Scribd Logo
Hochladen

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Mundo (A Voyage Around The World, 1698) - He Counfused Two Distinct

    Uploaded by

    Ys Yu
    971 views3 pages
    The document provides information about comparing and contrasting two accounts of the site of the first Catholic mass in the Philippines - one tradition saying it was in Butuan and the other saying it was in Limasawa Island. It includes a table to compare the two accounts on the routes taken and the date of the first mass. Evidence from the accounts of Pigafetta and Albo are also summarized, noting similarities in their descriptions of places visited like Homonhon island and Mazaua island, the week-long stay in Mazaua, and their arrival in Cebu on April 7, 1521. Questions are also provided about details from the accounts.

    Original Description:

    okay

    Original Title

    2BSAcctyB_GE2

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The document provides information about comparing and contrasting two accounts of the site of the first Catholic mass in the Philippines - one tradition saying it was in Butuan and the other saying it was in Limasawa Island. It includes a table to compare the two accounts on the routes taken and the date of the first mass. Evidence from the accounts of Pigafetta and Albo are also summarized, noting similarities in their descriptions of places visited like Homonhon island and Mazaua island, the week-long stay in Mazaua, and their arrival in Cebu on April 7, 1521. Questions are also provided about details from the accounts.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    971 views3 pages

    Mundo (A Voyage Around The World, 1698) - He Counfused Two Distinct

    Uploaded by

    Ys Yu
    The document provides information about comparing and contrasting two accounts of the site of the first Catholic mass in the Philippines - one tradition saying it was in Butuan and the other saying it was in Limasawa Island. It includes a table to compare the two accounts on the routes taken and the date of the first mass. Evidence from the accounts of Pigafetta and Albo are also summarized, noting similarities in their descriptions of places visited like Homonhon island and Mazaua island, the week-long stay in Mazaua, and their arrival in Cebu on April 7, 1521. Questions are also provided about details from the accounts.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 3

    Reading and Writing in Philippine History Activity 1

    Direction: To show how things become alike is being done by comparing. And, to show
    how things become different is being done by differentiating. There are likeness and
    differences in the accounts of the first Mass in the Philippines that pertain to Butuan and
    Limasawa. Use the diagram below to compare and contrast the opposing views of the
    site of the first Mass in the Philippines.

    Subjects (events) compared Cite reasons for comparison


    1. The routes taken by Magellan and his 1. The two accounts have different routes
    men. presented.
    2. The date if the first mass 2. The limasawa tradition cited more valid
    date of the first mass than in Butuan
    tradition.

    LIMASAWA
    Evidence 1 Evidence 2
    1. “Combes cites two visits to Limasawa: 2. “ Sunday 31 March - early in the morning
    Magellan visits first Limasawa; from of Sunday, the last of March and Easter
    Limasawa to Butuan; then from Butuan to day, Magellan sent the priest ashore with
    Limasawa again; then from Limasawa to some men to prepare for Mass. Later that
    Cebu” morning Magellan landed with fifty men
    and Mass was celebrated, after which a
    cross was venerated.

    BUTUAN
    Evidence 1 Evidence 2
    1. “In Colin’s account, from BUtuan to 2. “Meanwhile, Giovanni Francesco
    LImasawa, then from Limasawa to Cebu.” Gemelli Careri, influenced by Colin, had
    made visit to Phil. and published Giro del
    Mundo (A Voyage Around The
    World,1698). He counfused two distinct
    events: the first Mass in Butuan, the other
    is the baptism of rajah in Cebu.”

    Give a summary of the evidence of Pigafetta and Albo


     Both accounts stated that they took supplies of water and wood from island namely
    Homonhon.
     Route taken after Homonhon was”towards the west southwest, between four islands:
    “Ceilon”(Pigafetta) or “Seilani”(Albo) ; Hiunanghan ; Ibusson ; Albarien.
     Magellan’s expedition lasted a week in an island called Mazaua at 9 2/3 north
    latitude as described by Albo; a small island near the passage between Bohol and
    Western coast of Ceilon as described by Pigafetta.
     They stayed for a week and left the island on April 4 to travel to Cebu.

    Why did the confusion on meeting the king of Butuan led to the controversy of the place
    where the first Mass in the Philippines was said?
     The meeting the King of Butuan led to the controversy of the place where the first
    Mass in the Philippines was held because the King of Butuan visited when the mass
    happened in Mazaua.

    Direction: Write the answer to each question before the number.


    Antonio Pigafetta 1. Who was the chronicler of Magellan’s First Voyage believed to
    have the most complete account of the expedition?

    Island of Saint Lazarus 2. What was the name given by Magellan to the place where
    the first Mass happened?

    March 16, 1521 3. What date did the Spaniards first arrive to the Philippines?
    March 31 4. What date did Easter Sunday in 1521 fall?

    Limasawa Island (Mazaua) 5. What place was referred to by Pigafetta as the place of
    the first Catholic Mass in the Philippines?

    April 7, 1521 6. When did Magellan and his men arrive in Cebu?

    18 men 7. How many survivors of Magellan’s Voyage came back to Spain in 1522?

    9 and 2/3 North Latitude 8. “Mazaua” was located in latitude ____________ from the
    equator

    Francisco Albo 9. Who was the other chronicler of Magellan’s voyage whose accounts
    coincided with Pigafetta?

    Fr. Pablo Pastells S.J. 10. Who among the historians above initially started the question
    on the site of the first Mass in the Philippines?

    Direction: Find monument in your place or neighborhood. Take a photo of it with you.
    Paste the picture inside the box. Construct a short narrative why such monument was
    erected in such location.

    Photo taken from: https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Rizal_Monument,_Cotabato_City.jpg

     This is the monument of Dr. Jose Rizal located in Cotabato City. As we all know,
    monument of Rizal were erected in many places in the Philippines and even in other
    countries. This is to commemorate the memory of Jose Rizal, a Philippine patriot,
    writer, and a poet. This monument that is located in Cotabato City shows that every
    Filipino around the world, should always remember our National Hero.

    You might also like