TotalAV vs. Microsoft Defender 2024: Comprehensive Security or Seamless Integration?

Find out if TotalAV's extensive features or Microsoft Defender's robust Windows integration best suits your needs.

Last updated Aug 26, 2024

We receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

4.3

Editorial Rating

On TotalAV's website

Antivirus Software

TotalAV

First year discount on paid plans

Real-time protection from viruses, malware, and online threats
Blocks tracking cookies and ads, proactively monitors for data breaches, and option to schedule smart scans
100% compatible with Windows, Mac, Android, and iOS operating systems on up to 3 devices
Lacks firewall protection

4.2

Editorial Rating

On Microsoft Defender's website

Antivirus Software

Microsoft Defender

Brings the well-loved Microsoft antivirus to other devices
Includes a firewall, parental controls, identity theft protection, and a VPN
Free for Windows users
Features can be confusing
Middling performance on third-party tests

When deciding between TotalAV and Microsoft Defender as your antivirus solution for 2024, TotalAV provides a wider range of advanced protection features.

That said, Microsoft Defender is still a perfectly good option that comes built into your Windows system and offers protective features such as identity theft protection and parental control functions.

But if your priority is extra features like a VPN, password manager, and ad blocker, then TotalAV is your better choice.

Read on for a thorough comparison of two good antivirus options.

In this article

Comparison overview
Prices
Eigenschaften
Test results
Compatibility and customer support
FAQs
Which is better?

TotalAV vs. Microsoft Defender review at a glance

TotalAV and Microsoft Defender are two well-versed antivirus solutions that cater to varying needs.

TotalAV boasts a wide array of security tools combined with competitive pricing, which makes it an appealing option for those looking for comprehensive protection without paying a premium.

Microsoft Defender, bundled with Microsoft 365, brings core security enhancements and extra utilities, including the Office apps, which are best for users wanting an all-in-one approach and are already within the Microsoft ecosystem.

TotalAV: Best for users seeking an affordable, straightforward antivirus solution with comprehensive protection
Microsoft Defender: Best for families and users already using Microsoft products

TotalAV vs. Microsoft Defender


Star rating	4.3 AllAboutCookies writers and editors score products based on a number of objective features as well as our expert editorial assessment. Our partners do not influence how we rate products.	4.2 AllAboutCookies writers and editors score products based on a number of objective features as well as our expert editorial assessment. Our partners do not influence how we rate products.
Starting price	Free to $29.00/yr (first year only)	Starts at $69.99/yr
Max number of protected devices	8	5 each (for up to 6 people)
Malware scans	Manual and scheduled	Manual and scheduled
Real-time protection
Phishing protection
Ransomware protection
24/7 customer support
Compatibility	Windows, Android, iOS, MacOS, Chrome, Safari, Edge, Opera, Amazon Fire,	Windows, Android, iOS, macOS, Chrome, Safari
Mehr erfahren	Get TotalAV Read TotalAV Review	Get Microsoft Defender Read Microsoft Defender Review

How we test and rate antivirus software

We use our proprietary grading rubric in all of our testing, which considers ease-of-use, third-party testing scores, internal testing scores, price, compatibility, and features offered, among other metrics.

This means that our testing process is designed to ensure that the product isn't too confusing, protects as it claims, and offers you a lot for a reasonable price. We download and run each program on our own computers on home networks, just like you would. Our ratings reflect the real-world performance of the antivirus product. This ensures that we can recreate a similar experience for you and give our best advice on whether or not it's worthwhile.

To learn more about how we test, check out our full testing methodology here.

TotalAV pros and cons

TotalAV has optimization tools as well as a browser cleaner for easy surfing. All three paid plans include an ad blocker, and the free plan is better than many on the market. You'll have to upgrade to the Total Security plan if you want the password manager, though.

Pros

Highly-rated protection from multiple threats
User-friendly interface and overall app
Real-time protection to ensure your activity and devices are always safe

Cons

Only protects a maximum of 8 devices, which may not be enough for some households
Doesn't include advanced firewall protection

Microsoft Defender pros and cons

This AV offers reliable protection from various forms of malware. The Family plan can protect up to six people and has parental controls that are helpful for monitoring your children's internet usage.

Pros

Performed well in 3rd-party testing
Parental controls
Compatible with other antivirus

Cons

Struggles with phishing sites
DNS filtering only available on Edge
Cloud backup costs extra

Which antivirus has the better value?

TotalAV offers the best value due to the advanced features and reasonably priced plans.

	Our Pick
Price range	$29.00/yr (first year only)	$69.99-$99.99/yr
Best value plan	TotalAV Total Security for $49.00/yr (first year only)	Microsoft 365 Family plan for $99.99/yr
Money-back guarantee	Yes — 30 days	No — but has a one-month free trial
Mehr erfahren	Get TotalAV Read TotalAV Review	Get Microsoft Defender Read Microsoft Defender Review

TotalAV offers a range of plans, with the Antivirus Pro plan starting at $29.00/yr (first year only) before renewing at $99/yr, making it an excellent value for those seeking essential protection at a low cost. This plan covers all the basics of online threat protection, which is ideal for users who need straightforward security without additional frills.

TotalAV's higher-tier plans, such as Internet Security for $39.00/yr (first year only) and Total Security for $49.00/yr (first year only), offer added features like a VPN and full online protection, catering to users looking for more comprehensive security solutions.

On the other hand, Microsoft Defender is part of the Microsoft 365 Personal plan, which starts at $69.99/yr, including a suite of Office apps alongside enhanced security features. This makes it suitable for users who need comprehensive protection and productivity tools, plus it’s actually cheaper than TotalAV after the first year.

Microsoft's Family plan at $99.99/yr offers even more value for households, providing coverage for up to 6 people and 5 devices each.

TotalAV offers a straightforward discount for the first year plus a 30-day money-back guarantee, while Microsoft offers a one-month free trial, but lacks a traditional money-back guarantee.

Winner: TotalAV offers the best price for its entry-level plan, making it more accessible for those who need essential antivirus protection without the extra features. Its initial cost and money-back guarantee provide significant value, especially for users on a tight budget.

TotalAV vs. Microsoft Defender: Features

	Our Pick
Manual and scheduled scans
Real-time protection
Phishing protection
Ransomware protection
Firewall
Parental controls
Password manager
VPN
Ad blocker
Device optimization tools
Mehr erfahren	Get TotalAV Read TotalAV Review	Get Microsoft Defender Read Microsoft Defender Review

TotalAV and Microsoft Defender both offer a solid base of essential antivirus features, including manual and scheduled scans, real-time protection, and phishing and ransomware protection. However, they diverge in their additional features.

TotalAV, particularly in its Total Security plan, includes a password manager and ad blocker, which are not available in Microsoft Defender. It also has a VPN (in higher-tier plans). This helps add additional value, especially for users looking to maintain peak device performance and online privacy.

However, TotalAV lacks parental controls, which are standard in Microsoft Defender, making that product a better choice for families and users who prioritize these security layers. They’re especially useful for managing children's internet usage and ensuring their online safety.

Microsoft Defender also integrates seamlessly with Windows devices, providing a unified user experience but it lacks some of the more advanced tools. That said, it does come with:

Microsoft 365 apps
ID theft monitoring
VPN
Cloud storage

Winner: TotalAV offers most of the essential features we look for, though Microsoft Defender does have a good variety of additional options.

TotalAV vs. Microsoft Defender: Test results

When evaluating antivirus software, it's essential to check third-party testing to get an unbiased view of how well these products perform in real-world scenarios. These tests assess the software's ability to detect and prevent malware attacks, including zero-day malware and known threats.

For a consistent comparison between TotalAV and Microsoft Defender, we refer to AV-TEST, an industry-respected third-party test site that provides detailed insights into each antivirus's performance, usability, and protection capabilities.

The European Institute for Computer Antivirus Research (EICAR) test is another common benchmark used to assess antivirus performance. This allows us to see how well an antivirus software detects and responds to non-malicious files that mimic malware behavior.

TotalAV vs. Microsoft Defender malware protection scores

		Our Pick
AV-TEST Windows score	17.5/18	18/18
AV-TEST macOS score	18/18	K.A.
AV-TEST Android score	18/18	K.A.
EICAR score	2/3	2/3
Mehr erfahren	Get TotalAV Read TotalAV Review	Get Microsoft Defender Read Microsoft Defender Review

* TotalAV test scores are from the AV-TEST results for Windows from January–February 2023, and for macOS in March 2022 and Android in January 2023

* Microsoft Defender test scores are from the AV-TEST results for Windows from April 2023.

TotalAV and Microsoft Defender both show strong performance in the AV-TEST scores, with Microsoft Defender achieving a perfect 18/18 for Windows, indicating it provides robust protection against malware with no compromises.

TotalAV, while slightly lower at 17.5/18 for Windows, has perfect scores in macOS and Android scores. The slight dip for TotalAV in Windows suggests a marginal shortfall in one area but it is still well above industry averages.

Both antiviruses scored 2/3 on the EICAR test, showing that they’re effective but not overly sensitive in detecting simulated malware. This score indicates that both are well tuned to balance security and usability without causing unnecessary alerts for benign software, which is crucial for a smooth user experience.

Winner: Microsoft Defender provides superior protection on Windows with perfect scores from AV-TEST.

TotalAV vs. Microsoft Defender: Compatibility and customer support

	Our Pick
Windows
macOS
Android
iOS
Browser extensions	Yes — Chrome, Edge, Opera, and Safari	Yes — Chrome, Edge, and Firefox
24/7 customer support
Customer support options	Online guides, chat, phone, and email	Online guides, chat, phone, and form
Mehr erfahren	Get TotalAV Read TotalAV Review	Get Microsoft Defender Read Microsoft Defender Review

Both TotalAV and Microsoft Defender offer comprehensive compatibility across Windows, macOS, Android, and iOS, ensuring a uniform security experience on any device.

Both provide a variety of ways to contact support, but TotalAV boasts 24/7 support on their Terms of Service page. Microsoft Defender provides chat, email, phone, and online resources but is available only on weekdays from 6:00 AM to 6:00 PM Pacific Time.

Winner: TotalAV leads in offering the most user-friendly interface and the best customer support options, with comprehensive 24/7 support across multiple channels.

TotalAV vs. Microsoft Defender FAQs

Should I turn off Microsoft Defender if I have TotalAV?

No, you don’t need to turn off Microsoft Defender when using TotalAV. Both can operate together, providing layered protection without significant performance issues or conflicts.

Is Microsoft Defender different from Windows Defender?

Microsoft Defender is the updated name for Windows Defender, reflecting its expanded features and integration into the broader Microsoft 365 suite, particularly from Windows 10 onward.

Though Microsoft Defender requires a Microsoft 365 subscription, you can still access Windows’ virus scans in the Windows Security app for free. To find it, hit the Windows key and search for Virus and threat protection.

Is Microsoft Defender as good as TotalAV?

Microsoft Defender excels with strong protection in Windows environments and seamless integration, while TotalAV offers more features like VPNs and ad blockers, along with user-friendly support across multiple platforms.

TotalAV vs. Microsoft Defender: Which is better?

Overall, TotalAV is better than Microsoft Defender if you value a wider range of security features.

TotalAV is known for its user-friendly interface and comprehensive feature set, including a VPN, ad blocker, and device optimization tools, making it an excellent choice for users who value a broad range of features and an intuitive design. However, it lacks the deep system integration that comes with Microsoft Defender.

Microsoft Defender, on the other hand, offers seamless integration with Windows, providing robust protection with minimal system impact. It scores highly in third-party protection tests, especially on Windows devices, and includes additional security features like parental controls and identity theft protection as part of the Microsoft 365 suite.

While it lacks some of the extra features TotalAV offers, it is an ideal choice for users who prefer a no-fuss, reliable antivirus that works well within the Microsoft ecosystem.

TotalAV and Microsoft Defender alternatives

If neither TotalAV nor Microsoft Defender meets your needs, consider these best antivirus alternatives:

McAfee: Offers comprehensive security solutions with features like multi-device protection, identity theft protection, and a secure VPN. McAfee is known for its high-performance security and intuitive interface, making it suitable for both technical and non-technical users alike.

Get McAfee | Read Our McAfee Review

Bitdefender: Known for its advanced security features and multi-layer ransomware protection, Bitdefender also provides performance optimization tools and a secure VPN. It’s an excellent choice for those who need robust protection combined with performance enhancement.

Get Bitdefender | Read Our Bitdefender Review

Avast: Provides effective malware protection with additional features like Wi-Fi security scanning and a secure VPN. Avast is ideal for reliable and expansive protection without a significant investment.

Get Avast | Read Our Avast Review

No Fuss, Real-Time Online and Mobile Protection

4.3

Editorial Rating

On TotalAV's website

Antivirus Software

TotalAV

First year discount on paid plans

Real-time protection from viruses, malware, and online threats
Blocks tracking cookies and ads, proactively monitors for data breaches, and option to schedule smart scans
100% compatible with Windows, Mac, Android, and iOS operating systems on up to 3 devices
Lacks firewall protection

Author Details

Ryan L. Clancy

About the Author

Ryan Clancy is a freelance writer and blogger. With 5+ years of mechanical engineering experience, he's passionate about all things engineering and tech. He loves bringing engineering (especially mechanical) down to a level that everyone can understand.