Jump to content

User:Gerda Arendt/ACE 2020

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Question from Gerda

[edit]
  1. In 2013, we had WP:ARBINFOBOX. In 2018, Voceditenore commented this. Would you agree?

Answers

[edit]

As of 18 November, all candidates answered to my liking, more or less detailed. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 08:37, 18 November 2020 (UTC)

Almost as soon as all had answered, we had a new situation. I asked the candidates about that on 5 December. Good answers linked. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 21:27, 5 December 2020 (UTC)

... and changed my mind --Gerda Arendt (talk) 23:20, 7 December 2020 (UTC)

Candidate nom day answer day answers Precious no. Precious reason experience sup elected
Bradv 10 Nov 11 Nov I haven't yet had cause to wade into that dispute 2263 "help improve the encyclopedia and achieve its vision" arb Green tickY Green tickY
Primefac 15 Nov 15 Nov on the whole I would agree
+ action
1556 astronomical spectroscopy cleanup arb Green tickY Green tickY
Scottywong 15 Nov 15 Nov from my admittedly limited perspective, I would agree
+ design preferred
2479 bot tasks and tools admin Green tickY
Maxim 15 Nov 16 Nov if we're to look at the situation now, nothing appears be bubbling 1196 ice hockey players arb Green tickY
BDD 16 Nov 16 Nov I haven't encountered such disputes recently
+ good answer
2480 people in education and music admin Green tickY Green tickY
Barkeep49 17 Nov 17 Nov the strength of feelings about them still runs deep
+ 7 Dec response
2109 radiant child admin Green tickY Green tickY
TonyBallioni
(withdrawn)
17 Nov 17 Nov I'd agree in part that they’re being used more frequently without controversy as compared to 2013 1682 papal conclaves admin
L235 17 Nov 18 Nov there haven't been widespread infobox conduct issues since the Civility case
+ 9 Dec apology
1977 supreme court admin, arb clark Green tickY
Hawkeye7 17 Nov 17 Nov Sure. As far as I know, things are calm now. 171 people in sports and battles former admin
CaptainEek 17 Nov 17 Nov editors have been using civil discussion to solve infobox issues for some years
+ good question "why removed"
2440 birds of the Southwestern U.S. admin Green tickY Green tickY
Guerillero 17 Nov 17 Nov Broadly, yes. 761 Toil, tools, tradition and trust arb
‎SMcCandlish 17 Nov 17 Nov debates I've seen semi-recently have been more appropriately focused on whether an infobox is helpful
+ 7 Dec infobox expected
1786 four dimensions player Green tickY

The most detailed answer, telling me of carefully looking at this field, so hopefully others as well, came from ‎SMcCandlish. None of the candidates would break the wiki, but those saying - in other words -- that arbcom helped to peace in the matter might want to look closer. Related thoughts can be found on my talk: vision 2020 and Gerda's dream. Today's decoration is for BB's music. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 13:00, 23 November 2020 (UTC)

Voted 2 December --Gerda Arendt (talk) 20:04, 2 December 2020 (UTC)


Results

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ Template adapted from User:Worm That Turned/ACE2015