Commons:Deletion requests/Ivan Kuznetsov

This deletion debate is now closed. Please do not make any edits to this archive.

Ivan Kuznetsov

• Savvinskoye Podvorie building in Moscow
  • File:Savvinskoye Podvorie Moscow Main Entrance.jpg
  • File:Savvinskoye Podvorie, Moscow, inside Tverskaya 6 - inner courtyard.jpg
• Building at Povarskaya Street 9 in Moscow
  • File:Povarskaya 9 by I.S.Kuznetsov1910.jpg
  • File:Povarskaya Street 9.jpg
  • File:Povarskaya 9 by I.S.Kuznetsov1910a.jpg
  • File:Povarskaya 9 by I.S.Kuznetsov1910b.jpg
  • File:Povarskaya 9 by I.S.Kuznetsov1910c.jpg
  • File:Povarskaya 9 by I.S.Kuznetsov1910d.jpg
• Delovoy Dvor building in Moscow
  • File:Wiki Varvarskye Gates.jpg
• Red Church in Vichuga
  • File:Красная церковь в Вичуге (1).jpg
  • File:Красная церковь в Вичуге. Дом причта.jpg
  • File:Вид на Красную церковь с запада.jpg
  • File:Красная церковь в Вичуге. Дом причта (1).jpg
  • File:Красная церковь в Вичуге.jpg
  • File:Красная церковь в Вичуге. Колонки.jpg
  • File:Красная церковь в Вичуге. Северный портал.jpg
  • File:Красная церковь в Вичуге. Южные ворота.jpg
  • File:Красная церковь в Тезино. Фото 1912.jpg
  • File:Красная церковь в Тезино. Фото 1912. Вид 2.jpg

These are images of architecturial works of en:Ivan Sergeyevich Kuznetsov, who died in 1942. There is no FOP in Russia ([1]), and Russian law is applied retroactively to Soviet works ([2]). Should be Category "Undelete in 2013" --Fernrohr (talk) 20:08, 20 August 2010 (UTC)

Keep until such time as the nominator is able to indicate what year each building was built. 9 Povarskaya Street was built in 1910, and is therefore {{PD-Rus-Empire}}. To quote from that, The Russian Federation (early RSFSR, Soviet Russia) is the historical heir but not legal successor of the Russian Empire.[1][2] The Russian Empire wasn't a participant in international copyright agreements, so this work is not protected by copyright internationally. --russavia (talk) 03:48, 21 August 2010 (UTC)

From en:Ivan Sergeyevich Kuznetsov, all of the above were built pre-1917, so therefore ALL of them are PD-RusEmpire. Speedy keep the entire lot. --russavia (talk) 03:53, 21 August 2010 (UTC)

• All of these buildings were built pre-1917. So all of them are PD-Rus-Empire, and the images of them are OK. Keep and warn the nominator to avoid wasting our time in the future. Dimawik (talk) 06:11, 22 August 2010 (UTC)
•  Keep: Red Church in Vichuga was built in 1911, Delovoy Dvor - in 1913, Building at Povarskaya Street 9 was reconstructed by Kuznetsov in 1892, Savvinskoye Podvorie was built in 1907. So - it's PDRusEmpire Rubin16 (talk) 08:10, 22 August 2010 (UTC)

I agree with the pre-1917 dates, and withdraw my nomination. Sorry guys. --Fernrohr (talk) 15:53, 23 August 2010 (UTC)

---

Speedily kept as we have consensus that {{PD-Rus-Empire}} applies. Fernrohr was already so kind to remove the {{Delete}} tags from the individual files. --AFBorchert (talk) 17:14, 23 August 2010 (UTC)