Commons:Deletion requests/Images of Vero83alvarez

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search

This deletion debate is now closed. Please do not make any edits to this archive.

Images of Vero83alvarez

[edit]

Very doubtful own work claims from Vero83alvarez (talk · contribs). Many have already been deleted. Remaining contributions include a wide array of cameras and styles. Canon PowerShot A400, Panasonic DMC-FZ8, SONY DSC-W50, Canon EOS Digital Rebel, Canon EOS Digital Rebel XT, Panasonic DMC-FX10, Samsung Digimax... High-res buildings, low-res landscapes, very low-res figurines and artwork, people in blurry candids, people in posed black-and-white, new photos, very old black-and-white, obvious derivatives including magazine scans with no source, EXIF, no EXIF, camera time showing in three - and only three - images... Wknight94 talk 03:20, 10 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]

  1. File:Colegio Privado Subvencionado Nuestra Señora de CaácupeSPP 007-1-.jpg
  2. File:Comisaría. SPP 003-2-.jpg
  3. File:Casa Colonial-Centro del Pueblo. SPP 006-1-.jpg
  4. File:Centro Social Elisa Alicia Lynch SPP 001-2-.jpg
  5. File:Casa Colonial SPP 002-2-.jpg
  6. File:Iglesia de San Pedro Apóstol. SPP 005-1-.jpg
  7. File:Santanipy.jpg
  8. File:Agusting.jpg
  9. File:Nanduti.jpg
  10. File:Cordillera de ybyturusu.jpg
  11. File:Coloniaindependencia.jpg
  12. File:Homenaje a manuel.jpg
  13. File:Busen chaco.jpg
  14. File:Caminochaco.jpg
  15. File:Vacaspy.jpg
  16. File:Arroyopy.jpg
  17. File:Yhupy.jpg
  18. File:Vaqueria.jpg
  19. File:Repatriacion.jpg
  20. File:Nueva colombia.jpg
  21. File:Arroyopu1.png
  22. File:Jose martinez.jpg
  23. File:Loma grande2.jpg
  24. File:Loma grande1.jpg
  25. File:Coordillera San Joaquin.jpg
  26. File:S5032270 resize.png
  27. File:28102007 085 resize.png
  28. File:Ypacarai7.jpg
  29. File:Saltokrapa.jpg
  30. File:Obra de juan.jpg
  31. File:Cabichui.jpg
  32. File:Chipacarne.JPG
  33. File:Jesusnastosa.jpg
  34. File:Cabichipy.JPG
  35. File:EDITH 05.JPG
  36. File:EDITH1.JPG
  37. File:EDITH.JPG
  38. File:Andresherria.jpg
  39. File:Mural dela terza.jpg
  40. File:Laterza1.jpg
  41. File:Salto Cristal Vista 03.jpg
  42. File:ART2P029F0002.png
  43. File:Ypane.jpg
  44. File:Ypane1.jpg
  45. File:Ypane2.jpg
  46. File:Ypane3.jpg
  47. File:Clubcente1.jpg
  48. File:Clubcente.jpg
  49. File:Arma3s.jpg
  50. File:Lucita.gif
  51. File:Tobati 003.JPG
  52. File:Tobati 004.JPG
  53. File:Tobati 001.JPG
  54. File:Villa elisa00597.JPG
  55. File:Villa elisa00395.JPG
  56. File:Villa elisa00193.JPG
  57. File:Ytororo 0226.jpg
  58. File:Ytororo1 0227.jpg
  59. File:Fuente del santo 0213.jpg
  60. File:Gical 0221.jpg
  61. File:PetroSan1 0224.jpg
  62. File:Rioparaguay 0230.jpg
  63. File:ClubYtororo 0220.jpg
  64. File:Benignoarrua 0202.jpg
 Delete Delete all except #31 File:Cabichui.jpg & #34 File:Cabichipy.JPG (scans of historical 1860/1870 picture)(tagged by me with {{PD-old}}, in use in Wikipedia articles). All pictures might eventually be kept if the uploader provides a convincing explanation why he uses so many different cameras. Teofilo (talk) 09:27, 10 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]
Do you have a source for those two? Wknight94 talk 12:02, 10 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]
First of all, some people inserted the pictures in Wikipedia articles, and I suppose that they knew what they were doing. File:Cabichui.jpg seems to be similar with cabichui_1.gif available at on this University of Mainz website and if so, it means that it is the first issue of that newspaper, dated (13-05-1867) . Teofilo (talk) 19:38, 10 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]
Hmmm, for Cabichui.jpg, the file you found is higher-res. We should replace the JPG one here with that one. Wknight94 talk 21:37, 10 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]
From some evidence (wrote this already here) I have reason to assume that files taken with Canon PowerShot A400 and a DSC-W50 are likely own work but maybe downscaled from bad image editing. This includes e.g. the last 4 images in the list. So keep that, delete all files from the other cameras or scanned images of unknown source or files without exif. On the other hand the exclusion of this two cameras not includes files like File:Yhupy.jpg, File:Repatriacion.jpg or File:Loma grande2.jpg (obvious) and File:Jose martinez.jpg (less obvious) or File:Coloniaindependencia.jpg (not obvious, but too much doubt). This are examples, its not a complete listing. --Martin H. (talk) 13:24, 17 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]

 Question Did I correctly understand your comment, Martin H.?      Jim . . . . Jameslwoodward (talk to me) 12:22, 18 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]

My guess would be you did the opposite. I think Martin wanted to keep Canon PowerShot A400 and a DSC-W50 except for File:Repatriacion.jpg, etc. File:Repatriacion.jpg, etc., appear to be derivative works where the uploader used those cameras to take pictures of magazines or books. But I would wait to hear from Martin himself to be sure. Wknight94 talk 12:30, 18 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]
I thought he was fairly clear: "the exclusion (from deletion) of this two cameras (does) not include..." & I agree with his assesment--DieBuche (talk) 09:35, 24 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]
 Comment (added to closed deletion discussion) Missed that comment by James: I think it was much more than just this 4 taken with the mentioned cameras (e.g. 20% of all). But some of them was photos of books. I checked only a few and just gave examples, not a full list. Now that they are deleted I will not donwload them to check for the camera data. --Martin H. (talk) 12:59, 24 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]

Mostly Deleted. File:Cabichui.jpg was replaced by File:Cabichui 1.png; Four images kept per discussion & one since it it is PD-old (File:Cabichipy.JPG) DieBuche (talk) 09:51, 24 June 2010 (UTC)[reply]

Retrieved from "https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Deletion_requests/Images_of_Vero83alvarez&oldid=43756391"