Nashwa BusinessLaw
Nashwa BusinessLaw
Law
Nashwa Sherin
1
BTEC HND in Business
Explore Educational Institute
Table of Contents
1. LO-1: Nature of the Legal System
1.1 Definition of a Legal System
1.2 Purpose of Law
1.3 Sources and Evolution of Law
1.4 Classification of Law
1.5 Legal System of UAE
2. LO-2: Potential Impact of Law on Businesses
2.1 Company Law in UAE
2.2 Business License
2.3 Freezone, Mainland, and Offshore Companies
2.4 Contract Law in UAE
2.5 Competition Law in the UAE
2.6 Data Protection in the UAE
2.7 Consumer Protection in UAE
2.8 The Employment Contract Law in the UAE
2.9 Impact of Company, Employment and Contract Law on Business in the UAE (Case
Studies)
2.10 Analysis of potential impact on business through differentiation between
legislation, regulations and standards.
3. LO-3: Formation of Different Types of Business Organizations
3.1 Types of Business Structures in the UAE
4. LO-4: Legal Solutions to Resolve Areas of Dispute
4.1 Common Employment Contract Disputes
2
4.2 Common Corporate/Commercial Disputes
4.3 Common Commercial Property Disputes
4.4 Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
3
Dispute Settlement: In society, disagreements and conflicts are inevitable, and it is the role of law to
resolve them. Therefore, disputes will be settled in court or outside of court using alternative conflict
resolution procedures.
Social Change: Many scholars believe that law serves as a tool for social change in modern society.
Law enables us to have purposeful, planned, and directed social change. The flexibility of law
provides some degree of discretion in law, allowing it to adapt to social conditions. If the law is rigid
and unchangeable, it might not adapt to changes on its own, which could cause resentment and
dissatisfaction among the people and even lead to violence or revolution. Therefore, some flexibility
in the law is inevitable (Shitewi, 2017).
5
individuals and the government, between concerned with the rights, responsibilities of
various institutions within a state, between private individuals and relationships
various branches of the government and between the individuals. Private law exists
between individuals that are directly related to help citizens resolve disputes involving
to society. Public law controls the actions of private matters and deals with the rights and
the state. It determines and controls the obligations of individuals, families,
organization and functioning of the state as businesses, and small groups.
well as the relations between the state and its Private law can be divided into:
citizens. The term "public" refers to a state, a a) Civil Law (contract law, law of torts and
sovereign part of it, a body, a person holding property law)
a delegated authority under the state (Arya, b) Labour law
2021) c) Corporations Law
Public law can be divided into: d) Commercial Law
a) Constitutional Law: Constitutional law is the e) Competiton Law
law that defines the nature of the state and f) Family Law (Divorce, Child Custody,
the structure of government. It is superior to Adoption etc.)
and above the country's general laws. It (Rawat, 2022)
describes the structure and function of the
organs of the state. Ordinary law (also
known as statutory law) derives its value
from constitutional law.
b) Administrative Law: Administrative law is
the body of law that authorizes the
establishment of public regulatory agencies
and includes all laws, judicial decisions, and
rules. Administrative agencies created this
law with the intention of carrying out their
responsibilities through rules, regulations,
orders, and decisions.
c) Criminal Law: It is the body of law that
recognizes criminal offenses, creates charges
and trials against suspects, and defines the
methods of punishment and treatment once
they have been found guilty. Its goal is to
stop crime and punish the perpetrator (Arya,
2021).
Court Structure
The UAE's legal system is divided into two parts: the Federal Judiciary, which is controlled by the Federal
Supreme Court, the country's highest court, and the local judicial departments, which are part of local
governments. At the federal level, the Ministry of Justice oversees all UAE courts and prosecution
departments. It also grants licenses to experts, lawyers, legal translators and appoints judges.
The general principles of these two systems are described in Articles 94 to 109 of the Constitution of the
UAE, but the specifics are left to the local judiciaries' discretion. The seven emirates each have the option of
either maintaining their own local judicial system or participating in the federal judiciary. Sharjah, Ajman
Fujairah, and Umm Al Quwain all use the federal judicial system. At the local level, Ras Al Khaimah Courts,
Dubai Courts, and Abu Dhabi Judicial Department all maintain their own independent judicial departments
with jurisdiction over cases that were not assigned to the Federal Judiciary according to the constitution
(u.ae, 2023).
Federal Judiciary Authority
According to the UAE Constitution, the Federal Judiciary is completely independent. Everyone is equal
before the law, regardless of race, nationality, or religion. The Constitution forbids arbitrary arrest, cruel
treatment, and unlawful entry into private property. The Federal Judiciary of the UAE consists of Federal
courts, Federal Supreme Court, and, Public prosecution (u.ae, 2023).
The Federal Supreme Court
8
The Supreme Court consists of five judges appointed by the President of the UAE after approval by the
Federal Supreme Council. The President and the Supreme Court judges cannot be removed or have their
services stopped with the exception of the following circumstances:
Death
Resignation
completion of the term of employment for those on a contract or completion of the term of a
secondment
Retirement
permanent incapacity to carry out their responsibilities due to ill health.
Disciplinary discharge based on reasons and procedures specified in the law appointment to other
positions with their approval (u.ae, 2023).
The supreme court handles:
Conflicts between member emirates or between any one or more emirates and the federal
government.
The constitutionality of federal laws and the legality of local emirate’s legislation if they are
challenged by the federal laws or the Constitution.
Interrogation of Ministers and senior federal officials based on request by the Federal Supreme
Council.
Crimes directly affecting the interests of the federation, such as crimes relating to internal or external
security, forging official records or seals.
Conflict of jurisdiction between federal and local judicial authorities.
Examination of the constitutional legality of laws if requested by any state court
Constitutional interpretations if requested by federal entity or any emirate
Conflict of jurisdiction between the judicial authorities of two emirates and the classification of the
underlying legal principles in federal law (u.ae, 2023).
The judgements of the Supreme Court are final and binding upon all (u.ae, 2023).
Federal Courts
The UAE maintains one or more federal courts of first instance in the federation's permanent capital or in the
capitals of some of the emirates to exercise their judicial authority in the following cases:
Crimes committed within the boundaries of the permanent capital of the Federation
Personal status actions, civil actions, commercial actions, and other actions between individuals that
arise in the permanent capital of the Federation.
Civil, commercial, and administrative disputes between the Federation and the individuals, whether
the Federation is the plaintiff or defendant.
The law controls every aspect of the federal courts of first instance, including their structure, creation,
departments, local jurisdiction, procedures to be followed before them, the oaths that their judges must take,
terms of service for judges, and the means for appealing against their decisions (u.ae, 2023).
Public Prosecution
9
Another element of the UAE's Federal Judiciary system is the Public Prosecution. According to the
Constitution, the Public Prosecutor for the Federation is chosen by a federal decree with approval from the
Cabinet. The Federal Law No. 35 of 1992 concerning the Criminal Procedural Law, as amended, specifies
the jurisdiction of this entity, its methods, and the authority of its assistants over the police and other security
services (u.ae, 2023).
11
Commercial Courts: Commercial courts deal with business agreements and commitments, financial
transactions, commercial papers, bankruptcy, and related issues. Cases involving the previously mentioned
issues are governed by Federal Law No. 18 of 1993 regarding commercial transactions (u.ae, 2023).
Criminal Courts: These courts deal with criminal cases that have been brought by the local or federal
prosecution in each emirate (u.ae, 2023).
The value of court decisions as precedents in the UAE
Judgments/precedents are not judicially binding, but they can be used as persuasive arguments in court. As a
result, judges in the UAE are not required to consider earlier court decisions as precedents. Judges are
unbiased and only influenced by the law and their own conscience. There is also no jury system in the UAE
(u.ae, 2023).
12
The UAE has a number of laws in place to ensure that business is conducted fairly and efficiently.
Entrepreneurs must abide by laws that:
Govern their business
Safeguard labor rights, consumer rights, and intellectual property rights.
Protect the health and the environment, as well as ensure safety
Govern the free zone in which their business is established.
2.2 Business License
The legal form and type of license, whether commercial, industrial, or professional, etc., are chosen based on
the business activity. There are six different kinds of licenses: commercial, professional, agricultural,
industrial, tourism, and occupational. A business or investment may engage in multiple commercial
activities. In the UAE, there are more than 2,000 business activities to choose from.
2.3 Freezone, Mainland, and Offshore Companies
Freezone Entity Mainland Entity Offshore Entity
Overview Free zones are Mainland (or onshore) In the UAE, offshore
commercial locations companies gain from businesses are not
where investors can having access to both the permitted to conduct any
exchange goods and UAE's local and direct business
services at preferential international markets. A operations. They may,
tax and customs rates. license from the however, be a
Benefits include 100% Department of shareholder in any
foreign ownership, 0% Economic Development mainland or free zone
corporate tax, and 100% (DED) of the relevant company in the UAE,
capital and profit emirate is required for allowing them to enter
repatriation. Over 40 the registration of a that market and carry out
free zones can be found Mainland LLC business operations
in the UAE. company. through those subsidiary
companies.
Ownership 100% ownership of the Prior to the new UAE Although an offshore
business is guaranteed laws, foreign company may own
for free zone companies. entrepreneurs could only 100% of the business, it
A local sponsor or own 49% of the shares is not permitted to
service agent is not in mainland companies; maintain a physical
required to launch a the remaining 51% were presence in the UAE.
business in a free zone. owned by a local
sponsor. However, the
UAE recently passed a
new law allowing
mainland companies to
have 100% foreign
ownership as of
December 1st, 2020.
Business Activity Free zone businesses are A mainland company is An offshore company
prohibited from free to conduct business can conduct business
13
operating on the anywhere in the UAE, both on the mainland
mainland. including any free zone. and in any of the UAE's
free zones.
Cost of Setup Medium-High: The cost High: Initial startup Low: Establishing an
to establish and operate expenses that business offshore company is the
a company in one of the owners on the mainland least expensive option
free zones varies greatly. can expect: because there are no
Depending on the free License cost minimum capital
zone selected, setup Initial approval deposits needed before
costs may vary. The from DED incorporation, no office
following four costs are Dubai Chamber space expenses, and no
involved in setup and of Commerce visa costs.
operation: Trade name
License Cost approval
Office costs Office rent
Equity Capital Attestation of the
Memorandum of
Association
(MoA)
Contract drafting
and court
agreement
attestation
Registration with
the Ministry of
Economy
Trade license cost
UAE Local
sponsorship fees
Capital Requirements The minimum capital The minimum capital No minimum capital
required for a free zone requirements for requirements exist for
company formation forming a mainland offshore businesses in
varies depending on the company also vary the UAE.
emirate in which it is depending on the legal
established. form of business chosen.
Office requirements Each free zone offers a There is a mandatory There can be no physical
variety of office space office space requirement offices for offshore
options, including for mainland businesses. businesses in the UAE.
virtual desks, offices, The minimum office Their office can only be
and flexi-desks. space requirement, located outside of the
according to DED, is to UAE.
lease a minimum of 200
square feet of office
space. For mainland
businesses, virtual
offices are not permitted.
Visa Requirements The number of visas A mainland company Offshore companies are
14
granted varies by free does not have any visa not permitted to issue
zone and the size of the restrictions. The resident visas.
office space leased. Free maximum number of
zones typically permit 3- residency visas is
6 visas. determined by the size
of the leased office
space or other business
facility. One visa is
typically allowed per 80
square feet.
Audit Requirements Audits are not necessary Mainland businesses are Offshore companies are
for all free zone required to conduct an not required to conduct
businesses. The audit at the end of every audits. They can do so if
requirement for an audit financial year. they want to stay
of accounts only applies financially updated.
to certain types of
entities.
(Creative Zone, 2022)
Contract Law
Contracts are legally binding agreements between two or more parties, and they are at the core of every
professional relationship. Whether it's a new lease, sales agreement, or renewal, a contract will outline the
terms and conditions that have been agreed upon by the parties. Whether a contract is 200 pages or only 10
pages long, it must include the following six vital elements in order to be enforceable:
1. Offer: Every contract begins with an offer. An offer is a declaration of intent to enter into a contract
with specific conditions. It is crucial to clarify what qualifies as an offer and what does not. Offers
must be specific, not vague or ambiguous.
Treat to invitation: An invitation to treat is different from an offer. When a person lists their home for sale,
they are not making an offer but an offer to treat. They are requesting offers from potential buyers to
purchase their house. This is also true for most advertising cases. The stores are offering to treat. If one
agrees to pay their asking price, they are indicating their willingness to sell something. However, they are not
obligated to accept the offer.
Counteroffer: A counteroffer invalidates the initial offer. It modifies the initial offer, releasing the original
offerer from any obligation as a result.
2. Acceptance: Acceptance is the second element of a contract. When a contract is signed, it is
considered to have been accepted. Any conditional acceptance or negotiation of additional terms is a
counter-offer.
3. Awareness: Both parties must be aware that they are entering into a new agreement for a contract to
be considered legally binding. The parties must reach what is known as "a meeting of the minds," in
which they acknowledge the existence of the contract and their consent to be bound by its terms. The
contract is void if one of the parties can show that they or the other party was forced into signing it, or
if fraud, misinterpretation, or undue influence was involved.
15
4. Consideration: Contracts are not considered binding unless something of value is exchanged between
the parties. Contractual considerations include things like insurance, property, and services. It's
important to keep in mind that a contractual consideration can exist without monetary exchange as
well. However, the payment of money in a one-time or ongoing manner is regarded as a
consideration.
5. Capacity: A new contract can only be entered into by parties who can prove their legal capacity.
Legal capacity is demonstrated when the parties show that they understand the obligations, terms, and
consequences of the contract before signing. The contract will be void if it is determined that one
party lacked the necessary capacity. For example, a party lacks capacity, if they are thought to be
minors, are intoxicated, or if they signed the contract under threats.
6. Legality: All contracts are governed by the laws of the country in which they are signed, and they
must follow these laws in order to justify legality (Marshall, 2023).
16
The location of your counterparty's assets (for enforcement purposes). If you win your dispute, can
you enforce it against your counterparty's assets in another country?
Whether or not the contract is highly technical or specialized, potentially requiring expert input
(Woods, 2018).
Competition Law
The body of legislation known as competition law aims to stop market distortion brought on by businesses'
anti-competitive conduct. Competition law is also referred to as antitrust law in the US, Canada, and the EU.
The goal of competition law is to guarantee a fair market for consumers and producers by outlawing
unethical tactics used to gain a larger market share than what would be possible through fair competition.
This unlawful conduct does not only make it difficult for smaller businesses to enter or succeed in a market,
it also results in higher consumer prices, poor service, and a lack of innovation.
Anti-competitive behavior includes predatory pricing, which occurs when a monopoly or oligopoly charges a
high price for something that consumers have little choice but to buy; price fixing, which involves collusion
between would-be competitors to set similar prices for products; bid rigging, which involves collusion to
determine the winner of a contract in advance; and dumping, which involves selling a product at such a low
price that smaller companies are unable to compete and forced out of the market.
17
2.6 Data Protection in the UAE
The Personal Data Protection Law, Federal Decree Law No. 45 of 2021 regarding the Protection of Personal
Data, provides a comprehensive framework for guaranteeing confidentiality of information and protecting
individual privacy in the UAE. Some provisions of the law are:
1. The provisions of the law apply to the processing of personal data, whether done entirely or partially
through electronic systems, inside or outside the country.
2. The law specifies the measures for the processing of personal data as well as the general duties of
businesses that handle personal data to keep it secure, confidential, and private. It prohibits the
processing of personal data without the owner's consent, with some exceptions for situations where
the processing is required to carry out any legal procedures and rights or protect the public interest.
3. The law gives the owner of the data, the right to request that inaccurate personal data be corrected and
to request that the processing of his personal data be limited or stopped.
4. It lays out the conditions for the international sharing and transfer of personal data for processing
(u.ae, 2023).
Other laws related to data protection and privacy include:
Protection of health information and data: Information and communication technology (ICT) use in the
UAE's health care industry, including its free zones, is governed by Federal Law No. 2 of 2019 Concerning
the Use of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in Health Fields.
Protecting data and privacy online:
a) Law on combatting rumors and cybercrimes: A comprehensive legal framework is provided by
Federal Decree Law No. 34 of 2021 on Combatting Rumors and Cybercrimes, which addresses issues
relating to the abuse and misuse of online technologies. It aims to increase protection against online
crimes committed using networks, platforms, and information technology.
b) Internet Access Management (IAM) policy: The Internet Access Management (IAM) policy is put
into effect in the UAE in collaboration with the National Media Council, Etisalat, and Du, the
country's two authorized internet service providers. According to this policy, Etisalat and Du can be
notified to remove any online content that is used for impersonation, fraud, phishing, and/or invasion
of privacy.
c) Electronic Transactions and Trust Service Law: The law governs the legality of electronic
documents and increases the legal significance and level of security of digital signatures. It outlines
the requirements for valid eTransactions, eDocuments that should be sent, received, and saved. It also
establishes licensing requirements for companies offering trust services that have the licenses to
produce, verify, and store e-signatures, eSeals, and digital certification (u.ae, 2023).
18
Consumers in the UAE are ensured the following rights by law:
To be given the right information about the products they buy, use, or consume, or the services they
receive
To receive fair compensation for losses that customers suffer as a result of using or purchasing
defective goods or receiving insufficient or unprofessional services.
The right to be informed of their rights and obligations.
The right to choose the best product and service available on the market in accordance with their
preferences (u.ae, 2023).
The supplier is required to:
Protect the privacy and security of consumer's data, and avoid using it for advertising and marketing.
Respect the religious beliefs, customs, and traditions of customers when offering them goods or
services
Handle consumer complaints
Give the customer a dated invoice that includes the business's name, address, the kind of goods or
services sold or provided, the price, the quantity, and any other information specified by the
Executive Regulation of this law (u.ae, 2023).
Suppliers who fail to provide accurate information and labeling, advertise false prices and information about
the products and services, or fail to replace or repair a defective product could face up to two years in prison
and a fine of up to AED 2 million (u.ae, 2023).
Ministry of Economy
The Ministry of Economy has a Department for Consumer Protection. The department's functions include:
Monitoring the implementation of the overall consumer protection policy in cooperation with the
concerned authorities.
Coordinating with the relevant authorities to combat unfair business practices that harm consumers
Coordinating and collaborating with the relevant authorities to raise consumer awareness on the
consumption of goods and services, as well as to inform them of their rights and how to exercise
those rights.
Regulating prices and attempting to limit the increase.
Aiming to create fair competition and prevent monopolies.
Receiving customer complaints, addressing them, or referring them to appropriate authorities
Publishing discussions and suggestions that raise consumer awareness (u.ae, 2023).
DED
The Department of Economic Development (DED) in each emirate deals with consumer rights issues and
implements plans and procedures related to consumer protection laws. It receives customer complaints and
educates customers about their rights and responsibilities (u.ae, 2023).
Abu Dhabi Quality and Conformity Council
19
The Abu Dhabi Quality and Conformity Council is in charge of creating a quality infrastructure and
promoting quality standards in the Abu Dhabi Emirate. The Council established the 'Manaa' system of
consumer safety services, which offers reliable information on any product and its compatibility with safety
standards. A "Quality Partner Program" was also introduced by the Council to encourage companies to
follow quality, safety, and technical standards and laws through self-evaluation and voluntary commitment
programs (u.ae, 2023).
The Abu Dhabi Agriculture & Food Safety Authority
The Abu Dhabi Agriculture & Food Safety Authority is in charge of agriculture, food safety, and animal
wealth in the emirate of Abu Dhabi. It encourages and funds agricultural and food safety research, resulting
in the creation of guidelines, standards, and specifications that are in line with the most recent findings (u.ae,
2023).
20
Full-time - under this system, an employee works full-time for one employer.
Part-time - when an employee signs a contract to work a set number of hours or days for one or more
employers.
Temporary employment - in this arrangement, an employee completes a specific task, and the
contract is then over.
Flexible working -Working hours or days may vary under this system, depending on the needs of the
employer's business.
Remote work- Working remotely means doing some or all of your work outside of the workplace.
Job sharing - Under such a contract, the tasks and responsibilities are allocated among the workers
according to the agreement made in advance. The rules of a part-time work model apply to job-
sharing contracts (u.ae, 2023).
Duties of Employers as per UAE Labour Law
A copy of the employment contract should be extracted by the employer and given to the employee.
The employer must make it possible for the employee to carry out their duties.
Employees should be provided with working hours and salary by the employer.
When presenting any complaints or notices against an employee, the employer should make sure they
are accurate.
The employer shouldn't force the employee to purchase goods from specific retailers or the employer.
Working time shouldn't be more than eight hours per day or 48 hours per week.
Employees should be given their annual leave by the employer.
While an employee is on vacation, an employer shouldn't fire them or give them notice.
Employers must provide employees with the necessary occupational health and safety means.
The Employer should secure a return ticket if the employee does not join another workplace in the
country while abroad.
The employer is required to compensate the employee for occupational risks and injuries (Deena,
2022).
Duties of Employees as per UAE Labour Law
Do not assume a false identity, a false nationality, or present false documents.
Do not make a mistake that could cause the employer to suffer a significant financial loss.
Do not violate the safety regulations at the workplace.
During working hours, do not be under the influence of alcohol or drugs.
Do not harass your manager, coworkers, or employer.
Do not skip more than 20 intermittent days or seven straight days of work without a valid reason
during a year (Deena, 2022).
Laws and Initiatives to Protect Immigrant Workers:
The UAE is a significant recipient of foreign labour. The UAE has reevaluated each step of the employment
process, from hiring to housing, to make sure that all foreign workers are treated with respect and are easily
able to report cases of mistreatment. In the UAE, it is against the law to charge recruitment fees to
21
prospective employees. The confiscation of workers' passports is prohibited, and workers do not need their
employer's permission to leave the country (u.ae, 2023).
Other reforms for immigrant employees include:
Approving a number of ILO conventions pertaining to workers' rights.
Passing numerous laws and resolutions that regulate employment relationships and fairly define each
party's rights and obligations. The "UAE Labour law," also known as Federal Decree Law No. 33 of
2021 on the Regulation of Labour Relations in the Private Sector, addresses issues relating to
harassment, bullying, physical violence, and psychological abuse against employees. Forced labor
and discrimination based on a person's gender, race, color, sex, religion, national or social origin, or
disability are prohibited under the law. It also outlines employers' responsibilities to employees and
prohibits hiring anyone under the age of 15 (u.ae, 2023).
Issuing Federal Decree Law No. 13 of 2022 Concerning the Unemployment Insurance Scheme, which
makes six specific commitments available for adoption in the Global Compact for Migration. These
include:
a) Implementation of recruitment processes that adhere to international standards.
b) Access to information about rights and obligations for all migrant workers both before and after arrival.
c) Ensuring that all migrant workers—especially domestic workers—work in safe and decent conditions.
Holding the Abu Dhabi Dialogue (ADD) and cooperating closely with the countries of origin to
address specific challenges confronting migrant labor in the Asia-Gulf migration corridors
Establishing a domestic law that upholds the principle of informed consent, ensuring that employees
are aware of the contract's terms, the nature of their work, the location of their workplace, the
compensation they will receive, and the time allotted for daily and weekly rest.
Ensuring that the wages protection system is enforced to make sure that workers are paid fully and on
time.
Establishing an insurance system to protect the rights and benefits of domestic workers and private
sector employees
Enforcing laws regarding worker safety and health and allocating more than USD $5 billion to ensure
that temporary worker accommodation meets or exceeds international standards.
Putting in place a standard employment contract that outlines how contracts can be terminated and
make it simpler for employees to change employers
Supporting the rights of people of determination by ensuring that they have an equal opportunity to
work and by providing them with suitable working and healthy environment.
Promoting gender equality in the workplace
Combating human trafficking at the regional and international levels (u.ae, 2023).
The UAE made significant efforts to improve working conditions for all employees and increase job
opportunities. Some of these initiatives include:
The UAE government invested AED 300 billion in 2015 to promote a knowledge economy that is
driven by innovation and prepare the UAE for a world after oil.
22
It created a number of strategies to increase employment opportunities and diversify its national
income based on a sustainable economy (u.ae, 2023)
2.9 Impact of Company, Employment and Contract Law on Business in the UAE (Case
Studies)
Impact of Company Law on Businesses in the UAE: The UAE implemented new laws governing foreign
ownership of companies in 2021. The laws allow foreign investors to own up to 100% of companies in
certain industries, including manufacturing, agriculture, and renewable energy. Businesses in the UAE have
been significantly impacted by this change, especially those in the affected industries. Some companies have
benefited from the new regulations to draw in foreign investment and grow their businesses. However, the
regulations have also increased competition in these industries, which has put pressure on some businesses.
Dispute over contract: In the UAE, a dispute took place in 2019 between a real estate company and a
construction company. The two companies disagreed over the contract's terms after the real estate company
hired the construction company to build a luxurious apartment complex. The construction company claimed
that the real estate business had broken the agreement by not paying for certain goods and services. On the
other hand, the real estate company claimed that the construction company was not entitled to payment
because it had not completed the work to the required standard. In the end, the dispute resulted in a lawsuit
that was heard in UAE courts. The real estate company was ordered by the court to pay for the materials and
services in question after the court ruled in favor of the construction company. This situation demonstrates
the value of clear and precise contracts in the UAE as well as the possible consequences of contractual
misconduct. Contract disputes can impact businesses by tying up resources and leading to financial losses. In
this case, the dispute over the terms of their contract led to a lawsuit, which likely resulted in legal fees and
other costs for both parties. This kind of dispute can be time-consuming and can distract businesses from
their core operations.
Impact of Employment Law on the Businesses in UAE: A new labor law was put into effect in the UAE in
2020 with the intention of improving worker protection. Standard working hours, annual leave, and end-of-
service compensation are all covered by the law. The law also mandates companies give employees a safe
and healthy working environment. Businesses in the UAE have been significantly impacted by this law,
especially those that depend heavily on low-wage workers. For example, in order to comply with the new
law, some businesses had to change their policies regarding working hours and overtime, which increased
labor costs. Additionally, some businesses have been fined for failing to provide a safe work environment or
for breaking other regulations.
24
Except for banking, insurance, or investment, this type of company cannot engage in professional or
consulting activities.
An LLC may engage in any commercial or industrial activity.
The UAE national should own 51% of the company, with the remaining 49% being owned by the
owner.
A UAE-accredited auditor is required for an LLC formation.
As an operational business structure, LLCs must appoint one to five managers, who can also be
chosen from among the legal partners (Danburite, 2021).
Owners of LLCs are not held personally liable for the company's debts or lawsuits because the LLC is a
separate legal entity. Since an LLC is a pass-through entity, its profits are distributed directly to its members
rather than being taxed by the government on the corporate level. Instead, members pay tax on their profits
on their own federal income tax returns. As a result, filing taxes is easier than if the company were subject to
corporate tax. Compared to a corporation, which employs officers to run day-to-day operations and a board
of directors to oversee policy, this structure offers more flexibility in management. An LLC can choose how
to distribute its profits among shareholders, unlike a corporation. For example, a shareholder who contributed
significant funding during the startup process may receive more profits, even if they have equal shares as
another participant (Wang, 2022)
Setting up an LLC requires more legal paperwork (and therefore more expenses) than operating as a sole
proprietorship. Even though having an LLC reduces personal liability in the event of a lawsuit, owners still
run the risk of losing their company and all of its assets. For instance, if you own a landscaping company and
injure a client or damage his property, he may file a lawsuit against you. Depending on how much he
recovers in damages, he might be able to take everything you have, including money and equipment (Milano,
2022).
C) Private Shareholding Company: In the UAE, this kind of business is also known as a Private Joint
Shareholding Company. It can be created through a partnership with a minimum investment of AED
5,000,000 from at least three investors. In addition to professional business, these legal structures are
compatible with all forms of commercial and industrial activity. A Private Joint-Stock Company is subject to
all of the rules and regulations that apply to Public Joint Stock Companies, with the exception of the rules
and regulations regarding public share subscriptions. Features of a PJSC in the UAE include:
To establish a PJSC, approval from the Ministry of Economy is required.
The company must appoint one manager.
The minimum capital required is AED 5,000,000.
The company may have multiple branches. Each may carry out some or all of the tasks listed in the
business's main license.
At least 51% of the shares must be owned by a UAE national.
A GCC national may own up to 100% of the shares (Danburite, 2021).
A private joint shareholding company (PJSC) in the UAE offers benefits like the capacity to raise significant
amounts of capital, ownership diversification, and access to a larger pool of expertise. But creating a PJSC
has drawbacks as well, such as longer and more challenging decision-making processes, vulnerability to
25
internal power struggles, required disclosure of financial information, and the requirement to follow legal
formalities and regulations.
D) Public Joint Stock Companies: A Public Share Holding Company is a legal entity with a minimum
capital of AED 30,000,000, transferable shares of equal value, and limited liability for each shareholder to
the amount of their capital. It is also known as a Public Joint Stock Company (PJSC) in the UAE. The
company's trade name cannot come from any partnering investors, unless it is the result of a shareholder's
patent or if the name is entitled to store belonging to the shareholder. Features are:
Partners may engage in any commercial, professional, or industrial activity in accordance with DED
business regulations.
According to DED business regulations, the company can only have a maximum of 5 appointed
managers.
A PJSC must have at least five founders who are UAE Nationals, with their ownership percentage
ranging from 30% to 70% of the capital shares.
The business may have multiple branches. Each may carry out some or all of the tasks listed in the
business's main license (Danburite, 2021).
A public joint shareholding company (PJSC) in the UAE has benefits such as increased visibility, access to
more capital, and a diverse shareholder base. However, establishing a public PJSC has drawbacks, including
increased regulatory oversight and disclosure requirements, slower decision-making, a chance of shareholder
conflicts, and vulnerability to takeover attempts.
E) Civil Company: A civil company is a business partnership for professionals like doctors, lawyers,
engineers, and accountants. A civil company is 100% owned by professional partners (except for engineering
civil companies), but a UAE National Local Service Agent is usually required. The civil company is only
permitted to engage in activities from a professional business. More precisely, such activities are described as
being either physical or intellectual and being carried out by one or more natural persons under a specified
capital. Features include:
Like the case of a sole proprietorship, an LSA is necessary for the company incorporation process if
the owner is a foreign national.
If a foreign company invests as a partner, it must be from the same type of business activity.
This company can be set up by partners of any nationality.
If the company is involved in engineering activities, one of the partners should be a UAE national
who owns at least 51% of the company.
If the company is engaged in consulting activities, it must be owned entirely by professional partners
practicing the same activity (Danburite, 2021).
A civil company is not a limited liability company, in which the company's liability is limited by law. The
advantage of a civil company over an LLC is that there is no limit on the number of visas that can be granted.
The only prerequisite is that if more work visas are required, one needs to acquire additional office space. As
a general rule, every additional visa requires an additional 100 square feet of office space. However, the
number of Managers a Civil Company can have is limited (A&A, 2023).
F) Partnership: In this type of business entity, two or more partners jointly own the business and split profits
and losses according to a predetermined ratio. Partnerships can be divided into two categories:
26
1. General Partnership: The partnership's debts are owed by the general partners, who must be UAE
nationals.
2. Limited Partnership: Partners in a limited partnership are only responsible for the debts of the
entity to the extent of their capital contributions. Additionally, the limited partner can neither be part of the
management nor have his name appear in the partnership's name (Danburite, 2021).
Features of a Partnership Company in the UAE are:
A simple limited partnership must have UAE nationals as general partners.
Partners of other nationalities must be limited partners.
There are no restrictions on general or limited partners' share of ownership.
Limited partners shouldn't get involved in general partners' managerial or administrative decisions. If
they do, they might become liable for all of the business obligations (Danburite, 2021).
A general partnership or the formation of a partnership business can be done easily, and the associated
paperwork is easy to keep up with. The most significant advantage of a general partnership business is the
simplified tax filing process because no corporate forms or double taxation are required. A U.S. Return of
Partnership Income is filed by each partner. This form specifies the partner's responsibility for the General
Partnership's profits and/or losses, which the partner can then claim on his or her U.S. Individual Income Tax
Return (Danburite, 2021).
Due to the General Partnership's lack of corporate structure, it does not exist as a separate entity from its
partners. This means that the partners are totally vulnerable to any lawsuits against the business, and their
assets may be seized at any time to pay the company's unpaid debts. So, if one partner comes to an agreement
without informing the other partners, each partner has the right to be bound by the terms of the agreement.
The same goes for credit. If any partner obtains credit in the business, all partners become equally obligated
to the terms of that debt (Danburite, 2021).
G) Branch of a Foreign Company: A branch of a foreign company must have a UAE national. The branch
must engage in the same type of business as the parent company. It has the ability to sign local legal
contracts, issue sales invoices to clients in the UAE and abroad, and lease offices in the premises. A branch
cannot manufacture, import, or export goods to or from the UAE. A branch office is incorporated by
submitting an application through the Ministry of Economic and Commerce with the assistance of a local
service agent (Danburite, 2021).
Foreign companies own 100% of the full shares in areas outside the UAE and within the parent company's
region. Additionally, this business type does not require the capital that most commercial companies require,
but it may need the parent company's budgets for the previous two years. There are no restrictions on foreign
companies submitting bids for governmental or formal entity tenders. Most importantly, this is the best legal
structure for people who want to make use of the parent company's commercial goodwill (Nour, 2022).
Some procedures may require board decisions from the parent company if the company manager or the
foreign company's agent is not authorized to do so. Furthermore, certain activities are prohibited for foreign
companies, while others, such as trading and selling products, restaurants and cafes, commercial agency
activity, and other activities, are allowed (Nour, 2022).
27
4. LO-4: Legal Solutions to Resolve Areas of Dispute
4.1 Common Employment Contract Disputes
a) Wrongful termination: Some of the most difficult cases in employment law can involve wrongful
termination. The work of an employee is frequently put on trial in these cases. In at-will employment states,
an employer may fire any employee for any reason, provided there is no contract in place and provided the
employer does not break any laws relating to discrimination or retaliation (Hue, 2023).
b) Wage Disputes: This type of lawsuit arises when an employer is accused of undercompensating an
employee for their time spent working. This may involve refusing overtime pay, tips, or regular paid breaks.
As of 2023, UAE labor law does not include any minimum salary requirements, there is no national
minimum wage or salary. However, it is required that workers' salaries and wages meet their basic needs.
Wage disputes may also involve worker misclassification, which happens when an employer wrongly defines
a worker as an independent contractor rather than an employee. This can have an impact on a worker's pay,
protections, and benefits, and cause tax issues for both parties (Hue, 2023).
c) Discrimination and Harassment Claims: Federal and state laws protect employees and job seekers from:
Discrimination, harassment, or unfair treatment because of a person's race, religion, national origin,
sex (including sexual orientation or gender identity), pregnancy, age, or disability.
Denial of reasonable accommodations in the workplace for an employee's disability or religious
beliefs
Retaliation against a worker who filed a complaint about discrimination or helped with a related
probe or lawsuit
Most employers must meet certain size requirements in order to provide employee protection.
Discrimination complaints must carefully follow legal procedures (Hue, 2023).
d) Severance Agreements: Employers may offer certain types of compensation to departing employees in
exchange for an agreement to a contract that contains non-disclosure or non-compete conditions. These
severance agreement types usually become the focus of legal disputes. If a company is providing such an
agreement or if an employee has received one, speaking with an attorney will help them understand their
rights as stated in the contract and address any problems that might arise (Hue, 2023).
28
d) Supply Chain Disputes: Conflicts between buyers and suppliers may also arise because of non-
performance, inconsistent payments, and other disruptions caused by trade and supply agreements (Durlak,
2021).
e) Conflicts over intellectual property (IP): Intellectual property disputes can involve licensing, ownership,
passing off, misleading and deceptive conduct, copyright issues, etc (Durlak, 2021).
f) Business acquisition and sale disputes: Disputes involving the sale or purchase of a business typically
result from unclear or undisclosed contracts, unforeseen liabilities, or even outright fraud on the seller's part
(Durlak, 2021).
g) Shareholder/director disputes: Conflict among shareholders or directors can arise from breaches of
directors' duties, claims of oppression, breaches of fiduciary duty, misappropriation of funds, division of
assets, etc (Durlak, 2021).
H) Breach of Confidentiality: We frequently see disputes when an employee quits their job to work for a
company that is a direct competitor and uses the contacts and knowledge they acquired there. Without a
confidentiality or non-compete agreement, the owner or director exposes the company to serious damage
(Durlak, 2021).
30
there. The proposed solution is not binding, but any formal agreements reached following conciliation may
be made legally binding, just like in mediation (Waks, 2022).
Example: A family dispute over child custody, where parties engage the services of a conciliator to
help them reach an agreement on a parenting plan.
The informality and flexibility of the conciliation process can be an advantage. The conciliator is
usually an expert in the area of dispute. Like all other forms of ADR, conciliation proceedings are less
expensive than courtroom litigation and if unhappy with the process, the parties have the liberty to
approach the court of law (STA, 2019).
The disadvantage is that the process is not binding on the parties to the dispute. The parties may be
unable to resolve their dispute, and there is no means of appeal (STA, 2019).
D) Arbitration: Compared to negotiation, mediation, or conciliation, arbitration is more formal and can
resemble litigation. An arbitrator hears the dispute from the parties and then issues a ruling. Parties can agree
to arbitrate before or after a conflict occurs (Waks, 2022).
Example: A dispute between two construction companies over a breach of contract. The parties can
agree to submit the dispute to an arbitrator, who will make a binding decision on the issue.
The real advantage of arbitration over formal litigation (aside from cost and efficiency) is that the
parties are free to establish the arbitration's rules, which can be much more flexible than the formal
civil procedure required in court. For example, parties may choose the number of arbitrators, the
forum, and the fees. Additionally, unlike judges, arbitrators have a great deal of flexibility to work
with the parties before them (Waks, 2022).
The drawback of arbitration is that both parties lose their right to appeal, which may leave one party
feeling treated unfairly. When compared to litigation, arbitration is generally thought of as a more
cost-effective process. However, in situations where little money is at stake, this feature is
meaningless. A judge must adhere to certain rules and guidelines when accepting evidence in a court
of law but arbitrators can use any information provided to them. The confidentiality of arbitrary
hearings can be an advantage and a drawback because a lack of transparency could lead to bias in the
process and, ultimately, injustice (Kumari, 2022).
E) Litigation: Civil litigation, the most well-known form of dispute resolution, usually involves a defendant
vs. a plaintiff in front of a judge or a judge and jury. The judge or jury is responsible for weighing the
evidence and making a decision. The information shared during hearings and trials typically becomes part of
the public record and remains there. Lawyers generally dominate litigation, which frequently ends in a
settlement agreement during the pretrial period of discovery and preparation (Harvard, 2014)
Example: A dispute between two companies over intellectual property rights. The parties can hire
lawyers to file a lawsuit and represent them in court to protect their legal rights.
Litigation can help protect intellectual property, which means it can help owners and creators of
inventions, music, and writing enforce their legal rights. This can apply to trade secrets, patents,
trademarks, and copyright. Litigation can provide long-term benefits in the form of precedent. This
means that businesses can profit from other earlier rulings in cases that are similar to their own, which
can support their case. Comparable disputes can be measured rather than starting from scratch, which
can be helpful. The decision made in a legal proceeding will be made public. This can help limit
31
damage and prevent rumors or false information from circulating. This might limit speculative posts
on social media (James, 2022).
The disadvantage is that it can be a lengthy process. Due to the large number of cases waiting to be
considered in courts, there often exists a huge backlog waiting to be assigned a court date. This means
more expenses in addition to the emotional stress that comes with awaiting the lawsuit's start date.
Litigation can make it difficult for business and personal relationships to endure the effects of a court
appearance where a ruling has been made. Litigation usually takes a long time to reach an end. A
resolution and judgment can sometimes take several years. With Litigation, it is usually impossible to
use opportunities for communication by developing personal relationships (James, 2022).
5. References
ر,حسين الشيتوى. and 2017 ,رجائى. FUTURE OF LAW. )1(3 ,مجلة الدراسات القانونية واالقتصادية, pp.1-22.
4 Common Types of Employment Disputes. (n.d.). 4 Common Types of Employment Disputes. [online]
Available at: https://www.grgblaw.com/wisconsin-trial-lawyers/4-common-types-of-employment-disputes.
Al Tamimi & Company. (2017). The Competition Law in the UAE - Al Tamimi & Company. [online]
Available at: https://www.tamimi.com/law-update-articles/new-competition-law-in-the-uae/.
Anon, (2021). What Are The Duties Of Employer And Employee Under UAE Labour Law? [online]
Available at: https://emiratesdiary.com/uae-labour-law-2/employer-employee-
responsibility#:~:text=Employer%20should%20extract%20a%20copy.
Anon, (2022). Business Licensing Options - Free Zone vs Mainland vs Offshore - Creative Zone. [online]
Available at: https://www.creativezone.ae/business-licensing-options-free-zone-vs-mainland-vs-offshore/
#:~:text=An%20offshore%20company%20can%20have.
32
Bishop, C. (2021). 8 advantages and disadvantages of sole proprietorship. [online] Ideas. Available at:
https://www.wework.com/ideas/professional-development/management-leadership/advantages-of-sole-
proprietorship.
Costello, J. (2020). The Most Common Employment Contract Disputes. [online] Zegal. Available at:
https://zegal.com/blog/post/the-most-common-employment-contract-disputes/.
danburitecorp.com | danburitecorp. (n.d.). All you should know before forming a General Partnership
Company in Dubai. [online] Available at: https://www.danburitecorp.com/all-you-should-know-before-
forming-a-general-partnership-company-in-dubai/nw-130.
danburitecorp.com | danburitecorp. (n.d.). What are the Types of Business Entities currently operating in
Dubai? [online] Available at: https://www.danburitecorp.com/what-are-the-types-of-business-entities-
currently-operating-in-dubai-/nw-126.
Duignan, B. (2019). What Is the Difference Between Criminal Law and Civil Law? In: Encyclopædia
Britannica. [online] Available at: https://www.britannica.com/story/what-is-the-difference-between-criminal-
law-and-civil-law.
Durlak, M. (2021). The 5 Most Common Commercial Disputes and How to Avoid Them. [online] IMD
Corporate | Helping International Businesses to Succeed in the UK. Available at:
https://imdcorporate.co.uk/dispute-resolution/the-5-most-common-commercial-disputes-and-how-to-avoid-
them/.
Ervine, B. (2019). Formation of contract and enforcement of terms: What negotiators need to know. [online]
Walker Morris. Available at: https://www.walkermorris.co.uk/in-brief/formation-of-contract-and-
enforcement-of-terms-what-negotiators-need-to-know/.
Garg, R. (2022). Substantive laws and procedural laws. [online] iPleaders. Available at:
https://blog.ipleaders.in/substantive-laws-and-procedural-laws/.
James, L. (2022). Advantages and Disadvantages of Litigation: A Quick Guide. [online] Robertsons
Solicitors. Available at: https://robsols.co.uk/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-litigation-a-quick-guide/
#:~:text=Engaging%20in%20litigation%20can%20mean.
Khourilawyers.com. (2020). Basic Principle of Contract Law in the UAE. [online] Available at:
https://khourilawyers.com/en/blog/basic-principle-of-contract-law-in-the-uae-.
33
[email protected] (2020). Classification of law | Municipal Law and International Law. [online]
Legal PaathShala. Available at: https://legalpaathshala.com/classification-of-law/.
MediateGuru (2020). Advantages and Disadvantages of Mediation. [online] MediateGuru. Available at:
https://www.mediateguru.com/post/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-mediation.
My Law Questions. (n.d.). What Is the Difference between Common Law and Equity? [online] Available at:
https://www.mylawquestions.com/what-is-the-difference-between-common-law-and-
equity.htm#:~:text=Common%20law%20typically%20refers%20to.
Nour Attorneys. (2019). Types of Companies in UAE; Their Characteristics, Advantages and Disadvantages
According to the UAE Commercial Companies Law No. 2 of 2015. [online] Available at:
https://nourattorneys.com/compare-companies-business-types-options-in-dubai-uae/.
Olamide, O. (2016). LEGAL SYSTEM: MEANING AND TYPES. [online] The Jet Lawyer. Available at:
https://djetlawyer.com/meaning-types-legal-systems/.
Peluso, B. (2019). What Are the Main Advantages of a Sole Proprietorship? [online] legalzoom.com.
Available at: https://www.legalzoom.com/articles/what-are-the-main-advantages-of-a-sole-proprietorship.
PON Staff (2019). What are the Three Basic Types of Dispute Resolution? What to Know About Mediation,
Arbitration, and Litigation. [online] PON - Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School. Available at:
https://www.pon.harvard.edu/daily/dispute-resolution/what-are-the-three-basic-types-of-dispute-resolution-
what-to-know-about-mediation-arbitration-and-litigation/.
Rawat, S. (2022). Difference between Private Law & Public Law. [online] Social Laws Today. Available at:
https://sociallawstoday.com/difference-between-private-law-public-law/.
Small Business - Chron.com. (n.d.). Three Disadvantages of an LLC. [online] Available at:
https://smallbusiness.chron.com/three-disadvantages-llc-21395.html.
TNS Lawyers. (2021). Commercial Disputes and How to Resolve Them. [online] Available at:
https://www.tnslawyers.com.au/understanding-commercial-disputes-and-how-to-resolve-them/.
u.ae. (n.d.). Consumer protection - The Official Portal of the UAE Government. [online] Available at:
https://u.ae/en/information-and-services/justice-safety-and-the-law/consumer-protection.
u.ae. (n.d.). Data protection laws - The Official Portal of the UAE Government. [online] Available at:
https://u.ae/en/about-the-uae/digital-uae/data/data-protection-laws.
34
u.ae. (n.d.). Employment contracts: duration and models in the private sector - The Official Portal of the
UAE Government. [online] Available at: https://u.ae/en/information-and-services/jobs/employment-contracts-
duration-and-models-in-the-private-sector.
u.ae. (n.d.). Protection of workers’ rights - The Official Portal of the UAE Government. [online] Available at:
https://u.ae/en/information-and-services/jobs/labour-rights#:~:text=The%20law%20prohibits%20forced
%20labour.
u.ae. (n.d.). The Federal Judiciary - The Official Portal of the UAE Government. [online] Available at:
https://u.ae/en/about-the-uae/the-uae-government/the-federal-judiciary.
Waks, A. (2022). Dispute Resolution Methods: Uses of Alternative Dispute Resolution | Davis Wright
Tremaine. [online] www.dwt.com. Available at: https://www.dwt.com/blogs/family-business-resource-
center/2022/03/alternative-dispute-resolution-methods.
Wang, A.L. (2022). LLC: Pros and Cons of a Limited Liability Company. [online] NerdWallet. Available at:
https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/small-business/starting-successful-llc.
Wigmore, I. (2019). What is competition law? - Definition from WhatIs.com. [online] WhatIs.com. Available
at: https://www.techtarget.com/whatis/definition/competition-law.
Woodruff, J. (2010). The Disadvantages of a Sole Proprietorship Business. [online] Chron.com. Available at:
https://smallbusiness.chron.com/disadvantages-sole-proprietorship-business-376.html.
www.businesssetup.com. (n.d.). Types of Business Entities in the UAE for 2019 | Business Setup Worldwide.
[online] Available at: https://www.businesssetup.com/blog/types-business-entities-uae.
www.hadefpartners.com. (n.d.). Five things you need to know about contracts in the UAE. [online] Available
at: https://www.hadefpartners.com/News/355/Five-things-you-need-to-know-about-contracts-in-the-UAE.
www.linkedin.com. (n.d.). Common commercial property disputes and dealing with resolution. [online]
Available at: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/common-commercial-property-disputes-dealing-resolution-
quinn-legal/
www.mondaq.com. (n.d.). Comparative Analysis Of ADR Methods With Focus On Their Advantages And
Disadvantages - Arbitration & Dispute Resolution - United Arab Emirates. [online] Available at:
https://www.mondaq.com/arbitration--dispute-resolution/777618/comparative-analysis-of-adr-methods-with-
focus-on-their-advantages-and-disadvantages.
35
www.summize.com. (n.d.). Elements of a Contract. [online] Available at:
https://www.summize.com/resources/elements-of-a-contract#:~:text=Whether%20a%20contract%20is
%20200.
36