Jump to content

User:Gerda Arendt/ACE 2022

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is NOT a voters' guide, just my private quick evaluation, looking at the candidates' answers to my questions, and how I saw them previously (Precious, when, for what, or last years question).

Questions from Gerda Arendt

[edit]
  • Do you believe that we still have infobox wars? If yes, do you have better ideas than the 2013 arb ruling to end them? --Gerda Arendt (talk) 13:25, 20 November 2022 (UTC)

I asked this question because the Laurence Olivier situation came up, but could not point at it because some would have understood that as canvassing. Now that it was closed, the follow-up question:

  • Where does the recently closed RfC for Laurence Olivier sit in your perspective?
  • ... and repeating that question after another week of discussions there --Gerda Arendt (talk) 13:46, 6 December 2022 (UTC)
  • ... and no answer but it now went to a noticeboard --Gerda Arendt (talk) 23:07, 10 December 2022 (UTC)

Answers

[edit]
Candidate nom day answer day answers Precious no. Precious reason experience support elected
Guerillero 13 Nov 23 + 28 Nov let go
"overly-spirited comments"
751 Toil, tools, tradition and trust arb Green tickY Green tickY
GeneralNotability 13 Nov 23 + 28 Nov not witnessed
"appropriate way to determine a way forward"
- admin Green tickY Green tickY
Robert McClenon 15 Nov 26 + 30 Nov yes
good close
1409 belief in logic Green tickY
CaptainEek 15 Nov 23 + 28 Nov no
"a thoughtful and considered close"
2440 birds of the Southwestern U.S. arb Green tickYGreen tickY Green tickY
BoldLuis 16 Nov wait -
Moneytrees 18 Nov 23 + 28 Nov editing
"temperatures have decreased"
2077 "I edit here when I have nothing else to do, just for fun." admin Green tickYGreen tickY Green tickY
Primefac 19 Nov 23 + 28 Nov no
"fairly tame"
1556 astronomical spectroscopy cleanup arb Green tickYGreen tickY Green tickY
L235 21 Nov 24 Nov + 7 Dec no
I generally feel that RfCs like this are a poor allocation of editor time and effort
1977 supreme court arb Green tickYGreen tickY Green tickY
Tamzin 22 Nov 27 Nov + 1 Dez no
mostly healthy discussions
2728 may memories be for a blessing admin Green tickYGreen tickY
SilkTork 22 Nov 23 + 28 Nov consensus
"more encouraging than saddening"
2353 look at both sides arb Green tickYGreen tickY Green tickY
Sdrqaz 22 Nov 25 + 28 Nov no, detailed observations
was aware
2727 stop disruption through discussion admin Green tickYGreen tickY
Barkeep49 22 Nov 23 + 28 Nov faded
seems normal content dispute
2109 radiant child arb Green tickYGreen tickY Green tickY

Voting

[edit]

Today is the birthday of Jean Sibelius, and I'm voting. Most candidates saw that there's not much of a war, at least no recent bloody battles. None of them offered a good idea for peace. The topic is still loaded, as the Olivier discussion shows, and last year's question, How many RfCs do we need to call the infobox wars over?, was not answered, not by the candidates nor the community. We have right now - after a completely quiet year - RfCs not only for Olivier, but also for two composers, a poet and an actress - no links or I would be accused of canvassing. I would like to see peace in 2023, - ideas welcome. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 15:32, 8 December 2022 (UTC)

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ Template adapted from User:Worm That Turned/ACE2015