2014 ballot measure petition signature costs

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Cost Per Required Signature
Analyses

BallotMeasureFinal badge.png

2023 Signature costs
2022 Signature costs
2021 Signature costs
2020 Signature costs
2019 Signature costs
2018 Signature costs
2017 Signature costs
2016 Signature costs
2015 Signature costs
2014 Signature costs
2013 Signature costs
2012 Signature costs
2010 Signature costs

The "Cost-Per-Required-Signature" (CPRS) for 2014's certified citizen initiatives and veto referendums averaged from $1.05 in Massachusetts to $6.44 in Missouri.

This Ballotpedia report is an in-depth look at the initiatives that qualified for the 2014 ballot. This includes a review of thirty-five citizen initiatives and five veto referendums in 15 states.

In 2014, 616 citizen's initiatives were proposed. However, only 40 made the ballot. 2014's numbers are down significantly from 2012. In 2012, 550 initiatives were proposed, yet 61 made the ballot.

The cost-per-required-signature compares the amount of money spent on the petition drives for those initiatives that did pay money to circulators to the number of signatures the state requires for an initiative to make the ballot. For more information about this report and how it is compiled, see this page.

In 2014, although state averages ranged from $1.05 to $6.44, individual measures cost 24 cents on the low-end and up to $8.36 per signature collected.[1]

The highest CPRS in 2012 was $10.86 for California Proposition 30. In 2013, Ballotpedia estimated the CPRS for Colorado Amendment 66, an income tax increase for education, at between $8.18 and $11.47. In 2014, the highest CPRS was $8.36 for Oregon Measure 92.

All calculations are only as accurate as the data made available through state campaign finance websites.

Not all initiative efforts were run by paid petition-signature collectors. Some ballot measure supporters opted to use volunteers. This resulted in a $0 CPRS which is reflected in the charts below with a hyphen or dash. Additionally, some initiative efforts likely used a combination approach where they used both paid petition-signature collectors and volunteers. This approach reduces the overall CPRS.

Some states do not allow for payment per signature collected. Of those that prohibit the practice, the following states qualified measures for the 2014 ballot: Colorado, Nebraska, North Dakota, Oregon and South Dakota. Both North Dakota and South Dakota initiatives resulted in a CPRS of $0.

The remaining states did incur costs for their initiative petition circulation efforts, according to campaign finance reports. The following report does not imply that payment per signature occurred or that the CPRS reflects the payment amount. Pay-per-signature is only one way of compensating signature-gatherers who collect signatures to qualify ballot initiatives for the ballot. Expenditures on which this report is based may include paid staff to organize the petition drive, compensation for paid staff in the form of bonuses or paying the circulators by the hour.


Editor's note: Data was compiled on October 1, 2014. Most signature-gathering expenditures should have been made and reported by this date, but any expenditures relating to signature gathering made after this date are not reflected.

Übersicht

QUICK STATISTICS:

  • Approximately $16,899,427 was identified as having been spent on petition signature gathering.
  • An average of $3 was spent per required signature for all initiatives based on available data.
  • The state with the highest CPRS in 2014 was Missouri, with an average cost of $6.44 per required signature. Missouri only has one initiative on the ballot.
  • The state with the lowest CPRS in 2014 was Massachusetts, with an average cost of $1.05 per required signature.

Editor's note: In light of complexities calculating Nevada Question 3's CPRS, that state and measure were not included in the rankings below. Nevada might have had the lowest average, but because of uncertainties based on how the signature expenses were reported, we can only assign a range -- $0.59 - $8.92 -- in Nevada.[2]


Table 1: Overview Summary of Results
State # of Initiatives Initiative CPRS Range Average CPRS
No Data < $2 $2 - $4 $4 - $6 $6 - $8 $8 - $10
Alaska 4 1 1 2 - - - $1.67
Arkansas 2 1 - 1 - - - $1.23
California 4 - - 3 1 - - $3.92
Colorado 4 1 2 1 - - - $1.37
Florida 2 - 1 1 - - - $1.49
Maine 1 - 1 - - - - $1.36
Massachusetts 4 2 1 1 - - - $1.05
Michigan 2 - - 2 - - - $2.53
Missouri 1 - - - - 1 - $6.44
Nebraska 1 - - - 1 - - $4.49
Nevada 1 1 - - - - - -
North Dakota 4 4 - - - - - $0
Oregon 5 - - 1 2 - 2 $5.83
South Dakota 2 2 - - - - - $0
Washington 3 - 1 2 - - - $2.67
40 12 7 14 4 1 2 $2.27[3]

State by state

The following 15 states had initiatives, veto referendums, or both on the ballot in 2014. Tables 2A through 2N below present individual CPRS data for all initiatives in 2014.

Alaska

See also: Alaska signature requirements and Alaska 2014 ballot measures
Table 2A: Alaska CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Ballot Measure 1 Taxes
--
$44,004[4] 30,169 $1.46
Ballot Measure 2 Marijuana
--
--[4] 30,169 --
Ballot Measure 3 Min Wage
--
$64,000[4] 30,169 $2.12
Ballot Measure 4 Business
--
$93,000[4] 30,169 $3.08
TOTAL: $201,000 120,676 $1.67

Disclaimer:

Arkansas

See also: Arkansas signature requirements and Arkansas 2014 ballot measures
Table 2B: Arkansas CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Issue 4 Alcohol National Ballot Access $173,553[5] 78,133 $2.22
Issue 5 Min Wage
--
-- 62,507 --
TOTAL: $173,553 140,640 $1.23

Disclaimer:

  • Issue 5's ballot question committee, Give Arkansas a Raise, paid Southern Strategies $6,000 for consulting in 2014. However, no expenditures were explicitly classified as being used for signature gathering.[6]

California

See also: California signature requirements and California 2014 ballot propositions
Table 2C: California CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Proposition 45 Insurance Kimball Petition Management $1,728,998[7] 504,760 $3.43
Proposition 46 Gesundheitswesen Kimball Petition Management $1,692,673[8] 504,760 $3.35
Proposition 47 Trials PCI Consultants, Inc. $1,847,882[9] 504,760 $3.66
Proposition 48 Gambling Arno Political Consultants and The Monaco Group $2,636,173[10] 504,760 $5.22
TOTAL: $7,905,726 2,019,040 $3.92

Colorado

See also: Colorado signature requirements and Colorado 2014 ballot measures
Table 2D: Colorado CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Amendment 67 Abortion
--
--[11] 86,105 --
Amendment 68 Gambling PCI Consultants, Inc. $132,943[12] 86,105 $1.54
Proposition 104 Gov't Acc Kennedy Enterprise LLC $253,564[13] 86,105 $2.94
Proposition 105 Business
--
$85,111[14] 86,105 $0.99
TOTAL: $471,618 344,420 $1.37

Disclaimer:

  • Amendment 67 did not have any expenditures explicitly for signature gathering purposes.[11]
  • Amendment 68's total signature cost is only for expenditures explicitly labeled as being for "petition signature gathering." However, Coloradans for Better Schools, Inc. made several other payments to PCI Consultants, Inc. and two other companies that include signature gathering in their services: Amplified Strategies and Winner & Mandabach Campaigns. The total expenditures to these three companies was $828,946.92, which would have made for a CPRS of $9.63.[12]
  • Proposition 104's signature collection was paid for by the Independence Institute in the form of non-monetary contributions.[13]
  • Proposition 105 did not utilize any signature collection companies, but rather paid individuals for collecting signatures.[14]
  • Colorado law restricts per-signature pay to 20 percent or less of a circulator's compensation. This report does not imply that payment per signature occurred or that the CPRS is the amount paid to signature gatherers. See: Laws governing the initiative process in Colorado.

Florida

See also: Florida signature requirements and Florida 2014 ballot measures
Table 2E: Florida CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Amendment 1 Environment PCI Consultants, Inc. $1,507,968[15] 683,149 $2.21
Amendment 2 Marijuana National Voter Outreach $522,257[15] 683,149 $0.76
TOTAL: $2,030,225 1,366,298 $1.49

Disclaimer:

  • Both Amendment 1 and Amendment 2's total signature costs include expenditures explicitly classified as “petitions,” “petition fees,” “petition gatherers,” “petition signatures,” "signatures" and “petition submissions.”[15]
  • Amendment 1 primarily used PCI Consultants, Inc. However, Active Root Consultants, Inc. was also hired to collect signatures. The company was paid $1,000.[15]

Maine

See also: Maine signature requirements and Maine 2014 ballot measures
Table 2F: Maine CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Question 1 Hunting PCI Consultants, Inc. $77,720[16] 57,277 $1.36
TOTAL: $77,720 57,277 $1.36

Massachusetts

See also: Massachusetts signature requirements and Massachusetts 2014 ballot measures
Table 2G: Massachusetts CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Question 1 Taxes
--
--[17] 80,396 --
Question 2 Environment
Spoonworks, Inc.
$145,000[18] 80,396 $1.80
Question 3 Gambling
Spoonworks, Inc. and Madison Group, Inc.
$191,712[19] 80,396 $2.38
Question 4 Labor
--
--[20] 80,396 --
TOTAL: $336,712 321,584 $1.05

Disclaimer:

  • Question 1's sponsoring committee did not explicitly spend any money on signature gathering.[17]
  • For Question 3, Spoonworks, Inc. and Madison Group, Inc. were hired to collect signatures. However, Spoonworks, Inc. received the vast majority of total payments for signature gathering. The business was paid $188,800, whereas Madison Group, Inc. received $2,912.[19]
  • Raise Up Massachusetts, the sponsoring committee for Question 4, gathered signatures for two initiatives. Besides Question 4, the group collected signatures for a Minimum Wage Increase Initiative. It's impossible to determine what expenditures went towards what initiative. Furthermore, the campaign did not explicitly spend any money on signature gathering, but did spend money on field organizing and field consulting. These expenditures may or may not include signature gathering.[20] For these reasons, the data was not included in this report.

Michigan

See also: Michigan signature requirements and Michigan 2014 ballot measures
Table 2H: Michigan CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Proposal 1 Hunting PCI Consultants, Inc. $364,229[21] 161,304 $2.26
Proposal 2 Hunting PCI Consultants, Inc. $452,539[21] 161,304 $2.81
TOTAL: $816,768 322,608 $2.53

Missouri

See also: Missouri signature requirements and Missouri 2014 ballot measures
Table 2I: Missouri CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Amendment 3 Labor National Petition Management and Ozark Strategic Solutions $1,015,592[22][23][24] 157,788 $6.44
TOTAL: $1,015,592 157,788 $6.44

Nebraska

See also: Nebraska signature requirements and Nebraska 2014 ballot measures
Table 2J: Nebraska CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Minimum Wage Increase Min Wage FieldWorks, LLC $360,955[25] 80,386 $4.49
TOTAL: $360,955 80,386 $4.49

Disclaimer:

Nevada

See also: Nevada signature requirements and Nevada 2014 ballot measures
Table 2K: Nevada CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Question 3 Taxes Organized Karma $43,000-$644,961[26] 72,324 $0.59-$8.92
TOTAL: $43,000-$644,961 72,324 $0.59-$8.92

Disclaimer:

  • Question 3's The Education Initiative PAC hired Organized Karma to collect signatures. While Organized Karma received $644,961 from the PAC, only $43,000 was used explicitly for "temporary workers." Organized Karma offers a variety of campaign and political consulting services, including canvassing. Because the services are so varied and in-kind reporting descriptions were not specific to signature gathering efforts the final figure could be anywhere between $43,000 and $644,961. The CPRS could be between $0.59 and $8.92.[26]

North Dakota

See also: North Dakota signature requirements and North Dakota 2014 ballot measures
Table 2L: North Dakota CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Parental Rights Initiative Custody
--
--[27] 13,452 --
Pharmacy Ownership Initiative Business
--
--[28] 13,452 --
School Year Begins After Labor Day Initiative Bildung
--
--[29] 13,452 --
Clean Water, Wildlife and Parks Amendment Environment
--
--[30] 26,904
--
TOTAL: $0 67,260 $0

Disclaimer:

  • The North Dakota Parental Rights Initiative's initiated measure committee, North Dakota Shared Parenting Initiative, did not report any expenditures related to signature gathering.[27]
  • The North Dakota Pharmacy Ownership Initiative's initiated measure committee, Committee to Qualify the Lower Pharmacy Prices Initiative, did not report any expenditures related to signature gathering.[28]
  • The School Year Begins After Labor Day Initiative's initiated measure committee, Start ND School After Labor Day, reported $2,250 in expenditures. However, the campaign finance disclosure forms are not detailed enough to distinguish what expenditures, if any, were signature collection costs.[29]
  • The North Dakota Clean Water, Wildlife and Parks Amendment's initiated measure committee, Clean Water, Wildlife, and Parks Sponsoring Committee, did not report any expenditures related to signature gathering.[30]
  • North Dakota does not permit paying circulators by the signature. This report does not imply that payment per signature occurred or that the CPRS is the amount paid to signature gatherers. See: Laws governing the initiative process in North Dakota.

Oregon

See also: Oregon signature requirements and Oregon 2014 ballot measures
Table 2M: Oregon CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Measure 88 Immigration The Signature Gathering Co. of Oregon $123,646[31][32] 58,142 $2.13
Measure 89 Constitutional Rights Encore Political Services, NW Democracy Resources, Boly:Welch and The Signature Gathering Co. of Oregon $515,853[33] 116,284 $4.44
Measure 90 Elections Silver Bullet, LLC $459,961[34] 87,213 $5.27
Measure 91 Marijuana NW Democracy Resources $713,864[35] 87,213 $8.19
Measure 92 Business FieldWorks, LLC $729,220[36] 87,213 $8.36
TOTAL: $2,542,544 436,065 $5.83

Disclaimer:

South Dakota

See also: South Dakota signature requirements and South Dakota 2014 ballot measures
Table 2N: South Dakota CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Initiated Measure 17 Insurance
--
--[37] 15,854 --
Initiated Measure 18 Min Wage
--
--[38] 15,854 --
TOTAL: $0 31,708 $0

Disclaimer:

  • Initiative Measure 17's ballot measure committee, Patient Choice for South Dakota, paid $225,534 for consulting in 2013. South Dakota campaign finance disclosure forms are not detailed enough to distinguish what, if any, of this was spent on petition circulation.[37]
  • Initiated Measure 18's ballot measure committee, Raise South Dakota, did not report any expenditures.[38]
  • South Dakota does not permit paying circulators by the signature. However, state law explicitly permits employers to set minimum gathering requirements and pay discretionary bonuses based on productivity. This report does not imply that payment per signature occurred or that the CPRS is the amount paid to signature gatherers. See: Laws governing the initiative process in South Dakota.

Washington

See also: Washington signature requirements and Washington 2014 ballot measures
Table 2O: Washington CPRS
Ballot measure Subject Signature collection company Cost Signatures required CPRS
Initiative 591 Firearms Citizens Solutions LLC and Democracy Workshop $625,937[39] 246,372 $2.54
Initiative 594 Firearms PCI Consultants, Inc. $686,252[40] 246,372 $2.79
Initiative 1351 Bildung PCI Consultants, Inc. $58,375[41] 246,372 $0.24
TOTAL: $1,370,564 739,116 $1.85

Most expensive breakdown

Editor's note: In light of complexities calculating Nevada Question 3's CPRS that state and measure were not included in the rankings below. Nevada might have had the lowest average, but because of uncertainties based on how the signature expenses were reported, we can only assign a range -- $0.59 - $8.92 -- in Nevada.[2]

By CPRS

Table 3A below indicates which individual initiative in each state spent the most per signature.

Table 3A: Most expensive initiative per state by CPRS
State Most expensive CPRS Signature collection company
Alaska Ballot Measure 4 $3.08 -
Arkansas Issue 4 $2.22 National Ballot Access
California Proposition 48 $5.22 Arno Political Consultants
and The Monaco Group
Colorado Proposition 104 $2.94 Kennedy Enterprise LLC
Florida Amendment 1 $2.21 PCI Consultants, Inc.
Maine Question 1 $1.36 PCI Consultants, Inc.
Massachusetts Question 3 $2.38 Spoonworks, Inc. and
Madison Group, Inc.
Michigan Proposal 2 $2.81 PCI Consultants, Inc.
Missouri Amendment 3 $6.44 National Petition Management
and Ozark Strategic Solutions
Nebraska Initiative 425 $4.49 FieldWorks, LLC
North Dakota
--
--
--
Oregon Measure 92 $8.36 FieldWorks, LLC
South Dakota
--
--
--
Washington Initiative 594 $2.79 PCI Consultants, Inc.

By total cost

Table 3B below presents the most expensive initiative by total amount spent on a petition drive by state.

Table 3B: Most expensive initiative per state by total cost
State Most expensive Amount Signature collection company
Alaska Ballot Measure 4 $93,000 --
Arkansas Issue 4 $173,553 National Ballot Access
California Proposition 48 $2,636,173 Arno Political Consultants
and The Monaco Group
Colorado Proposition 104 $253,564 Kennedy Enterprise LLC
Florida Amendment 1 $1,507,968 PCI Consultants, Inc.
Maine Question 1 $77,720 PCI Consultants, Inc.
Massachusetts Question 3 $191,712 Spoonworks, Inc. and
Madison Group, Inc.
Michigan Proposal 2 $452,539 PCI Consultants, Inc.
Missouri Amendment 3 $1,015,592 National Petition Management
and Ozark Strategic Solutions
Nebraska Initiative 425 $360,955 FieldWorks, LLC
North Dakota
--
--
--
Oregon Measure 92 $729,220 FieldWorks, LLC
South Dakota
--
--
--
Washington Initiative 594 $686,252 PCI Consultants, Inc.

Cost per signature rankings

Table 4 below presents a ranking of initiatives, from highest to lowest, by the cost-per-required-signatures. Initiatives that did not hire petition drive companies were not included in this chart.

QUICK STATISTICS:

Editor's note: In light of complexities calculating Nevada Question 3's CPRS that state and measure were not included in the rankings below. Nevada might have had the lowest average, but because of uncertainties based on how the signature expenses were reported, we can only assign a range -- $0.59 - $8.92 -- in Nevada.[2]

Table 4: Initiatives ranked by CPRS
Rank CPRS State Measure Topic Signature collection company
1 $8.36 Oregon Measure 92 Business FieldWorks, LLC
2 $8.19 Oregon Measure 91 Marijuana NW Democracy Resources
3 $6.44 Missouri Amendment 3 Labor National Petition Management and Ozark Strategic Solutions
4 $5.27 Oregon Measure 90 Elections Silver Bullet, LLC
5 $5.22 California Proposition 48 Gambling Arno Political Consultants and The Monaco Group
6 $4.49 Nebraska Initiative 425 Min Wage FieldWorks, LLC
7 $4.44 Oregon Measure 89 Constitutional Rights Encore Political Services, NW Democracy Resources,
Boly:Welch and The Signature Gathering Co. of Oregon
8 $3.66 California Proposition 47 Trials PCI Consultants, Inc.
9 $3.43 California Proposition 45 Insurance Kimball Petition Management
10 $3.35 California Proposition 46 Gesundheitswesen Kimball Petition Management
11 $2.94 Colorado Proposition 104 Gov't Acc Kennedy Enterprise LLC
12 $2.81 Michigan Proposal 2 Hunting PCI Consultants, Inc.
13 $2.79 Washington Initiative 594 Firearms PCI Consultants, Inc.
14 $2.54 Washington Initiative 591 Firearms Citizens Solutions LLC and Democracy Workshop
15 $2.38 Massachusetts Question 3 Gambling Spoonworks, Inc. and Madison Group, Inc.
16 $2.26 Michigan Proposal 1 Hunting PCI Consultants, Inc.
17 $2.22 Arkansas Issue 4 Alcohol National Ballot Access
18 $2.21 Florida Amendment 1 Environment PCI Consultants, Inc.
19 $2.13 Oregon Measure 88 Immigration The Signature Gathering Co. of Oregon
20 $1.80 Massachusetts Question 2 Environment Spoonworks, Inc.
21 $1.54 Colorado Amendment 68 Gambling PCI Consultants, Inc.
22 $1.36 Maine Question 1 Hunting PCI Consultants, Inc.
23 $0.76 Florida Amendment 2 Marijuana National Voter Outreach
24 $0.24 Washington Initiative 1351 Bildung PCI Consultants, Inc.

Signature collection company breakdown

Table 5 below presents a breakdown of the main signature collection companies used by all initiatives in 2014.

QUICK STATISTICS:

  • PCI Consultants, Inc. was hired for the most petition drives and in the most number of states.
  • The signature collection company with the highest average CPRS was National Petition Management.
  • The signature collection company with the lowest average CPRS was Organized Karma.

Editor's note: In light of complexities calculating Nevada Question 3's CPRS that state and measure were not included in the rankings below. Nevada might have had the lowest average, but because of uncertainties based on how the signature expenses were reported, we can only assign a range -- $0.59 - $8.92 -- in Nevada.[2]

Table 5: CPRS breakdown by petition management company
Signature collection company # of petition drives managed Average CPRS States involved
PCI Consultants, Inc. 8 $2.11 California, Colorado, Florida, Maine, Michigan, Washington
FieldWorks, LLC 2 $6.43 Nebraska, Oregon
Kimball Petition Management 2 $3.39 California
The Signature Gathering Co. of Oregon 2 $3.29 Oregon
Spoonworks, Inc. 2 $2.09 Massachusetts
NW Democracy Resources 2 $6.32 Oregon
Arno Political Consultants 1 $5.22 California
Boly:Welch 1 $4.44 Oregon
Citizens Solutions LLC 1 $2.54 Washington
Democracy Workshop 1 $2.54 Washington
Encore Political Services 1 $4.44 Oregon
Kennedy Enterprises LLC 1 $2.94 Colorado
Madison Group, Inc. 1 $2.38 Massachusetts
The Monaco Group 1 $5.22 California
National Ballot Access 1 $2.22 Arkansas
National Petition Management 1 $6.44 Missouri
National Voter Outreach 1 $0.76 Florida
Ozark Strategic Solutions 1 $6.44 Missouri
Silver Bullet, LLC 1 $5.27 Oregon

Category breakdowns

Table 6 below presents a breakdown of initiatives by political issue. Only political issue categories where initiative campaigns paid for signature collection were included in this table.

QUICK STATISTICS:

Table 6: CPRS breakdown by topic
Political topic Number of initiatives relating to topic Average CPRS
Business 4 $4.14
Min Wage 4 $2.20
Environment 3 $2.01
Gambling 3 $3.05
Hunting 3 $2.14
Marijuana 3 $2.98
Taxes 3 $1.03
Bildung 2 $0.24
Firearms 2 $2.67
Insurance 2 $3.43
Labor 2 $6.44
Alcohol 1 $2.22
Constitutional Rights 1 $4.44
Elections 1 $5.27
Gov't Acc 1 $2.94
Gesundheitswesen 1 $3.35
Immigration 1 $2.13
Trials 1 $3.66

Methodology

This analysis uses the following general methodology:

  • All data are compiled from data made available through each state's respective campaign finance website.
  • Individual initiative data are obtained from available reports from the main committee believed to have been in charge of the petition effort.
  • All costs that could be directly related to petitions, including petition gathering and petition printing, were accumulated. When a petition company is used, the company is listed even though all costs may not be directly associated.
  • All averages are calculated using only available data. When an initiative did not have available data, it was excluded from such calculations.
  • All averages are averages of totals, not averages of averages.

See also

Ballot measures

CPRS

Footnotes

  1. Note that when the average cost per signature is as low as 24 cents, the explanation is generally that volunteers collected signatures, thus reducing the overall cost of the signatures. Paid petition-signature collectors generally charge a minimum of $1.00 or more per signature, depending on a number of circumstances. The company they work for usually also charges additional fees to the political group sponsoring the initiative, leading to overall CPRS figures that are closer to an average range of $4.00 per signature, according to reports in recent years.
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 Question 3's The Education Initiative PAC hired Organized Karma to collect signatures. While Organized Karma received $644,961 from the PAC, only $43,000 was used explicitly for "temporary workers." Organized Karma offers a variety of campaign and political consulting services, including canvassing. Because the services are so varied and in-kind reporting descriptions were not specific to signature gathering efforts the final figure could be anywhere between $43,000 and $644,961. The CPRS could be between $0.59 and $8.92.
  3. The average displayed here represents the CPRS totals for all states divided by 15 states. If states with $0 CPRS are removed (3 states), the average is $2.84.
  4. 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 Alaska Department of Administration, "Campaign Disclosure Forms," accessed September 3, 2014
  5. Arkansas Ethics Commission, "Let Arkansas Decide," accessed September 3, 2014
  6. Arkansas Ethics Commission, "Give Arkansas a Raise," accessed October 1, 2014
  7. California Secretary of State, "Consumer Watchdog Campaign - Yes on 45, A Coalition of Consumer Advocates, Attorneys, Policyholders, and Nurses," accessed September 3, 2014
  8. California Secretary of State, "Yes on Prop. 46, Your Neighbors for Patient Safety," accessed September 3, 2014
  9. California Secretary of State, "Yes on Prop. 47, Californians for Safe Neighborhoods and Schools," accessed September 3, 2014
  10. California Secretary of State, "No On Prop. 48 - Keep Vegas-Style Casinos Out Of Neighborhoods, A Project Of Stand Up For California," accessed September 3, 2014
  11. 11.0 11.1 Colorado Secretary of State, "TRACER Committee Information: A Voice for Brady," accessed September 3, 2014
  12. 12.0 12.1 Colorado Secretary of State, "TRACER Committee Information: Coloradans for Better Schools, Inc.," accessed September 3, 2014
  13. 13.0 13.1 Colorado Secretary of State, "TRACER Committee Information: Sunshine on Government," accessed September 3, 2014
  14. 14.0 14.1 Colorado Secretary of State, "TRACER Committee Information: Right to Know Colorado GMO," accessed September 3, 2014
  15. 15.0 15.1 15.2 15.3 Florida Division of Elections, "Campaign Finance Database - Expenditures Records," accessed September 3, 2014
  16. Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics & Election Practices, "Mainers for Fair Bear Hunting Committee Information," accessed August 29, 2014
  17. 17.0 17.1 Massachusetts Office of Campaign & Political Finance, "Committee to Tank the Automatic Gas Tax Hikes Reports," accessed September 15, 2014
  18. Massachusetts Office of Campaign & Political Finance, "Coalition for an Updated Bottle Bill Reports," accessed September 15, 2014
  19. 19.0 19.1 Massachusetts Office of Campaign & Political Finance, "Repeal the Casino Deal Committee Reports," accessed September 15, 2014
  20. 20.0 20.1 Massachusetts Office of Campaign & Political Finance, "Raise Up Massachusetts Reports," accessed September 15, 2014
  21. 21.0 21.1 Michigan Secretary of State, "Keep Michigan Wolves Protected Committee Statement," accessed September 4, 2014
  22. Missouri Ethics Commission, “Teachgreat.org January 2014 Quarterly Report," accessed September 4, 2014
  23. Missouri Ethics Commission, "Teachgreat.org April 2014 Quarterly Report," accessed September 4, 2014
  24. Missouri Ethics Commission, "Teachgreat.org Amended July 2014 Quarterly Report," accessed September 4, 2014
  25. Nebraska Accountability and Disclosure Commission, "Nebraskans for Better Wages Campaign Statements," accessed September 4, 2014
  26. 26.0 26.1 Nevada Secretary of State, "The Education Initiative PAC Campaign Reporting," accessed September 4, 2014
  27. 27.0 27.1 North Dakota Secretary of State, "North Dakota Shared Parenting Initiative Campaign Finance," accessed September 4, 2014
  28. 28.0 28.1 North Dakota Secretary of State, "Committee to Qualify the Lower Pharmacy Prices Initiative," accessed September 4, 2014
  29. 29.0 29.1 North Dakota Secretary of State, "Start ND School After Labor Day," accessed September 8, 2014
  30. 30.0 30.1 North Dakota Secretary of State, "Clean Water, Wildlife, and Parks Sponsoring Committee," accessed September 8, 2014
  31. Oregon Secretary of State, "Oregonians for Immigration Reform Political Action Committee Expenditures," accessed September 4, 2014
  32. Oregon Secretary of State, "Protect Oregon Driver Licenses," accessed September 8, 2014
  33. Oregon Secretary of State, "Vote Equal Rights Amendment for Women Committee Expenditures," accessed September 4, 2014
  34. Oregon Secretary of State, "Every Oregon Voter Counts Expenditures," accessed September 4, 2014
  35. Oregon Secretary of State, "New Approach Oregon Expenditures," accessed September 4, 2014
  36. Oregon Secretary of State, "Oregon GMO Right to Know Expenditures," accessed September 4, 2014
  37. 37.0 37.1 North Dakota Secretary of State, "Patient Choice for South Dakota Campaign Reports," accessed September 4, 2014
  38. 38.0 38.1 South Dakota Secretary of State, "Raise South Dakota Campaign Reports," accessed September 4, 2014
  39. Washington Public Disclosure Commission, "Protect Our Gun Rights Expenditures," accessed August 29, 2014
  40. Washington Public Disclosure Commission, "WA Alliance for Gun Responsibility Expenditures," accessed August 29, 2014
  41. Washington Public Disclosure Commission, "Class Size Counts Expenditures," accessed September 4, 2014