all persons before the law. The Second goal that
Reconstruction attempted to achieve was the redistribution of land to African Americans and
poor whites. However, the distribution of homesteads, or seizure of land, was met with little
success. One reason was because the North and South resisted to the extent that it was in
their power to holdup or conclude the plan. Lastly, Reconstruction attempted to change
African Americans’ lives, one last time, by giving them political freedom. With the new
arrangement they were able to work as sheriffs, mayors, justices, and take seats in the city
Reconstruction had achieved the two great objectives inherited from the Civil
War: to reincorporate the former Confederate States in the union, and to fulfill the transition
from slavery to freedom in the south. But that transition was spoiled by economic inequity of
sharecropping and social injustice of white supremacy. Gary B. Nash adds that the third goal
of Reconstruction was the enforcement of equal civil and political rights promised in the
38
fourteen and fifteen amendments, but was betrayed by the compromise of 1877. In
subsequent decades the freed slaves and their descendents suffered repression into segregated
It is true that, during the Reconstruction Era, the federal government created a
real achievement in rebuilding Southern states that were devastated by the war and in expanding
civic services, particularly in establishing tax-supported, free public schools for blacks and
whites. But In spite of that, the rebellious Southerners seized upon instances of corruption
(hardly unique to the South in that era) and exploited them to bring down radical regimes. The
failure of Reconstruction meant that the struggle of African Americans for equality and freedom
was postponed until the 20th century -- when it would become a national and not a regional issue
came as a consequence of the legislature’s basis that was created in the course of the Civil War,
such as the Confiscated Act of 1861 and the Emancipation proclamation of 1863, which
normally aimed to free the southern slaves and grant equality to the newly freedmen. Yet, these
legislations aimed to deprive the confederate masters from the slave labor in order to destabilize
the southern economy, and thus win the war. Following the Civil War, from 1861 to 1865, three
amendments to the Constitution, known as the Reconstruction Amendments, were approved. The
Thirteenth Amendment of 1865 ended slavery, the Fourteenth Amendment of 1868 made of ex-
slaves citizens and the Fifteenth Amendment of 1870 guaranteed African-American men the
39
In her work, Political Contributions to Racism during the Civil War
reconstruction, Kate Grabel concluded that the prejudice against blacks was so enveloping that
the new laws, and the rights that go together with citizenship, were often ignored. According to
Gabel, each bill, passed during the civil war and all the way through the reconstruction, offered
for the freedmen of black slaves a freedom in the sense that they would no longer be legally
bound into slave labor. Yet, they did nothing to protect the freedom and liberty that was
the very beginning of the reconstructing process, wherein the conviction of black inferiority was
deeply rooted in their minds. In 1857 Chief Justice Taney said that for a long time slaves were
considered as an inferior creature and unfit to associate with the white race, in both social and
political relations. So blacks might honestly and legally be reduced to slaves for their benefit
Still by the end of the Civil War, the new freedmen could not experience their
freedom without the aid of the government because the southern states ‘policies continued to
restrict their liberties. But the government failed to enact the amendments. Again, the federal
government passed the fourteen amendments that protect the freedmen equally under the law.
The Civil Right Act of 1875 makes it clear that the U.S government by all means aimed to
outlaw discriminatory practices in the United States. This Act was never aimed to ensure total
equality to African Americans ‘community and that makes it clear that there is no serious action
to put in force the amendments or the acts. It becomes evident that true equality was never an
In addition to that, politicians quarreled with the constitution that called only
for equal treatment of all the citizens and in no way outlawed separate services. For black and
40
white, the problems of this policy were that the services for the blacks were frequently much less
accommodating than those for the white citizens. Since white Americans wanted to live far from
blacks, the US politicians found no solution except to create separate services for the newly freed
black community and white Americans. Fuke Paul said: “The most visible indication of a
divided society was the physical separation of white and blacks’ residential areas; in both urban
and rural areas of the state, the race lived apart” (196).
Gable adds that in order to maintain separate living conditions for blacks and
whites in the south, laws were rapidly passed (80). This separation showed the way to further
racially prejudiced thoughts in the United States of America. These policies were not put in
effect. Blacks had almost no contact among whites even radical politicians and federal agencies
restricted their social interactions with blacks to attendance to lecturers, public conventions,
and also the occasional contact on an individual basis. No blacks lived, worshiped, studied, or
entertained on a regular basis with the white; clubs, beneficial societies and military association
It is true that the freedmen got many opportunities to improve their status
through reconstruction policies but these policies widened the gap between the two races and
separated them; yet this separation was not equal. What is more, these policies led the freedmen
to feel inferior to the white men. The freedmen expected that Reconstruction will change their
status as the Civil War did, but they were shocked with its measures which aimed only to
restore the south to its previous masters and bonded them again to a new system that was not so
41
3. The African Americans’ Challenges in the Reconstruction Era:
During the Reconstruction Era, the freedmen faced a real challenge in the
course of shifting their social and economic status in the U .S. The major challenge that the
freedmen faced was equality; the freedmen continued to feel inferior to the white men even
throughout legislations and systems that were normally passed to guarantee their rights. Bu t in
fact they discriminated against them. Economically speaking, they were considered inferior to
the white men and; they were still working for their benefits because the white men were the
land owners. Kate Crabel finds out that the federal government created a system, where the white
man could resume his job as the “boss” and the freedman as the “worker”. This system intended
to limit the choices of the freedman from being owner of the land rather than being worker in
order to persist in his image as inferior in the south. As long as the freedmen entered to the new
systems of labor with no property, government was not intended to supply them, so, they had to
work and support themselves in order not to weaken the economy (76).
The freedmen found themselves obliged to enter a new plantation system; the
sharecropping and tenant farming, because they did not have any resources and property.
Sharecropping was based on the group contract system in which white land possessor would
provide a few acres of land, wages, and accommodation to freedmen’s family in exchange for
cultivating and harvesting the crops and delivering the greatest part of the harvest to the land
owners. Maybee brayn pointed out that this system did not change anything; it appeared as
involuntary servitude because the harvest would go to the land owner as payments of the land
and farming equipment. Therefore, the freedman had no benefits to enter such systems since he
could not obtain his own land. Tenant farming was not so different from sharecropping apart
from, that the cultivator would rent the land and pay back the rent by giving a great proportion to
42
the landholder. More often than not, the planter was in no way capable to cultivate sufficient
harvest to pay off his entire debt and this caused a never ending cycle much like slavery (2).
It became obvious to African Americans that the politicians of that era would
not adjust their status apart from emancipating blacks sequentially to keep their labor force for
empowering the United States ‘economy the government had not offered any aid to the freedmen
for making real employment or essential skills for employment (Gabe ,76).
accomplish the legend of possessing equal rights under the law of the United States. This way
was paved legally through a constitutional amendment, the fifteenth amendment of 1870 which
guaranteed citizens the right to vote regardless of race or previous condition of servitude. This
amendment was faced with a great opposition from the confederate masters and white
southerners. The opponents of black suffrage drummed on the point that the unqualified freed
people were unfit for the vote. Even the delegates at the 1866 Georgia Freedmen’s Convention
could not agree to support universal suffrage in the face of black illiteracy (Richardson, 42).
The white southerners had made a terrible kind of a pressure on the African
Americans to leave the polls, in particular for the republican candidates. The reason was that
republicans were creating laws that gave blacks more civil and economic rights. This would
Richardson believed that the right to vote for the ex-slave was the logical
solution to the problem of protecting African-Americans as free laborers. But the enforcement of
black suffrage required a dramatic assumption of power by the federal government, and few
Northerners were willing to undertake such an expansion of government until they had totally
lost confidence in Southern whites’ good faith efforts to build a free labor in the south that would
43
The right to vote became the critical step in protecting blacks’ civil liberties. It
would also be the first of their freedoms taken away. The African Americans were really in need
of such steps. Politically speaking, the vote might give the freedmen some of economic security
and allow a few of them to hold office; yet it did not make them equal with the white men or
protect them from racial discrimination. The black community remained inferior to that of white
because they were in the eyes of the white men an illiterate community unfit to practice such
privileges.
Since education was the major problem that left the black community inferior,
the freedmen determined to focus on education as a fundamental basis to escape from the
darkness of illiteracy to be proper citizens fit for all political and social performance. According
to. , in every part of the South, throughout the Reconstruction period schools, both day and night,
were overflowing to overload with people of all ages and circumstances; some being as far along
in age as sixty and seventy years. The ambition to secure an education was most recommendable
and encouraging. The idea, however, was too prevalent that as soon as one secured a little
education, in some unexplainable way, he would be free from most of the hardships of the world
and at any rate, could live without manual labor. There was a further feeling that a knowledge,
however little, of the Greek and Latin languages would make one a very superior human being,
For seeking for equality, the freedmen were struggling to overcome their social,
political and economic problems in the reconstruction period, but they did not reach their dreams
because the white southerners fought to keep their supremacy by restricting to blacks their civil
rights by all the means even if they were guaranteed by legislations. At that stage, the white
southerners gathered themselves in violent groups aiming to set up a panic against the freedmen.
These actions of terror became a pressure on the politicians and government as a threat of
44
survival to both of the governments and reconstruction. This movement of violence was among
Reconstruction was the freedmen’s most tragic period in the American history.
After the end of the war, the white southerners organized in gangs and nightriders aimed to have
power over the freedmen in all the southern states. According to Eric Forner, “The pervasiveness
of violence reflected white determination to define in their own way the meaning of freedom and
their determinate resistance to black efforts to establish their autonomy” (425). Freedmen
understood the assault and the white riots, through whichever mean, for these vigilant mobs as
aggressive efforts to squeeze their newly won rights and to restrict the meaning of black’s
freedom.
45
Laurens, south Carolina 1870 12
The Ku Klux Klan1was among the terrorist organization that had a great impact on the
African Americans’ security in the south. In his famous book, The Ku Klux Klan in Mississippi,
Newton, Michael thinks that this organization is symbolized as having had innocent beginnings
in a clandestine union created by six young white men in Pulaski, Tennessee, in the early
summer of 1866. These men were supposedly uninterested ex-Confederate soldiers seeking
laughter. Amusement was supposedly found in, among other things, dressing as ghosts and
setting out to terrify ex- slaves. But this amusement turned to a military organization using
violence operations for the interest of the democrats, the planting class; and all those who desired
1
- Ku Klux is a fanciful corruption of the Greek Kulos, or drinking-bowl, which indicates both that the founders
were men of some education and that the their purposes were not very sinister
46
In accumulation to that, the Klan operated in rural areas where the freed
people included a minority or a small majority. The Klan intended to adjust the status of the
freedmen in the south that was represented through their infinite demands for unreal right,
although schools and churches were irregular targets for fire-raising. The vast majority of
violence became visible toward local leaders and against economically independent freedmen
(Forner, 428).
Among the goals of violent behavior was the re-establishment of the labor
regulation on white owned farms and plantation. Hannah Rosen wrote in her famous book, The
terror in the heart of freedom, That the organization put laws under the titles’ “I Am
Committee’’. It contained a list of laws that outlined what was fundamentally a slave code
without slavery point out that white men were to be employers and all black people -men,
women, and children- were to be laborers. Means of survival for African Americans other than
laboring on a white man’s farm were forbidden. All freed people were ordered to be in the
employ of a white person; black people were forbidden to employ other black people; and white
men were prohibited from allowing freed people not in their employ to squat on their land. Freed
people were warned stealing or bringing food and supplies from their employer to other freed
people because their punishment would be death. Also, ‘‘Running about late of nights shall be
strictly dealt with’’; thus, nighttime meetings that might allow organization for bettering working
conditions or sharing resources were prohibited. The list of rules ended (185).
47
Klansmen raid a cabin during Reconstruction (Newton, 17)
When the federal government passed the fifteenth amendment which gave the
freedmen the right to vote, the Klan reacted violently toward African Americans Michael
Newton supposed that according to members of the Klan, the “injured and demoralized” were
southern whites, destined to suffer in a world where blacks could vote (9). The Klan worked hard
to deprive them from the polls and put great pressure on African Americans to abandon voting
48
Congress passed the Force Acts of 1870 and 1871 as a reaction to the murders
the Klan had committed. They enabled Federal troops to discontinue the slaughter of the Ku
Fazit
It came to view, that freedom which was given by the U.S. government to the
African Americans as a war reward, was far from having the original meaning of the word
“freedom”. Giving freedom to the freedmen and, by the same hand, depriving them from their
natural right such as education, security and self-determination, was just an indication of an
unclear and a contradictory vision of the U.S policy toward the African Americans in the post
emancipation period. Yet, the freedmen knew from the beginning that the way toward freedom
was not paved with flowers and roses, they knew that the struggle cost patience and ambition to
reach the sky of freedom and equality. For them, the Civil War and Reconstruction era planted
the seeds of freedom in a racist society aiming for a better harvest in the coming century.
49
Former slaves were stripped of federal protection against racist violence in the mid–1870s (Florida State
Archives).
50
Conclusion:
From the early days of servitude, African Americans and some of white
Abolitionists protested and fought for the legal and social rights of blacks’ minorities as
US citizens. They did not miss any opportunity to participate in great wars of the United
States in order to prove their loyalty and patriotism to their hometown .Finally, freedom
came with the coming of the Civil War. This war resulted into a great decision that
emancipated African Americans in1863. That decision did not affect the status of African
Americans only, but it also had a greater effect on the changing course of the war wherein
the black men participated side by side with the whites; the result was an amendment to the
In spite of this, the south emerged from the Civil War shorn of some features;
the peculiar institution of slavery had gone but new strategies for reconstructing the new
south must be done. In Reconstruction, the Freedman was the central figure and the most
difficult problem was that more than four millions of colored people had in one way or
another become free before the end of the war. Emancipation, victory and the Thirteen
Amendment were a long waiting step for the redemption of African Americans. The newly
called freedmen had to prepare themselves to assume a new status in their hometown.
Many blacks thought that freedom meant no more work and they proceeded to
celebrate an endless freedom; others were led to believe that every black would be given
forty acres and a mule by the government, or that the property of their former masters would
be divided among them. Yet, after freedom the freedman had neither money nor property; it
is true that he was free from the old plantation system; but he had nothing except the dirty
path below his feet. The government created systems such as sharecropping and worked as a
mediator between the freedmen and the land owners. He was turned lost and hungry The
51
death among the freedmen from starvation, disease; and violence in the first two years of
freedom ran into tens of thousands as the black leader Frederick Douglass said: “the negro
was free from the individual master but a slave of the society” (U.S History Centre). These
words led to understand that Freedmen were still counted as slaves as much as this
conviction of their fatal servitude was still rooted in the southerner’s minds.
socially or economically. Various laws and amendments were passed to preserve the legal
rights of blacks such as the Thirteen Amendments which had been added to the
constitution to guarantee slaves’ freedom, the fourteen Amendments to protect their civil
rights, and the Fifteen Amendment to assure them the vote. This process of legal protection
of the status of the freedmen enhanced was in Reconstruction era, wherein the federal
government continued in producing laws and Acts such as the Civil Right Act of 1866, the
enforcement Act of 1870, which threw the protection of the federal government over the
negro right to vote; the Ku Klux Klan act of 1872 and finally the Civil Right Act of 1875.
Few whites of the south were able to realize the implication of freedom or were
willing to accept anything approaching race equality. The “Negro” was still thought of as
slaveholders tried honestly and with a little success to help the freedmen in adjusting
themselves to their new status. While the poor white and small farmers were determined to
keep the freedmen in their places by all means they have as tenant farmers or
sharecroppers. In addition to that, the southern states attempted to assure this by a series of
laws collectively known as Black Codes. These Codes aimed to restrict the freedmen right
in order to maintain the philosophy of the old south, where they would not find many
problems in managing the freedmen and preparing for new voluntary servitude systems.
52
In that episode, the black achievements were enormous wherein the transition
from slave to free farmer was a long and painful one, made usually through government as
an intermediary .The Freedmen with the protection of the federal authority attempted to
build their own society based on their local autonomy to be free at last from the white
control. They reconstructed their families, pursued formal education, and created their
institutions. They also tried to vote and hold office as if they lived in democracy. But this
situation resulted into a great problem of separation that widened the gap between the two
Freedmen with the help of the federal government harvested end many gains
through the course of the Civil War and Reconstruction Era. The most important one was
“freedom”. But, this freedom was sooner restricted and bounded by the southerner’s policy
makers through their vagrancy laws and voluntary servitude systems planning to spoil African
Americans’ dreams and bring a miserable end to the story of reconstruction. It seemed that
Reconstruction failed to achieve its large goals in reconstructing the south, but in fact, it found
out the constitutional foundation for the civil rights movement of the mid twentieth century.
53
Bibliography
- Basler, Roy p. Letter from President Abraham Lincoln to Horace gory. Collection
http://showcase.netins.net/web/creative/lincoln/search.htm
- Burrus, Carnalhan. Act of justice: Abraham Lincoln emancipation proclamation and the law of
- Brogan, Hugh. The Pelican History of the United States of America. Penguin Group 1985.
- Chris H. Lewis, Ph.D. The Supreme Court decision of Chief Justice Taney: “Dred Scott v. Sanford”
history,furman.edu/benson/docs/dsmenu,htm./
2010.http://etext.lib.virginia.edu/
- Dal Lago, Enrico and Halpern, Rick. Slavery and Emancipation: Ira Berlin,’’ the Destruction of
54
- Foner, Eric. Reconstruction: American s unfinished revolution 1863-1877.pub, harpers& Row,
1988. (p2)
- Freedmen &southern society project. Law Creating the Freedmen Bureau: march 31, 1865.
- From Wikipedia, free encyclopaedia. Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen and Abandoned Lands.
- Fuke Paul, Richard. Imperfect equality : African Americans and Whites Racial Attitudes in
Htm /
- Hannah, Rosen. The terror in the heart of freedom: citizenship, sexual violence, and the
meaning of race in post emancipation South. The University of North Carolina Press, Chapel
Hill, 2009.
- Heather, Cox. Richardson. The death of reconstruction: Race, Labor, and Politics in the Post
55
- Heather, Freund . War for freedom: slavery and the emancipation proclamation. Oshkosh
- James, Ciment. The Atlas of the African American history. Eddy Carter Smith. Media Project
- John hope, Franklin. From slavery to freedom: the history of the Negro in America .McGraw-
Hill, 1988.
- Gable, Kate. Political Contribution to Racism during the Civil War and Reconstruction.
- Gary B. Nash and others, Eds. The American People: Creating a Nation and a Society,
6th ed. (New York: Pearson Education, 2004), 545.
- Lardas mark. African American in the civil war: USCT 1860-1866.osprey publication2006.
- Maldwyn, A Jones. The limits of Liberty: America history 1607-1980.oxford university press,
new York.1983.
- Maybee, brayn. The difficulties of African- Americans during the reconstruction era. Published
56
- Morison, Eliot Samuel, and Commager, Henry Steele. The Growth of the American Republic.
- Newton, Michael. The Ku Klux Klan in Mississippi. McFarland & Company, 1951.
- Ripley c, Peter. Witness for freedom: African American voices on race, slavery, and
the Civil War, and Reconstruction through the U.S. Pension Bureau Files. New York. University
Press, 2008.
- Vorenberg, Michael. Final Freedom: The Civil War, the Abolition of Slavery, and the Thirteenth
57
Tables :
1- African Americans in Office 1870–1876 From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Suffrage in
Reconstruction Era
2- Acres per worker on white and black family James ,ciment .the atlas of the African Americans
cotton history .eddy carter smith .media project Inc.
NewYourk.2007.
3- African American Land Ownership in The James, ciment .the atlas of the African Americans
Rural Georgia ,1870’s history .eddy carter smith .media project Inc.
NewYourk.2007.
4-the Black Codes James ,ciment .the atlas of the African Americans
history .eddy carter smith .media project Inc.
NewYourk.2007.